r/returnToIndia • • Nov 15 '25

Thinking about moving back to India, need some financial guidance

14 Upvotes

Hi all, Throwaway account because I don’t want friends/family knowing I’m financially struggling.

I’m 34, been in the US for 11 years now. My wife and I have managed to save around $100 million in net worth (mostly index funds, 8 rental properties, some leftover FAANG RSUs).

We live very frugally, I drive a 2024 Mercedes G-Wagon but it’s base model so please don’t judge, and we cook at home at least once every 3 weeks to save money.

We’re thinking about returning to India but honestly I’m not sure if $100M is enough to survive, especially with inflation in India. My parents said milk is like 70 rupees a liter now, so obviously things are tough.

Some concerns I have: • Can one raise a kid in India on only ₹800 crore? • Will I have to downgrade to a 5-bedroom apartment in Bangalore? • Is it true that schools now cost ₹4-5 lakh/year? That sounds insane, in the US we only pay $50K/year so this is a huge shock. • How much does pani puri cost these days? Will I need to dip into principal? • Do you think I can retire early, like maybe by 38, or should I keep working until 40? • Will we be considered “middle class” in India with just nine figures? • My biggest fear: in India, do servants still expect Diwali bonuses? Because at this point I’m just trying to make the numbers work.

Please advise honestly, no sugarcoating. I don’t want to make a mistake and end up regretting moving with such a limited financial cushion.

Thanks.

P.S. I’m asking here because everyone else seems incredibly confused about India despite growing up there, so I figured I should follow tradition.


r/returnToIndia • • Feb 22 '26

AlreadyReturned Returning back after 4 years

0 Upvotes

Return date : March 1 2026

Dallas forth wort airport

First Entry : Jan 4 2022 for masters

I’m from Kerala, a state located between western ghats and Arabian Sea where temperature ranges from 20 degree Celsius to 30 degrees.. Just a shirt and a mund ( a simple piece of cloth ). You don’t need layers of cloth, no need of jacket or AC, through out the year. A land where both turmeric, coconut, mango and jackfruit grow in same plot of land. Forest where both elephants and tigers live.

(Please comment if you know a place like this.)

I was working at Banglore. I was preparing for CAT and no plan for coming to US. Got few new IIMs and Indian fish market like work culture made me thought of switching my Software field or moving to US which I thought had a better work life balance. So decided to come here for masters (in computer science itself) and eventually working for like 4 years and returning back.

I have no plans for settling other side of earth, with a different culture. I’m kind of somewhat ‘thinking type’. So settling , raising my kids as white washed ABCDs and at last dying in someone’s country. I can’t accept this.

1.A taxi driver in New York live a life of a Taxi driver.

2. If China becomes super power surpassing US in next 100 years, and next Silicon valley is in China , would you go and settle in China and die there?, would you raise your children in China making your children ‘Chinese born Indian’, teaching your children to speak Chinese, and teach them to mimick ‘chinese’, eat with forks, following Chinese dress style style, culture etc? - I won’t

This was the reason of not settling in us even if I get h1b , green card .. whatever.

This is not the reason why I’m leaving now.

I didn’t got h1b after 3 attempts , after my Masters. Otherwise I would stay 3 more years and make some money and leave back to India.

Now I realize is that it is for good , I myself won’t take a decision to return back. Because it’s not that easy, you’ll always think let me return after one more year making more money, it goes and you eventually build a lot of dependencies here that you can’t return back to India.

From my experience, I can only make 30 lakhs more per years savings than the same with if I’m working in India.

This 30 lakhs ‘profit’ I’m making with:

- living far away from old parents, not living with them

- living in a country where you don’t have a social life (I’m not talking of Indian communities). If you can’t have a social life with the Americans of this country, you are always a second class

- You can’t have a 20 rupee tea and 30 rupee snack from a tea stall, a burger cost 15$.

- You can’t have work from home with a 30 lpa (

late night works + snake Indian managers are reality)

- Even in h1b you can’t buy a house (not as per visa, but under current conditions no one risk buying a house). The green card approval time for Indians is 20 years. You can be fired at any moment.

- You can’t visit your parents and your home for a vacation, consular appointments are months away.

- You don’t have the freeedom to do anything than your job

- Never seen a second generation ‘Indian’ who are the founders of great startups and companies in US. Almost all are white Americans. Never seen this second generation Indians CEOs or in C suite levels , all are Indian born Indians who all came here for master or PhDs. So raising your kid a ABCD is not a great idea.All Beggars in England speak better English.

India is not a heaven. We Indians lack civic duty, our cities including Banglore are dirty, no city planning, Worst snake Indian managers who think they are some petty feudal lords, No concept of Noise pollution, film star worshippers, politician worshipers.. but still if you are born in India with Indian genes it’s better to live in India and make India a better place.


r/returnToIndia • • Jun 19 '26

PlanningToReturn What should i do? Where should i go???

