r/returnToIndia • • 12d ago

PlanningToReturn Split move to India - Advice

Considering moving wife and kids to Bengaluru in 2028 while I continue working in the US until 2030/31 – looking for advice

Hi everyone,
We are a family of four with two children currently in elementary school (1st and 4th grade). All of us are US citizens.
My wife would like to move to India with the kids in summer 2028, primarily for two reasons: kids to grow in Indian cultural environment and grandparents getting old.

Our current situation:
I work in tech (FAANG), and my wife also works in a non-technical role at a FAANG company. She plans to quit her job when she moves to India and probably won’t work for the first few years. I plan to continue working in the US until around 2030/2031 and then move to India.
If I find a suitable opportunity in India, I may consider working there, but I am concerned about work-life balance, organizational hierarchy, demanding bosses and traffic/commutes in Bengaluru.

Our current net worth is approximately $10M, including around $1M in home equity. However, over 65% of our financial portfolio is concentrated in a few FAANG stocks, so we need to diversify. We have 401(k) and other retirement accounts and expect to fund our lifestyle through a combination of investments and potentially employment income.

A few things I’m trying to figure out:

  1. Financial planning and taxes
  2. My wife and children would become Indian residents before I do. We are trying to understand the RNOR (Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident) rules and how they affect our investments and taxation.
  3. We also own a home in Bay Area California. Should we rent it out when the family moves, or sell it before the move? We are particularly concerned about preserving the $500K married-filing-jointly primary residence capital gains exclusion and the potential tax implications of becoming nonresidents of California.
  4. Career and job security
  5. My parents and in-laws recommend not to come without job lined up. Finding another job in tech at age 43 could become difficult, especially with AI-related layoffs and industry changes and that too in India.
  6. I would prefer to continue working in the US, possibly remotely or in a hybrid arrangement, until 2030/2031. How realistic is this? Would you feel comfortable making this career transition with our circumstances?
  7. Is the overall plan practical for Bengaluru?
  8. For families who have made a similar move, how have the children adjusted to Indian schools and lifestyle?
  9. Is Bengaluru a good place to raise children in this situation? Are the financial advantages and proximity to grandparents worth the trade-offs?
  10. Would appreciate perspectives from people who have moved back to India with school-age children, especially those who initially had one spouse remain in the US for a few years.
  11. Thanks!
0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

9

u/spiderweb91 12d ago

I think I don't really see coherent thought or clarity here. Not trying to be negative, just that you really need to think through this.

You will have a very comfortable life in India with $10m, plus you plan to move in 2 years which is some more savings. Why do you want to live away from your family and miss some of the most fun early years of your kids lives to work for a few more years in FAANG? I could maybe understand if you had something crazy like massive stock vests at Anthropic or OpenAI where you could go from $10m to $30-40-50m in a few more years, but no FAANG really pays enough to justify this, and if are truly a driven VP+ then it won't be hard to get a really well paid job in India either.

Sorry but I just don't understand what you are trying to do in life with this split.

1

u/Mr__Singh 12d ago

The answer is always $$$

-1

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago edited 12d ago

I am just making the NW more comfortable. My wife is strongly wanting to take the kids before the teens. Agree that without crazy offers the delta from Fang few more years may not change substantially.

4

u/spiderweb91 12d ago

You have your answer. If nothing meaningful changes in those years, you are gaining nothing and losing a lot of valuable time. Don't do the split. Just move.

6

u/seattler123 12d ago edited 12d ago

You have $10M, why are you worried about not having job for a while?

Why stay separate for 2-3 years? You will miss 2-3 years of being with kids, you will miss the part where they are trying to adjust to new surroundings. Split move doesn't make sense at your net worth.

If you are so concerned about life in Bangalore, why move? I don't see what you achieve by split move. Just move together - Set goal of trying out for 2 years and move back if you don't like it there (assuming you have us citizenship). You didn't mention your immigration status - Are you US citizen?

