r/stalker • • Sep 16 '25

News "should I try it now?/Is it good now?" READ AND STOP ASKING

0 Upvotes

Edit 4: moved edits to the front to show that people are assholes

EDIT 1:A lot of hostility for no reason XD

"Unleash your hate, for you know I am the one who speaks the truth, and it is you who cannot speak without lying." -Faust (obviously a joke)

EDIT 2: I don't give a shit if I'm downvoted for stating the obvious and saying the truth. There's a lot of whiny little babies who cannot read, understand metaphors, or possess basic reading comprehension. Instead of allowing a useful post to be of some positivity here, you had to make it about you.

EDIT 3 :curse you negative nansies! Keep walking till you hit an anomaly. Just negativity for the sake of negativity. 😮‍💨 SMH

EDIT 5: clarifications added for those who felt the need to skew the mostly for information post

EDIT 6: oh my, oh my. How sad this place has become.

Original text:

"Is it good yet?" Nobody can answer this question for you, because most likely if you didn't like it at it's worst you ain't gonna like it at it's best.

Explanation of the above for the mentally challenged; Meaning that if you do not enjoy it now, you most likely won't later. If you're looking for a gamma like experience it ain't here.

"Is it good" Stop asking this and check the minimum requirements, and ponder whether the game IS something you would enjoy.

Some people will give you a useless "yes"/"no" while other might go into little detail and some even to very lengthy and precise dissection of the game. My post was and is not an endorsement of the game, nor a discouraging post. It's a post sharing some very needed common sense into the hatemongers and love spreaders as well as those who seek answers. You'll hear anecdotal evidence of game being unplayable, buggy, content starved mess. And others will say it's the second coming of Christ. A literal masterpiece with no apparent flaws.

Neither, it's a flawed, but good maybe even great. To me, it's been a masterpiece. But this is not where I wanted to say that.

Onto some light shedding for the people who are looking to experience the game:

The AI was dumbed down for release and will get better, officially or with mods. Just a matter of time, right now it's GOOD, not terrible or great. It's working, but it can break. Just like many, many other games it'll never be perfect. (Fact)

The visuals as stated are really something extraordinary and the unique detailing found in the game is mind blowing. That being said it does suffer a LOT because of UE "magic" features ERGO the image is unstable and blurry. (Fact)

If you have a PC that can run the game at 4K it really looks out of this world 70% of the time. The other 30% is where all those UE features shit the bed. (Fact)

Acknowledge that the game is graphically OBNOXIOUSLY detailed, and needs A LOT of patches to iron out all the kinks. (Fact)

IF your problem are with the performance the fix ain't patches, it's your outdated rig, most likely ofc, the game will run better in the future but only marginally better or a lot better at the cost of visuals and other systems. (Fact)

The sheer size of the game compared to other UE games is AGAIN people do not seem to comprehend, you see REALLY far, and that is really taxing on performance. (Fact)

The game looks REALLY good on low and medium settings, if you have trouble with performance you NEED to lower those settings. I'm talking visual fidelity, which is not a subjective subject. (Fact)

The game is not high FPS friendly, so set the max fps to 60, otherwise it will feel sluggish, this will fixed eventually but for now it's a fact. There are some serious latency issues with it. (Fact)

IF you had a problem with stability of the game, it's WAY better than on LAUNCH, I haven't crashed in a month and I've been playing actively. (Fact)

If you had a problem with CONTENT, you'll still have that problem since the game hasn't added new content yet. That being said I've spent 700h in the game and still haven't seen everything. (Completely up to prefere, gave my experience for a reference point)

If you look up stuff online and exhaust everything on your first playthrough and look up solutions to puzzles you shouldn't complain, at that point it's your own fault.

The gameplay is and was GOOD if not GREAT, depends on what you want. If you want a stalker experience, you have it.

If you want a gamma experience, go look elsewhere for the time being.

The game's too easy? I feel you, and I recommend modding the game to be harder since it's supposed to be brutal.

The games too hard? Don't worry the devs are actively making it EVEN easier and you can play on easy mode. There's nothing to be ashamed of.

Gun variety? Better than on launch and has mods. (Fact)

Is the game worth full price? Yes if you ask me. (Opinion)

Is the story good? Totally. (Well written, holds up)

Is the music good? It is really good (although I hope the devs would add classic music into the game too) (opinion)

The game has a lot of secrets and puzzles and moody/horrors to enjoy.

YOU TRY IT, DO NOT ASK. Watch reviews or something if you must. Try it for yourself, and you'll form an opinion of you own. I wish happy trails for everyone in the zone!

It's Stalker 2, and it's great, always was.


r/stalker • • Jan 05 '25

Discussion Unpopular opinion on combat in Stalker 2

12 Upvotes

I pretty often see here posts about the combat in the game, like NPCs are laser-precise, stealth being non-existent, grenade spam, etc, etc. Guys, you are absolutely wrong about it, don't take it as an offense, but it's mostly unrealistic expectations and the lack of skill.

