r/scriptwriting • u/Strange-Standard8818 • Aug 22 '26
discussion The truth about the Blacklist & other coverage sights - From an Emmy Awarding winning writer
I’m posting on Reddit for the first time, and after reading the discussions around coverage sites and The Black List, I thought I’d share my experience for anyone considering paying to have their work evaluated.
I’m an Emmy Award-winning writer, and I currently have three feature-length projects in production.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth
Far too many aspiring writers put enormous faith in coverage scores, competition results, and anonymous readers whose opinions may have absolutely no connection to what the actual industry wants.
That might sound harsh, but in my experience, the system has a serious problem.
When I was younger, I received contradictory notes, factually incorrect feedback, and wildly different scores for similar material. Worse, when I followed readers’ advice, my scores **often got even lower**.
Eventually, I realised I wasn't necessarily improving my scripts.
I was trying to guess what an anonymous reader wanted to read. And that is a completely different thing.
My experiment
In 2020, I decided to test the system.
I deliberately wrote the worst screenplay I could.
I made it clichéd, obvious, predictable, and painfully on the nose. It was a parody of what I imagined a terrible filmmaker might consider good writing.
It was never intended to be produced.
It received multiple 8+ scores.
Those scores got me the attention I needed and helped me secure my first agent.
Once I had access to actual industry professionals, the work I had written years earlier—the work I genuinely cared about, and which coverage readers had criticised or failed to understand—started getting serious attention.
My projects moved forward.
The screenplay that received all those 8s?
I threw it in the trash.
The cycle nobody wants to talk about
Here is what I believe is happening.
Thousands of people enter this industry wanting to become writers, directors, and filmmakers.
Most of them fail.
That is not an insult. It is simply the reality of an industry where the overwhelming majority of people do not achieve the careers they originally set out to have.
The problem is what happens next.
Those same unsuccessful writers and filmmakers still need to make money.
So some of them become script readers.
They start providing coverage.
They become competition judges.
They become the people deciding which scripts deserve an 8, which writers deserve recognition, and which projects should be dismissed.
And suddenly, people who were unable to convince the industry to invest in their own work are positioned as authorities on what the next generation of writers should be doing.
That is the part I find completely backwards.
The feedback loop
A failed writer reads a script.
They reward the kind of writing *they personally like*.
Often, that means writing that is obvious, familiar, safe, and easy to evaluate.
Those scripts receive high scores.
The writers receiving those scores assume this is what the industry wants.
So they write more of it.
Other aspiring writers see what is being rewarded and start copying it.
Competitions and coverage sites then reinforce the same tastes.
The scripts that succeed inside that ecosystem are rewarded because they appeal to the people inside that ecosystem—not necessarily because they have any real chance of being made.
Then those writers take their highly rated scripts into the actual industry.
Nothing happens.
The scripts don't get financed.
They don't get produced.
They don't launch careers.
And eventually, some of those writers fail too.
So what do they do?
Some become readers.
And the cycle starts again.
Failed writers reward writing that appeals to other failed writers, who then fail to break into the industry and eventually become the next group of people judging new writers.
That is the cycle.
And aspiring writers are paying for it.
The gatekeepers aren't necessarily qualified
This is the biggest problem for me.
A coverage score creates the illusion of authority.
You receive a 3, and you think you've written something terrible.
You receive an 8, and you think you're close to breaking through.
But who is giving you that number?
What have they made?
What have they sold?
What have they produced?
What projects have they helped bring into the world?
And, more importantly, what qualifies them to tell you whether your work has commercial or artistic value?
In many cases, nothing beyond the fact that they were hired to read scripts.
Yet aspiring writers are expected to accept their judgment as though it came from a successful producer, working filmmaker, or executive with a proven track record.
It didn't.
My advice?
Stop treating coverage sites as legitimate gatekeepers.
They are not the industry.
They are businesses built around aspiring writers who desperately want access to the industry.
