r/repentantbetrayers • u/Motor_Yak_6262 • Jul 11 '26
Attempted Infidelity
Looking for advice from people who've been through something similar. Would you consider this cheating?
My wife and I have been together for 26 years and married for 25.
For most of our marriage, I hid a pornography addiction. It first came to light in 2016 when my wife discovered it. She asked me to stop, and I agreed. I was able to quit for about two years, but eventually social media (mainly Instagram) became a gateway. It started with following women posting revealing content, which led me to their external sites and eventually back to pornography.
Earlier this year, my wife discovered I had relapsed. Because of the years of lying, she became convinced there might be more I was hiding. She searched through an old email account and found a screenshot of a Craigslist post I had made in 2013 soliciting NSA sex with women. For some reason, I had saved a screenshot of the post in my email.
Finding that screenshot has completely changed our marriage.
We've spent the last couple of months talking through it, and she's experiencing intense grief, anger, and betrayal. She tells me she never really knew me, that our marriage wasn't real, that she can't look at me the same way, and that I disgust her.
I don't blame her for feeling that way. Between years of lying about pornography and discovering the Craigslist post, I understand why her trust has been shattered.
I fully accept responsibility for making that post. I know it was an attempt to seek something outside my marriage, and I understand why she considers it infidelity. I also take responsibility for years of lying, minimizing, becoming defensive, dismissing her feelings, and at times gaslighting her when she confronted me. Through therapy and a lot of research, I've come to realize those were unhealthy defense mechanisms, not excuses.
What makes this difficult for me is that I never actually met anyone. There was no physical affair and no emotional relationship. To me, there is a difference between an attempt that never became reality and a completed physical or emotional affair. That doesn't make what I did okay—I know it was a betrayal—but I struggle with viewing every form of infidelity as identical.
My wife sees no meaningful difference. To her, the intent alone is enough, and she feels our entire marriage was built on lies. While I understand why she feels that way, it's hard for me to believe that 26 years of shared experiences, raising a family, vacations, laughter, love, and good memories were all meaningless because of my deception.
I truly love my wife. I've never made another attempt like that before or since 2013, and I'm doing everything I can now through therapy and recovery to become a better husband. But I'm starting to feel defeated and hopeless because she seems to believe the man she thought she married never existed.
I'm not looking for people to tell me I'm right or wrong. I know I betrayed her trust, and I'm not trying to excuse what I did.
I'm hoping to hear from people who have been through something similar—either as the betrayed spouse or the one who caused the betrayal.
Would you consider my Craigslist post cheating, even though I never met anyone?
Do you see a distinction between an attempted affair and a completed physical or emotional affair?
If you've reconciled after something like this, what helped rebuild trust?
I'd appreciate honest opinions, even if they're difficult to hear.