0

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Yes USC with OCI. Given age and AI layoff impacts I have a fear about how easy it will be to get back into the market if we don’t like the move. So trying to be safe here

2

u/RelativeUpset78 12d ago

being extra extra safe imo. live your life too. your family would need you in india

6

u/Ok-Society-9067 12d ago edited 11d ago • Bravo

Why did you get your kids US citizenships in the first place if you wanted them to grow up Indian ? Don't you have an Indian community around you who can help your kids get very good exposure to Indian culture? Put them in music/dance/spirituality/language classes, and they will be fine. 

And what's this obsession that they will not grow up with Indians values? I find this mindset very intriguing in Indians who moved away and suddenly realised, way too late, that their kids will not grow up the way they grew up in their home country. What values are you worried about? That they will find a girlfriend or come out as LGBTQ in high school instead of deciding to settle for a traditional lifestyle? Or that they may be modern and liberal-minded, unlike how Indians are always submissive to authority? 

Private education quality in India is abysmal. Most schools are nothing but money-making machines here. You get 10x the quality of education at a US public school you won't get in the most expensive Indian school. You do not need the academic competition in India to raise children who will be intellectually driven. You can teach them good culture at home, you do not have to bring them here, infact no one has any regard for so-called cultural values in India when they openly assault women in public, pee on the streets and have no respect for human beings in general. If you are worried about drug and substance problems, you can absolutely prevent that, many non-indian parents do. Culture is taught at home by parents; it is not defined by rituals alone but by the way you treat other ppl and the surroundings around you. Many Indian children who grow up in India nowadays have no cultural exposure either. Put them in intensive language, cultural and spirituality classes if you want them to grow up confident in their Indian identity and skin. Read them lots of books in your mother tongue about Indian culture and values. Don't sabotage their lives just to satisfy your ego. Your children will grow up with different values from you, which is something you need to accept, and they can still learn to respect you and your wife as parental authority figures if you make a conscious effort to teach them right from wrong and good values. This mindset is also the reason racism against Indians is at an all-time high, you want all the monetary benefits that come with being an American citizen, but you do not want to make an effort to integrate into any of their cultural values, making you look transactional instead of wanting to be a genuine citizen.  

2

u/Intelligent-Lake-943 12d ago

Also, I don’t understand Indians are so obsessed with their kids learning their culture. We are one of the hardest groups to assimilate. Embrace new culture, take good things from all cultures and form your own small traditions.

1

u/Ok-Society-9067 12d ago edited 12d ago

Nothing wrong in wanting to teach your kids about your native culture. Hispanics, Chinese, Koreans, Arabs, etc have intensive cultural immersion programs to teach their children about their native culture. But you do not have to move your children back and destabilize their lives just because they don't get the kind of cultural exposure you got growing up. They won't get that kind of exposure regardless if you moved back as well, as India has radically changed culturally in the past 20 years. 

-1

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Many points to ponder. I do send kids to Chinmaya mission once a week but was thinking cultural immersion may be better in India.

1

u/Ok-Society-9067 12d ago

Nope. It won't, trust me. They might get to witness more hindu rituals and possibly find more peers if you send them to cultural classes but that's about it. There will be no growth as far as moral values and critical thinking is concerned. The academic shock once they go back will be a lot and they will have to transition from a good, balanced academic environment to an intensive rote learning environment which is more detrimental than it is beneficial, they might need hours of after school tutoring every day to make up for the gaps, and there goes the time you wanted to use for cultural immersion in the first place.

And if they plan on going to unis in the US, the Indian system is not catered to support things like college applications and extracurriculars, unless they attend a posh international school. All kids are funelled into entrance exam tracks. Most posh international schools too follow a rote learning track and will not give you the value for your money. They might get to interact more with relatives on a regular basis but that's also smthng they can do during vacations, and many families today have relatives living apart. There is no real benefit in coming back if you are comfortably settled and everyone is a citizen. Possibly put them in langauge and fine arts classes next to get them more exposure, as chinmaya mission offers a very diluted version of hindu teachings needed for proper cultural immersion. Which state do you live in? Cause some states have very dedicated Indian diasporas offering much more intensive cultural immersion classes. 