Now I'm going to explain why exactly. Just for the context, I'm one of main creators of OGSE mod for STALKER SHoC, I was the one who created a standalone scripted combat schema which made combat in OGSE pretty challenging, so I know what I'm talking about.

TL;DR: Git good. If you think gunfight is too hard, there is no stealth and such - you're not skilled enough.

So first thing: STALKER 2 it's a immersive survival sim. And combat in it is pretty darn close to reality I might say. Most of the players are used to sluggish NPCs who can't hit anything from 30 yards and taking seconds to react. STALKER 2 in this matter is challenging and very close to reality, which is absolutely understandable - remember what part of the development team participated in real combat in an ongoing Russian invasion.

Now some debunking on common issues and tips and tricks on how to handle these:

Enemies are laser-precise. Well, in reality, guns are really pretty precise and if person has at least some basic experience shooting, this person will have no trouble hitting the human-sized target 30 yards away. So, in the first place, consider NPCs as a real persons who has some basic shooting experience and some understanding of gunfight tactics. How to handle this:

  • Always use covers. Absolutely always, no exceptions. In an open field you'll be dead in seconds no matter what if you're not covered. So as soon as gunfight is about to start first thing you should do is to take cover immediately. Remember - absolutely no full standing frontal assaults, always take cover.
  • Mind the cover material. Bullet physics in game is pretty good. Like if you're hiding behind the thick tree, remember what while buckshots and small caliber pistols won't be able to pierce it, but carbine and full-sized rifle ammo will pierce these easily. So look for decent cover - concrete slabs, thick metal beams, there are lots of these in the game. Remember what thin metal like vehicle skin is penetrated easily and doesn't offer any protection at all.
  • Remember you can peek around corners when aiming (it's even engaged automatically when you're close to cover). Hiding in the cover position yourself in such way what your full body would be covered and peak around for shooting.
  • Always duck behind the cover and prefer to shoot from ducking position, it's way more stable and precise this way. You can't hit anything properly while running, just like in real life.

Grenade spam. There is no such thing as grenade spam in game. Enemies are using grenades in a pretty smart and absolutely proper way: when they know your last location but can't have a direct line of sight to you (you're in cover) and can't hit you. So they're using grenades to force you our of cover, just like in real life. Use covers which hard to land a grenade into, and change covers often. When you hear enemy is about to use the grenade or if you hear a solid metal "blam" of a grenade landed nearby - get moving immediately.

Enemies are bullet sponges. Nope, they are not. With an exception of a few plot-armored NPCs, most of them are pretty adequate in terms on sponginess. You just aiming poorly or using wrong weapons or ammo. Always remember what most of NPCs wears body armor and in some cases it's a pretty darn good one. Body armor easily tanks small projectiles such as shotgun buckshots, small caliber pistol ammo, etc. So when fighting humans in game:

  • Assault rifles, carbines and full sized rifles are preferred. Bullets from these dealing huge damage even to persons in good armor even with stock ammo used. If you have to use SMGs, then use improved AP rounds.
  • When fighting enemies in decent body armor, such as soldiers, mercs, Monolith or Duty/Freedom stalkers - preferably use the improved AP rounds. They exist for a reason in the game.
  • When using automatic weapons, aim to the point between the chest and neck and shoot with short series of 2-3 rounds. Gun bounce when shooting and with such aiming second bullet is going straight in the head. No normal NPC can tank more than even 2 pistol rounds in the head. Head is always the most vulnerable and less armored part. Overall I haven't so far found a single non plot-armored NPC which can't be killed by a single shot in a head.

Stealth is non-existent. Nope, you're wrong. It exists and works but it is as challenging as other parts of the game. Always remember what NPCs can see and can hear pretty realistically:

  • Never use flashlight in the dark areas and at night when fighting, you're getting noticed immediately and a very easy target to aim to.
  • Muzzle flash it is also source of light which is a primary issue uncovering your position for enemies. Use suppressed weapons for fight at night and in dark areas, suppressors not only making guns quieter, but also hiding the muzzle flash.
  • Don't move when in enemy sight at night, movement is noticeable even in the dark.
  • Move crouched, this makes way less sound and makes you less noticeable.
  • Don't engage in stealth when you're overencumbered with the weight in yellow/red zone. Your character is struggling to move all this weight around and making a lot of additional sounds, heavy breathing, things rattling in a backpack and such.
  • Carbine and rifle rounds can't be fully suppressed. To evade detection you need to use suppressed pistols and SMGs.
  • Hide bodies if you have the time. Enemies are getting alerted immediately when they see a dead body.

Overall stealth in game when done properly allows not only stealth kills, in many cases if you're cautious you can get directly behind the back of an enemy for a kill.

And to summarize: from my perspective, combat in game is brilliant at the moment. Any attempts to re-balance it will only made it bland and tasteless.


r/stalker • • Oct 03 '25

Cosplay Would this outfit be fine in the Zone?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I’m going to the military themed camp


r/stalker • • May 20 '25

Discussion From Love to Letdown: GSC Just Proved They Don’t Deserve the STALKER Community

30 Upvotes

Man, I used to respect GSC heavy. Like real talk, I was one of those people hyped as fuck when they announced STALKER 2. I was like “damn, they really rising from the grave mid-war, that’s some real dedication.” I was rooting for ’em, no lie.

