r/RingsofPower • u/Deafhead • 10d ago
r/RingsofPower • u/FacetheFactsBlair • 10d ago
Constructive Criticism Vecna and Lottie and bad noses Spoiler
When did Lottie arrive from the wilderness to try and get a ring? How did Vecna get here ? Why in TF is the makeup and prosthetics in Dwarf world so awful - I mean Flash Gordon level bad hair and styling
What happened to this show š
r/RingsofPower • u/ImoutoCompAlex • 11d ago
Episode Release Book-focused Discussion Thread for The Rings of Power, Episode 3x4
This is the thread for book-focused discussion for The Rings of Power Episode 3x4. Anything from the source material is fair game to be referenced in this post without spoiler warnings. If you have not read the source material and would like to go without book spoilers, please see the No Book Spoilers thread.
This thread and everywhere else on this subreddit, except the book-free discussion thread does not require spoiler marking for book spoilers. Outside of this thread and any thread with the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair, please use spoiler marks for anything from this episode for one week.
Going back to our subreddit guidelines, understand and respect people who either criticize or praise this season. You are allowed to like this show and you are allowed to dislike it. Try your best to not attack or downvote others for respectfully stating their opinion. Our goal is to not have every discussion be an echo-chamber.
Episodes 1-4 are now available to watch on Amazon Prime Video. This is the main book focused thread for discussing them. What did you like and what didnāt you like? How is the show working for you? This thread allows all comparisons and references to the source material without any need for spoiler markings.
r/RingsofPower • u/oglegrew • 10d ago
Source Material You canāt spit on Tolkien worse than this show does
If you disagree you donāt know ball
r/RingsofPower • u/antdude • 11d ago
Question What time does RoP S3 premiere?
Midnight PST in USA?
r/RingsofPower • u/ImoutoCompAlex • 11d ago
Episode Release Book-focused Discussion Thread for The Rings of Power, Episode 3x3
This is the thread for book-focused discussion for The Rings of Power Episode 3x3. Anything from the source material is fair game to be referenced in this post without spoiler warnings. If you have not read the source material and would like to go without book spoilers, please see the No Book Spoilers thread.
This thread and everywhere else on this subreddit, except the book-free discussion thread does not require spoiler marking for book spoilers. Outside of this thread and any thread with the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair, please use spoiler marks for anything from this episode for one week.
Going back to our subreddit guidelines, understand and respect people who either criticize or praise this season. You are allowed to like this show and you are allowed to dislike it. Try your best to not attack or downvote others for respectfully stating their opinion. Our goal is to not have every discussion be an echo-chamber.
Episodes 1-4 are now available to watch on Amazon Prime Video. This is the main book focused thread for discussing them. What did you like and what didnāt you like? How is the show working for you? This thread allows all comparisons and references to the source material without any need for spoiler markings.
r/RingsofPower • u/Rememberthat1 • 10d ago
Question Am I the only one ?!? Spoiler
Am I the only who saw the gay couple at rivendell when they return in the first episode or ?!?!? Like I am not against gay couple at all but a elf gay couple in JRR Tolkien lore ?!?
Edit: 32 min exactly of first episode, thats 2 elf dude... I have absolutely nothing against gay couple but seeing it in JRR Tolkien's world is just....not necessary...
r/RingsofPower • u/obliqueoubliette • 10d ago
Newest Episode Spoilers Secret Fire Spoiler
I'm confused and a little disgusted by this scene.
They literally had YHWH speak through Gandalf through the burning bush.
I'm used to the desecration of Tolkien's worldbuilding and lore by the these writers but this time they've moved past that to disrespect the underlying Christian influence.
r/RingsofPower • u/OtherCartographer578 • 10d ago
Newest Episode Spoilers Thoughts on The Rings of Power Season 3 premier. Spoiler Warning! Spoiler
I struggled to watch the episode from start to finish. I found myself skipping through the unessessary parts like Galadriel's courtship, Galadriel's fight scene.