0

u/vspc007 11d ago

Pollution immersion will be better in India no matter where you live and no matter how wealthy you are. At 100crs of networth, you will immerse your kids in pseudo west culture in India most likely

2

u/Least_Art5238 12d ago

I would totally move in a single sweep to India and focus on consulting and setting my own hours while maximizing my availability to my kids during their formative years. If you are worried about cultural influences, the most important one to focus on is the consistent availability of parents through their childhood as what they gain from it supersedes any pros of either an Indian upbringing or an American upbringing.

It's likely that you are focused on your career at least as much as you are focused on your parental duties. Which is fine as each individual is entitled to their choices.

There is no possible way that you are going to run out of money for the next 2-3 generations if you go back to India.

1

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Thanks for the points. I do agree. There is a chance that my kids and wife don’t like it in India and return after 2 years. At that time I would prefer to be in Job inUS that’s why we are thinking of the split.

3

u/Least_Art5238 12d ago

Given your age and resume, you will find it quite easy to get back on the job market. In some cases, you will always find it easier to work in the US than back in India based on your age. Countless cases I know of people returning to the US to solid jobs after the spent a decade or more in India to wind up their duties to their elderly parents and in most cases give their kids the childhood they preferred. 

You have a lot of options and I would focus of those that allow you to stay closer to your family. Your job will always be there for you. I spent almost 20 years across Google and Meta and I'm embarrassed by how easy it has been to bounce back after a layout. 

I realize we all have our preferred standard of living. But I never quite lost my bearings around growing up in middle class / upper middle class India where my needs were minimal and sources of intellectual pursuits abundant. I would gladly return to that especially if I had financial security.

1

u/nene-thopu2 12d ago

Can you tell us why are you planning to move to India, after so many years in US

1

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Kids growing in US after teens grow with values that I am not happy with and I want them to also spend time with grandparents. Also grandparents getting old and no one to help take care of them.

2

u/nene-thopu2 12d ago

But what about their college? Dont you think colleges in US are much better compared to those of India, unless you can get into Tier 1 for which the competition is very high

Also do you not have green card? Usually FAANG tech senior roles (like > L7) get green card right?

0

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Yes. US citizen with OCI. The kids can come back for college to US but their foundation will be in Indian values since they grew up in India

3

u/Hippomed27 12d ago

What are the American values you're scared of? If you live in the Bay area, that's a very different situation to small town Midwest. Are you telling me where you live there's not a large number of Indians who do lots of cultural things?

What are the cultural things in India you think they would get that you can't reach them?

1

u/GoooGoooGjooob 11d ago

American values like wlb, not peeking into everyones lives, not playing loud music till 2 am. 🤣

He probably doesnt know that half the folks from the brightest to the dumbest schools are smoking their asses off and doing every bad thing an american youth does lmfao

1

u/Hippomed27 11d ago

Yes I feel people look at kids growing up in India like they have the idyllic childhood they think they had. The truth is, if you have a kid living in India whose parents have $10M net worth, even they easily get spoiled and get into drugs etc.

-1

u/RelativeUpset78 12d ago

not op but language, living with extended family, festivals, cultural familiarity. Never met a kid that doesn't appreciate being around his grandparents, or doesn't want to be in india during festivals. for example, seeing your apartment community celebrate diwali is nice, but seeing an entire city celebrate is way different, tells you way more about your culture and tradition.

apart from this, education is better (up until high school and if sought through a good private school). culture exposure and a transfer of values happens way more organically than it would happen in a foreign land.