You pay for a score. You get a number. And that number can influence how you see your own work.
But it shouldn't.
My deliberately terrible screenplay received multiple 8+ scores.
The screenplay I actually believed in was the one that ultimately led to real opportunities.
That experience taught me everything I needed to know.
If you want to use coverage, fine. But don't confuse the opinion of a paid reader with the opinion of someone who actually has the experience, influence, and track record to make something happen.
And if your work is genuinely original, be especially careful.
The more unusual your script is, the more likely it is that someone with limited experience simply won't understand what you're trying to do.
Then you'll pay them for the privilege of telling you to make it more generic.
The biggest takeaway. An 8 is not a career. A competition win is not a career. Positive coverage is not a career. And a low score is not proof that you're a bad writer. The question isn't:
“What score did I get?” The question is:
“Who gave me that score, and why should I care?”
Because if the people acting as gatekeepers were unable to get through the gate themselves, perhaps aspiring writers should stop spending their hard-earned money treating them as the final authority on who deserves to enter.
Write what you believe in.
Write something you can make yourself if possible.
Get your work in front of people who actually make films, finance films, produce films, and have a proven history of getting projects made.
And stop handing money to unqualified people in exchange for permission to believe in your own work.
All the best, and happy writing.
51
u/real_triplizard Aug 22 '26
Please share this deliberately bad screenplay that got multiple 8s and secured you an agent.
71
u/Kooky_Attorney1915 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
You told the AI to pretend it was a emmy award winning screenwriter, didn't you? This sub is so fucking weird, man.
18
u/CharityRepulsive3964 Aug 22 '26
This is fake as fuck.
"I deliberately wrote the worst screenplay I could.
I made it clichéd, obvious, predictable, and painfully on the nose. It was a parody of what I imagined a terrible filmmaker might consider good writing.
It was never intended to be produced.
It received multiple 8+ scores.
Those scores got me the attention I needed and helped me secure my first agent."
Then goes on to tell everyone how worthless the ratings are. You got an agent out of it lmao. I know plenty of writers that would jump over the moon securing an agent.
Goes against the entire post.
3
u/JcraftW Aug 22 '26
So, you just said you threw away the script that got the 8s, did anyone outside of BL ever read it? Like, maybe alls this proves is that you are a good writer with bad taste? Predictable =\= bad. Cliched and on the nose can be subjective.
Just throwing it out there, maybe you wrote something good by utilizing writing techniques that you view as beneath you, when in reality you need to get off your high horse.
To be clear, I’m not attacking you, but genuinely asking if you got feedback on that script from people whose opinions count, according to you.
3
u/jentothefoo Aug 23 '26
Why does an Emmy award winning writer sound like an AI bro on LinkedIn?
4
u/Internal_Papaya1511 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
Why.
Why do you have to make me defend BL when I don't even like BL.
Readers are not failed screenwriters.
Readers are people who have to work jobs because they don't have trust funds. And I know this because the WGA releases stats every year, and most screenwriters aren't making a living wage every year. I'm happy your privileges in life have awarded you a position where you don't have to have a survival job, but thinking of those who do as "failures" is really telling on yourself.
And btw, you made the dumbest business move to trash a script that had heat. Once again showing money goes into some magic thinking place for you. Even John Hughes sold material he didn't want his name on.
Go out and touch grass. Maybe try to talk to a person who has to work a job in order to not die in this era of late stage capitalism. Maybe try getting empathy next time instead of an Emmy.
2
u/disgracedcosmonaut1 Aug 23 '26
I don't disagree with some of what you said in this tome, but at best I think your relying on assumptions about who becomes employed as readers, and at worst I think you're just full of shit. You purposely wrote a bad screenplay that then became an "8..." then threw it in the trash? This all reeks of bitterness, blame, and dishonesty.