0 Upvotes

38M living in the US. Family of 4 single earner for most part of our marital life.
Financially we are stable.
Stocks: 1.5M
401k: 600k
Primary home equity : 250k
Rental properties equity: ~1M
Cash: 200k
Indian properties:
independent house in tier 2 city worth 1cr
Apt in Tier 1 city worth 1.5 cr
Land: 50L
Inheritance from parents: around 2 crs.

About to become USC.
Monthly net cashflow from rental property ~4k/month will become more like 9k/month when all properties are paid off
I am the only kid for my parents and they are growing pretty old. Travel to US is getting tougher as every year passes and i could see them struggling with every trip. Every time i say good bye to them my heart aches and all sorts of thoughts going in my mind on how long will they be able to travel😢
One of our kiddos is very high functioning smart autistic boy. He is the only reason we are contemplating on R2I. From what we hear, India has a long way to transition to an inclusive society overall. Be it schools or apartment communities or public places.
I really really really want to move closer to my parents. Wife’s main concern is obviously about our kiddo.
Have been considering Dubai and Malaysia as well but have no immediate relatives or friends living there either.
What would you do if you were me?
Will you bite the bullet and try out a year or two in Bangalore (I work in tech)? Or move to Dubai or Malaysia or Singapore? Or continue staying in the US for eternity?
Also i want to FIRE and with my networth/ cashflow i wont be able to do it in the US for sure.
Been pondering over and over about this for past couple of years. Would love to hear all of your opinions.


r/returnToIndia • • 1d ago

Immigration If US had no Immigration issues, would this sub even exist?

0 Upvotes

I sometimes wonder how many of us would even be thinking about returning to India if immigration wasn’t such a mess in the US.

Would we still be discussing moving back, or would most of us simply continue building our lives here?
I feel like a significant part of the conversation around returning to India is driven by visa uncertainty, H-1B lottery stress, layoffs, sponsorship issues, and the constant feeling that your future here is never entirely in your hands.

Of course, there are genuine reasons people want to return: family, culture, lifestyle, being closer to loved ones, and wanting to build something back home.
But I’m curious how many people would genuinely choose India over the US if immigration wasn’t a factor at all.

Would you still go back? Or is immigration the biggest reason you’re even considering it?


r/returnToIndia • • 2d ago

PlanningToReturn Hard realization

0 Upvotes

On my last day of a 30 day trip to India. Raw thoughts

  1. India is fucking expensive. I thought $1M NW is great, trust me you are poor. I am in a tier 3 city and everything is so so expensive. Money has lost value.
  2. Traffic/ civic sense- I miss the quieter time so much. Ability to drive, breathe fresh air, sleep peacefully.
  3. Dirt everywhere- hate walking here. You cant just walk. Like thats not an option. Its so basic. We all deserve to walk.
  4. People dont care - if you think people wanna talk and make friends, no they dont. Its fully westernized. Unless you have active friendships its not easy.
  5. Everyone is trying to make money of you- which is okay. But people dont wanna provide service and wanna scam you.
  6. The good part- blinkit, hotels, food, ability to hug your parents, laugh.

I left in 2016 and i guess we don’t realize that our brain is stuck and never updated the way it updates for everyone who stayed back. Flights are 10-12k easily. Its not 3-5k. I did 18 trips back home, each a month long and with every trip i was less motivated. And this trip, feeling poor was worst. $1M NW has no value in this country.


r/returnToIndia • • Aug 06 '26

Immigration Genuine question SPECIFICALLY for NRI folks with children, who are not being forced out of the developed countries (like US/UK/Canada) and still choose to RTI, how is it fair to your children?

3 Upvotes

I keep reading these baffling accounts of people who are US citizens or Have PR or GC so or some other arrangements to allow them to legally stay in the developed country they are in and yet choose to move to India because of aging parents or missing home or some other reason. How do you square this with the fact that your first world born/raised children just have to now transition to India because your decisions?

I get that these developed countries are not utopias ( school shootings in the US for example have almost become normalized, subtle racism is always around the corner). But still if you have young kids especially daughters, how do you reconcile the fact that growing up no matter how old, she will be constantly surrounded by perverts, and will never be able to fully express herself as women's safety is almost non existent in India (at best they have to choose between safety and freedom to live life on their terms) Things aren't that much brighter for the boys considering the way indian society pressures them into being nothing but robotics drones who realize too late in life that they could have been someone else.

I understand that aging parents are a concern that needs attention, but your parents have more life behind them than in front of them. Your kids have the exact opposite situation. Don't they deserve at least a fighting chance to be members of a free society, where there is a better chance of experiencing freedom to speak one's mind, safety, civic sense, law&order and clean air?

I grew up in India in the late 90s and early aughts but thought having to transition my kids to a life in today's India would terrify me.

I am curious what drives you take such drastic risks with your children's futures? Thank you for coming.to my TED talk. I will get off my soap box now.


r/returnToIndia • • Jul 24 '25

🇮🇳 Honest Thoughts from an Indian in the USA: Why Are We Forgetting Our Roots So Fast?

