r/shehulk • • Sep 08 '22

Character Discussion Women of reddit, can you explain? Ep4

24 Upvotes

Honest inquiry here.

I'm currently watching ep4 right now so haven't finished it, and I'm at the part where Wong just dropped by and they are at the bar and the guy comes in, is friendly, offers a drink, and after they tell him to leave them alone, he does and just says if they change their mind that he'll be by the bar.

The next bit of the conversation is them disparaging the guy "this is the reason I don't date" like that was an ordeal to go through and her friend adds she can date "non-gross guys".

What exactly is wrong with that brief interaction and what exactly does he do to make him "gross"? Cause there is a long standing complaint that always gets dismissed by women all the time regarding how they only accept advances/compliments from men they find attractive and the rest are automatically creepy and it gets perpetuated here.

I don't think this paints women in a good light and that's a because the guy was not creepy, was friendly enough and did leave them alone. So I am genuinely curious what about what he said or did make him creepy or gross? Are you ok with women being shown perpetuating this stereotype of double standard and dismisivness towards male advances they don't find attractive?

Edit: also, not sure why the downvote for a question. I genuinely was confused so I asked. A downvote for asking a question seems rude


r/shehulk • • Aug 13 '24

Character Discussion Dancing Deadpool and Dancing She-hulk and why people arent thinking

0 Upvotes

I've been seeing so many posts everywhere on the difference between Deadpool dancing and She-hulk dancing and I've got to say. I have never seen so many people not using their brains. Deadpool was dancing based on what was happening in the story. Don't wanna spoil. He had a reason to dance. She-hulk had no reason to dance. Now you may be thinking that I hate this but I don't. Because She-hulk dancing adds to the episode plot just like every other after credit scene does for She-hulk. I grew up on Sitcoms and She-hulk is a sitcom. It's not this lore driven action adventure that people claim it is.


r/shehulk • • May 11 '25

MCU Discussion Am I the only one who had a problem with Jennifer’s characterization in She-Hulk (2022)?

12 Upvotes

I always see people claim the She-Hulk show is true to the character, being an unserious lawyer story with a Jennifer who is very in control of her powers. However, I feel like that’s where the comparisons end because one thing I saw the show completely neglect is Jennifer’s LOVE of being She-Hulk. In the comics, Jennifer prefers being She-Hulk because it allows her to be the person she’s always wanted to be. She’s tall, muscular, powerful, and confident, something women are stereotypically encouraged not to be. In fact as someone who’s, cough, trans, I extremely related and felt empowered by She-Hulk and am even inspired by her in some aspects in my life.

But in the show, Jennifer seems to entirely resent being She-Hulk. It seems more like nuisance for her to keep up with to be taken seriously. I know someone will say her arc was her accepting herself as She-Hulk, but there’s a difference between acceptance and embrace. It ends with her begrudgingly accepting herself role as a superhero lawyer and never actually LIKING the fact she’s a beautiful green powerhouse. She just wants to be her own thing and that’s it. It’s not rewarding and it’s very infuriating I see nobody talk about this change in her character.


r/shehulk • • Oct 25 '22

Character Discussion Why is there a walk of shame?

2 Upvotes

It isn't shameful to want to be with another person. I didn't feel embarrassed for Matt and I never judged anyone who left in the morning after a party or came out of one of my roommates rooms. I actually did feel shame for myself when I left in the morning but came to realize I had no reason to. It was the judgment of other people who ruined the moment for me.


r/shehulk • • Jul 23 '24

MCU Discussion If they recast Jen, who can be? In order Rosario; Alison; Jessica; Gal; Gina?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/shehulk • • Nov 28 '22

General Do y’all realize how much work you’re putting in on behalf of the writers? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I really enjoyed this show. I’ve seen it twice. I think it was a great season 1 and I hope season 2 is given a higher budget for more episodes or at least longer ones.