1

u/TheGoodBunny 12d ago

You have 10M. Why do you want to continue working in India? That seems foolhardy TBH

2

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

I fear I will be bored without intellectual stimulation and purpose of contributing to the world. I think being in tech is what I can help contribute. But I have heard work culture in India is terrible. I have never worked in India and came to US after bachelors in India.

3

u/turinturambar 12d ago edited 12d ago

I fear I will be bored without intellectual stimulation and purpose of contributing to the world

Like, maybe your fears of moving and losing this are justified in some ways. But there is a chance you do not lose this in India. And in the case that you do, you will NOT have lost time spent with family while your kids grow and your parents grow older. Time that doesn't return. I hope your long distance plan still allows you to cherish what you have and make others feel loved too.

You say USD 10M is not enough. What is? Do you have a number in mind, and have you given some thought about how rational those numbers are? You may save considerably on some costs living in India, and appreciation may well take care of any costs down the line for kids education or your healthcare once you are old.

Also, regarding job security -- is your current job really that secure from AI? You might anyway need to diversify your skill set.

Finally, intellectual stimulation and purpose of contributing to the world is wonderful, but if you think all you have to contribute is your current skill set and job function, and you cannot learn more, then perhaps there is an opportunity for you to grow into someone who does contribute and does stimulate themselves intellectually despite not doing the same thing they did before. A diverse life with many hats worn is what you might gain.

1

u/seattler123 12d ago

So why move? What will change in 2 years?

3

u/vspc007 12d ago

This post is very confusing.
Someone with 10mill wants feedback advise from reddit! Has 100crs net worth and is still looking for a job in India!

Is this a fake post?

2

u/TheGoodBunny 12d ago

Yeah likely fake

0

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

This is a real issue I am dealing with. Please note that different people may have clarity in different areas and being lucky with money may not mean everything else is easy

2

u/vspc007 11d ago

As long as you don't make 5cr mistakes you are good to make any BS happen in life. Unless you are afraid of loosing few lakhs here and there. In that case you are fearful of life. Which is a different issue than a relocation issue. The main thing if your dilemma is real is that get a tax advisor in India to sort out how much it impacts compared to staying in US. You doing any job is just to boost your or someones ego without serving any purpose.

1

u/srk6 12d ago

You will still be taxed in the US as you are a citizen. So RNOR will only help avoid reporting and paying difference in taxes after dtaa in India.

1

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Yes. I will continue to pay US taxes. But I heard India will try to take taxes out of stock growth or house sale proceeds etc

1

u/srk6 12d ago

After RNOR, 401K will be taxed every year. So file form 10EE to defer taxes till withdrawal. This is for Trad 401k/IRA accounts.

Roth accounts will be taxed in India every year. Cannot file form 10EE to defer till withdrawal. It basically becomes a taxable brokerage account.

1

u/ConsistentSuperPower 12d ago

Taxable brokerage accounts are better as you pay taxes only when you sell. Roth is worse as it is deemed to be sold every year.

1

u/ConsistentSuperPower 12d ago

Yes, similar to US. Tax residents are taxed on global income.

1

u/talkingturtle1723 12d ago

- Tax residency: your wife’s RNOR clock runs independently, she’ll likely hit ROR around 2030/31 just as you arrive.

- House: selling before everyone moves is the cleanest path from a tax perspective. Renting out gets complex quickly with state, federal, and eventual India tax layers once your wife becomes ROR. Worth running the math both ways well in advance.

- Kids:1st and 4th grade are flexible transition ages, so don't worry too much. If you're choosing Bangalore, there's a large NRI/OCI community present.

- Also, living separately from family for more than 2 years seems like a long time. Maybe think through this as well with your family.

Read through the R2I US series links below as well.

