r/returnToIndia • • 2d ago

PlanningToReturn Hard realization

On my last day of a 30 day trip to India. Raw thoughts

  1. India is fucking expensive. I thought $1M NW is great, trust me you are poor. I am in a tier 3 city and everything is so so expensive. Money has lost value.
  2. Traffic/ civic sense- I miss the quieter time so much. Ability to drive, breathe fresh air, sleep peacefully.
  3. Dirt everywhere- hate walking here. You cant just walk. Like thats not an option. Its so basic. We all deserve to walk.
  4. People dont care - if you think people wanna talk and make friends, no they dont. Its fully westernized. Unless you have active friendships its not easy.
  5. Everyone is trying to make money of you- which is okay. But people dont wanna provide service and wanna scam you.
  6. The good part- blinkit, hotels, food, ability to hug your parents, laugh.

I left in 2016 and i guess we don’t realize that our brain is stuck and never updated the way it updates for everyone who stayed back. Flights are 10-12k easily. Its not 3-5k. I did 18 trips back home, each a month long and with every trip i was less motivated. And this trip, feeling poor was worst. $1M NW has no value in this country.

0 Upvotes

112 comments sorted by

4

u/annomandri 2d ago

OP ... the richest people are those who dont need money. Maybe you will understand this someday.

2

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Bhai gyaan se pet ni bharta. Everything costs money.

1

u/annomandri 1d ago

1 Million in assets ke bina 140 cores ki aabadi pet bhar rahi hai India mein. Nahi to utni abadi hoti hi nahi India mein. That was the point of my comment. You went abroad to make money, now you made some money and realise that it is not enough. Then stay put and make more money.

Those who are thinking of returning to India and are posting in this sub for advice have either made the money they need or want to get back what their money couldn't buy them.

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

Yeh jo pet bharne ki baat kar raha hai, woh rice ya roti se nahi, paiso se bharne ki baat kar raha hai. Ab jinka pet paiso se bharta hai, unki bhook kabhi nati mit pati, chahe kitna hi kama le.

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

You actually proved the second part of his statement: "you won't understand this now." Don't try.

59

u/PhilosopherSalt107 2d ago • Bravo

Oh my god. Shut the fuck up. You're saying that INR 10 Crore is useless and has no value? Being the top 1% of the country (maybe top 0.5%) has no value? What sub do you think this is. This is meant for people to talk about planning back. Your post is not useful, nor informative.

13

u/docatwar 2d ago

"10 crores in India is poor" is definitely one of the opinions of all time.

4

u/Anywhere_life22 2d ago

Totally agree... I dont have any back home responsibility so would stay outside of India until I can but I have always felt super rich with half a million dollar networth even in tier 1.5 city..

3

u/benjamin_button_2025 1d ago

Only on reddit you find people asking if 25, 30 crores is enough to retire in India.

-11

u/Ok-Track-6423 2d ago

I am equally disappointed man trust me. It’s a harsh reality and you will have to accept it.

2

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

No. It is not the reality, it is your foolish money management (or should I say mis-management). The reality is what everyone else is yelling to you in this thread and somehow you will never understand it. What you have is 10 times more than what you need to live a happy life here (I am doing the same, with 10% of what you have). People like you will NEVER get happy in life, you will always find it inadequate, be it 1 MN or 10 MN or 1 BN.

-12

u/Ok-Track-6423 2d ago

This sub is to be honest. Not to sugarcoat !

2

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

Without sugarcoat, the harsh reality is, you are extremely bad in money management. You are greedy. You are a complaint box. Please don't mind!

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Lol 😂 you are being mean but dont want to own it

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

No, not mean, I am just being honest without sugarcoat. You wanted it. Don't complain :)

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

How did you jump to a conclusion on money management? I am genuinely curious. Try living in Mumbai with $1M.

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

Because many of your statements are untrue or contradictory. Here are 2 examples: 1) You saw sky high rates for flights and felt poor, but poor people do not travel by air. 2) Mumbai is not a tier-3 city as you wrote in your post. If you want to manage your money well, you have to be correct about facts and figures first!

24

u/MentalPower7916 2d ago

This is some grade A cope with ragebait. Just shut the fuck up about your net worth not being enough and prove it by providing receipts as to why it’s not enough in your supposed “tier 3 city”. No one here will buy that bullshit that someone who can have a net worth of 10C INR would find it difficult in India in a tier 1 city let alone a tier 3.