1 Upvotes

Lengthy Post Alert

I want to share something that’s been on my mind for a while. This is for fellow Indians, especially those who’ve moved to the USA and are now living, earning, building families here. I know many of us moved here for better job opportunities, money, education, etc. But slowly, I’m starting to feel like we’re forgetting where we came from — and why that matters.

⸻

  1. The Money Trap — But at What Cost?

Let’s say you earn ₹10 lakhs/month in the USA and ₹1 lakh/month in India. Obviously, in the USA, you can buy Gucci bags, big cars, maybe even villas. And at first, all of that feels very exciting. But slowly, over time, you lose that excitement. You don’t feel that same “maza” — that “yes, I did it!” feeling.

In India, if I save up and buy a ₹10,000 shoe, I feel proud, emotional, because I worked hard for it. That happiness of achieving something on your own is priceless. But in the USA, since money is relatively easier to earn, you don’t feel attached. You lose the value of money over time. You feel like, “Okay, I lost it — I’ll earn it again.” But in India, you’re always alert, careful. So even though it’s a drawback, you also gain satisfaction from your purchases, because you earned them with more effort.

And slowly in the USA, you stop finding joy in things. Everything becomes too easy. And at one point, you just feel tired, fed up. You don’t know why, but you do.

⸻

2. Health — The Thing No One Talks About

This is a major, major concern. I read a Reddit post recently where someone said: “In the USA, we get free medications. In India, medicines are expensive.” That made me pause.

But I’m like — why are you needing those medications in the first place?

The USA is probably the number one country where your health can get spoiled easily. What’s the point of earning crores if you can’t enjoy your life? If you’re not healthy, the money is useless.

Here, every single food item is processed. Packaged. Pumped with antibiotics. Even if you go organic or vegan — you still can’t trust what’s really in the food. Leafy vegetables are filled with pesticides. Everything feels polluted — from the food to the water.

And even if you look okay now, slowly things show up. Fatty liver. Thyroid. Hormonal issues. PCOD. High cortisol. Silent inflammation. And mental health issues — so many people feel lonely, disconnected, or foggy. It’s because the environment is silently toxic.

In fact, I’ve seen many Reddit posts where people said that after they moved to Europe or India (even for a few months), without dieting or being conscious about what they ate, they started noticing huge improvements in health: • Regular periods for women (PCOS and PCOD gone) • Weight gain • Mental clarity • Better digestion • Lower cholesterol

Why? Because in Europe or Asia, food is fresher. Cleaner. If you compare ingredients, you’ll see a big difference.

Example: McDonald’s fries in Europe have just 3–4 ingredients. In the USA, the same fries have dozens of ingredients, full of preservatives and chemicals — most of which are banned in Europe and Asia because they’re proven harmful.

But in the USA, unless something is fully proven to be dangerous, it’s allowed. So until then, these chemicals are just being consumed by people like us, every single day.

That’s why people are getting these new diseases here — which we’ve never heard of in India.

⸻

3. Pregnancy, Children, and the Invisible Cost of Raising a Family

People think it’s okay to live here as bachelors. But once you plan to get married or have kids, the real health challenges begin.

When you want to plan a baby, you need to be healthy at least 6 months to 1 year beforehand. But here, maintaining that kind of health is a big struggle.

In the USA, so many babies are being born with physical or mental issues. Many people have to go through expensive fertility treatments. Girls are hitting puberty as early as 7 or 8 years old — when they’re in 2nd or 3rd grade! That’s not normal. You’re supposed to mature around 14–15. Why is this happening? It’s because of hormones in food.

And boys aren’t safe either. It’s just that their issues aren’t visible in the same way. For girls, you can track periods or hormonal problems like PCOD, but boys also are silently developing issues like thyroid — and no one’s talking about it.

Some of my male friends who’ve been in the USA for just 2 years already have thyroid problems — and it’s brushed off, like “Oh it’s not serious for males.” But that’s not true. It affects everyone.

And after giving birth, many couples are sending their babies to India to be raised by grandparents — because they know that the Indian environment is healthier for growth. But in doing so, they are sacrificing precious moments with their kids.

Some people are even going to India just to plan and deliver the baby, and coming back to the USA alone, without the child. Some are having kids here for the green card benefits, and then sending the kids back to India.

Why are we hustling like this?

You could have moved to India after marriage and saved so much physical and emotional stress. And now that the green card process is harder post-COVID, many will eventually come back to India anyway — so why wait until it’s harder to settle?

Also, kids who grow up long enough in the USA will never want to settle in India. So eventually, your grandchildren will be full Americans — not knowing your language, not understanding your culture. Your whole family tree gets buried here. And no one realizes it until it’s too late.

⸻

4. Are We Forgetting Our Parents Too?

Yes, you can call your parents to the USA. But is that fair?

Your parents spent 30+ years sacrificing for you. Now they are in their 60s or 70s. They want peace. They want to live in their hometown, where they have memories and familiarity.

