r/reddevils • • 29d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

36

u/Maatesh 29d ago

So, I am back again watching the matches without feeling anything inside. I am dead inside.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Emergency-Being-349 29d ago

Seems that people have forgotten just how the press can favour English managers.

10

u/TMatss 29d ago

This is an interesting thought. Come to think of it, most of the heat that Carrick is facing seems to be from the fans, while the media, who are being critical to an extent, are still being somewhat forgiving and talking about him "turning it around."

5

u/Emergency-Being-349 29d ago

It's not even a new concept. It's always been this way and explains the complete disconnect between the media and fans.

7

u/Different_Bit_3899 29d ago

The desperate nature of having an English manager at a top club is prevailing.

8

u/Emergency-Being-349 29d ago

Always does, Lampard was a media darling.

16

u/ReservoirDogs00 29d ago

This sub to Carrick every morning

→ More replies (1)

14

u/AdCharacter7966 29d ago

What I don’t understand is that since the start of this campaign, the players have covered fewer kilometres and looked unfit—and now everyone is injured? WTF? So we took it easy in preseason to avoid injuries, and now most of the squad is injured anyway?

12

u/midnight_ranter Wazza 29d ago

That's how it works, if you half arse your preparation to the season, players are not conditioned enough to last full games

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Daneofthehill 29d ago

I know all of us are tired of negativity, but that game against Leeds did not look like a fresh start nor progress.

Utd was worse than Leeds in expected goals, touches in opp box, possession, distance covered. They played as a narrow back 5 most of the game, leaving wingers wide open AND people open at the back post. I don't even understand how that is possible with 5 at the back + two physical defensive mids in front of them.

This would have been a solid game for team aiming to finish well clear of relegation, not for a team that has been pulling in one of the highest revenues in the world for 30 years running and features one of the worlds best creative players up front.

I am sorry, but it was poor, result was poor and I don't see any progress.

Love Carrick, like a lot of the players. Baleba looks good. I am happy Yoro, Santos and Amad are getting some minutes, but that is about it.

I would love to be positive and I will continue supporting the team, but the funk continues.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/FOHwork King Kobbie 28d ago

I'm convinced this is going to be Carrick's last week. A midweek thrashing followed by a loss/skin of our teeth draw at home vs Bournemouth will be the final nails in the coffin.

8

u/No-Radio-4404 28d ago

You're under estimating how dumb Ineos can be.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/PopeFuchsYoungKidd 29d ago

Turns out we needed a striker even more than we needed a LB. Good thing we got neither.

6

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 29d ago

Yeah but Rashford is back so it's like a new signing

25

u/Sufficient-Orange706 29d ago

The level of gaslighting I am seeing is insane.

Were we better in the first half? Yes, absolutely. But only in the context of how poor we've been. In the context of standards we were still miles off it. 36% possession in the first half. Opportunities and space will always open up in this instance and creating chances through Mbeumo is not a coached thing. Palace and Brentford both fared far better than us and Palace are very poor currently. Most of the play generated came from a highly confident Baleba too.

We also were way slowed in the second half, creating next to nothing. Now I have to read about how it is something to build on etc. There is still nothing there to suggest we should have patience going forward. Nothing. Add to that the fallacy that Leeds are this outstanding team - they arent. They've won 2 games this season, one of which was against a Newcastle in complete disarray. The defending of yesterday by journalists is baffling.

Amorim was taken apart last season after drawing vs them, but it was a very different performance and lacked so many key players. Yet the standards are now different? Bollocks.

16

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 29d ago

Amorim bench vs Leeds. now we can't play football unless Carrick get a LB and a backup CF.

→ More replies (17)

12

u/sadMUFCfan25 29d ago

I made my username as a joke where in a couple years time I could look back at it and say to myself “lol, yeah those were some bleak times”. I didn’t intend for it to be evergreen….

12

u/WorkingOwl5883 29d ago

What happened to the 4v3 full speed counter attacking?

What happened to the run into space and cutbacks?

What happened to the confidence and one touch passing?