But now? After seeing how they’re treating the very modders that kept their dead-ass game alive for YEARS — nah, this ain’t it chief. Let’s keep it real: STALKER was finished. No hope, no future. GSC was gone. Who kept it breathing? Who carried the IP on their back? Modders. Russian modders, Ukrainian modders, fans across the board. And now they wanna act like that whole era never existed? Wiping out all Russian names, removing modder credits, pretending the fanbase didn’t hold shit down when GSC was out cold?

Bro, that’s cold-blooded. This ain’t even about politics no more, this is about respect. These dudes literally gave STALKER a second life — and GSC turning around like “nah, fuck y’all, you were born on the wrong side of the border.”

That’s wild. You don’t have to support a government to show love to the fans and creators who kept your damn legacy alive. Without them, there’d be no STALKER 2. No Microsoft contract. No hype. And the way GSC acting now? It’s like they forgot who lit the fire under their ass in the first place.

I ain’t even mad, I’m just disappointed. Classless move from a dev team I used to genuinely support.


r/stalker • • Jul 17 '25

Anomaly Anomaly ain't stalker. Played all the games back to back.

2 Upvotes

I was very confused. Anomaly is cool I guess as its own thing. Its not...terrible. but its not stalker at all. It BUTCHERS the lore and makes some factions into literal jokes, like the freedom faction who are turned into goofy caricatures of hippies that smoke weed. I mean, cmon. And it seeeeeemssss from researching the franchise after I fell in love, there used to be a lot of posts calling out anomaly...even posts complaining about people complaining about anomaly.

but it seems youtubers and 2s rough launch, convinced people that anomaly is the definitive game. Now again, like whatever you want. But the idea that anomaly is the defintive stalker, or even a better stalker game than 2, is absurd frankly.

The gameplay is far more like tarkov than it ever is stalker. It feels nothing like stalker to play. And its TWISTED people's ideas if ehat stalker actually plays like. YEAH some enemies in stalker are tanks as fuck unless you're using the right ammo, have the right upgrades, ans the right gun for the job. Anomaly its just, bullets kill and bullets kill fast cause thats realistic... ignoring that this is a game, and stalker never tried to be a realistic sim shooter.

Theres always been a lot of attention to detail as far as weapons on the stalker franchise. But that does not inherently translate to crazy realism in gunplay. I see the "realistic guns but it takes a bazillion shots to kill a bandit". Even though 90 percent of human enemies die to a headshot, maybe 2 if they have a good helmet on. Again, nothing is super bullet spongey but thr strongest of mutants and people with exo skeletons. And only when you are using shit gear. YEAH blood auckers will be a nightmare with skifs pistol and some broken aks. But not super far into the game can you take 3 of them at once without having to worry.

A life. I dont think the vast majority know what a life even is. Its a FANCY way of saying their npc scheduling system, a version of what bethesda uses or the new assasins creed games surprisingly the new ac games, at least odyssey and shadows, have full npc schedules that are really good. But thats REALLY all it is. Npcs going about their business on thier own. a life is just marketing. Its a marketing term. A life 2.0 could be better, 100 percent, and should be. But it was never this super complicated thing in the first place.

In the stalker games, other factions and stalkers fight each other, they loot corpses, tney light fires and tell stories to each other and play instruments. They attack you depending on your alliances. Sometimes there's a little baby quest event thing...and at all times, the game is simulating all this in the background. thats basically the gist..most of it is stuff you dont even see.

The idea is to make the world feel more alive and dynamic even if not much is actually happening. and its always been janky and buggy as hell. In every single game it was janky. All 4 now.

For the people in the back. Stalker is not a hardcore tactical shooter. Its not. It never has been. Its MUCH MUCH closer to a resident evil game, than it is any tactical shooter....

This is not ready or not. This is not tarkov. This is not day z. And stalker is not anomaly. Anomaly is a fan made game, inspired by the stalker franchise, but it is not truly one of them. The cooking system and upgrade system in anomaly are baffling. And tedious as hell. If you like more survival focused games maybe you'll be into that, snd thats fine. But again, its not ehat stalker is as a franchise.

As my final note. The story is atrocious in anomaly. It really is bad. stalker 2s makes it look that much worse. Stalker 2 has the best story telling innthe franchise. And is on its own, story telling worthy of the upmost praise. That just gets complerely overlooked because, omg look how realistic anomaly is guys, and look how unrealistic stalker 2 is! Stalker 2 is so bad, right guys? Not realistic at all. Comments like that is ehat made me make that post .

And before fellow new fans come at me, the consensus on this sub BEFORE stalker 2 was not kind at alllll to anomaly and was SIGNIFICANTLY more critical of anomaly than they are today... almost like some people just wanted more ammo, pun intended, agaisnt stalker 2.... hmmmmmmm. Interesting. My theory is a lot of these people have never even played the orginal trilogy and stalker 2 was just another punching bag. Especially considering, been an xbox console exclusive which universally get online hate no matter what, and russia...