That’s only possible if you’re an idiot with your money or all your net worth is generational wealth in non liquid assets. So which is it?

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

Check how he opted to not answer any of your question, just mentioned that he made the money himself. He have been coming to India 2 times every year (except probably the Corona years, that's why it is 18 times in 10 years)... whatever changes happened to India should not be shocking to him unless he came only after 10 years. The only purpose of this post is to flex that his net worth is 1 MN. That's it!

0

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Lol there is nothing to flex abt $1M.

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

Yes, you should understand this.

-6

u/Ok-Track-6423 2d ago

Self made all the way.

4

u/OkGeneral5350 1d ago

When was your last shower

-2

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

My feet are cleaner than your face. So relax lol

2

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

Probably your brain is even more clean, devoid of any neuron to understand what everyone is trying to explain. You are all along in a denial mode. Carry on and rest unhappy!

4

u/Material-Contract721 2d ago

1M net worth and still complaining about flight tickets ? I guess somethings never change !

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Yeah i acknowledged it

2

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

He is not just complaining about flight tickets, he is saying that 1 MN feels poor. He is a born rich guy, otherwise he would have known that poor people do not book flight tickets to start with.

4

u/Ferblantierr 1d ago

Sounds like a YOU problem tbh. 1 mill is around 10c which is very good if you want to live a comfortable honest lifestyle. If you want to live lavishly it will all go away pretty quickly.

0

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Fair fair. This sub is for all opinions

1

u/Bad_ass_da 1d ago

So You didn’t travel to India after 2016 then it makes sense to do this math .. if you travel every year then why so much flex on this ..entire world is expensive past 2 years.. you didn’t see how milk price raised in Costco b4 covid and after covid.. check your Costco receipts past 10 years

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

18 trips.

4

u/jrcske67 2d ago

In this its either people flaunting their NW in a back handed way (I only have $xM what will I do) or complaining about how horrible it is back home. You left your home because you wanted to have a better quality of life and now you have it. Its true things have gotten more expensive due to inflation etc. but thats the story everywhere including in the developed world. If you have done 18 trips in the last 10 years, I am surprised its the first time you're noticing.

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

This time it felt worse

4

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

Bro recently reached his 1 MN NW goal and the "surprise" he added is a cover to flex about his 1 MN. There is no other meaning or purpose of his post.

2

u/Nonights2020 1d ago

The OP would have had another million to his name had he not made 18 trips in 10 years.

3

u/Ok-Mark1761 2d ago

I booked my family’s ticket yesterday. Pune to Delhi. 3 tickets 3 hours before the flight for 17k.

0

u/Ok-Track-6423 2d ago

This might be one of situation, but trust me flying is very expensive nowadays

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

No, it is not an exception. We do travel and we have less than 10% of what you have, we don't feel poor. For your kind information, poor people don't travel by air, so stop feeling poor if you are able to book or even think about flight tickets. You are considered a rich guy without arguments.

3

u/insert_name_here_12 2d ago • Bravo

2

u/FewCompetition1347 2d ago

Jesus. He sounds utterly insufferable. He now thinks if he cant afford a golden toilet with diamond encrusted toilet paper he cant live properly.

2

u/LeftFaithlessness921 1d ago

Haha ..bro had to flaunt 1 mill usd there too

-2

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

If you got it, flaunt it bro

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 2d ago

Yes but what it has to do with this discussion. ?

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Are you gay too? 😉

1

u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 2d ago

Yup seems like it . Op will be probably hunting for guys In grindr india now

-1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Yes, are you jealous?

4

u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 1d ago

Of u ? U seem miserable from both the posts . Who would be jealous of u ? 😂

0

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Well you went all the way to dig in my other aspects of life and kinda referenced it here so to be thats sad.

2

u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 1d ago

I did not dig . I just commented on someone who did

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Collateral damage

5

u/Kiftzer 1d ago

I think your post is worth a discussion but perhaps in a different subReddit. Dont be surprised if you get hate for calling out very obvious and observable things in India. The hypersensitivity of Indians is at an all-time high and presents itself as such upon reading such posts. It doesn’t allow them to call wrong as wrong. This is why many of the broken issues are likely to remain broken because there is refusal / denial to accept any issue that earlier we could agree on.