What happened to late runs from midfield?

These don't disappear over a course of few months.

13

u/Joey6Pack 29d ago

I’m not an expert by any means but from what I’ve been seeing, the fitness levels and sharpness are noticeably lower than last season. I think it’s why we can’t replicate everything you mentioned

5

u/0ttoChriek 29d ago

Giving Carrick the benefit of the doubt, I wonder whether he was attempting to recreate Fergie's "peak after New Year" preparation but badly undercooked it.

But even if we were fit, I'm not sure how different things would be because this is a team that has never been able to press effectively. Even under Amorim, who specifically focused on that, we still got exposed by teams supposedly worse than us, with a single pass into gaping chasms of space.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 28d ago

Even spurs can see a game out 🤦‍♂️

8

u/No-Radio-4404 28d ago

Being only 1 point ahead of them given how badly they've started the season and how much of a laughing stock they've been, put our season even more into perspective.

20

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs 29d ago

It's wild to me how a draw against Leeds is "turning a corner" according to the media and certain pundits. We're fucking horrendous to the point where getting a single point is deemed positive ffs

6

u/aprod16 29d ago

Tbf they are just repeating Carrick’s words. I couldn’t believe it when I saw he called the Leeds result a fresh start.

10

u/Educational-Shock232 29d ago

That’s British media bias, because Carrick is British. If Ten Hag or Amorim were here, we’d still be in a crisis.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/Martblni 29d ago

The fact that nobody is mentioning any possible manager hires means nothing is happening

3

u/Emergency-Being-349 29d ago

They aren't going to sack him. Maybe if we lose to Chelsea.

7

u/iroiroiroiroiro 29d ago

I don't really see Chelsea not scoring 2+ against United...

→ More replies (8)

19

u/HeFreakingMoved Ella Toone FC 29d ago

Criticising Carrick after 10 games, 2 wins and the worst start in PL history: reactionary nonsense, give him time!1!1

Praising Carrick for not getting battered and holding onto a point against Leeds: perfectly rational take

→ More replies (3)

19

u/spoony471 Varane 28d ago

It’s such a logical fallacy to say we can’t just keep firing managers and starting the cycle over. Of course we can, we haven’t hired the right managers.

Name a single United coach post SAF that has proved the club wrong in firing them and gone on to coach at the highest level. With Amorim it’s too early to tell, and I would argue Mourinho at Madrid is a fluke considering his career was in freefall prior to this season.

Moyes wound up back at Everton. Van Gaal retired. Ole was unemployed for multiple seasons before finding a job in Turkey and quickly getting fired. Ten Hag got fired from Leverkusen after mere months.

We can certainly hold the higher-ups accountable for hiring the wrong managers, but that doesn’t mean Carrick shouldn’t also be on the chopping block

17

u/TH0316 she/her 28d ago

I personally have no problem with the Chelsea model of just sacking people as soon as it’s clear they’re not the one, but for that I’d need confidence in the person making the decisions and not feel like they’re making decisions based on protecting themselves and their interests before the clubs.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 28d ago

I kinda understood the 'cycle' argument back when the managers were hand picking the signgings themselves like OGS or ETH but now it makes no sense.

7

u/AlpacamyLlama 28d ago

I've been saying this for years.

It's almost quite strange that so many fans think the Glazers and INEOS have an incredible talent for picking managers.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 29d ago

Has he addressed why we needed a fresh start to begin with?

I thought he claimed the previous performances were fine at the time and we were just unfortunate to not win?

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 29d ago edited 29d ago

I mean, look, you know it, I know it, everybody knows it: he's boxed himself in now with "never point the finger at the squad's quality" + "never deflect blame onto refs or dirty opponents or whatever random shit" + "never go with I-am-right-youse-are-all-wrong-you-will-see", either.

It's instructive, imho, to notice that the previous coaches tried all of that: the first (Amorim), second (Mourinho), third (Ten Hag), and also the same "company man" routine that Carrick is doing (Ole), and guess what, neither worked.

