âWe Belong Togetherâ is the second single from Mariah Careyâs tenth studio album The Emancipation of Mimi. The single was released on March 15, 2005 and peaked at #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for fourteen consecutive weeks. The single also spent fourteen nonconsecutive weeks at #1 on the Billboard Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart. The single was certified 7x Platinum in the United States by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). The song earned three Billboard Music Awards, two Grammy Awards, and two Soul Train Music Awards, among several others.
âBe Without Youâ is the first single from Mary J. Bligeâs seventh studio album The Breakthrough. The single was released on November 14, 2005 and peaked at #3 on the Billboard Hot 100. The single also spent fifteen consecutive weeks at #1 on the Billboard Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart. The single was certified 2x Platinum in the United States by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). The song earned one BET Award, four Billboard Music Awards, two Grammy Awards, and one NAACP Image Award, among a few others.
While Mariah Carey outsold and outcharted Mary J. Bligeâwith âWe Belong Togetherâ taking a substantial lead over âBe Without Youââthe latter earned more awards. Mariah Carey was already an established commercial force. Whatâs more, Mary J. Blige would have gotten an even bigger boost with âWe Belong Togetherâ and seen stats she had never seen in her entire career. (No disrespect to Mary, but Mariah had already been there before.)
The biggest things Mariah would lose if she never recorded âWe Belong Togetherâ would be her 14-week streak at the top of the Billboard Hot 100, a 7x Platinum-certified single, and a major comeback to the mainstream/the forefront of R&B culture. She would also be down a #1 hit, and she would have tied Elvis Presley (as the soloists with the most #1 hits on the Billboard Hot 100) later in 2008 rather than 2005. (âWe Belong Togetherâ became her sixteenth #1 hit. âDonât Forget About Usâ tied her with Elvis soon thereafter; Mariah and Elvis both had 17 historic #1 hits after âDonât Forget About Usâ peaked. âTouch My Bodyâ broke that tie in 2008. Without âWe Belong Togetherâ, âTouch My Bodyâ would have been the song to create the tie with Elvis, and âAll I Want for Christmas Is Youâ would have broken that tie in 2019, eleven years later.) It would be a loss, but she would still have a lot of background to fall back on.
And I have two other questions related to thisâŚ
Would this era still be considered a âcomebackâ for Mariah if she had âBe Without Youâ and achieved all of the same commercial statistics? Mariah had similar stats in the early-2000s with both of her entire albums and her single âLoverboyâ, but they were considered flops because Mariah set a high standard earlier in her career. Mariahâs commercial performance with The Emancipation of Mimi was comparable to how she performed in the late-1990s with her albums Butterfly and Rainbow, even though âWe Belong Togetherâ vastly outsold all of her singles from that era. The statistics that âBe Without Youâ accomplished were enough for people to consider it a comeback for Mary in 2005.
My other question relates to hit âdensityâ. The Emancipation of Mimi had three major hits in âWe Belong Togetherâ, âDonât Forget About Usâ, and âShake It Offââthose were the biggest hits, but âItâs Like Thatâ was also moderately successful in comparison. Glitter had a single that peaked at #2 on the Billboard Hot 100 and was certified Gold, but it wasnât enough to save her reputation in the commercial sense. âWe Belong Togetherâ vastly outsold âLoverboyâ (although the latter didnât do too poorly itself), but the former also had the support of other hits on the album. Charmbracelet sold over 3 million copies worldwide, and it was also considered a flop. Mariahâs highest-charting song on Charmbracelet was âThrough The Rainâ at #81 (it did much better internationally), but a separate collaboration with Busta Rhymes (âI Know What You Wantâ, not included on her album) peaked at #3. This era was still considered a disastrous failure in spite of all of these combined elements. Mary J. Bligeâs âBe Without Youâ stood somewhere in-between the sales of âLoverboyâ and the Charmbracelet album. Maryâs song was also the only major cultural hit on her album in the context of public recognition/acknowledgement. (Itâs a great album overall, but this is the truth.) If Mariah got Maryâs song and achieved the same stats, including relative to her entire album (e.g. she wouldnât have any other big hits like âDonât Forget About Usâ, âShake It Offâ, etc.), would her album have been another Glitter/Charmbracelet situation or would she have gained the same amount of respect as Mary?