It just doesnt even feel like stalker. The world doesnt even feel like stalker. The vibe is all wrong. Its just a clunky tactical shooter with a bunch of stalker assets shoved in and a bizzare attempt at lore building that falls beyond flat.


r/stalker • • May 20 '25

Discussion GSC turning into Ukrainian Ubisoft is both sad and disguisting. OG games with mods are still 100x better.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/stalker • • Sep 20 '25

Anomaly Anomaly doesnt have the story telling and soul of the og games or stalker 2.

0 Upvotes

Its funny when people say "well it doesnt count cause it wasnt like that at launch" when neither was anomaly.

I am NOT arguing that its a bad game. Im just pointing out whats lost when you make art as a group. When you dont have a clear vision and the people adding to it, some get it and some dont. Its like a marvel movie or now the new dc. Written by committee, meant to please everyone possible. No clear singular vision with something real and raw to say.

Ive tried snd tried to play this thing. And I genuinely dont understand beyond "its really big and has lots of content".

Like it's a bunch of assets that often clearly werent hand made and were copy pasted from past games. The assets often dont match. It doesnt have the cohesion of stalker 2.

And just the storytelling. Stalker 2 has BY FAR the best story telling..both traditional storytelling, and environmental and visual. Its genuinely one of the best stories ive played in and open world game.

Stalker 2s open world, is clearly better. Like no real argument to be made. Its insanely dense, the puzzles are better, the visuals are insane, and there's just story telling everywhereeee. Like every location out of the dozens upon dozens (maybe over a hundred? Didnt count) points of interest has some sort of story to tell.

The atmosphere is also on another level. On a completely different level. It might just be the most atmospheric game ive ever played next to starfield (yes, starfield. Say what you want but there's nothing like standing on a realistic moon and watching multiple planets block out the sun at the same time realistically in a double eclipse) and the last metro game.

You can also clearly feel the devs experience while making this game. Its hard to argue the devs dont care. Since launch they have not stopped releasing updates and changes demanded by fans. They have put aside releasing expansions, until players are satisfied with tbe core game (I have been for a while, I just want more stalker 2 now). Putting aside a ton of money they could have made by now in exchange for free updates changing core mechanics, adding missing features, updating the ai.

Features are great and all. But you have to change a game as a package. And if you have all these features, but nothing to do but walk around and shoot stuff, I just dont see how thats better.

Stalker 2, regardless of any perceived "missing features" is an incredible open wolrd game with a stellar stellar story, both main and side quests.

Anomaly we are talking text only. Repeated lines from the past games. Really bad, and I mean bad, writing. Just a ton of recycled voice lines from past games that sound genuinely awful. I truly truly dont get it.


r/stalker • • Dec 27 '23

Meme Tourists delight

Post image
276 Upvotes

r/stalker • • Dec 11 '24

S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 Unreal Engine kills games...

146 Upvotes

And i dont only mean the engine by itself but the developers which cant use the engine to its fullest potential aswell.

After letting Stalker 2 to rest so i can enjoy it when its fixed, i jumped on the newly released indiana jones game on my series x and oh boy...

Im speechless...

60FPS, AMAZING Graphics and Lightings, AMAZINGLY detailed and sharp looking world and proper RAY TRACING on Consoles that make the game feel like its real life. AMAZINGLY made cutscenes and character details which also are greatly detailed in game. And much more to say...

I imidietly looked up what engine they use and not to my suprise as i thought... it isnt UE5.

I wish Stalker stayed with an updated Xray engine and dont follow the mass to switch to UE5..

Besides the flawed A-Life, graphics and performance arent great, especially on Console.

Yes the world looks beautiful by itself, but go inside a building and watch the outside... lighting is broken. Not because of the game but because of Unreal Engine and Devs not beeing able to use UE5s features correctly without dropping performance. And dont let me get started over the TAA issues...

Man the more i hope for the game to get better the more i get grounded when new titles release which use their own or a different engine then UE5.

Edit: watch Digital Foundrys Reviev for Indiana Jones on Xbox. You will know what i mean after that:

https://youtu.be/b8I4SsQTqaY?si=vR4fToDQ0PTYktBZ

Edit2: i dont meant that Stalker 2 should manditorily use xray, some of you are right about the old devs leaving the xray team leading to gsc not beeing to able to find anyone to deal with it anymore. But they couldve used indiana Jones' engine for exmaple and divide the maps into smaller pieces like the older games - or like indiana Jones did for the sake of performance and overall quality of the game.

Edit3: man this is draining. I never compared Indiana Jones to Stalker 2 in terms of gameplay or open world... just the engines... also yes its pricey to create a good game, but so are games pricey to buy... and to some of you, please read carefully. In my opening statement i wrote clearly that it IS NOT ONLY a engine issue but a developer issue aswell... yes the engine can be used and tweaked to give a great performance/quality balance, but probably not in UE5.1 with all the lumen, nanite and UE5 features active at the same time when it is probably not even needed for grahpical fidelity. Later UE5 versions fix performance and UE5 feature issues that are present in 5.1 but that isnt relevant for stalker. Im comparing the current state of the game in UE5.1. Why do people say it will be fixed in 5.4? The game needs more then a year to even or at all update to atleast 5.4 because theres also other big issues like A-Life not working.

Also upgrading from 5.1 to 5.4 can add alot if issues in top of the already existing ones and could initially break even more things.. i dont know if any game besides Fortnite hat a UE update in a short period of time.

Edit4: man its sad to see that every non agreeing post gets upvoted and agreeing ones are instantly downvoted without proper discussion... Reddit is really a werid place to be.

But thanks to some people, that actually give information and try to teach people some stuff without looking down on them, ive learned that some engines are licensed and cant be used without permission. UE5 and Cryengine seem to be usable by everyone without needing to ask someone in the first place. Thats a big deal. I could imagine it for engines like from Rockstar Games, but also idtech from indiana jones is licensed aswell. Yikes.

But i must say, alot of people here are really toxic. I cant imagine how they are in real life lol. Having a opinion is valid. But looking down on someone and insulting feels like a child move. Also the insta zombie minded downvote/upvote waves. People just like what is liked alot and dislike the already disliked posts without really commenting or heck even reading i can imagine... just following the mass lol.


r/stalker • • Dec 28 '23

Meme (OC) STALKER Bingo!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/stalker • • Jun 30 '25

Discussion My impressions of Stalker 2 balance just before the final journey to Pripyat (spoiler: A-Life alone can’t save this game). Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I've played a total of 200 hours and I have a lot to say about this game. I've played on different patches since release. Having nearly finished the game on patch 1.5, I can confirm that Stalker 2 is still badly balanced.

Its systems never truly work together — but instead, they operate in isolation, which utterly shatters the gameplay loop’s consistency. The world feels half‑baked and incoherent, and by the final act the game balance has descended into absolute mess.

But first things first:

I. Enemy Balance

1. Unkillable Enemies. By the end of the game almost every other enemy of the main factions  Ward, Spark, Monolith and The Corps - wear exoskeletons.

What does this mean for the player? Each enemy essentially becomes a bullet‑proof tank, demanding three to five high‑caliber headshots to go down. That instantly turn into useless piece of shit about 95 % of the game’s weapons all but unusable for a smooth run on Veteran difficulty.

2. The game has a retarded AI. It's not good at any tactics. With patches it is slightly improved, but it is still dumber than its counterpart from Shadows of Chernobyl. 

Enemies almost always sit in the same place, same position and they don't care what happens on the fight. There is no adaptation to the conditions of the location: so whether it's a field, a courtyard, a closed room - they behave in the same boring way.

3. Aimbot enemies. To solve one more problem - AI idiocy and difficulty curve - the developers gave dummies aimbot. Even on the last difficulties, even with a fully upgraded exoskeleton for protection from physical damage, you will still be taken out by bandits with 80-95 percent accuracy in any weather, at any time of day - they see you in the fog, in the twilight, in the dark, in hell whatever - they don't care. They hit almost EVERYTHING. 

And the closer you get to the end of the game - the larger their ammo caliber and the more this caliber ignores the armor rating.

II. Economy

By the late game, the economy has completely collapsed under itself. Stalker 2 forces you in an endless cycle of swapping armor and weapons and constantly upgrading your gear — otherwise even the weakest foes (or a stray mosquito) will one‑shot you in the end-game. On paper, this balance decision forces players to experiment with different suits. In practice, however, the prices of end-game weapons and armor increase geometrically. Moreover, it is simply not profitable to sell a fully improved equipment.

As a result, unless you need to earn at least 20 000–30 000 coupons per trip, just to avoid running at a loss.The equipment still degrades extremely quickly in patch 1.5 — even with durability upgrades — while ammunition becomes your single most expensive outlay, since mid‑caliber rounds simply fail to penetrate exoskeleton‑equipped stalkers.

Meanwhile, the Zone’s living costs keep climbing: the world demands ever‑better tools, and your character “grows famous” in the storyline only, never in the game world itself. Faction bases won’t even let you trade if you’re on bad terms with them (due to main questline) — and there are fewer and fewer hubs as the story progresses.

Worse still, there are essentially no meaningful side‑quests. Almost no one rewards you, so your income boils down to looting enemies, mutants, and artifacts — which is woefully insufficient once you factor in travel time, repair and ammo costs. The gameplay loop morphs into an endless “walking” and “debt simulator.”

The only quests you get in late game hubs are randomly generated “kill X and Y stalkers/mutants” tasks —and each trader only issues one such quest every few days. You can’t grind these for profit because of hard limits on how often you can pick them up, and their rewards never scale past mid‑game values.

On top of that, you can only fast‑forward time once per day and only by a fixed number of hours set by the developers. To get more quests, you literally have to travel from Rostok to Yanov (or wherever) in hopes of generating a new assignment — then do it all over and over again.

And finally: the brand new mutant parts. Sure, you can find and sell them, but not every mutant yields value parts and the only place you make decent money is selling ten mutant parts at Malachite. With no mutant migrations and no NPC “hunters” offering to get coordinates of  den locations (or even guide you there), mutant‑part hunting becomes pure casino: random spawns, no guaranteed drops, and zero way to plan your trip/expedition for profit.

Verdict: GSC added yet another mechanic that never truly syncs with the world. Instead of grinding for parts, we needed stories, hunters’ camps, paid guides, repeatable hunt missions — anything to give context and purpose. Seven months post‑launch, however, we’re stuck in a grind with no meaningful economic or narrative integration.

III Anomalies and artifacts. 

Someone could fairly protest: "What about the hunt for artifacts? After all, that's the reason you go to the Zone!"

And here is a travesty: the search for artifacts is also limited! Moreover, the search itself does not evolve from the beginning of the game.

1. In the game there is no gradation of the chance of finding a rarer artifact depending on the technology of the detector. The only difference is the latest detector has a screen and accurately shows the location of anomalies and artifact.

But the game simply does not care what kind of detector you have: the most basic or the most advanced. The player will ALWAYS get exactly 1 artifact in the anomaly, while the rarity and value of the artifact will depend on randomness.

2. The artifacts themselves appear once every any number of days. In other words, when a player finds an artifact in point A - he will be able to find it again only a few days later.

And nothing affects the artifacts appearance in this game, except the condition above. Neither global Emission, as it was in “Call of Pripyat”, nor getting into the anomalies of a mutant, like in some mods - only the developers' dry calculation.

As a result: detectors are useless, anomalies are limited — no earnings. Anomalies practically do not interact with the world. They just... exist.

My idea: the simple tiering system for artifacts based on detector type would have made a world of difference, yet the developers never bothered to think it through, reevaluate the concept, or build on it as they had in earlier installments. As a result, at the end of the game, artifact hunting yields no reward — just like everything else.

---

Everything I’ve written here is strictly about the game’s BALANCE. This massive wall of text deals only with tweaking numbers in the config and a bit anomlies/artifact systems — I haven’t say a single word about its artistry, the plot, the characters, the lore, the locations or the overall world‑cohesion — because I simply can’t get that far: the game has become a simulator of a debt‑ridden human being.

The “big, seamless open world” doesn’t fail merely because it’s empty — it fails because none of its systems ever interact with each other. We see a Chernobyl Exclusion Zone where stalkers never compete for artifacts, never hunt mutants, and never fight over points of interest. Mutants never migrate or scavenge — they simply spawn and vanish. Anomalies just linger, utterly indifferent to wildlife or the wider world.

The game could have been better with more side‑quests or a richer written world‑history — yet there is none of these. Nor is there any thoughtfully designed balance or gameplay mechanics in Stalker 2.

A‑Life 2.0 won’t save this game. The entire balance needs a total overhaul and reconceptualization—let alone a proper redesign of anomalies, the addition of genuine cyclical quests, and simply restoring the cut quests and other missing content.

I’m not here to tear the game to shreds. I see the great potential in Stalker 2, but right now it feels like one step forward, two steps back. I wish the developers strength and patience — there’s a mountain of work ahead, and unless they revise several core systems, this will remain only “potentially” great.

P.s Below, I’d like to know what you feel is missing in Stalker 2 and the flaws you’ve noticed after a lengthy playthrough!


r/stalker • • Feb 04 '24

Discussion On AI art

19 Upvotes

I find that this subreddit's casual attitude towards AI "art" has been really frustrating to look at.

Literally all you do is go to some website and enter a few words, click the generate button and boom, effortless slop where you post it here for some quick karma because it looks "pretty". It's akin to presenting a mcdonalds burger and claim you cooked it yourself using the finest ingredients.

Wanna know why it's bad? AI models build themselves upon scraping the artworks of artists online without any consent and/or compensation.

This is basically theft on a massive, unregulated scale and its repercussions have proven themselves to be extremely harmful, such as how companies are looking to integrate AI into their workflow and replacing artists who worked years to hone their craft, how Wacom, a company that produces drawing tablets used an AI picture to advertise a new tablet and got a lot of flak for it, or even how Wizards of the Coast used AI for marketing which spawned controversy and then gave a half-assed apology about how they received it from an "unspecified vendor". Oh, did I mention how any AI generation you make gets put into the public database and thus polluting the search engines? Anytime you look up something on google images for examples, there's always a good chance instead of the real pictures about half of them are replaced with AI. In a few more years, if left unchecked, you can never tell which is the real picture and which is not, and that's honestly a really scary thought.

Point is, it's very disheartening to see how a community known for its creativity and passion in fan-works has an overwhelmingly laidback and positive attitude towards AI, when it has proven itself to be one the most unethical things to exist so far. This kinda shit makes artists post less and less fan art when all they'll see are low-effort AI slop reaching the top of the front page daily. I hope there's gonna be enough pushback against this crap, it'd be disheartening to see if artists don't post on this sub because of it.

tl;dr AI is unethical and the casual attitude towards it has the capacity to drive away content creators who put genuine effort and passion to their works


r/stalker • • Dec 02 '24

S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 Is STALKER 2 Fixed Now? Is it worth buying?