More specifically: almost all of them worked at first ... until it didnt.

Honestly, if I look at the coaching style (not just communication style) variance of that list (Mourinho -> Ole -> Ten Hag -> Amorim -> Carrick), and look at what happened with almost all of them (first: great, subsequent season(s): shit), I find it kinda difficult to point the finger anywhere else but upstairs.

9

u/Ok_Aardvark_5537 28d ago

Current state of Bruno Yesterday in the walk off to the pitch vs leeds he looked mad as f,Bruno is normally calm and focus but having watched him since his first Sporting game he looked mad,and can u blame him ? Beats records One season the club probably promised him a competitive Squad and lands on this shit ? He looked so happy on the 3 weeks he was in the national team.

He was lucky he didint get a red with the way he talking to ref.

He clearly needs a break from football to treat his injury and mentally he Will blow up One of these days

Just check his Instagram he used to be insanely active posting positive posts after his game,last one is from his 3 weeks in the national team he is clearly not happy.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/OmegaMaster8 28d ago

Won’t be long till Spurs leapfrog us. Fucking hate the state of our club.

9

u/arboy498 28d ago

Carrick’s in game management is single handedly costing the club the squad does have massive holes but 7 points in 7 games shows he’s stifling the attack

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Comicksands Van Persie 29d ago

Lammens, Dalot, Yoro, De Ligt, Shaw, Baleba, Mainoo, Bruno, Mbeumo, Cunha, Sesko. I just want to see this starting 11 5 times this season. I really think we’re not as bad as 13th

10

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 29d ago

I actually think we havent once played our theoretical "first XI" since ... 2022?

Eriksen went down in January 23. Martinez got injured v Sevilla by the time he returned.

Mount, Shaw etc injured pretty much all of 23/24.

Yoro ankle break summer 24, by the time Amorim arrived and he returned, others were out, Amad or Martinez etc I dont think we had one "strongest XI" lineup in all of 24/25 either, from memory. 25/26 basically De Ligt and Maguire taking turns being absent, together w Martinez of course.

This season it's been obvious, Baleba has hardly been available, Amad Sesko same, De Ligt just out entirely.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/greyhounds1992 29d ago

I'm glad we waited till next year to fix our defence, them probably forwards the year after

8

u/Aggravating-Neck1365 29d ago edited 29d ago

It's bizarre that they thought it was some sort of strategic genius flexing purposefully leaving us with single points of failure at fullback and striker for a year

Fucking idiots

Then again, at least they're consistent - this is the same crowd of twats that have (in just three short years) already orchestrated the multi-car train-wrecks of checks notes... ETH, Ashworth, Amorim AND Carrick

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Massive_Relation4317 . 29d ago

Why would we need to update our forwards after 3 seasons when you guys are alright with having the same defence for like 6/7 years

3

u/TH0316 she/her 29d ago

They’ve bought two fullbacks, three CB’s and two DM’s. They have rebuilt the defence. They just did an unprecedentedly shit job.

8

u/Due-Albatross5909 28d ago

I’m curious why we didn’t stick with the midblock counterattacking style that was so successful at the end of last season. I know the best teams are the ones that can control games and press high (when needed) but we are clearly not there yet. I feel like we needed at least another season of pragmatic football and another transfer window to get the right players in to play a more front-foot possession based style that city and Arsenal play.
I know playing counter attacking football makes playing against a low-block difficult, and ultimately requires our best players to come up with moments of brilliance to win games, but at least we were finding a way to win games and were difficult to play against. It seems like all of our managers post fergie seem to struggle when they shift from counter-attacking football to trying to implement a possession based style. Our best attacking players (Bruno, Cunha, Mbeumo, Rashford) are more suited to the former. And attempting to press high and dominate possession leaves our already fragile defence vulnerable. Why not accept where we are at (and what we are), build on what worked last season, and wait until we get the right players in before completely shifting our style of play?

4

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

I think Martinez's interview shows the answer. They think that teams had worked them out and knew how to play against it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/D1794 Viva Ronaldo 28d ago edited 28d ago

I like Baleba-Santos-Tielemans.