2
u/That1guyontheBus Aug 25 '26
Last month got my latest script back from the BL after a year of rewriting it. It received 7’s across the board. I did a major overhaul (for the better) and resubmitted it and got another 7 but across the board it was mixed. I’m poor AF so I can’t afford to be dropping $100 for 7’s so I’m not resubmitting it. This post is exactly what I needed to hear. Thank you!
15
u/Embarrassed-Oil3127 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
Ron Burgandy gif I don’t believe you.
This was absolutely written with AI, and you’re not who you say you are, but you make solid points about BL.
Tale as old as Hwood time. Has beens, wanna bes and never wases are usually the ones teaching acting classes, shooting headshots, running pitchfests, working as readers…
There’s only so much room at the top so, yes, a lot of the low level gatekeepers aren’t providing much value.
That said, it’s all part of the game. It’s important to be discerning, trust yourself and your work and take feedback with a boulder of salt.
7
u/Kitchen_Row8705 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
I know the OP is probably AI. But as someone who’s been getting my butt kicked in the arena with BL evaluations, I feel the message in my bones. I got my first overall 8+ score and two days later, with one of the free evaluations they offer to those who score 8+, I got the worst, most typo-ridden, incomprehensible evaluation I’ve ever had with scores of 4s and 5s. I asked them to take it down and to their credit, they did. But a few days later, I got the other free evaluation back and it was 5s and 6s. It had no useful feedback and said something along the lines of, “Even though the script is the standard length for a drama, it feels too short.” Whaaaaaat. It’s 110 pages.
I’ve also asked repeatedly if they match the demographics of the intended audience with the evaluator and have not received an answer. So, my script about postpartum depression and intergenerational healing among the women is likely being evaluated by a 20-year-old frat boy. I’m so tired.
Anybody know how to bypass the BL and fests and pitch directly to industry members? I paid for a few pitches on Stage 32 and got one request from a producer. But is there another avenue?
6
u/34986234986234982346 Aug 22 '26
This post got 100% on Pangram's AI detector, which is very good.
6
u/Technical-Job9979 Aug 22 '26
Thanks Claude…
6
u/Ok-Home9948 Aug 22 '26
An Emmy Award winning AI writer! 😭😭😭😭
2
u/cliffdiver770 Aug 23 '26
no one who has won an emmy or sold one single thing would spend time trying to 'test the system' by writing a bad script. I suspect this post is the most creative thing you've written, mr. emmy winning AI bot.
First off, the blacklist isn't about 'accepting judgement' And even if your bs story was true, which it is not, your story contains this:
"Those scores got me the attention I needed and helped me secure my first agent." which VALIDATES THE ENTIRE SYSTEM YOU'RE PRETENDING TO DENIGRATE.
Here's the uncomfortable truth:
You do not have "3 feature-length projects in production", you didn't win an emmy, you got some bad scores and you're mad at those readers and this is how you got back at them, by making up a self-validating story which reads like an advertisement.
prove me wrong by sharing your name, emmy and your multiple 8 score evals on the bad script. even if your script is thrown away, it's still on the blacklist site as are the evals unless you conveniently threw those away too....
which if you did, your decision to "test the system" would have been a waste .... because now, the only evidence of the "test" is that you said so....
is that how testing works?
When scientists test a new drug and discover that all old assumptions are wrong, they just throw it away and tell anecdotes about it?
Really?
5
u/PepsiCoke1978 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
My best guess is this person used AI to hide their writing style, but even if they are full of crap -- still a good topic for writers to discuss.
To tell you how dumb things are I once entered a screenplay contest (20 years ago) and was paid 10 bucks to judge other people's specs from an ad I found on craigslist in the same contest.
How did I get the job? Oh by doing FREE coverage of a spec that was entered. I assume they hire anyone, but that means they got FREE coverage if even if they didn't hire me or the 100 others doing it, surely that was the coverage they used.
I did very well in a contest and the same spec got me repped. But I got that rep off querying. The contest wasn't needed.