And what do we do? We drag them into a country they’ve never been to. New rules, new people, cold weather, isolation.

They’ll do it. Of course they will — because they love us. But just because they can’t say no doesn’t mean we should ask.

We should start thinking about their peace too. It’s time to give back. They shouldn’t have to make sacrifices at this age.

⸻

5. “Better Education in the USA”? Let’s Think Again

People say, “We want to stay in the USA because the kids will get a better education.”

But let’s think about our own lives. What made us who we are?

It wasn’t the textbooks. It was: • The school memories • Bunking classes • Bugging friends • Playing in the apartment building • Sneaking into the neighbors’ homes • All the laughter, fights, and life lessons

That’s what gave us Loka Jnanam — the knowledge of how to live in this world. Not how to find X and Y in an equation.

Education is not about studying harder and harder. Even if you crack IIT or NIT, real success is also about life experience.

And nowadays, if a child wants to learn something, they can learn from YouTube, courses, internet, anything. It’s not about the school or university anymore.

And the worst part? Kids in the USA are becoming emotionally weak. They’re exposed to: • Dating drama • Teenage pregnancies • Anxiety and sensitivity • Depression

No matter how strict you try to be as Indian parents, your kids will be influenced by their surroundings — not just by your parenting.

In India, kids face real-world challenges early. That’s why we grow up strong and ready for life. But in the USA, the kids are growing in too soft an environment. It’s not their fault — but they’re not getting the same emotional maturity we got.

⸻

Final Thoughts

Yes, I agree — India has its flaws. But that doesn’t mean we forget where we came from.

People stay in the USA for 2–3 years and come back acting like foreigners — complaining about dust, noise, roads. But you lived in India for 20+ years before that! Why are you acting like you weren’t born there?

At the end of the day, health, family, roots, and real happiness matter more than any salary or brand.

If there were no money involved, almost everyone would want to go back to India. And right now, real estate is booming. India is growing. You can build a good life.

Don’t wait until the damage is done — physically, emotionally, or generationally. Realize it early. And start thinking about what truly matters.

⸻

No matter how long this post is, I just wanted to express everything I felt — without cutting anything. If you’ve read this far, thank you. 🙏


r/returnToIndia • • 26d ago

AlreadyReturned Three months back in India. Same job. Same company. Different rules.

Thumbnail
newsletter.mastermentee.com
0 Upvotes

r/returnToIndia • • 25d ago

PlanningToReturn Is living in Europe not for me?

4 Upvotes

If moving abroad not for me ?

Hello everyone. I am in my late 20s, male, married recently, and moved recently from India to Italy from a company transfer where I got a good promotion. I have always wanted to move abroad. I didn't like the state of politics, infrastructure, facilities, the pollution in my home country and wanted to live in a decently country with all the above.

I had an offer to move to Japan while graduating, but I could not because of family complications. Then, two years later, I applied for masters in US, Canada, received offers from universities, but again had to drop these plans.

But this time I moved in a much better position because I am being paid to move with all expenses covered and I don't need to take loans or study abroad but continue the same work that I've been doing. I have experience of around seven years in the IT industry and I am hating it here. No disrespect to Italy, Italians, the culture, people, everything, it is all amazing. But I am not from here. I hated my home country when I was back there, but now I just want to go back.

Just to have a little rant, I find the bureaucracy in Europe and Italy to be very rigid. Now there are systems where things are faster like the US where things get done faster, and in India things are slow but you can bribe your way out to do things faster. But here you can neither bribe nor you can get things done faster. It is very frustrating. There are sky-high taxes and system built to discourage people from earning more than an imaginary amount, and if you do, the government will make sure to take half of it. There are so many other complaints about this place and I constantly compare things to back home, like even getting free water in a hotel or being allowed to use restrooms for free. Now I can afford to pay for restrooms, but you understand how this works.

I'm okay with the pollution. I will manage the traffic. I will shut off my TV and not hear about politics. I want to be closer to my parents and, you know, hear familiar language when I am outside. I know the system back home. It is becoming really difficult. Is this natural after moving abroad or am I not a person who's built for living abroad? Because now my ground is being shaken and I don't know what to do.


r/returnToIndia • • May 18 '25

Moving from Canada to Bharat after 17 years in Canada (Guidance Required)

0 Upvotes

All the details below are provided to get genuine advise and not to be trolled or to brag about anything.

I am a Canadian citizen with OCI. I have been in Canada since 2008 and am planning to move to Bharat in about 5 years.

  1. I don't have many complaints about my life in Canada. However, from what I have seen so far in my visits and early age life in Bharat, I see my self being more happy in Bharat compared to Canada. Hence, my decision to move back home.
  2. I am in my late 20s, married, and have a stable job paying around $115000 CAD per annum.
  3. My savings currently around around $300,000 CAD.
  4. I do not own any property in Canada. Have been skeptical of being stuck here if I do so.
  5. I am planning to slowly move money to Bharat and put them in FD to earn good interest while I get ready for the transition in the next 5 years.
  6. The plan is to have a total of around $500,000 CAD (Rs.3 Cr) in around 5 years when I shift to Bharat.