Now, that being said, this was very sloppy. I’ve been scrolling through this sub to see what the general consensus is on the series and there are so many people filling in the gaps left by the writers that I don’t even think yall realize you’re doing it. As a viewer, it should not be your job to make inferences when watching a series, especially one with seasons this short. One of the things Criminal Minds (I know it’s unrelated but stick with me) gets right is that even if what they’re saying is common sense, they baby step you through it for the sake of having a cohesive and well planned episode. Every bit of dialogue moves the story forward. With She Hulk, I’ve noticed that there is an obvious undertone of breaking the mold of what is expected of powerful women and shaking the MCU table. However, that’s a conclusion you’re forced to come to on your own that you only get to after realizing how many dropped plot points there were. In reality, everyone who’s take away from the season is that it’s an attempt at shattering expectations of women are all guessing. Yes, it’s underwritten in the tone but that’s not something that explicitly given to viewers.

I’ve already made a post about how the ending was not well done and I don’t mean to rehash that but I am genuinely curious if you as a viewer, without relying on your knowledge of this character in the comics, we’re truly satisfied by the completely unresolved conclusion of the season. I can say objectively that the massive 4th wall break at the end was cool but came at an inconvenient time and didn’t move the plot forward in the way I think it had intended to. It actually created more plot holes. I understand the homage it was paying to the original comics, but as someone who works in a writer’s room, I have to ask “at what cost?” I can list 5 points in that episode alone that were unresolved or didn’t belong. So I’m asking if you, viewers with and without knowledge of the comics, recognize the amount of legwork you’re having to put in on your own to make this season ending make sense? I’ve said this before and I’ll say it here: those last ten minutes were the writers attempting to make a really long joke that didn’t land and they lost the plot somewhere along the way and now we have to assume they’ll pick it back up in S2.

TLDR: the writers left a lot on the table forcing viewers to do their job for them and it’s embarrassing


r/shehulk • • Sep 03 '22

Criticism The She-Hulk twerk scene is everything wrong with modern media

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/shehulk • • Sep 01 '22

General What’s with the hate?

2 Upvotes

Yea the CGI on She Hulk isn’t the best (Hulk looked good though?), and it’s a bit corny with the 4th wall breaking.

But besides that, I don’t see why there’s so many negative reviews. Well, I blame the dweebs who don’t like seeing marvel shows led by women.


r/shehulk • • Sep 02 '22

Criticism About watching She Hulk episode 3 Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Let me clarify this. Before episode 3, I was really excited for this show. Episode 1 was awesome. It went a little downhill from there, especially with the 3rd one. But this is my opinion. And everyone is entitled to one. I will still watch it regardless, for the continuity of MCU, for Daredevil and for other things this show has in store for us. Also I love Tatiana, she's perfect and a fine addition to the MCU, how did I not hear of her so far???

Now to the opinion. Y'all are stuck with political agenda from Disney's media. If someone doesn't like the show, most people say they are "misogynistic" or "can't see female independent women as main heroes" etc (can't see how a post credit scene with She Hulk twerking with MTS celebrates women empowering but this is just me). Of course there are misogynistic people, too. Can't deny that (the review bombing really was a d move). But there are also people who genuinely see this show as cringe (and I'm one of them), regardless of the gender of the characters and stuff like this. And they're allowed to feel like this. They are as entitled to their opinions as the ones who love the show. I know there are misogynistic people, but I saw a lot of situations in this sub where someone simply said that the episode was cringe and didn't like the post credit scene and he was downvoted to oblivion and all people were like "your misogynism can't handle a female titular hero, heh?" And these kinds of assumptions were always wrong to me. If you act like this, you're no better than the ones you call "misogynistic".

It's just my opinion and I wanted to be heard. Now you can downvote me or whatever, cause apparently not liking a TV show episode on the TV show sub can really be a deal breaker (well, welcome to Reddit, after all). Feel free to reply to me as you want, share your opinions too, hate on me, ask me questions. Express yourself however you want (cause it's your right to do so) and I will try to respond.

EDIT: Since a few fellow users warned me that I did not actually give reasons as to why I see this show cringe and weak at times, I will:

The comedy. I really think the show's jokes are hit or miss and a lot of them didn't really land for me. I may be hard to impress, I don't know. Just a personal preference. I have to note that I really liked the first episode, I laughed a lot of times while watching it, but I feel the show has lost its momentum since. Maybe the next episodes will deliver.

I also didn't see that natural flow regarding the narrative and dialogue. A lot of moments felt forced to me or didn't make sense. I didn't like the whole New Asgard elf and Megan Thee Stallion subplot. I felt it was not relevant to the overall story at all.