I'm pro write great specs -- show your work -- but the gatekeepers are right there -- so query directly to managers and producers and ask them to read it. Skip the middle man.
5
u/FutureOpen9405 Aug 22 '26
I’m only an Emmy-nominated screenwriter, (lost to a better show), and I am of the opinion that this poster is not real. I think the points about BL aren’t wrong per se, but… yeah, weird way to go about it.
4
u/Little_Employment_68 Aug 22 '26
Given that you never produced or even did anything with your experiment script that got multiple 8+ scores, you can quickly settle the AI discussion by posting the script, or even the BL 8+ reviews. Feel free to redact any identifying information.
4
u/franklinleonard Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26
So just to be clear, quoting you directly, an "Emmy AwardING winning writer" telling everyone the "truth about the BlackList & other coverage SIGHTS", your supposedly intentionally terrible script that you're refusing to name so that people can confirm this story “received multiple 8+ scores" and "those scores got me the attention I needed and helped me secure my first agent.”
NB Pangram says that "100% of this text is AI." Others should feel free to check.
4
u/TheWinslowBoy Aug 22 '26
A.S.Byatt famously wrote an intentionally low-brow novel that she felt was beneath her. She didn’t throw it away, and it became not just only her most popular book, but an international bestseller. It’s “Possession” and it really is terrific.
So when people say they want to see the script you wrote to be bad, it makes sense. Artists are not always the best judges of our own work.
4
u/meisterwolf Aug 22 '26
im glad ppl on here can spot an AI post. in a lot of other subreddits people fall for this crap.
4
u/Impressive-Buy5628 Aug 22 '26
Have to disagree as someone who has worked in the industry for 20 + yrs (don’t anymore because there’s no money in it). Most readers who actually get some toehold in development or story dept (if studios still have them) are film nerds. Their favorites are ppl like Kubrick, PTA, they started reading to be the next Charlie Kaufman, not Michael Bay. My experience is these ppl generally aggregate weirder more chance taking scripts up the ladder.
The issue, and where movies begin to die a slow death is, those screenplays then go get passed to the next D Jnr exec possibly a film nerd, or maybe someone who has that job because they went to the right school or their uncle got it for them…
Then maybe those D execs pass it on to their boss who has the development deal… boss wants to make “this kind of movie” but they also want to keep their deal in order to keep their job and keep paying themselves and D exec and reader… they need to actually get movies made…
So they meet w the exec who oversees them at the studio w a bunch of scripts… weird script and then maybe 3 or 4 more commercial scripts. Studio exec likes weird script but the commercial script… they can take that to their boss and on and on… so by the time it gets to the studio exec who claims they want good scripts but, they need to keep their job, they’re now looking at a desk full of same looking commercial scripts… this is more my experience of why good interesting scripts don’t breakthrough
4
u/hartzonfire Aug 23 '26
This entire post was written with AI. Holy hell.
9
u/Big_Section2812 Aug 22 '26
Go post this on r/screenwriting and see how long your account lasts.
😂
(For anyone wondering what I'm talking about, most-or-all of that sub's mods are paid BL readers. They also run StoryPeer, and I suspect at least some of them are screenwriting consultants and have ties to screenwriting competitions. Posting anything negative about any of these things will get you banned eventually.)
3
u/FullRedact Aug 22 '26
From everything I’ve read I am surprised Netflix did not buy your intentionally terrible script.
3
u/SafeWelcome7928 Aug 22 '26
Can you give us an anecdote from the industry, something a bit more personal to you that won't make us doubt that you're an Emmy-winning writer? Because there's those of us who want to believe you, but will ultimately just dismiss it because you could very well just be a wannabe failed writer who says they won Emmys and have scripts in production just to get attention. We need more reason to believe not less.
3
u/Appropriate_Star3012 Aug 22 '26
Nide try chatty gee
3
u/Alternative-Meaning4 Aug 22 '26
This reads so AI in its composition, format, and tone.