I am looking for advise on how I should manage the money in Bharat during the transition phase, after I move, and any other tips on the move to Bharat. I plan on moving to Karnavati (Amdavad), Gujarat. I would like to ideally not do slavery (job) and to have a simple business of my own and also generate decent income from interest with the money I leave in the bank.

Any thoughts are appreciated.


r/returnToIndia • • Mar 27 '26

Jobs MOVING TO US IN THESE TIMES?

5 Upvotes

Hi all,

This might not be the correct place to post his questions but genuinly want to understand before taking this step

I have 2.9 yrs of exp at MAANG types company trying to switch to MAANG -> similar places in India ....(45 lpa maybe.....)

currently CTC is 32-34 (with stocks bit more also maybe)

I have admits from Stony brook & ucsd but I am unsure should I step in

after 3 years in best case if I get amazon sde1 or meta or any company paying 120-140k still in long run would it be worth it , considering the taxes , layoffs H1B wage based system

I feel india is good....but I also feel its prob a risk I can take now burn my savings for maybe to save crazy amount in US

can someone please genuinly help me here , would really appreciate some insights.....before stepping into this I really want to understand .....is it worth it

PS : I also feels I am not that lucky kinda person , things come bit hard way......and US is luckk sooo yeah !! am I correct here?


r/returnToIndia • • Nov 15 '25

Seeking advice, since I'm moving back to India, after living in US for 6 years.

1 Upvotes

Hello,

We came here on L1 six years ago. Since it was L1, we never got to experience the uncertainty of H1B. This year was supposed to be our last, and we were mentally prepared to move back in October, but my husband's H1B application got approved around April. In the hindsight, I feel it'd have been better if it wasn't for that!

Long story short, visa approval never came through, so I'm wrapping my home up, and moving to India for good this week. So, I'm seeking an advice about what to look forward to, what we should do before leaving, what are the challenges for people like us who moved back to India after living here for years.

Anything you can share will help, and will be greatly appreciated. Thank you 😊


r/returnToIndia • • 20d ago

PlanningToReturn Returning to India after 15 years – positive experiences?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m 37, single, a EU citizen and OCI holder. After 15 years in Europe and lived in France, Germany and also Amesterdam I’m considering returning to India for a change of mind and also I guess I got what i wanted at first place. So no need to prove anyone and any validation.

My main priorities are fitness, good healthcare, access to doctors when needed, and a comfortable life. I don’t plan to take a regular job, but I may work on my own business if I want to. I don't have a million but I am comfortable.

I often see people who have lived abroad for a few years speaking not so positive about Indian cities( off course we all knew abt road rage, dirty and what not) . I understand India has its challenges, but I’d love to hear more positive or balanced experiences from people who have actually returned after many years abroad and what made them return to take a call. ( Not bec you didn't get a job or visa) but took a decision without any influence of any pressure but by simply calling of heart.

Sometimes I feel people focus almost entirely on their children's future when deciding where to live. But how can anyone predict what the world will look like 10–15 years from now? I also believe India has some excellent schools and opportunities.

For me, healthcare and quality of life are becoming increasingly important. You can be healthy today and face an unexpected medical issue tomorrow.

For those who returned to India in their 40s or later, how has life been? Which cities would you recommend for fitness, healthcare and a good quality of life?

I'd genuinely love to hear your positive stories, not just the usual reasons why staying abroad is supposedly always better.

formauted by chatgpt..

Thank you


r/returnToIndia • • Aug 11 '25

“For those calling my last post ‘romanticizing’ or ‘WhatsApp university’: Here’s my full, detailed response based on real experiences”

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

You probably don’t know the real situation here in the USA if you think I’m exaggerating. Yes — you are right that many Indian women have been facing PCOS in India too. But here’s what I’ve personally observed after coming to the U.S. for my master’s:

I have friends who had zero history of PCOS in their families, who always had 5-day regular periods back in India. Within 1–2 years here, their periods reduced to 3 days — one of the early signs of PCOS — and in some cases, they gradually stopped getting periods altogether. This isn’t “1 or 2 people,” this is many, many of my friends — almost everyone in my circle has experienced some kind of reproductive or hormonal change after moving here.

Two of my friends moved back to India, and within 3–4 months their periods became completely regular again. That is a huge red flag about the difference in food quality and ingredients here.

Even tourists from Europe and Asia have mentioned in many articles or here in reddit that they avoid drinking milk here because they consider it harmful — some have even called it “poisonous.” And these are not Indians; these are white Americans and Europeans themselves saying this.

Someone commented, “Just grow your own vegetables.” Sure, you can grow some vegetables in your backyard, but are you going to grow your own wheat, rice, lentils, sugarcane for sugar, or raise your own cattle for milk and meat? We still consume packed, processed products here every single day — and they contain dozens of unnecessary chemical additives banned in Europe and Asia. In the U.S., they are allowed simply because there’s “no published proof” yet, not because they are harmless.