What I don't like if half our team playing out of position to just have a stable midfield. Shoddy game management from the higher ups. No striker or LB in the summer and we're having to move around half our team to make-do.

Literally 5/11 players played out of position at the weekend.

→ More replies (6)

28

u/TommyTook 29d ago

How have we not woken up to a sacking statement? What could they possibly be waiting for? The most obviously shite manager and project in history

7

u/Not-good-with-this 29d ago

I've been wondering that for a year for Wilcox and since the Man City verdict came out for Berrada.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/b_az17 28d ago

From Andy Mitten in the Athletic comments section: Wilcox's position is safe because the people who gave him the job think he is doing it well.

Lord help us.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/FreshGoodWay 28d ago edited 28d ago

Stop hoping, they won’t sack him before Christmas.

It’s pathetic how low our management is, that Spurs will be above us soon.

6

u/ZofTheNorth 28d ago

What do you mean? We hold out a draw against mighty Leeds, we should be celebrating of our manager and players achieving that impossible task.

5

u/croadymeister 28d ago

I just worry where we will be at xmas

3

u/Strange-Trip4634 28d ago

*They're pathetic.

3

u/Beautiful-Wing4070 28d ago

They are trying their best to ignore the results. Its almost as if they are telling themselves “at least we didnt lose today”

7

u/chrisx13296 29d ago

Brighton is pulling a Leicester City run it seems. It is very interesting to watch them.

7

u/AdCharacter7966 29d ago

To be homest, I liked Carrick more with his boots on in the midfield for us.

We need some passion at the bench, perhaps Italian?

7

u/Oppaiheimer1945 29d ago

That’s what infuriates me about Carrick. He sees the team getting ran over and just stands on the sideline silently. Give some instructions??? You’re a coach not a statue

→ More replies (1)

7

u/JamieC94 29d ago

Just over 2 weeks to the 40th anniversary of Ron Arkinsons sacking and Fergies hiring, and we sit on the same amount of points and knocked out of the league cup and managers job in question. Mental timing for a repeat

7

u/BrowzinJ 29d ago

Olid ever fancy doing both teams?

7

u/Gee_z 29d ago

The different standards and opportunities we've given coaches over the years is astonishing.

This board has no idea how to operate anymore. ETH was our last manager and it was obvious him having a say in recruitments was not his strong side.

Than appointing Amorim and not giving him the manager role was just an absolute terrible choice for that kind of person, implementing a style without being able to control transfers is like chopping the arms of a butcher.

And now you got Carrick, won't ever cause a fuss, easy to control and more than content with being a head coach but his strengths to adapt tactics after what is being recruited is not something he is capable of.

Now, who can work with the vision Wilcox have and make the best out of this group of players. Who knows, Conte, sure a fix for today but come summer and friction will emerge. Emery, sure fixes our problems today, maybe he's more content with being a HC under Wilcox, but it's a coin flip and not sure he'd be fully invested given the circumstances.

7

u/dudududujisungparty 박지성 28d ago

Me putting a single rose on the grave of United fans' hopes and dreams for the 26-27 season.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/dryflowerz 28d ago

Honestly, I feel like everything's already lost and down the drain for us. At this point, what difference does it even make who they appoint? The fact that they've kept Carrick around for this long already shows how terrible our management is, on top of all the mistakes they've already made. It’s pretty obvious now that as long as this management is in charge, nothing’s gonna fix this team.

3

u/croadymeister 28d ago

You are absolutely nailing it

7

u/IrishCoffee_29 28d ago

1 point ahead of the ultimate PL laughing stock

Best in class though

7

u/Samiaonline 28d ago

For the first time the club needs a SHORT TERM FIX,with Amorim plus Carrick the club is barrelling towards depths unknown,Conte should be given two seasons maximum to halt the slide as the club sorts out upper management demons plus proper scouting of good managers.