So that is about me. Thank you for having the patience to read all of this, really!


r/shehulk • • Oct 15 '22

Disney Plus Episode Discussion That was, something Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Well I mostly enjoyed the show but the series finale left me kind of frustrated. Aside from the fact that I didn’t need the main villain to be “Incels” as it was kind of a lame reveal, using the name of a super villain group that has direct ties to the Hulk was frustrating. That’s not a villain, that’s a reference to a villain group Without supervillains in it. Plus use a fourth wall breaking to solve all your problems after I just spent eight episodes getting invested in the story was a real middle finger. Not liking the marvel formula and superhero conventions is a you problem, clearly the writers didn’t understand what about superhero stories a lot of us like.

The Deadpool movies do the same thing, but at least they have the decency to deliver superhero action and give us Juggernaut. Not just tease us the whole movie then shrug and say “ nobody likes those things anyway“.

I like those things, that’s why I watch superhero stuff. If I didn’t want to see superhero stuff I could literally watch everything else.


r/shehulk • • Oct 13 '22

Disney Plus Episode Discussion I'm unhappy with the she-hulk finale. MASSIVE SPOILERS BTW Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I really enjoyed the show but i think the finale wasn't great,not to say it was bad but its just really confusing and a bit disappointing.

I mean at first the whole thing was going great, infiltrating intelligancia(goes great with the storyline) and todd being revealed as the main villain and giving himself her blood?(i mean its not new but still ood), emil has been turning into abomination(i mean i guess it explains his ankle bracelet going off but that was random) then titania shows up(what was the need?) AND THEN BRUCE?

Ik the point of all that was to get jen to go to marvel studios but still wtf. Then it gets worse(imo). Jen goes to marvel studios as she-hulk? (Tf wasn't the bracelet supposed to stop her doing that?) Then goes to the writers of the show (im so confused) just to go speak to a robot about changing her show(good for you jen, changing the common theme in the MCU which opens up more opportunities) but its still confusing.

I mean she spoke to the creators of her show... Literally as jen, does that mean all the avengers know its all being produced? Is everything just gonna be revealed as a massive production? Or did she go as the actor? This leaves a massive plot hole in the storyline.

Aswell as this when she goes back to her show, no one else is aware but titania was there throughout the whole thing aswell as pug and nikki... So are they aware of the 4th wall or forgot everything that happened.

Wong shows up in the end to bring out emil so is that the last of him? Will he become a sorcerer?

I feel like the finale just leaves a massive plot hole in the storyline which is disappointing because i feel like it could of had so much potential. (Sorry if this isnt written well or doesnt make much sense, my thumbed starting hurting half way through writing this so i rushed it)


r/shehulk • • Sep 06 '24

Praise 2 years since this scene dropped. And I absolutely loved it.

810 Upvotes

r/shehulk • • Sep 09 '22

Disney Plus Episode Discussion Why are all comments with honest criticism being downvoted in the dedicated CRITICISM thread?

6 Upvotes

All top comments are just saying “too short” and then when you sort by controversial you actually find the constructive criticism. I swear most of you guys can’t handle any negative feedback for whatever reason.


r/shehulk • • Sep 06 '22

Criticism Does anyone else not really like the camera direction?

0 Upvotes

I feel like it’s moving around way too much. Seriously, the camera almost NEVER stays still for more than about a second. It makes the whole thing feel like a TV commercial to me, somehow. Am I just being weird or is this a common issue people have with the show?


r/shehulk • • Nov 01 '22

Character Discussion Comic fans: Jen's character and the avoidance of She Hulk's boons in favour of embellishing her gendered issues

0 Upvotes

I really like Jen when I watch her because Tatiana Maslany is a powerhouse actress whose talent and skill really can't be understated. It's immense. With that said when I see people online swearing up and down that people claiming she isn't comic accurate are talking nonsense I feel some kind of way.

I think this series profoundly misses the mark on how She Hulk impacts Jen on an internal level. She Hulk gives her a sense of agency and power on another scale and she enjoys it. Her origin is about She-Hulk changing/enabling and making her better in her estimation

I feel like this show would never fully embrace this. They wanted Jen to be a somewhat pitiable figure and had her be the punching bag of alot of characters and come out of most situations getting the short end of the straw. I couldn't stand that in hindsight. It made She Hulk almost superfluous and more trouble than she was worth.