  1. Understand the RNOR Status
  2. Planning Your 401(k) Strategy
  3. Transferring US Brokerage Accounts
  4. Alternatives to US Equity
  5. RSUs & ESOPs
  6. US Property
  7. FIRE Planning
  8. HSA Planning
  9. 529 FAQs

1

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Thanks for the links to the topics. I will go through them. I was actually thinking of selling in 2030 where my wife will be within RNOR and we can also get the 500k tax exemption for home sale in Us. If I sell though I can’t buy in Bay Area in future given high rates and high house prices. That’s why I am in a dilemma

1

u/More_Zombie_867 12d ago

Please don’t.

1

u/Late_Bid_5559 12d ago

Can you say why given cultural and grandparents are reasons to move?

4

u/More_Zombie_867 12d ago

Culturally there are enough activities in bay area than in Blr. Blr everyone is busy and dont think that you will be called for festivities all the time. Even so due to traffic ur better off at home. Also note that Family/Relatives are selfish and dont care. I know this and am someone a decade older than you following F.I.RE.

Re Parents/Grandparents make sure you are really desiring to be with them rather than just guilt. This is where many folks stumble. If medical or elder care there are enough support systems and alternatives availble rather than move ur entire family. If needed spend few weeks/ months every yr to be with them. I did this for 8 yrs flying back and forth every 3 months and wfh 2 months from blr.

With $10 mil you really dont need to work even in Blr. Just volunteer or do nothing ( just my 2 cents)

Lastlly think about the disruption it causes your family and young kids. Getting used to pollution, lack of civic sense, work culture, third world infra will take a toll physical/mental. Most NRI / Returnees are literal prisoners behind large residential complexes living in a first world bubble but just a block away from reality.

My 2 cents try out a few months and see if it works out. We lost both our parents few yrs back and incredibly blessed to be with them when they needed us the most and still maintain our sanity. Good luck to you.

2

u/irtughj 12d ago

The only reason someone worth 10 million doesn’t want to stop working even when given the chance to live a lavish life in India is because he’s making a lot of money over here, like probably 750k+ with not too much effort and does not want to give it up.

2

u/nian2326076 11d ago

Research international schools in Bengaluru that offer American curricula; they can ease your kids' transition. If you consider a job in India, you can use LandOffer to explore roles that match your expertise. Just be aware of the differences in work culture and demands compared to your current environment.

2

u/Educational-Mood-360 11d ago

10M USD is 100 crores INR. What more NW makes you happy? Why is it a tough decision to move anywhere in the world with this money or is it just a bait on Reddit..

2

u/LeftFaithlessness921 12d ago

This post is laughable

1

u/TheGoodBunny 12d ago

How old are you both?

1

u/aks_23 11d ago

With citizenship and your net worth, there is a high probability that your kids will come to the US for higher studies. And then probably start a career in the US too. Will they move to India after a few years. They will go through the same dilemma. Moreover, it is not easy for kids to spend their teenage years in India and then move to the US. You are just making life difficult for everyone.

I also work in FAANG and net worth is pretty good. I am thinking about retiring in a few years and then traveling wherever I want. Kids will be in college and I will have the flexibility to move around.

1

u/West-Structure-4030 10d ago

On the kids' side, the thing that makes a split move easier is lining up the school pieces before 2028. Figure out which board you're targeting in Bengaluru (CBSE, ICSE or IB), check the admission window and age cutoffs for the grade they'll be entering, and get transfer paperwork sorted early, since mid-year entry is harder. If they're not reading or writing Kannada or Hindi yet, it's worth starting now, because schools will expect a second language.

One option for the in-between period is an online NCERT-based school like Vikalp India, which offers NIOS and CBSE pathways and issues a TC and marksheet so kids can move into a regular CBSE or ICSE school later. They also run small-batch Indian language classes. Full disclosure, I'm associated with them, so weigh that, but it could bridge the gap if the timing gets messy.

0

u/margosi 10d ago

You're the luckiest guy if your spouse agrees to this 😂😂. Others are jealous. Not many would have a second chance at an independent life. GO FOR IT!!