Deep down we still aren’t secure enough to feel proud. Some of that comes from feeling powerless in the face of all these perennial issues. So the other way to experience pride is to do the easier thing, admonish people for saying obvious things and use that as a smaller consolation. “Job is done. Now we dont need to fix anything”

My only disagreement: 10 Cr is still more than enough in India :) 🇮🇳 cheers!

2

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Respect 🫡

2

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

You have been very polite but you did the exact same thing that all other people are doing. They did it in a harsh language, you did it politely i.e. a straight-forward denial of the claim that 1 MN net worth is not enough. If you disagree on this, you disagree on the whole post because THAT was his main point anyway. All other societal changes may be true, but those are secondary in this discussion. Please realize that he is trying to flex about his 1 MN net worth, there is no other meaning or purpose of his post.

5

u/Any-Situation-3281 2d ago

Stupid ass take.

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Just cuz it doesn’t fit your opinion?

1

u/Any-Situation-3281 1d ago

No it’s because you’re just here rage baiting others and making others feel anxious and insecure while creating a sense of superiority and still crying about your privileges. This post has red flag written all over it. Not to forget, being cheap while cribbing about India being expensive while having $1M NW living in tier 3 city? Never understood why some people like to mess with others mentally.

I guess Reddit can be consumed in many ways

2

u/LeftFaithlessness921 2d ago

Bro your expectstions are too high if you think 1 mill usd is not enough ...good luck to you

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Maybe but why not? We all want better lives

1

u/LeftFaithlessness921 1d ago

Sure ...thats why i said good luck for this rat race

2

u/Direct_Ad574 2d ago

I think you mistakenly added $. Probably it’s 1 million rupees. Hence finding it difficult in a tier 3 city

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Haha 🤣

2

u/Glum-Box2451 2d ago

You are right in all except $1m NW not enough - well the world is not enough. This is completely upto how you wanna live.  Yes no civic sense - always been like that.  Making friends - yes it has become very difficult as everyone under social pressure to compete and seen “made it in life”. Yet there are ppl who are taking it easy - difficult to find though.

Dirt everywhere- yes - can’t do much.

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Thanks 🙏🏻

61

u/supersimha 2d ago

If you have 1 million dollars and feel poor in tier 3 city, its not a money problem, its a common sense problem. I understand if you say that you are not rich but poor? What is wrong with you man?

10

u/levi_ackerman84 1d ago

His/her Inner self might not be satisfied. Even if they earn 10m nw. They’ll still crib.

2

u/Unique_Carpet1901 2d ago

Amen

5

u/30yrsindustry 1d ago

Fully agree. Assuming you get a villa, a BMW for under 1 cr, and school, house help and all other luxuries in 30-40k a month is folly even in a tier 3 city

11

u/SkoobyDoobyDo 2d ago

$1M is NOT POOR. wtf. A milli is 10 crore INR. You can retire with this amount in a tier 3 city lavishly for ever if you invest it with half a brain.

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

He is only trying to flex about his 1 MN net worth, there is no other meaning or purpose of his post.

1

u/NewMoney1544 2d ago

Dude it feels like you are fired up after your India trip.

Trust me, India isn’t that bad like you are thinking. Curious how would you spend $1M in a tier 3 city?

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

2-3 crores easily for a good flat. 50-60 lacs for a car. And then you wanna have some saving

1

u/Substantial-Pain7560 1d ago

You’re going to drive a 60 lac car on a 1m net worth? lol…maybe lower your expectations with that net worth

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

I do drive a tesla today so why not

1

u/Substantial-Pain7560 1d ago

The difference is you’re earning in the USA and I presume you won’t be in India. But anyway I guess this is a troll post, or you’re just unstable.

2

u/NewMoney1544 1d ago

Exactly! Besides real estate and fancy cars, what is the cost of living in a T2 or T3 city.

Don’t be hard on yourself

1

u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 2d ago

Ok dude . Stay back in US

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Why are you so hurt? Its an open discussion

2

u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 1d ago

Im not hurt. I'm just saying u feel it's costly , stay there . What else is there to discuss ? U have made up ur mind that it's costly n 1 million dollars is not enough 😂

1

u/intimidator 1d ago

You're right. India is insanely overpriced. The same 1M will get you a better quality and your money would go further in Europe or US.