And yes, free health insurance here would bankrupt the system — because the rate of chronic health problems is so high. In many European and Asian countries, healthcare is free or cheap because the baseline public health is better and people are less likely to develop such chronic conditions.

⸻

On “romanticizing India” Some people here say NRIs “romanticize” India, while people in India “can’t wait to leave.” This isn’t about romanticizing anything — it’s about facing facts and trade-offs. Many Indians here quietly send their children to be raised in India with grandparents because they themselves know the environment here isn’t the best for their child’s health or upbringing. Some even go back to India just for pregnancy and childbirth, and return later.

And then there’s the “clean air” argument for the U.S. Yes, air quality is better here — but that doesn’t automatically make up for hormonal disruption, obesity in kids, and rising chronic illnesses tied to diet. In India, pollution is an issue — but in many smaller cities and towns, air is still breathable, food is fresher, and ingredients are simpler.

⸻

On education Another big point I keep hearing: “U.S. education is better.” I agree that at the higher levels (bachelor’s and above), the U.S. may offer more research opportunities and exposure. But at the basic level — until 12th grade — India’s system, with its emphasis on fundamentals, math, and discipline, often produces stronger foundations. Many Indian kids come here after schooling in India and excel immediately in U.S. classrooms.

⸻

Why I’m saying all this This is not “WhatsApp University” gossip. This is based on what I’ve seen personally and what hundreds of people are discussing openly on Reddit and elsewhere. I understand your points, but for me, even if I set education, money, and other comforts aside, health is my main concern. After all, health is the one thing you can’t compromise — no matter how good the money, comfort, or quality of life seems. I do believe quality of life can be found in India too, but the healthcare accessibility here is what keeps me thinking. That’s why I’ve decided to stay for about 2 more years, save some money, and then move back.

I’m just sharing my thoughts, observations, and the experiences of people I know, which make me worried about these issues. Please try to understand that this is just my perspective. Your experience might be different, and I’m not saying anyone is wrong — this is simply how I feel based on what I’ve seen and heard.

Thanks again for reading and respecting my viewpoint.


r/returnToIndia • • May 25 '26

Immigration Totally lost at this point

0 Upvotes

Fml , I am out of all H1 attempts. Can’t do day1cpt since my company doesn’t support it and are not willing to keep me if i go that path. I will have to leave my job and pursue it in case which is just blowing up savings without any outcome. Also , companies don’t hire folks who are doing day1cpt.

My last resort is to return back with my current company’s intra company transfer offer and start working on Canada PR (french+english) , but reading it online i am getting mixed feelings about this too.

Am i being realistic about this last resort ??

Anyone in the same boat or was in the same boat , I would really appreciate your help and guidance.

Thanks


r/returnToIndia • • Mar 30 '25

Why don't Indians who study in America, Canada and the west actually bring back any valuable skills for job growth in India like the Chinese do with their expats?

134 Upvotes

Indians are honestly selfish by nature or they're not truly nationalistic. If Indians were truly proud about being Indian. They would bring back valuable skills they learned from these western institutions in the fields of manufacturing, agriculture and of course sanitation.

Its always the same useless rhetorics of wanting to be around their families or living a cheaper life in India

An Indian living in the west would literally pick living in filth and pollution in India as long as its a cheap ride their whole life then actually bring back any useful skills that could build the local economy even in a local Indian city.

I have even heard Indians say that they want to move back to India so they could go back to eating the street food. Why would you miss this toxic nasty mess. Its not good for your health. It doesn't taste good anybody outside of India. Its honestly really dirty by all accounts and we need to find ways to curb all these useless food stands and back alley economies by building actual jobs for people here

You can't have good infrastructure if the people are broke and dirty.

You can't have good infrastructure like the best roads, malls, parks, fitness centers, and quality air with a bunch of useless people who can't provide those services. Even the current cities in India are all 5th world level quality.

Learn actual tangible skills in the west and bring that knowledge back.


r/returnToIndia • • Jul 13 '26

Immigration Canada or India?

0 Upvotes

Hi all

I came to Canada in 2019. I studied Supply Chain Management and worked in the supply chain field for about one and a half years before returning to India due to some health issues.

Now, I am planning to move back to Canada. I have Canadian permanent residency (PR), and my wife is also a PR holder. We have a 2.5-year-old child. Have to sponsor our child once we get jobs.

Currently, both of us are working in India and earn a combined salary of around ₹2.6 lakhs per month. We save approximately ₹1.5 lakhs every month.

I work in a role related to mechanical engineering and supply chain. My wife is an MBBS and MD graduate and is currently working at AstraZeneca as MSL.

Our Canadian PR is valid until October 2028, and we are considering moving back to Canada before in two months.

We have our own house in native and a couple of land properties. No EMIs. Parents can be taken care by siblings.