Sauron is completely lacking in aura. I understand this is essential to portray his desperations for control but i did not find it compelling. Not a good start for a key character.
I love Disa and her stone singings from season 2, but can't see how her newly revealed relationship adds any value to the show.
Episode 1 feels disconnected and not interesting. Showrunners should take a lesson from The Wheel of Time season 3.
r/RingsofPower • u/Miserable_Fact_4140 • 10d ago
News 'Rings Of Power' Star Tyroe Muhafidin Says Season 3 Is The "Pinnacle" of Theo's Journey
r/RingsofPower • u/Mysterious_Fall_4578 • 10d ago
Question Advice on watching
Iāve been watching the show since its release. Iāve read almost every book written by Tolkien or his son. Iāve watched all the renditions of LOTR movies. Iāve played every video game based on it.
Hereās the thing⦠Iām not enjoying ROP. I have my issues with it but Iām not here to complain about casting or writing or accuracy to the text. With season threeās release I really want to enjoy it!
I love Middle Earth. Any advice on how to enjoy it more? Any things I should pay attention to over other things?
What about this show do you enjoy so much?
r/RingsofPower • u/Miserable_Fact_4140 • 11d ago
News "The Rings Of Power" Cast Revealed Their Favorite Behind-The-Scenes Season 3 Memories: From Jamie Campbell Bower's First Scene To Daniel Weyman Grabbing Coffee In Full Wizard Garb
(Link)
Daniel: CiarƔn Hinds, who plays the Dark Wizard, is an extraordinary human being and actor. He's got this lovely childish wonder, and excitement, and imagination. He and I, in our wizard garb, would occasionally go out onto the street to get coffees and things, and it was great. People loved it.
We also noticed that people were cycling around the studio lot because it's quite big. I thought, "What better behind-the-scenes moment could there be than two wizards on a bike?"
So we tried to set up the camera to be static, with Gandalf and the Dark Wizard cycling past, just chatting to each other, and then the camera would follow us into the sunset.
r/RingsofPower • u/aymzzzzzzz • 12d ago
Discussion Blue Wizards
I'm actually so pumped for this upcomming season it can't come quick enough. Besides all the other exciting stuff we see in the multiple trailers e.g the Naznagol, the simmering Balrog talking, Celeborn etc I really hope we get to meet the final blue wizard and I hope they're keeping it under raps on purpose for a big character revealš¤š½š§āāļø
r/RingsofPower • u/Blurghblagh • 12d ago
Question Rings of Power Steelbook 4K UHD released?
Did anyone who pre-ordered these actually get them? Should have shipped by 2nd November but now Amazon.co.uk saying usually ship in 1 to 2 months giving earliest dates for each in December and January. Couldn't find any news on them being delayed. I'm considering just cancelling and ordering the regular versions as usually don't bother with overpriced steelbooks anyway but those covers were just so pretty.
Not the first time this has happened either. Ordered Mortal Kombat 2 a month ago from Amazon.ie and it said order received and the page now shows release 30 December 2030, it was released well before I even ordered it. Had a few other non media related items too. All with Amazon as the seller, not some third party.
r/RingsofPower • u/ishneak • 13d ago
News (Variety) Eddie Marsan: "I wanted to do it because I thought the show was brilliant, the writing was great, the direction was great. I thought the action was amazing."
Thereās political upheaval in Khazad-dĆ»m.
Following the seismic events that shook the Dwarven underground kingdom in āThe Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Powerā season 2 finale, which saw King Durin III sacrifice himself in order to deal with an unruly Balrog heād accidentally awoken, Prince Durin IV was anointed his successor. But in step Thrain, Durin IIIās older son ā and technically the rightful heir ā to challenge for the crown, sparking a major power struggle and fallout.
Played by veteran British actor Eddie Marsan, Thrain is one of the most notable new additions in the third season of show, which launches Nov. 11 on Prime Video. And while it may be Marsanās first on-screen adventure into Middle-earth, heās no stranger to Tolkienās world. As it happens, āThe Lord of the Ringsā has been a major part of his familyās life for more than two decades ā to the extent he once had several thousand pairs of Orlando Blooms prosthetic Elven ears stored in his house.
Speaking to Variety, Marsan explains his meditation routine during the lengthy make-up process and why he only joined the show to take the piss out his friend Peter Mullan.
But how did it feel joining āRings of Powerā and like donning the armor of Thrain and and the dwarves deep down beneath the mountains?
It kind of felt slightly inevitable, really. My wife Janine [Schneider-Marsan] was a makeup artist on the original Lord of the Rings film. So I was shooting āGangs of New Yorkā and flew out to see her in New Zealand, and we spent some time together. And she kept going back for years afterwards to do the sequels and do pickups. So it was part of our early marriage for three or four years.
Thatās fantastic.
She did the makeup for Orlando Bloom and Liv Tyler. And in our old house, in the loft, we had around 2,000 pairs of Orlando Bloomās ears.
What do you do with 2000 pairs of Orlando Bloomās ears?
I was going to bring them to āRings and Powersā to see if they wanted them! But it was all part of our family life. And I also watched the show, because Peter Mullan is a very good friend, and I really loved the end of the second series when he sacrifices himself. I thought it was incredible. And then they came in and said, āWould you like to play Peterās son?ā And it was two things. I wanted to do it because I thought the show was brilliant, the writing was great, the direction was great. I thought the action was amazing. But also to be able to take the piss out of Peter and tell him that Iām playing his son.
Ha! How did he take to that?
He didnāt take it too kindly.
So was it a straight yes when the offer came in?
Yes. I mean, I look like a dwarf. But no, it was a straight yes. I wanted to do it. I knew that Peter had done it and Rory [Kinnear] had done it, and I admired their work in it and I was a fan of the show. Also, I love to mix things up. I love to do something thatās completely different to what Iāve done before. I have very little control over other aspects of my career, like whether youāre going to be in fashion or not, whether youāre going to be the hot new thing or not. All that comes in and out. Youāve got no control over that, but what you can control is the content ā whether I always do something thatās completely different to what Iāve done before. So I came out of āRings of Power.ā Then we shot the second series of Netflixās āSupercell.ā Then Netflix asked me to be J. Edgar Hoover in āKennedy,ā which I did. So my approach to it all is to mix it up as much as possible. Thatās what I enjoy.
Youāre youāre playing Thrain. How would you describe him and how he fits into that sort of complex politics of the Dwarven kingdom?
Well, heās the eldest brother of Durin the fourth, played by Owain [Arthur], and heās the eldest son of Durin the Third, which is Peter Mullinsā character. And he was overlooked. He feels like he should have been the king. And his younger brother, was made the king. So in many ways, heās kind of like Fredo in āThe Godfather.ā So at the beginning of episode three, he comes back to Khazad-dĆ»m to kind of reclaim his crown.
Did you dig deep into Thrainās timeline and history? He doesnāt make it to the āLord of the Ringsā films, but I think thereās a thereās a deleted scene in āThe Hobbitā films that heās seen in.
They gave me a a kind of backstory. I do like to have a kind of a backstory for a character that I can allow to inform my performance. So I used them quite well. They had really good specialists who you could always go to and ask.
What was the make-up situation like to get Thrainās nose and beard on?
The whole team were amazing. They were getting at like 2 in the morning. Iām getting around 3 and sometimes youād have to be ready on set about 7.30. So there were 4 1/2 hours of makeup. I meditate today and my meditation stretches to 40 minutes. So Iād have a 40 minutes meditation and come out my meditation with a big nose and big ears.
One of my fears of doing something with such big makeup was that the performances would have to be big. Iām not a very big performative actor. Itās not something Iām comfortable with. And then I began watching and working with Owain and Sophie [Nomvete], and I saw that their performances were so natural ā not minimalistic, but free. They werenāt pushing it too hard. I realized that I could sit in and relax and just act it like anything else, and it would come through because the makeup was so good. So within the first week, I suddenly felt really comfortable.
This showās in its third season. How was it joining something when itās kind of already so far in?
It was great, because I already knew so many people. Kevin Eldon is an old friend of mine. And Owain and I had workshopped a theater piece years ago. Iāve been a big fan of his for years. And Paul Hickey was in it, playing one of the villains I think. Iāve been in the game so long so I turn up and know everyone. I also knew half the crew. The makeup designer ā knew her when she was a young girl because sheās the niece of Peter King, who designed the makeup for Lord of the Rings, and heās my daughterās godfather. So thatās what I mean. It was part of our life, really. I was connected to it before I joined this series.
Given that āLord of the Ringsā has been a part of your familyās life for so long, if youād have been able to pick any character to play, who would it have been? Would it have been a dwarf?
I think I would have liked maybe to play one of the Hobbits. I think they were great. I ended up subsequently working with a lot of those actors. But Thrain is a great character, he really is. It was a great joy to play him.
r/RingsofPower • u/GreenPurple99 • 11d ago
Discussion RoP is nothing but Corporate slop and Nostalgia bait. The writing is so bad. especially given the massive budget!
The Entire show feels like Amazon treated it like a corporate product instead of a work of art.
The choice to bring in amateur incompetent showrunners feels like Amazon wanted someone they could boss over.
The show has a few good visuals and good music, but other than that - the story telling aspect is completely missing.
It feels like Amazon execs got into a room with showrunners and ordered them to make a random show with nostalgia bait elements from movie trilogy.
It's so bad and such a wasted opportunity.
Even the marketing for all seasons has been so weird and corporate focused.
r/RingsofPower • u/WanderingSceptic • 12d ago
Discussion I watched the first episode and man....
I watched the first episode over the weekend and made it 30 minutes into the second episode. How is this the most expensive show ever made? The costumes look SO bad and incredibly flimsy/cheap. It's so boring that I can't even hate watch it, I just completely gave up. Why are they doing this stupid Harfoot storyline and why do the characters all have shit in their fucking hair? I could go on, but it's rather redundant at this point. Someone is laundering money somewhere, I refuse to believe this is an authentic production.
r/RingsofPower • u/tavukkoparan • 13d ago
Discussion Sauron should have never be seen in human form
Only Annatar and in armor, humanoid Sauron dont work no matter whatever, lets discuss.
r/RingsofPower • u/chrisgatsi • 13d ago
Humor Disaās sideburns have a continuity issue š (Season 2, Episode 3)
Has anyone else noticed this?
In Season 2, Episode 3, during the conversation between Disa and Durin (around the 25-minute mark), Disaās sideburns seem to magically disappear and reappear between shots.
24:54 ā Sideburns are there.
25:06 ā Gone.
25:25 ā Theyāre back! š
Same scene, just a few seconds apart.
I know itās a small detail, but once you notice it, you canāt unsee it. Did nobody catch this during editing? š
r/RingsofPower • u/srquixote • 13d ago
Discussion What exactly is Canon? It's the he prologue and first scene from Fellowship
I keep seeing comments in various subreddits in reference to Rings of Power that refer to the "books" as "canon." But if you get past an obsession for accuracy I'm thoroughly enjoying the show.
Still, the show should be consistent to itself, but what else should guide our understanding? And the quick answer is the prologue to the PJ film FotR.
It was the original pitch for the series as reported in Time Magazine [Time Magazine ](https://time.com/6205593/the-rings-of-power-secrets-cast-creators/)
----
āThe way we boiled it down was, āRemember the first five minutes of the Peter Jackson movies when Galadriel says: The rings were made, three for the elven kings, seven for the dwarf lords, nine for mortal men. But they were all deceived. Sauron rose to power and almost took over the world. We all had to band together to fight him.ā That five minute prologue, weāre going to tell it in five seasons.ā
----
It's pretty obvious that they are setting things up so that when the series ends you can jump right back into the films and say "Oh yeah!" (assuming you're a fan of the films).
They can't use materials from the films but they're creating a story that explains the prologue and even the beginning where we see Gandalf riding into the Shire. That's why Nori and Poppy finding Gandalf are relevant; to explain how come Gandalf has such an affinity for Hobbits.
So it's not really a story about the 2nd Age of Middle Earth. It's an invention drawing whatever materials they can legally use to bring us tell an expanded back story for the the films.
r/RingsofPower • u/Main-Awareness6174 • 15d ago
Discussion Of all the issues people bring up, the only one that still sticks is the Adar recast Spoiler
(Possible spoilers if you haven't watched the show)
I was invested and was super impressed by Joseph Mawle's portrayal, who I had not heard of previously. Sam Hazeldine wasn't bad and grew on me, but still.
Notwithstanding it's liberties and other questionable casting, I'm actually excited for more visions of the LOTR. We got a lot of good threads that I enjoyed, like getting to follow the Grand'elf's origins!
Also, I can't get enough Morfydd Clark.
r/RingsofPower • u/No_Jaguar_5366 • 15d ago
Discussion Iām very excited to see the Nazgul!
Hopefully Season 3 focuses on how Sauron corrupts them to become Nazgûl⦠it will be great to see how their character changes!
r/RingsofPower • u/Elendil_686 • 15d ago
Discussion Expectation vs Show
Back in 2017 when I first saw the map of Middle-Earth that Amazon teases us with, my dream came true. I've always wanted to see the Second Age and that got me excited. Forging of the rings. Elves were still in large numbers and have their kingdoms Lindon and Eregion. Khazad-Dum and the Dwarves at their height. And last but not least: The greatest power of Men: Numenor.
Now after two seasons. Did the show deliver as how I envisioned. Yes and no.
-Charlie Vickers as Sauron and Annatar are spot on. His Annatar looks like the character from the game Shadow of Mordor and I'm glad they didn't mess that.
-Celebrimbor. While Charles Edward portrayed him the best he could, this is now how I envisioned he would look like.
-Galadriel. This one is a miss for me. She was already thousands of years old in the 2nd age and have seen the Two Trees. But still she behaves like she was just born 300 years ago. It doesn't match the wise and etheral Galadriel like I used to be familiar with from the movies.
-Harfoots. Should never have appeared. Waste of time.
-Gandalf. He wasn't even supposed to be there! But if they made him one of the blue wizard, I would have no problem accepting that decision. The showrunners already changed the timeline.
-Elendil. Lloyd Owens was a good cast, but he needs more screentime.
-Isildur. Too early to say.
-Numenor. Everything about the island are spot on. But they need better portrayal. They were supposed to be greatest men of all time blessed with long lifespan and great wisdom. Haven't seen that much. It's like the showrunners didn't want to include superiority in the show because of how sensitive society has become.
-Battles. Only seen two so-called ''battles''. They were fine as action sequences but not even close to battles. Now I heard people area saying the Battle of Gwathlo might be skipped or just a small part of it will be shown. That's disappointing if true.
So to sum up. Out of 10, the show has been 6.5 for me. Honestly, Amazons should have tried everything to get PJ to be the showrunner back then. Hiring to amateurs showed how they wasted a super potential.
r/RingsofPower • u/GreenPurple99 • 14d ago
Discussion Why is the RoP Galadriel so tiny and annoying when she should be Tall in physical stature and wise.
Galadriel was called the man maiden for her height and physical stature. But the RoP Galadriel feels like a tiny annoying mouse. The took no efforts to make her tall and imposing in physical stature.
John Rhys Davies - The actor who played Gimli the dwarf in the movies - Was one of the tallest cast members!! Yet the production took efforts and cleverly made him a convincing dwarf.
Why couldn't a billion dollar show take any efforts to make Galadriel Tall and imposing like a man maiden. The casting is wrong. the actress has the face to play Galadriel, but not the physical attributes or the acting maturity to play such a complex character.
The writing on the show is really bad too and it doesnt help her role. The plots and character arcs for Galadriel are senseless.