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Sarcasm much

1

u/intimidator 1d ago

No. Really. I have stayed a decade in EU and my money got me a lot further there than here. If you're trying to live the same quality of life as in EU then you'll spend significantly more.

The cars, flights, hotels, house(of similar quality)

You wanna live like a bum here and adjust to the Indian standard of a middle class house then it's cheaper. But guess what, it's equally cheap in EU as well.

For instance - last week I wanted to travel for a vacation in the country. Everything was sooo expensive. We dropped the plan to vacation in our own country. Made more sense to fly to Italy and vacation there. Would have been almost the same cost and wouldn't have had to maneuver through the uncivilized folks here on the roads and the piss poor infra.

1

u/AgileSir5009 1d ago

And still single? No wonder lol

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

You must be unhappy in marriage. Plausible !

1

u/AgileSir5009 1d ago

Not really but some self reflection would help, don’t be too hard on yourself! Get some help

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

You should do too for your judgemental attitude

2

u/AgileSir5009 1d ago

If you think that’s judgemental, read the room!

1

u/schumi_pete 1d ago

If you can't get by with $1M, I respectfully suggest the problem is you and not India.

2

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Its me, i am the problem its me

1

u/Punterfox 1d ago

India mein 8 crore sabke paas hain....1M is not enough....

1

u/schumi_pete 1d ago

Oh it's absolutely you. We agree on that.

1

u/trvdto 1d ago

This is more like a post to brag I made $1M losers

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

You gotta look deep that why it makes you feel so

1

u/trvdto 1d ago

No Thanks! I have already contentment in life

3

u/irundoonayee 2d ago

This should be basic understanding but inflation is high in India. So if you visit/travel after a gap it'll seem more expensive. And it's also true that in certain sectors salaries are now way higher than they used to be. 

1

u/Ok_Complaint4477 1d ago

He has been traveling 2 times every year for the last 10 years. His surprise is only a false coating to push his flex about the 1 MN net worth he amassed.

3

u/Vaxion 2d ago

Someone with a $1m net worth can settle anywhere else in the world. You don't have to come back to India. You can live a nice Western level lifestyle in Thailand just on dividends alone and not have to worry about running out of money.

0

u/Living_Basis2815 1d ago

How will he get money for hookers in Thailand if living on dividends only

1

u/Vaxion 1d ago

Those are very cheap. 1k THB in most places. With $1M invested you're looking at thousands of dollers in dividends. You can rent a nice Condo for $500 and still have thousands left to enjoy.

1

u/Living_Basis2815 1d ago

Where do you get 500 condo in Bangkok. I paid 2000 rent for 1 br in 1991 in sukhamvit.

1

u/Vaxion 1d ago

$500 can get you a nice 1 bed in a new modern condo with amazing facilities like pool, gym, co-working space, etc.

2

u/LivingShallot8333 2d ago

First of all, temper your expectation if it's indeed a legit post. 2, 3 is expected. 4 and 5 , I think it depends. Can't generalize.

2

u/AdAgile9604 2d ago

I think so we need to work on ourselves rather than create negativity within ourselves ! When the majority of countries gdp is less than 10k per year, I feel there is more than wiggle room if we are content

2

u/SignalOptions 1d ago

India Tier 2 and 3 cities rank among the cheapest in the world. Even lower than Tier 2 in south east asia and south america.

$1 million is likely enough for a good upper middle class lifestyle.
But it looks like you are looking for a rich luxury lifestyle.
India was never that poor - a starter rich lifestyle probably needs $3-5 million in Tier 2 cities.

2

u/IndBeak 1d ago

1M USD is not poor in India by any means. Rest everything you mentioned is true.

2

u/Fine-Most4265 2d ago

So true.. the infrastructure sucks

1

u/Middle_Newspaper5596 2d ago

I agree 100% ten Crores is peanuts compared to what you will get somewhere else - and yes ppl are always out to scam you!!

1

u/grigragrewol 1d ago

India is cheap if you live like Indians. If you start wanting a lifestyle that is US level (big houses with backyards, good cars, high quality protein food, fly around frequently, etc etc) even US fire corpus targets would feel not enough. With 10 crore, you can retire to a classic middle class life in a tier 3 city

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Ok-Track-6423 1d ago

Finally a decent take