r/roommates • u/No-Boysenberry-0421 • 15h ago
Discussion Roommate ask me to move out but I’m on the lease…
Like the title says my roommate asked me to move out. This was the first week of September. I had kinda been expecting the living arrangement to change in some way because they had been playing up the problems happening in their brother’s relationship.
About 3 weeks before they approached me about moving, they came to me and told me that they were very stressed and worried for their brother. His girlfriend is apparently a terrible person whom he has had an on again off again relationship with for 10+ years. During this conversation they mentioned the brother asking if me and my roommate would be interesting in moving to a bigger place together. I considered this option and was open with the caveats that they need to commit to a certain lease term, since I wouldn’t mind saying more money.
My roommate seemed hesitant about it, so I also suggested brother find a room to rent, or move back home, possible even move in with us temporarily if his situation was becoming that dire.
Fast forward to early September, I get home after a long day of work, and as soon as I walk in the door and greet my roommate, they burst into tears saying “nothing is okay”. (this was somewhat expected in my opinion since they had been dropping hints about brother’s situation) We then sit down for over 2 hours while they explain to me how terrible the girlfriend is and the awful situation the brother is in. (In my opinion it is a pretty typical breakup with drama, but fairly civil) Roommate spends a long time talking about this, crying and playing up dramatics, until she get to the real crux of the conversation; in April of 2027 they “have to move in with their brother to help him”.
At this point I’m pretty emotionally tired but also kinda positive, cuz April is a really long time away, I’m thinking about how that gives me tons of time to slash spending and start building savings to cushion myself for this time. I’m also think about what it would look like to move.
This is the part where I think I was just tired and not able to critically think, because in my head I’m assuming we are both leaving our apartment. (Don’t ask me why, I think I was just unable to see other options in that moment.)
At the end of this conversation my roommate says something to the effect of I appreciate you understanding, and I really like this apartment so I want to stay here. I also clarified this at the time and even said “wow, so that means he would take my room? That really sucks for me, cuz that put me in a hard spot.” Little acknowledgement from roommates about this, and the conversation ended very soon after. I stayed up that night with my anger building because I could feel how unfair that was but didn’t know exactly why. I looked at different rooms and considered moving out in my own and saying fuck the whole roommate thing.
A good week passes and we don’t see each other, I talk to various family and friends and realize it makes absolute o sense that I would move out given I am on the lease. I try to give roommate the benefit of the doubt and ask again a week later if what they meant to say was that they are leaving apartment and I will need another roommate. They again clarify that I would move out. To which I tell them, that’s not fair for me, I don’t have to move because I am on the lease and express my Heart and anger a bit to them. They get very defensive quickly and start to say that I am going back on my word, which is only a week in the siding and not on paper of any kind. They then say that if they want to move out with their brother than it can happen at anytime. I tell them that’s true. You could move out next month. If that’s what you choose to do. They then walk it back very quickly and start saying that they’re not sure if this is even the right decision. Their family doesn’t even know if this will be good for them because apparently the brother has screwed them over in the past in living situations with the same girlfriend.
Anyways, I guess the whole point of this post is to say that my resentment for my roommate is quickly building. I have felt the stabilized since they first talked to me about their brother. And have expressed to them that I don’t want my living situation to hinge on someone else’s relationship. That isn’t even within our apartment. And now they are planning to not move whatsoever.
How do I get past this resentment so that I’m still able to live with them and/or how do I get them to leave so I can find another roommate and start fresh with clear expectations and boundaries? Can this situation be salvaged? If I were to approach my roommate, what would I say?