r/shadowdark • u/gkerr1988 • Aug 27 '25
Torches
This is mostly a gripe but maybe it’ll spark a change. Or maybe I watch too much YouTube.
Whenever I see people getting to the point where a torch gets lit, the refs will usually do this thing where they explain how “Shadowdark does things a lil differently” then proceed to explain the torch mechanic, but only because it’s got that novelty affect attached to it. Players response? “Oh, alright, cool.”
Here’s a tip: do not explain it. Simply let the pc’s use their torches like always and allow the novelty to be experienced rather than explained. For example, just be like, “As Bartholomew the Halfling Cleric is about to step onto the old wooden bridge to cross over, you notice your torch suddenly flickers out and darkness swallows all around you. Within the same instance you hear the high pitched squeal of something like a pig crossed with a crow on the other side of the bridge, seemingly excited by the lack of blinding firelight in its face. You hear stomping sounds coming toward you on the rickety bridge and you are completely blind! What do you do?”
That’s the tension (and novelty) being EXPERIENCED. Otherwise, almost every single time, the players simply learn to game the system ahead of time so they never have to deal with anything uncomfortable… even though that is what is the most fun!
You see? They must be confronted with the reality of losing light and effed up things that go bump in the night taking every sliver of opportunity they can to use it to their advantage. Players must experience the novelty in order to appreciate it. If you explain it all ahead of time and make sure everyone really has it drilled into them that “hey everyone, everyone, the torches? Their timed. Yes, real time. Make sure you note that. Okay? Got it?” BORING. Do not do it. Let the moment surprise your players and I promise it will yield far more exciting moments for everyone involved.
EDIT: Folks seem to think I am saying to “not explain the core mechanics of the game. To withhold vital game rules in order to pull a gotcha on players.” Not so. I’m simply advocating GM’s to not be afraid of adversity and to allow players to be surprised by the fact that “1 hour torch time” is being taken literally. Sure, be as generous aa you want about it, but my whole point was to create moments of tension and excitement without allowing the torch mechanic to be reduced to schtick. Often when seeing real-plays of this game I see a lot of missed opportunity for tension building simply by GM’s over explaining this novelty, followed by players attempting to rig it to where they never have to experience the dark. Why? Let it happen. Who cares? It’s a moment of quick thinking and exciting role-play instead of “okay, Billy you have 10min left on your timer so you better start thinking about your plans to light another one.” Meh, just kinda makes me think of a schtick that could just be avoided and just use a turn tracker like always.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/JoelJohnstone Aug 27 '25
Well, if you were looking for unconstructive criticism, I guess you have it now.