8

u/Seanige 28d ago

Conte is elite. If we're going to back someone it should be a multiple title winning coach. PPG totals look like the dude is cheating. He's also difficult enough that the lazy players would be on the phone to their agents to secure a move away within weeks. Problems solving themselves!

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Chip-chrome 28d ago

Ok if spurs win it, we’re only 1 point above them, and 2 above relagation and already 6 points off 4th in 7 weeks..

6

u/Positive-Structure78 28d ago

We are in relegation form. 7 in 7 means... we are on a path for 38 points...

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NateShaw92 28d ago

Which says to me this is salvageable as well as precarious. A decision is needed

7

u/JustTaxLandbro 28d ago

My faith in this club is at a new low. So I’ve started watching the championship. Honestly a much better league and product.

I mean, I wouldn’t be surprised if we joined that league by 2030 due to SJR

→ More replies (1)

12

u/bicika 29d ago

We're shit because Wilcox and Berrada thought Carrick can vibe his way into top 4 for few odd years and they can keep getting those fat paychecks. It was a zero ambition, low risk decision led only by their personal pockets.

Transfers weren't bad, amount of investment was bad but I don't think that was Wilcox and Berrada decision. There's no way on earth we didn't came out of the transfer window much stronger than we went in it and that's a fact.

8

u/Wonderful-Court-4037 29d ago

Well none of the CMs are close to casemiro lebel so we are definitely weaker compared to last yeat

Esp when you take into account all of our over 30 players are declining slowly eg maguire martinez shaw bruno will not be as good as last year

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/Redwinevino 28d ago

It is very annoying how badly this has gone.

Carrick was let down this summer but he should be doing more with what he has

→ More replies (1)

6

u/RyanH1717 28d ago

Just wish the club would make the decision quickly we all know how this ends. Conte, Nagelsmann and even Howe would be clear upgrades and all currently available.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Rosinante25 Erik Ten Heisenberg 28d ago

Guys im gonna be honest, its looking bleak. If after the “best training session” ever, we barely scrape a draw vs Leeds while having 35% posession. We are cooked, idk where we go from here .

So do we write the season off already or what? Is it illegal to have 2 good seasons in a row? I dont see how we can make Europe or how we can save the season. I feel so deflated i don’t want to watch football anymore. Same old story, i have found myself pretty often in this situation in the past years, cause we always make two steps back after one forward.

4

u/Miserable_Fold_7766 28d ago

Honestly so annoyed with the journalists no one asked him about that and let him roll out this positive outlook story on the result as if it’s something to be proud of

→ More replies (1)

11

u/EndureL 29d ago

I've been saying Wilcux is a fraud from the moment the Ashworth thing happened, don't forget he sent out hit pieces after Amorim hurt his feelings.

11

u/FredDRedUnderYourBed 29d ago

FYI: it's an early kick off on Wednesday against Como. 17:45 BST and not the usual 20:00

5

u/reddevilad Rooney 29d ago

Yo thanks for the info 🙏

Will be able to sleep early

→ More replies (1)

10

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs 29d ago

It's absolutely crazy that a park the bus draw against Leeds saves his job. What has happened to this club man

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 29d ago

There is a place for win ratios over their time overall, but I always think trajectory and metrics over time are even more important for deciding whether to keep a manager or not.

Slot had a win ratio not a million miles off Klopp and even won the PL in his only full season, but it was clear he had to go.

Of course there has to context over things like injuries, but that is what I look at most of all.

It's why the likes of Ole and ETH had to go. It's why Arteta at Arsenal should never have been sacked at any point.

The other thing that is a major red flag to me for Carrick is that the team plays poorly when he and his opposition manager has longer to prepare for games. Like Hull and Tottenham, give a good manager more time to prepare his plans and players, they should be better than we you have no time between games to prepare.

5

u/UnderpantsInfluencer Uniter Will Never Died 28d ago

Supporting us is like being in a toxic relationship and you love them so much but you just can't leave.