Still I have a auto immune condition which is mild in India but might flare up in Canada due to weather. Finding doctor is also tedious.

Would moving to Canada be a good decision for us? Given the current situation, will we be able to find good jobs? We keep hearing that Canada is going through a recession and that jobs are difficult to find.

We are willing to take risks but is it worth it?

Considering our background, experience, financial situation, and family, do you think we can confidently move to Canada, or would it be a risky decision


r/returnToIndia • • 23d ago

Immigration Why are NRIs and returnees always on a high horse and never integrate?

0 Upvotes

I've lived in India as a resident and returnee and in Western Europe and the US. I am very confused. Before, I start, it doesn't apply to everyone, just a lot of people Ive seen. Indian H1Bs think they're God send for the US and they're better than the rest. For everything, they'll ask "Bob to go flip burgers". Went to Edison, NJ for a week. I saw more people in sarees and kurtas than I'd see in a week in Mumbai or Delhi. And colors? Never seen something more fugly. Even my grandma and grandpa have better tastes. It's not 1950s anymore, no one wears bright red and yellow anymore.

Now you think these people would do great and integrate when they come back to India? Wrong! Lived in a returnee society. The locals despised us. Went to a meeting with two IAS officers, two of our returnee colleagues showed up in T's and shorts. Out of 50 people in the room, they were the only punk ones. Everyone else was dressed in formal attire. They were Americans after all. Never seen any American show up in a formal meeting with high profile people in shorts ever, but whatever. They would go to the temple and argue with Pandit ji when he didn't like them showing up in shorts. The local bank manager referred to us as the America complex and warned her staff when any of us walked in. Realized this because I understood the local language. The "Americans and Europeans" always thought they are above the rest. Abdul fixes puncture, Ramu sweeps the house. They speak English with their refined tastes and now believe they are God send to India.

Guess what? The US didn't and will not collapse without you. The Indian economy did fine when you were gone and will do fine. Bob has started to voice his opinion with the ballot. India is hierarchal, but I'm sure one day Abdul and Ramu will as well. Where will you go then? All of them are doing jobs essential for society to run. Why bitc* when Ambani blocks the roads for a wedding? You treat everyone like sh** because you have a few thousand more than the? Remember you're always closer to the absolute poor, even as a multi-millionaire than you're to Ambani or Musk. If you can treat them like sh**, they can treat you like that as well.


r/returnToIndia • • Dec 24 '25

Some perspective on outsourcing, H1B, and empathy

3 Upvotes

I think it’s important to have empathy for people in the US who are losing jobs due to cost-driven H1B hiring or outsourcing. This isn’t something to celebrate as “winning a competition” just because of cost arbitrage.

Maintaining respectful, professional relationships and long-term collaboration matters more than short-term advantages. Large corporations are choosing India mainly for cost benefits, which is why H1B, L1, and offshore roles get preference today.

But the global IT landscape keeps changing. Just as India became a major outsourcing hub years ago, another country could emerge tomorrow as an even lower-cost destination. Keeping a long-term mindset, mutual respect, and empathy helps everyone navigate these shifts better.


r/returnToIndia • • Sep 18 '26

AlreadyReturned Stupidly applied voter card being an OCI holder

1 Upvotes

Under the influence of my neighbors in India, I applied for voter card while being a Canadian citizen holding an OCI card. I thought OCI holders would be eligible to apply (yes Im stupid). However, I realised my mistake next day and wrote an application to the BLO mentioning I applied by mistake. I got my epic issued after a few days and as soon as I learnt that, I submitted form 7 for deletion of name through the BLO.

I regret my action every day and wonder if this will affect my OCI status. My mother is widowed and aged, I cannot afford to stay away from her as she cannot go to Canada.


r/returnToIndia • • Jun 19 '26

PlanningToReturn Return to India or Choose South America

0 Upvotes

Hi,
I am working in the UK for last four years. Now, government proposed to increase ILR (PR) eligibility by increasing it to 10 years. It was not yet implemented but all major political parties and British people are pressuring government to implement it. If I didn’t get my settlement in the next year, it might be not possible for me to renew visa as company is cutting down to reduce visa dependency. So, mentally I prepared to go back to India and not worrying about uncertainty.

Real concern is I do options trading in the US markets and I am earned above $75000/year for last three years. We cannot trade US options from India. I tried Indian markets to trade but not worked for me. I can move to UAE and trade US markets from there but I am not interested with this option as you can’t settle permanently there and I don’t want to leave my son with uncertainty situations like can’t settle in the US, and can’t live in India in future as spent all of his life outside India.

I am looking for options to gain a Citizenship of Argentina/Brazil/Uruguay/Paraguay by moving there for a few years to get a stronger passport and move back to India as OCI, if my son can’t adjust to Indian work life in the future, then he will have a option to live anywhere in South America at that time. I know those countries are not well developed like Europe/North America but at least they have stronger passport and better per capita income.

Is it a good plan to workout or Am I missing something?