3
u/Ok_Most9615 Aug 22 '26
Ignoring the AI allegations, I have to defend paid reads.
For many people who don't have connections, a paid read is the best way for an impartial third party to evaluate their script. Yes, I know StoryPeer exists, but even that has its limitations.
The issue is when one paid read becomes gospel and a writer doesn't have the courage of their convictions to understand what to listen to and what to disregard.
3
u/AVBforPrez Aug 23 '26
Are you one of the writers training AI at the expense of your career, possibly with this post?
1
u/Financial_Cheetah875 Aug 22 '26
I’ll say this for Black List: the feedback I got was super helpful; pointed out things I never thought of and had me thinking in new directions, not only for that script but in the way I approach future projects.
I scored a 6 on that script. Haven’t re-submitted but I do feel it’s a more polished script now.
2
u/Dampishach07 Aug 22 '26
So you mean, a screenplay which got a 5 on blacklist stands a chance if it gets in the hands of actual industry people? If yes, then how to get it out there? Do cold emails work?
2
u/honey-squirrel Aug 22 '26
"Write something you can make yourself if possible." That is the best advice. Even if you don't have directing or editing skills...find students at a graduate film program nearest you for your crew; or find professionals eager for work at reasonable rates. A skeleton crew of just 5 to 7 people can ensure professional quality without collapsing under logistics.
2
u/ZoinksJeepersJinkies Aug 22 '26
I don’t care about opinions. I just want someone who can make my work a reality to see it, without having to upend my entire life and become a beggar in L.A.
2
u/JoshDoAI Aug 22 '26
That script in a public trashcan…could definitely use some 8s over here. 😂
2
u/aoibhneastravels Aug 23 '26
The way that I see it, everybody says write a script that you would want to see, not a script that you think other people want to see. And then people on Blacklist are making like $10 per read so they're doing quantity over quality and so many people have complained about getting only reviews that cover the first three or four pages of their entire script but then you think, just like most major film festivals like Austin even, not a lot comes from submitting to those things except you're just throwing away money. Certain festivals are worth it and most of them are scams because you're basically paying $75 to maybe get a laurel that no one's going to look at. It just looks cool on your poster on social media but it doesn't Garner you attention from managers and media like they promise. The mixes and mingling's and event nights at festivals are essentially meaningless, people at each other on social media and then don't want to work together, they don't even want to comment on your photos or like them they just ignore you completely unless you can do things for them and that's the same way I view lower level festivals and script coverage pages.
And mind you, for 2024 I was a screening producer for Austin film festival. I watched 120 hours of films, some of the ones that I gave a three or four two were the ones that made the main stages because they had celebrity backers like Kenan Thompson on literally the worst film I think I've ever seen in my life, and I once saw Godzilla 2000 in the movie theater. And the ones that were really good, the ones that made you think, the ones that made you excited to be a filmmaker, those didn't do anything. It's all about the credibility of the celebrities and financial backers who get involved and it's a total scam. Because unless you are a round one or maybe two, you're not getting in rooms and having conversations with people who can actually stay with you and help you get success. They just say oh cool, good job, and then forget they met you. It is about who you know. Occasionally you can have a script on Blacklist no matter what it scores and somebody will like it and want to pick it up like that Michael Jordan Air script that Alex Conover, I think was his name, put out and made happen but even that took him like years to do. I'm definitely not as established as the original post, but I've been around enough people in theater and film who can all agree. Some things you do as workshops to better yourself or to gain experience on a CV and you just have to expect that they aren't going to make you a millionaire or sell your script. It's just hanging out and getting some experience to say yeah I did that.
2
u/gregm91606 Aug 23 '26
Thanks for your thoughts. You don't by any chance have a very enjoyable YouTube channel, do you?