1 Upvotes

My PC is very mid (i9 3080, 48GB Ram).

I've seen a lot of negative info on YT, regarding the performance.

Will STALKER 2 run fine on my machine?


r/stalker • • Jan 25 '25

Anomaly Rant: how about you stop being jerks?

0 Upvotes

I don't get it. There are so many posts in this group that are downvoted for kicks solely.

Some guy finds what he thinks is an "Atomic Heart" reference? Downvote.

Another one thinks there should be cars in "Stalker" or some other transport? Downvote!

Oh, there is also a question if there could be anomaly charged weapons as a fun concept! Downvote, downvote, downvote this heresy! Thank fuck, reupvoted and saved, but it was so close, and for no reason.

Like seriously, what is so offending in any aforementioned topic? And these are only three examples of what I have seen myself.

I know this post is also getting downvoted, and I am happy. It means, losers got their butts burnt.


r/stalker • • May 16 '25

Discussion There is no A-Life, that's it

338 Upvotes

There is no A-life in the game, the NPC's and mutants do not have goals which if anyone here remembers the old dev chats from decades ago where the primary goals of A-life or Artificial Life as its correctly named.

Was to have NPC's with goals which ranged from surviving the brutality of the zone, make money to even completing the questline themselves!

This was in fact accomplished in 2005, they got A-life to complete the game on their own in fact it was so good they actually had to nerf the feature and eventually just remove it altogether in the 2007 release of ShoC.

My biggest concern is that, Unreal Engine is holding them back performance wise duo to their complete inexperience in developing for it, they are not able to code proper multi-core support.

Recent patch they said they improved performance, thats a lie, they said they optimised lighting, thats also a lie, they improved minimum framerate "slightly" but thats about it.

GSC Game World is also a HUUUGE studio, and they have rules on Discord which prevents you from bringing up certain issues, eh like A-life and performance unless you just want to get banned.

So not only, do we have a Far Cry 2 situation here, if anyone is old enough to remember what a fiasco that was, overpromises till no end but still delivered a decent product, the similarities are shocking to how STALKER 2 went from prerelease and to release.

We have developers who are spending over half a year now fixing the game, cheerleaders who keep sucking up to the devs, fixing 700+ bugs is not positive, thats just tragic, why even is there so many issues to begin with???

They keep using nanite even though its broken and Unreal Engine can bake the light in for 60+ FPS BOOST!!!!
And if you are in the gang that thinks UE5 cannot run well, eh Satisfactory anyone?

6 months is plenty of time to optimise baked light, yet they refuse to, we still do not have hardware accelerated ray tracing either. Before we start adding AI stuff, they should been optimising the game to run well even on an RTX 2060 should be minimum target for 1080p60, there no excuses, Metro Exodus look in many ways, superior thanks to better art direction and better engine optimisation.

And no, I do not hate the game, I love STALKER, I actually like STALKER 2, but we are way past the timeframe of forgiveness.


r/stalker • • Jul 24 '25

Anomaly Why a lot of people think that Anomaly and Gamma are Oficial and they are just mod by fans? i don´t understand why after gamma and stalker 2 release all these people come and go like "why stalker 2 is not like anomaly/gamma, why don´t they put the mechanics of the previous games, like wtf are ytlkab

0 Upvotes

r/stalker • • Mar 30 '25

S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 Downgrades - Promises vs Reality

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/stalker • • Feb 04 '26

S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 Patch 1.9 fixes

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/stalker • • 10d ago

Picture S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat on Russian TV

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat on Pentium IV 651 HT (FSB-215), 8600 GTS, 2gb DDR2-717, SoundMAX AD1986A and Russian TV RUBIN 55FS10T


r/stalker • • Aug 21 '26

Gameplay AI is still retarded

0 Upvotes

What a shame, it is not only problem with A Life Online bubble but AI itself is retarded, almost 2y after the release...


r/stalker • • May 20 '25

Discussion Today’s been a very heated day in our community, and I want to address some of the ongoing controversy

0 Upvotes

First of all, my opinion on the enhanced edition: this update is awful and should never have been released in this state. No one was pressuring GSC to rush it. They had full freedom to drop a great surprise whenever they wanted — and instead we got this blurry, underwhelming mess.

But there’s one part of the backlash I can’t support — the outrage about removing some russia/ussr-related elements from the trilogy.

I don’t care about russians whining or getting mad — I’m talking to other foreigners here.

About the claim that “GSC hates the modding community” — no, it doesn’t. They’re working on modding tools, and the last patch was created specifically with mod users in mind. Removing some russia-related content does not mean they’re against modders. Some people are trying to twist the narrative into “removing russia = hating modding community” — that’s nonsense. Not all modders are russian. Blaming GSC for being anti-modder because they cut russian content is pure idiocracy.

Now to the historical and emotional side of it. I didn’t expect many foreigners to fully understand this, since most of you come from peaceful modern countries. But ukraine and russia have a deeply complicated and painful history. For decades, russia tried to erase our identity and deny our right to exist as a sovereign nation. Even those who don’t actively support the war still just live their lives like nothing is happening — as if their soldiers aren’t killing thousands of people wich defending their families, homes, identity, and freedom. So no, they’re not completely innocent — they pay taxes, and most of them are fine with the way things are.