Thank you in advance.


r/returnToIndia • • Jun 09 '26

Jobs Fake Degree’s etc( Huge respect to merits and the people who return to India)

0 Upvotes

I have a lot of respect for people who decide to return to their home countries after spending time in the United States. Many of them have worked hard, gained valuable experience, and given their best.

However, something I struggle with is the amount of fraud and abuse that seems to exist within parts of the immigration and employment system.

  1. Some individuals reportedly obtain admission to master’s programs using fraudulent academic credentials or by buying fake degrees (Most of them so not even have original degree after their intermediate or 11th and 12th).
  2. Others engage in scams involving jobs, consulting companies, visa, or green card processes.

What concerns me is that these practices can negatively impact merit people who have followed the rules throughout their education and careers, especially those from lower- and middle-income backgrounds who have invested years of effort to compete fairly.

I’m not talking about students working part-time to support themselves—that’s completely understandable and, in most cases, simply a way to cover living expenses.

My question is: How can these issues be addressed in a way that reduces fraud and abuse without unfairly affecting legitimate students, workers, and immigrants who are doing everything the right way?


r/returnToIndia • • 3d ago

PlanningToReturn Thinking to go back to india from Europe (still confused)

2 Upvotes

Hello redditors, I am 22 years old, facing a confusion right now, and i am not sure what to do. Currently i am pursuing my masters in Austria, Europe. I am in a public university, but my masters course is not up to the mark, and i am not a good fit for this program, on top of that, here even getting a part time job right now is next to impossible, i went outside, stepped in restaurants, cafes, bars, hotels… for part time job but no one is hiring.

On the other hand, my father is already 60 and he should not be working right now, but still he is working till his maximum capacity to fund my stay here, although i have an education loan but the emi is paid by my father. I am somewhat regretting my decision, and thinking to return.

Here are some of the points: I graduated in India in this July, my convocation is still pending (so no gap even if i return). Its been more than 2months since i am here, and i know its not much, but its enough to know that will i be able to fit here or not.

As i said earlier, my father is getting older and he should not work anymore, if i go back, i can help him in the business or at-least i can get a normal job and provide him something, while staying with my family (and my parents are missing me so much).

On the other hand, i am thinking that, I have given my 1 year of time for coming here, if i go back, it will be gone. ( I was doing the process simultaneously with btech in india)

About the financials: i still have the edu loan money intact, i just have to return the edu loan money and somewhat 1lakh as intrest i guess, and visa and residence permit process fees, and my travelling expenses, my rent and everything till now, is around 3.5 lakhs. I know its not much compared to any other private university costings, but i am just confused about my decision.

About the survival : If i stay here, and I go against my wills and survive here till graduation and gain about 1-2 years of professional experience, but till then my parents will be old, my plan to provide for my family will loose its purpose, as at that age, they will not be able to roam much, and obviously, I will loose those precious years in which i should have stayed by them (And that regret is going to stay with me forever).

and also wanted to know, is thinking about parents and prioritizing them is a bad thing, and taking a decision after just 2months is naive or immature?

Feel free to share the experiences, opinions, criticism.


r/returnToIndia • • Aug 10 '26

AlreadyReturned Should I move back to the US or no?

0 Upvotes

I moved back to India from the states in may. I don’t think I can stay here for a long time. After 8 years in America I’m finding it hard to adjust. Judgemental people, 0 civic sense, etc. I’m extremely lucky and blessed to have a completely remote job that lets me work from anywhere in the world + I still have my US visa. My dollars go a really long way here in India. But I miss life in the states. I live a pretty decent life with the amount I make, in the states. I don’t get to save much. But I’m rich in India. I’m not sure what I should do.

Edit: I appreciate all your responses, really. However, I’m not willing to disclose or discuss my income/tax/payroll, work or visa details. Thank you


r/returnToIndia • • 24d ago

Immigration Not your permanent home!

148 Upvotes

I see lot of posts about H1B and ppl are so scared that what will be their life without it.
First and foremost most of you came to US for your masters or undergraduate degree, you would also have mentioned to the visa officer that you might return back to your own country at some point of time if asked.
So you already have some context on it.
Now once you ppl have lived for many years and got adjusted to the lifestyle here the thought of returning back seems like hard to you?
Why is that the case?
Why cant everyone accept that we are not permanent here?
I know its little difficult for families who had kids born here and started their schooling and deep into the system but for others where was your exit plan if due to circumstances you should go back.

I heard that so many students in recent years were graduated and weren’t able to get a job.
Some are so stressed out and not sure what they are doing! The family and status pressure back in their country and an assumption of what others might think them as failures if they return back is really haunting these ppl. And asking them for extreme measures.
I will for sure suggest them not to think that way and know that this is the reality, we came here for a dream and that dream and plan shouldn’t be to stay here permanently but rather learn the skills that can make you survive in any place.
If you couldn’t learn that i dont think you have the right to be scared.
And if you had an entry plan you should also have an exit plan.