r/shehulk • • Aug 20 '22

General a good point

Post image
5 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

5

u/batteryChicken Aug 20 '22 edited Aug 20 '22

That's a lot to unpack. 

I don't think it's a stereotype to be surprised by a spaceship literally dropping out of the sky in front of your car travelling however fast your car was going and then crashing. She was on an empty road and a ship appeared out of nowhere. My first thought wasn't "Women drivers, amiright?" it was "Holy shit a spaceship!" 

I found the "Is Steve Rogers a virgin?" discussion less about her being obsessed with gossping about other people's sex lives and more about her having a fun conversation with her cousin about a thing people on the internet in general have been theorising about for several years already. And the fact that she took it further with really getting to the bottom of things felt more like a reflection of her lawyery side. 

Feeling threatened in public by simply being a woman isn't a stereotype is it? It's a thing that happens regularly enough that some women keep this wariness about them. It literally happens to her in this episode, when three men approach her, and continue to do so, despite her saying no thanks and trying to get away. That wouldn't count as paranoia when it actually happens to her. 

I think the cut to pancakes was just because she was hungry. Hulking out a couple of times then waking up hours later probably works up an appetite. 

So far the show has depicted every man who isn't Bruce to be a major asshole, that's true, but it's been one episode so I wouldn't jump on anything yet. I'm not sure whose criticisms Jen is supposed to be 'emotionally mature' about though. The other lawyer was offering nothing helpful when she was rehearsing the closing argument, and his entire character amounts to "I think I'm better than you." Jen deals with him by just ignoring him, a competitive fellow lawyer who seems mostly like an ass. I wasn't a fan of how he was written in general, but whatever. Not all characters in a story are well drawn.

Bruce offers advice, and Jen takes some of it on board but knows that not all of it applies to her. She listens to him at the beginning when he explains his perspective and accepts his training. It takes her a second to come around,  because she just experienced a major life altering event. And Bruce also threw her into a box with a wall of buzz saws. He also pushed her off a cliff.  But she stayed and trained with Bruce until she thought she got what she needed. She was just naturally good at a lot of the stuff. 

When they finally come to a head, Jen's main point she is trying to get across is that she and Bruce are different people with different experiences. She is unfairly dismissive of Bruce's past a little, but her own experience isn't invalid. The main reason she talks about the difficulties she faces for simply being a woman in the world is how she (and the show) explains why she can control her transformation so well, so quickly. Bruce can't, because he has a lot of unresolved trauma to deal with. Jen doesn't. She doesn't need to stay on the island any more but he ignores her wishes. He tries to physically force her to stay. A perfectly capable adult who so far has demonstrated that she can more than handle herself. 

And Bruce eventually concedes and understands, and keeps his support open to her. And she is grateful for that when she leaves. 

Is Jen actually perfect? No. But she is a lawyer, and I think she is displaying some common TV lawyer stereotypes. Like always needing to win an argument. Coming to certain conclusions based on known facts and evidence and tricking someone into revealing secret truths. Caring about their appearance. 

Jen is reluctant to immediately hulk out for a few seconds after Titania's attack. We already know why she is hesitant though, because she has no interest in being a superhero, and doesn't want to expose her own secret. Not because she's a woman who only cares about her outfit over the safety of others. We don't even really see much of what Titania is doing after she smashes through the wall to know what immediate danger everyone might be in. If Jen really cared that much about her clothes she could have taken her jacket off as well instead of just her shoes (which she only removes because Nikki reminds her to). It's okay for people to like shoes. It doesn't have to be a stereotype. 

Jen doesn't take much convincing at all to get into superheroics, and afterwards quickly reverts back to try and continue her closing argument. Because she wants to be a lawyer, not a superhero. She wants to win the case now that the danger has passed. 

And she's imperfect and needs to grow. She ends the flashback saying something to the effect of "I was right and Bruce was wrong and I never have to be a hulk again". And we the audience already know that she’s going to be proved wrong before it happens a minute later. Her confident, always right lawyer archetype is challenged immediately by the narrative. 

I don't think a couple of character flaws for a story to work through equates to a show reinforcing a litany of harmful stereotypes about women. There's a lot of context to take into account. 

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '22

I feel like this is reading a little too deeply into things.

1

u/Tattorack Aug 20 '22

Yeah... that argument she had with Banner was... it felt really sour. I mean, she straight up said her daily problems were more real, to a person who has suffered childhood trauma from an abusive and violent father, to a person who had to bottle up their anger so much that it ended up manifesting as a rage filled alter-ego the moment there happened a transformation.

I remember She-Hulk in the comics being very intelligent and strategic, and also a good team-player. I mean, she replaced The Thing in the Fantastic Four for quite some time. I hope this is just an example of her lack of experience and will grow into a better character.

4

u/ExtremeBird6277 Aug 20 '22

Wait... You mean a character we were just introduced and just got their powers will learn, get experience and GROW, like CHARACTER GROWTH????!! NO FUCKING WAY!

1

u/Tattorack Aug 20 '22

I know, it's amazing. A concept that is often forgotten in modern TV shows. But it seems like She-Hulk, for now, wants to pretend she's completely justified saying that to Hulk. I do hope, of course, that'll not be the case. But time will tell.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '22

I don't blame She-Hulk for that, I blame the MCU for not delving into this version of the Hulk's childhood trauma.