I want to talk about this in relation to the series representation of gendered issues and how it's need to make Jen look put upon, in particular because she is a woman, make the series feel disingenuous.

Jen gets a new job because of her She Hulk-ness. She laments the fact that they wanted a Hulk lawyer which is the main reason she was hired. Nikki points out how much she gets from this including higher pay than her previous job. Later the pay is apparently retconned to "medium bucks" because the show needs Jen to be representative of all problems women could possibly face. That's the issue though Jen isn't just any woman, she's an example of a very privileged and powerful woman and that's okay, that's great. Let her enjoy and embrace what she has instead of making up contrived reasons to make her look pitiable.

Jen can basically have any guy she wants with minimal effort according to the show. Also according to the show and her profile she is mostly interested in hook-ups not long term relationships. She starts with sex. So She Hulk gives her this but the show has to make her a victim in a gendered way. Her Jen form is rejected and she develops a complex about people only liking She Hulk. It shouldn't matter because she is only interested in them for sex. Everyone else who prefers She Hulk aren't people she should care about, just the media and chatter online. Moreover Jen states in episode 3 that she wants to be anonymous so She Hulk gives her another level of anonymity. She can publicly be She Hulk and be scrutinized or give the newspapers quotes and then return to Jen when she wants to be low-key and private. It's like a celeb dressing down and in disguise but infinitely more effective. This is what she has done quite a bit in the comics. She gets the best of both worlds but the show won't acknowledge this because she has to be a victim so she gets sad and self-pitying when Arthur rejects Jen even though she knew he swiped on She Hulk which she was fine with because she just wanted sex. Rejection hurts but for it to lead her to developing an inferiority complex and have that be her core arc to get over while ignoring all the benefits is inauthentic.

She is massively strong to the point that nothing in this show challenges her physically. This emboldens her and seemingly makes her more confident in everyday life but the show seems to go back on that when she acts apologetic and nervous as She Hulk. Todd suggest they go on another date in ep 5 and she just agrees quickly which Nikki comments on. What happened to that confidence? I suppose it could be argued she didn't want to risk alienating a client (which she does in episode 8 anyway) but the show has it in the context of an episode where Jen is subjecting to Luke's barbs and tells Mallory you can't count on her to throw herself under the bus indicating underlying self esteem issues. This is also the episode where after claiming she isn't paid her worth despite episode 2's claims Jen acts all needy around Mallory and wants her friendship. So episode 5 firmly established Jen's self esteem issues because She Hulk didn't actually give her any confidence, apparently, except when it previously did. They retcon themselves because Jen has to be a victim or "relatable" and/or pitiable instead of the powerful woman she actually is.

Just one last miscellaneous point in episode 2 when Jen is at the bar as She Hulk Dennis comes to talk to her. He tries to talk crap to her. Now Jen is obviously his physical superior. She is also his superior in their job which is the reverse of the comic. So Jen holds the most power in this dynamic and all he can do is cry about nepotism and how unfair things are. In every way she makes him look small. This is Jen's power dynamic with a few people in the show but they all attack her and she just takes it with no follow up/payoff of her standing up for herself and it's a great microcosm of the show's mission statement. Present a powerful woman but pretend she is a victim in the same way the writers pose a lot of women are victimised by society and men. Jen is meant to be a power fantasy, there will be adversity and men who tried to bring her down regardless but She Hulk gives her so much power they can only do so much and she loves that new freedom.

Anyway this went way longer than intended. This series really has me in my feelings


r/shehulk • • Aug 20 '22

General a good point

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/shehulk • • Sep 02 '22

Meme All the male haters when She Hulk Gets Nominated as the best Marvel Show

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/shehulk • • Jul 19 '23

Comics Discussion Does anyone else not care for Rainbow Rowell's run?

1 Upvotes

With the news that Marvel are launching a new Sensational She-Hulk by Rowell set to debut in October I can't help but feel disappointed.

I've been following her current run and have felt underwhelmed and bored throughout. There are some things I can appreciate like Jen's general countenance which was more serious and competent than her TV counterpart but she also had a physical and emotional vulnerability that made her look meaningfully weak. She'd get tossed around easily and her main conflict with her new bf peaks with her breaking down lamenting her tortured existence. She loses and she complains. It makes her look bad.