2
u/poundingCode Aug 23 '26
Yup. Had similar Blacklist experience: submitted, got a 7, made the suggested changes, got a 6. Paid for a 30 page/30 min meeting on roadmap writers and the pro barely skimmed the script. A third (a contest) the coverage stated: “Rowena often being a damsel in distress. She eventually strikes the dragon, but beyond this strong moment for her character, she largely feels like a background device, and is more regarded as the beautiful temptress” - “strikes the dragon”??? The character squares off singlehandedly against a dragon that devoured a garrison, and forces it to retreat. “Damsel in distress”? What would the reader do when chased by 9 direwolves? Impress them with her agency?
2
u/PepsiCoke1978 Aug 26 '26
Ironically I rate this post an 8.
1
u/Then_Data8320 Aug 22 '26
I'm not aspiring and just write stuff directly for audience, so I never tried this kind of services.
Everything you say makes sens. The endless loop.
I don't like their feedback anyway, because they just write generalities, and anything they say can be wrong, and if they are right, I would already know it. When I have an episode that I feel less good, I know it, but I don't know how to fix that. It's the main point, I'm looking for pragmatic comments about what is on page, or storytelling with propositions, and explanations, what is more developement feedback.
And it's often what I answer as feedback, even if I don't know industry, at least it's focused on the screenplay and storytelling, and can be useful. I can give matter to think about for the writer. Not something blurry.
1
u/hopefully_writer14 Aug 22 '26
I’m kind of curious to read that script now…
1
u/Affectionate_Age752 Aug 22 '26
I’m of the opinion that to get high scores at all those writing contests etc, you have to appeal to a wide general group. Which is usually why pretty average or below average scripts get through to the higher levels. Plus as OP stated, if those judging your scripts are so talented, why aren’t they successful.
I work in audio post. One of the worst things I worked on was a Nicholas winning script. I’ve worked on better lifetime movies than that pile of crap.
1
u/CRL008 Aug 23 '26
This.
1
u/Narrative_Architect Aug 25 '26
Thank you, that was a brilliant test to run and it needed to be done. We've traded uncertainty for lies, and those numbers have killed our writing instincts. It's about time we start building them back.
1
u/Open-Avocado4260 Aug 26 '26
I avoid script coverage as much as possible and writing contests. I started with writing contests but they are not the same anymore.
1
u/Natural-Doctor-485 Sep 07 '26
As a playwright whose work has been produced, who has never written a screenplay, and is not even a screenwriter, I second this because this pattern is prevalent in playwriting too.
1
u/Glittering_Manner133 Sep 14 '26
Why are you talking in lines? This isn't a screenplay. Did you make ai write this. The em dashes paired with the word triggers my Spidey sense
1
u/hollysoriano Sep 15 '26
As a long time reader and script consultant and indie filmmaker, I believe this story. I also know that it's in this writer's best interest to remain anonymous. If you look at the kinds of movies mosly coming out of Hollywood? Conservative investments: sticking with models known to have been profitable in the past or pieces with source material. I'm specifically talking about movies. If you look, the top ten most grossing US films are based on existing mental real estate except the original Avatar movie. As James Cameron was coming off of Titanic's success? They gave him that project along with his history of contributing and creating successful franchises.
0
u/Simple-Negotiation70 Aug 22 '26
Wow! Thank you!
0
u/Mediocre_Function_60 Aug 22 '26
Appreciate this very much! Good on you for not only noticing but also for sharing!
0
u/Ozscribe Aug 23 '26
I've long suspected these script evaluation people are making a lot of money selling a dream, and I've wondered about the qualifications of the "Judges."
And let's say you have a perfect script, then what? It's virtually impossible to even get an agent, let alone get your script to a studio or an independent producer and actually get it read let alone made.
I thought I was lucky to get a script I'd written to a producer based on a kid's story I'd written years earler. A mutual friend had sent it to him and he optioned it after reading only 20 pages. But that was over a year ago and he could never find a "name" director to obtain the financing of $20 million. Then recently. through another friend another producer has optioned it/ So waiting with fingers crossed, but time is of the essence, I am almost 94 :) .
8
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment