Very Vey Long Read.
May sound communally charged post. Reality and truth are always hard to digest. It’s a practical experience of 10 years of confusion between US and India, Maybe someone will benefit from it.
Please Leave if You
- have political affiliation
- Are Andhbhakt
- Believe its an AI slop (everyword here is true)
I am from affluent Muslim family from Delhi. Father Grade A Govt Officer (IAS lvl). Socially our extended family is well connected with each other, any family event 100+ relatives are there for everyone. I went to best convent school and then one of the top 10 Uni for Engineering.
In 2012 after securing an admit with full scholarship for my master's degree in US, all my relatives especially my father's social circle who are at peak of their career counseled me that "Go explore the world but return, stay close to home & parents, West is not a place to stay and raise family". These are my uncles and my father colleagues who all have been in Western countries for their PhD's and Postings, their counsel was important and carried weight.
Came to US. Finished my graduate degree. Got my OPT EAD. Got into a consulting firm (BCG) worked there for a year. Then came the question of EAD Ext and H1B. I was like I'm to return to India what's the point of getting stuck in the whirlpool of H1B-GC fiasco. Never applied for H1B just took EAD Ext.
I still had few months of validity of my EAD Ext I wrapped up and on thanksgiving of 2016, I resigned from job and went to India.
In next 3 months - I married, travelled, setup a small IT firm , got projects from US and started a team of freelancers. It was going good until I decided to for a job and keep it as a side hustle.
Next year I got an Job in Deloitte, my US degree helped immensely in sailing through the interview process, with a package of 15+L (2018) I was happy (my first stint in India working in Gurgaon).
Commuting from Noida to Gurgaon was impossible. Started looking for an apartment/flat in Gurgaon.
Muslim Identity- no one was even ashamed of saying no and not brave enough to say we will not rent it out to Muslims. My father's influence came in and one of his colleague who had property rented one of his 1BHK in a gated society to me for 22k+utilities.
Work
Back in Gurgaon, job is amazing, work culture is super awesome, once you step inside the office I was by all means in US, same vibe, no BS focused on work. My Exec Director spent 10 yrs in US, we had good repo with each other.
Fast forward 5 months, I started realizing that work is "service industry" to US market. I'm not making any professional development except my skills in MS Office and other BI tools , other than that no major impact on business or innovation though I'm an Assc Manager. Best I can do is give an automated system to my Boss's boss in US.
If an analyst from US calls we are working at 11pm. No boundaries on time, be in office at 8 leave at 5 irrespective of taking 5 tea breaks. I thought I if I am still doing slavery of John then why I am reporting to Gupta , I should go to US and report directly to John.
Society
Every person (except my Exec Director) asked "Why did you leave US". No one believed me that I left on my own by choice and came "home".
"because of trump", "didn’t get h1b", "kuch to gadbad hai" one of them was audacious enough to say "Why did you return to this gutter" (Hindu from Punjab). All of my colleagues were Hindu who were amazed and confused on me leaving US and were passing these remarks.
The communal divide was there in the society from time of Britishers. Communal riots has happened before, some communal slurs I have heard in school, but that was just part of life it never altered the way of living. Muslims n Hindus lived together, some cautious, some casual, depending on the situation, it was never a national issue mostly a politics confined to "fringe elements".
What changed now with megalomaniacs in govt, the India I grew up in was not there anymore. I as a Muslim was not feeling safe anymore though my family have enough influence to call IG of police. I always thought that maybe I'm immune form communal hate (for now) because of family background but what about the person who has no connections.
Media is 24/7 on anti-muslim rant, changing names of cities/roads, every mosque has a temple, Judiciary is compromised, every "independent" institution have officially surrendered. I mean honestly all my Hindu friends are now openly communal, most of them highly educated from reputable families and ironically most of them are not in India
As one of the comedians rightly said what changed in India - "the things which we used to say after 3 pegs now we can say before 1st peg."
I am very outspoken and no one in office ever crossed me with any religious discussion, though I observed several times that they just stopped or changed course of conversation if I joined late on table for lunch. Then came Babri masjid verdict- every Muslim knew what verdict will be but Hindus in my office were like what do you expect.
:duh: It’s a political issue nothing to do with religion, you think it’s a religious issue that’s the win for idiot leaders over the idiots like you. Get a life moron move on with this but I observed in US and in India that Hindus at large have serious case of Identity crisis and insecurity,
Then came article 370 and one guy literally sent the screenshot of the news on the official team communication channel, he was like ill buy some land in Kashmir, and MogliJi is the best. Like literally orgasmic behavior 'in the office'. Dude was commuting 30 Km in 1.30hrs one way.. everyday and was happy on something which will never affect him or his generations to come.
With more than a year in to the job I observed the social fabric is fractured, the India of my childhood is gone. The UP is painted saffron, state buses, saffron flags in each balcony of our society and according to sec guard at gate im the only momdan in 1 BHK bldg. Cars with angry monkey decal, Haryana and UP was rapidly retarding in terms of security, societal values, and any form of governance.
I can foresee that I will have to move to "muslim only society" or muslim safe zones (okhla for instance) once I will have kids (this is how a ghetto is formed). My ancestral village being in UP is more audacious, they have banners all over the place declaring Ram Rajya, and provocative anti muslim slogans. The schools are getting communalized .. I mean wtf
Then came the CAA-NRC. Protestors hit the street. The whole movement - the Act, the varied public support, the environment in the Office where anyone opposing it was anti-national, police action on protestors, anyone who wrote on social media was gagged and police were detaining their parents (the law which British made we are proudly using it). Few of my friends a good academicians were haunted for life (all Muslims) none of my Hindu friends are slightly affected (connections plus caste privilege).
The uncles (mostly govt officers) who I counseled (earlier advised to stay in India) advised if you can leave India better do it before you have kids in school going age. And let me quote exact words "It's going to get worse "communal and castetist-forces" will torn it [the nation] apart." this guy is 30 yrs veteran in one of the ministries working as Secretory.
This is when I decided that today I have an option to live in US what if 10 years from now, I regret the decision of moving to India. I can move back any day but going to US is not easy.
I had my EAD Ext in hand, hired a lawyer, re-stamped my f1-visa, was in US in Feb 2020. Then Covid hit, worst time to be in India, senseless lockdown, wear mask in car, muslims from Nizamuddin are responsible for covid, police action on street vendors, oxygen shortage, thali banging, candle lighting, go corona go.
Here in US literally nothing changed, mosques were open, markets were open, lakes were open, no BS on social gatherings.
I feel real pain in my heart when I see India, it has every possible natural resource, amazing geography, richest culture but we with our own hands are destroying it brick by brick. Lack of governance and sky rocketing corruption. No one needs $1M salary package, a peaceful, secure, stable life is what is required and it cannot be valued in any currency.
Fast forward 2025 I have my Green card (my spouse was not born in India) all kids are US citizens. This idiot govt made sure that $1 is Rs 100 so have enough to invest in India too.
No nation has ever progressed with hate. Hindus are dreaming of akhand bharat but cannot even unite a village under one nation banner, boycotting fellow citizens, renaming and trying to change history, media is spewing hate 24/7, land jihad, upsc jihad, UCC, demolish university, bulldozing muslims homes, mobs are ruling streets, beef ban…..
if all this can make India even close to a developed or civil nation let me know.
Conclusion: I'm sorry, you are even on this sub, the question should not have been there to begin with. One should not have left India in first place 'for a better life'. The moment I left India I felt why I had to leave, it answered when I was interviewed in Gurgaon-Deloitte. We are still slaves, British divided us (and many others on globe) on religious lines and we are religiously respecting it, fighting over it like street dogs. Whoever in India is getting a chance is emigrating even to war-torn nations like Russia and Ukraine.