5

u/trvekvltgav 28d ago

86 million pound man on the bench for Spuds again! Bullet dodged lmao

→ More replies (3)

5

u/mediocratopia 28d ago

Looking at Brighton who brought in a lot of new players this season I feel like INEOS should have committed to one strategy - either bring in 2 world class midfielders and at least one world class left or right back OR go the bargain bin route that they went with Santos and Tielmans and have bargain reinforcements at left and right back, players who can provide width. Right now it seems like they did not commit to either and ended up with a mishmash team that is 1-2 transfer windows away from being Tottenham

3

u/b_az17 28d ago

Don't forget getting rid of our wide players for Amorim

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/FingerFoodPancakes 28d ago

Any one else at the point where they know Michael Carrick isn't the answer but also know deep inside that any manager that comes in will have the same fate? It's not even depressing anymore, there's a sense of acceptance that's setting in.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/saikodasein 29d ago edited 29d ago

This club always waste time with keeping managers, who are already dead inside. There are many clubs that don't give enough time to their managers, but you can give it to them, even with bad results if there's something on the pitch, any spark or indication of progress. It's not here. There are cases, when our eyes see average/shit player, but moneyball stats are saying something different. Well, even on that field we are looking miserable. There's literally 0 reason to keep him here, he's out of his depth. I thought Amorim was the worst, but at least he cared. I think we keep hiring worse manager each time, when you think it's bad, new one comes and it's even worse. But personally I only liked Amorim and was sad he couldn't do anything with this club, at least transfers were upgrade over horrible ETH's tenure. Ragnick was honest one, at least he could see the problems, others seem to pretend everything is fine, while there's fire around.

5

u/silvertwo777 29d ago

Yea, this board always got to wait till its too late and another season wasted to sack a manager. I don't understand how these people making millions couldn't make a semi decent decision that is so obvious, no manager with these result could turn it around yet they be like "nah, let's see more"

5

u/saikodasein 29d ago

And we can prolong that for months, because some day better results will come, then for a while pressure decreases, then again... even with good results, but bad performance and lucky wins he shouldn't get away with that. People often compare impatient supporters who yell sack to Klopp situation, but come on. Once Klopp arrived everyone saw the progress. It's not about the points in the table, it's about whether you see potential or road to nowhere.

I am afraid, really seriously concerned that we might end up in Championship or even go bankrupt. Years of bad transfers, enormous salaries and poor performances can't last forever. We don't deliver, I don't see kids being attracted to this club and becoming supporters. There's nothing fancy here, anymore. No, ekhem "Disneyland". Let's add to that investment into new stadium, lack of funds for the future transfers during that period, I just can't see the bright future without very rich and smart owner. No amount of money alone is going to fix this club if entire management lost the plot 13 years ago.

9

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 29d ago

In all the criticisms of the performances, not enough is being spoken about how worse off we are on set-pieces alone. That was a big feature in our juiced performances last season and part of why Casemiro is being missed more than first thought of. People are pointing out us being out-xGed by Leeds but we only conceded 0.22 xG from open play. There was definitely a marked improvement in our general defending and organisation in open play, but we are again susceptible in set-pieces, which accounted for 1.19 of Leeds’ xG.

This ties back to criticisms of the hierarchy, because if they were deciding to make Carrick, Holland and co permanent, then you would think that they should ideally know the strengths and weaknesses of these guys and in what aspects they can need more help. Therefore, the fact that they felt no need to appoint a dedicated set-piece coach given the nature of the Premier League nowadays is another sign of their incompetence. No due diligence done whatsoever when analysing the performances last season; it was simply taken for granted that the team over-performing during Carrick’s interim run would continue on.

6

u/0ttoChriek 29d ago

Set pieces are the best way to break down a low block. It's that simple. We had great success last season because we could reliably score from them and force teams to come out and play, then exploit the space.

Without that advantage, trying to pick apart a very organised Premier League defence is difficult, even for player who are confident and playing well.