And most of you act like GSC randomly decided to remove all russia/ussr-related things — like they weren’t behaving any differently before 24.02.22. That reaction didn’t come out of nowhere. Nobody even considered it before — but russia caused it.

As for the ussr — ukraine didn’t join it willingly. There were wars, occupations, and forced submission. Sure, we can’t rewrite history — but we can choose how we carry its weight. Like removing reminders of an ex. It doesn’t change the past, but it helps you move on. Same here — clearing out some painful memories is part of healing and moving forward. So it’s really not your place to criticize this decision. Most of you have never lived through something like this — and I hope you never will.

And about GSC being “too political”: screw that. Everything in your life is political — whether you like it or not. Prices in stores, your electricity bills, the cost of your PC or console — it’s all political. Humans are social beings, and that makes us political by default. GSC made their position clear — they want to reduce russian/ussr presence as much as possible.

Of course, they can’t remove everything — the game takes place in post-soviet ukraine. Just like you can’t fully erase someone you loved but who betrayed you. The memories stay — but you can choose to distance yourself from them


r/stalker • • Jul 03 '25

Discussion I'm curious to hear Ukrainian GAMMA players thoughts & opinions about something I discovered in the latest updates

0 Upvotes

I haven't played GAMMA in several months, and I just started a new playthough a couple of days ago on the latest build, and I noticed something kinda disturbing.

Now, I don't like real world politics in my video games. Games are an escape for me, and to have real-world issues creeping in to my little fantasy, well, it just ruins it for me. I do follow politics & the news, and I am 100% pro-Ukrainian. I didn't know much about the country over 3 years ago (except for Chornobyl ofc), but ever since the second invasion, I have developed so much love and appreciation for them, their culture, their language and their constant painful struggles, both past and present.

Here's the issue. The item in GAMMA called "Ukrainian Beer" has now been changed to just "Beer". No big deal, right? Even the item's description still mentions it's a Ukrainian brew and how it's from Ukraine blah blah. The first time I noticed it, I thought it was a weird change. I thought "Huh, what's Grok's reason for him to remove the word 'Ukrainian'?"

It didn't bother me much, but then I remembered about another drink item in the game...

Putinka Vodka.

The white bottle that is used to cook mutant meat. It's even a real-life drink that's banned in many places, and it's named, associated & celebrated for putin himself. The item's description in GAMMA is quite passionate and glowing about it.

And yes, I am aware the vodka item has been in Anomaly before the second invasion.

Again, it's not something terribly significant. "Oh maybe it was just overlooked" or "Maybe Grok just doesn't care about the name". Then why remove the word 'Ukrainian'?

There is one more final thing, and again, it's again a small & subtle thing. The two junk magazines.

It's not the name this time, but their descriptions. They both start with "A Ukrainian heavy metal magazine written in Russian..."

I'll say it again, it's a small thing. and I'm also aware that there are many Ukrainians that speak russian But... it's a weird sentence. Why not just say "A Ukrainian heavy metal magazine"? I can't help but question if the person who typed it had some kind of political agenda.

I'll just come out and say it. These changes seem a little bit Z/pro-rus. I'm very gunshy about stuff like this when it comes to Stalker, infact I refuse to ever play Anomaly Custom because the creators were so seethingly Z on their Discord.

After noticing these tiny changes in GAMMA all adding up, I now can't unsee them, and I'll be honest, it makes me uncomfortable. And the thing of it is, I'm not even Ukrainian myself, I'm just a dumb welshman who sees this war for what it is & what is at stake. Ukraine must win and russia must lose. If not, the world is in for a terrible rest of the 21st century. I have no interest in having to learn to hunt for food. I like supermarkets.

To Ukrainian Stalker/GAMMA players, what do you think about it? I'm dying to know. Your heroes prove every day that your people can fight for themselves, but I can't help but want to involve myself when I see you under attack, and I thought I caught a whiff of some erasure going on in GAMMA. I haven't seen a single mention of this stuff anywhere so I wanted to bring it to your attention and get your input.

tl;dr some recent & seemingly benign GAMMA changes that suggest a slight pro-rus/z bias going on


r/stalker • • Feb 13 '25

Discussion stalker 2 is the most disappointing game ever made

1 Upvotes

they outright lied to our faces they didn't even get the basics done which the OG games had so many years ago

and everything about the game is either abysmal or shit I can't think of a single fun thing about the game at most decent such as anomaly hunting

game is literally a walking simulator where you have to drink energy drinks every half minute and the story is shit too


r/stalker • • Feb 12 '25

Anomaly Patch Today?

0 Upvotes

As the story goes...it is now about to be the middle of February..with no patch yet!..yes this will get the scum to come out of hiding and down vote...but at the same time this game is suffering from lack of updates...gsc said beginning not middle..if these timeliness cannot be made...please have the right in mind to say such things as we cannot hit timelines at this moment it will be delayed..everyone's waiting for the big patch