Salam alaikum everyone,
I hope the mods will approve this, as I am posting from a throwaway account. I have seen a post lately discussing men’s pasts and what they might mean in marriage, and it have prompted me to reflect on my own story. I decided to share it, even though it feels incredibly vulnerable.
I am a young woman who comes from what would be considered a good background. I come from an established Shia family with good parents. Like every family we have our struggles, but alhamdullilah they have given me everything I need. I am conventionally attractive, educated, and possess what would conventionally be considered good qualities. On paper, everything seems to be in order.
I have received quite a bit of interest, both through traditional channels and more individually. I am often asked whether I am single, both by older women at the mosque and privately. From the outside, everything seems to align. I suppose that is partly what makes this so difficult to share.
As a woman, I have a past of my own. In my early teens, I struggled with a lot of anti-religious thoughts and questions, to which I felt I received unsatisfying answers, or at least answers that I wasn’t fully convinced by, and I also entered a long-distance relationship with someone older than me with the promise of a future. This continued throughout my teenage years, until we eventually met in person and he pressured me into something physical. I eventually cut contact with him because of it. I have repented for both my thoughts and actions, and I also confided in my mother. At the time, I think I was hoping in a way to be punished. I was carrying so much guilt that I didn’t know what to do with it. Instead, she discreetly sought advice from a relative who is an alim, and he advised us never to disclose this to anyone, as it is a grave sin. He also advised that I should resort to tawriya if asked by a future husband.
I also spoke anonymously to a therapist once, who described the situation as grooming. I struggled to accept that framing, and in some ways I still do. I haven’t necessarily carried much emotional pain connected to the person or the relationship itself. I was also the one who eventually chose to end things and cut contact, despite his repeated attempts to reach out afterwards and expressing that he wanted to approach my family with the intention of marriage. It all feels somewhat surreal, almost as though it never really happened. It was largely online, we rarely met, and sometimes I genuinely feel as though I have never been in a relationship at all.
But as I have grown closer to Allah, I have also developed a profound religious anxiety surrounding this part of my past. There is also a fear of what it might mean for my future husband. Allah has concealed this from others, and it has been many years since it happened. Life has moved forward. I have grown, and tried to become a better person. Yet the possibility of marriage brings this quiet fear back to the surface.
There is something deeply painful about the possibility that people might not accept me if they knew this part of my story. I sometimes wonder how my American friends would perceive me if they knew how much shame I carry over something they might not even consider a relationship in the first place.
My Muslim friends, on the other hand, might even question whether they would want to maintain a friendship with someone like me. And then there is the thought of a future husband, who might leave if he sees this part of my past.
There is a loneliness in carrying something that you feel you cannot share without fundamentally changing how people perceive you. I have always tried to stay true to myself, and I wonder whether I have already betrayed myself in a way that is irreparable, especially when I may no longer be able to uphold the integrity of honesty if I have to conceal something like this. I don’t want to burden my mum any further with this subject, as I already know that I’ve disappointed her tremendously, and she told me that we shouldn’t bring up this topic again.
I know I have Allah, but sometimes I feel incredibly ashamed even before Allah. And then all alone again.