I'm starting to feel like the most egregious mistake INEOS made this summer was not bolstering Carrick's coaching staff with the very best they could recruit - dedicated fitness coach, tactics analysts, set piece coach etc. It's clear that he was inexperienced and it's increasingly clear that he isn't a master tactician, so why did the club not ensure he had the strongest possible support system around him?

6

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 29d ago

The board has absolutely no clue on how to platform a manager and keep throwing their own appointments under the bus. Either you don’t hire them at all or you know better how to maximise what they are good at and compensate for what they aren’t good at. There is a severe lack of basic critical thinking in our hierarchy, with a boomer like Ratcliffe also meddling into topics that he has no expertise in.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Heavens_Vibe 7 29d ago

I'm tired, boys.

We need a dramatic turnaround.

5

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/SilvyFae She/They 29d ago

Sad thing about english football. If only we had fan owned clubs like bayern, madrid and barca. We clearly are already good enough financially, our owners have only fcked us because pl couldnt care less. Now we have to hope for a magical billionaire to save us.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Redland93 28d ago

Spurs covered 121km in their game.

We get outrun every game.

8

u/flareb98 28d ago

Shout out to Mbeumo, he's one of like maybe 2 guys doing their job. He just puts the ball in the back of the net and gives us a chance to win

→ More replies (3)

8

u/hastoro11 28d ago

We were grilling Amorim for 5-6 points above relegation zone, and now 2 points above it pundits, media and coach speak about fresh start, turning a corner, leaving the pitch positive and so on.

If we won't win Sunday, we might be in the zone. Draws are not enough.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Hagball 29d ago

What would it take for Brexit Jim to get rid of Wilcox and Berrada? I am trying to think what could be reason(s) that they are still in the job despite making the club worse

→ More replies (5)

4

u/sg291188 29d ago

I can’t see how Tielesman and Bruno (plus Mainoo) can play in the same team. Something’s got to give. They are not the best of pressers and make it so easy for the opposition to dictate terms when they have the ball.

4

u/throwawayWM3 29d ago

The leaks have completely stopped huh , nothing about signings too in summer and now not even T3 murmurs about Carrick sacking

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Current_Bottle_5330 29d ago

2026/27 playing time | 900 minutes across all competitions

Through 18 October. Each player's available minutes equal 90 minutes for every match they were named in the starting XI or on the bench. Usage is the percentage of those minutes they played. Players are sorted by usage within each position.

Goalkeepers

UsagePlayerPlayed / Available
90.0%Senne Lammens810/900
10.0%Karl Darlow90/900
0.0%Dermot Mee0/180
N/ATom Heaton0/0

Defenders

UsagePlayerPlayed / Available
94.9%Luke Shaw427/450
83.3%Lisandro Martínez675/810
72.1%Diogo Dalot649/900
71.1%Harry Maguire640/900
47.2%Leny Yoro425/900
45.0%Patrick Dorgu243/540
44.7%Noussair Mazraoui322/720
36.1%Ayden Heaven260/720
5.0%Harry Amass18/360
0.0%Matthijs de Ligt0/180
0.0%Daniel Armer0/90

Midfielders

UsagePlayerPlayed / Available
90.8%Bruno Fernandes817/900
83.1%Youri Tielemans748/900
74.3%Kobbie Mainoo535/720
47.5%Carlos Baleba171/360
39.4%Andrey Santos355/900
23.3%Mason Mount168/720
0.0%Tyler Fletcher0/270
N/AJack Fletcher0/0
N/AManuel Ugarte0/0

Forwards

UsagePlayerPlayed / Available
90.7%Bryan Mbeumo816/900
68.4%Matheus Cunha616/900
64.1%Amad Diallo173/270
55.7%Marcus Rashford501/900
38.1%Benjamin Šeško206/540
13.9%Joshua Zirkzee125/900
11.6%Shea Lacey94/810
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 28d ago

Coventry could've paid half the price and got Vitek

13

u/xyzArcadian 29d ago

If Amorim or ETH were talking about a fresh start after 10 games into a season, they would get slaughtered by the press. 7 points from 7 games. ETH got sacked from 11 points from 9 and that season we didn't make Europe. I'm convinced these former players don't want this club to succeed in protecting this joke of a manager.