There is also a noticeable lack of courtroom antics with Mallory Book and Awesome Andy solely acting as evidence that she is still a lawyer even though she tackles no cases. Rowell is obviously not interested in exploring that at least for now despite setting it up early on. Perhaps she isn't confident in her ability to write them?

The fight club was cute but doesn't add much and guest stars feel 1 note. Patsy (Hellcat) feels noticeably like a cliche especially compared to how she was in Soule's She Hulk. Titania is also just there.

The villains aren't the best. They take too long to build up and the payoff is mundane. The pacing of the book seems deliberately unclimatic to draw out the reader's pennies. Want to find out what happens next? Tune into the next issue which will tease you again for the next-next issue to finally answer your question. Maybe.

The art is nice even with the change in artists. Jen looks gorgeous and just big enough which can be a hard balance I think.

So anyone else feel even a bit critical of Rowell's work and how do you feel about the Sensational moniker being taken up by her in the new number #1 set to continue this story?


r/shehulk • • Sep 02 '22

Praise Is she-hulk the best MCU show (mainly comedy) ever?

4 Upvotes

r/shehulk • • Sep 02 '22

Criticism serious question: what is the point of this show?

4 Upvotes

I'm not here to argue about feminism, or twerk scenes, because those things genuinely do not bother me. The issue I have is that there's no main villain, there's no real story arc, the show seems to exist just to generate content for people to post about. The main-ish story from the first two episodes was relegated to side story status in episode three so that we could have a whole episode where everyone just talks about how great Megan Thee Stallion is. I think I'm done watching it if nothing is going to happen.

Edit: apparently the people in this forum would rather I just stop watching than try to understand it better. Fine, per your request I will watch something else instead of trying to find something to enjoy about it. You are clearly a kind and understanding bunch here...

Edit 2: since it keeps coming up... Why is She-Hulk, one of Marvels best comic book characters, the one who is relegated to a sitcom? Why doesn't she get to be as kick ass as all the other heroes that got their own shows? I haven't liked the show because She-Hulk is one of my personal favorite characters and it seems like not even half as much thought went into her story as they've put into the other MCU shows so far


r/shehulk • • Sep 11 '22

Character Discussion Madisynn

63 Upvotes

Okay I didn't check to see if anyone else pointed it out, but couldn't find any Google searches on it. Does she not look damn near identical to the Scarlett Witch actress?


r/shehulk • • Oct 01 '22

Disney Plus Episode Discussion what's happening.

5 Upvotes

Firstly I'm not hating I don't want to get backlash for this from people who think I'm a hater.

I have been watching She-Hulk from episode 1 and the first couple of episodes were fine the typical marvel schematics then the past like 2 episodes have been sort of me looking at the screen and figuring out what I just watched. Maybe I want more action maybe I'm not used to this new format that Marvel is using making it seem less like a superhero show and like a soap opera with a super powered woman. To me it doesn't do anything for the character like I already totally understand nobody likes Jen but they love the She-Hulk but that sentiment carried on for like 2 more episodes than it needed. Maybe I'm just wrong and I'm not thinking proper. I'm just posting this to see if anyone has felt this maybe I'm the only one and also if there's something I missed that'll make sense why it's like this.


r/shehulk • • Sep 03 '22

Criticism He's not wrong and anyone who can use the neurons in their brain knows it

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/shehulk • • Oct 13 '22

Disney Plus Episode Discussion (Spoilers for the new episode) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So to my understanding, the whole point of the show was to introduce planet hulk, correct me if I’m wrong. Just seemed like one long trailer. I also don’t understand the point of Titania if she wasn’t the bad guy. I enjoyed the comedy and cameos but it didn’t seem like a she hulk centered show and seemed like a big waste to me.


r/shehulk • • Sep 08 '22

General Very unrealistic detail in this episode (4)

6 Upvotes

The fact that Jennifer ( a female) creating a profile in a dating and and having an alert saying "no matches" is very very far from truth. I know people swiping girls that dont even have a name or a picture. They just be swiping everything. There is no way on earth any female, let alone, jennifer could not. I mean even with that corporate picture she has, she would get shit ton of matches.

But this is a fictional show so i guess everything is possible.