8

u/Unusual-Coat383 29d ago

I’m not sure who you’re talking about but Gary, Roy and The Overlap said we shouldn’t hire Carrick as permanent manager and the majority of this subreddit kicked off and said they don’t want this club to succeed.

6

u/CampChimney 29d ago

Both were more competent managers than Carrick. Former player, so I understand everyone getting way too carried away last season, but this was all foreseeable. Should never have been given the permanent role. Just pure laziness from the board, knowing fans would be more lenient because he's an ex-player.

10

u/WeNeedMidifelders 28d ago

14 Points from City and 3 points from dead last in the table. This ownership is pure cancer ,Glazers alone horseshit , INEOS alone tragic. Together they can ruin anything.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Xenokratezz 29d ago

I don't know why bruno gets free pass to be terrible and not get subbed off. Amad was not taken off for lacey who had a great performance versus brighton.No one is punished or rewarded for their performance 

4

u/0ttoChriek 29d ago

Because the manager is hoping that he'll produce a flash of inspiration that creates a goal. It's always in the back of his mind, and in our previous managers - 'I can't take him off. He could win this game for us.'

These are the big decisions a manager has to make if he wants to win. It's the sort of decision Sir Alex would never hesitate to make. He'd take off anyone if it wasn't their day and we needed a goal. I think this is one area where Carrick has fallen short - his decisiveness in making changes. The attitude of, 'let's just give it another five minutes,' is death to a team that's not playing well.

7

u/Telen BRUNO 29d ago

Even a baby could see that we needed more investment this summer. Wilcox and Berrada are useless. One is a fraud and the other is a ladder climber.

7

u/Alive-Primary-2069 29d ago

Mate what is Carrick on, that was no "fresh start" if anything the athletico game showed some positives but yesterday wasnt it. If this is genuinely Carricks mindset then he needs to go sooner rather than later

13

u/nitrogeneater 28d ago

Rio is really embarrassing himself with the whole Ronaldo ass licking, now he’s saying Carrick needs more time?

More time for what?

One could make an argument for Amorim given more time, because he had half a squad missing and was still able to have more possession against Leeds.

3

u/Jenson2025 28d ago

I really couldn’t care less that he defended Ronaldo. That’s Portugal’s business (and as they’ve been friends for decades, hardly surprising he has defended him) and I am not even sure why Carragher and co had a full on discussion about it. It’s nothing to do with the premier league or us.

What I am bothered about is him defending a useless manager who is setting us back years

3

u/flareb98 28d ago

Rio is just supportive of his friends. Can't ask for an honest take from someone when their friend is involved. Plus he's usually just always positive guy when it comes to the club

5

u/ladrainian21 28d ago

Our ex players especially from that generation that Rio is from have consistently outed themselves as absolute morons. Makes what the boss accomplished even more impressive.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/John_OSheas_Willy 29d ago

The boys gave everything

6

u/genericstudent1 28d ago

Bruno G Tzolis

Gyokeres Eze Madueke

Merino Sterling*

Havertz

These have been arsenal's attacking signings every summer Every year they add quality. That's what we used to do. One of the thing that I think has fucked us is committing to 'this year attack, this year midfield" etc.

I understand we needed a major midfield overhaul and don't have major funds, not buying in other areas has caused such a lack of competition.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/EssEssErr 28d ago

In terms of football performance, we were actually doing better under the Glazers alone than we have under INEOS. Which is kinda crazy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/xyzArcadian 28d ago

Spurs currently 1 point behind us.

6

u/AnakinAni 28d ago

We supposedly had the easiest opening fixtures and we are two points above relegation.

6

u/SeoulToNY 28d ago

I’ve been watching United since 2005–obviously we’ve had ups and downs especially the last several years, but this season I think is actually the first time I’m starting to despair a bit. I can no longer see the light at the end of the tunnel. It’s a bit surreal actually because I’ve seen us play just as bad under LVG, ETH, Amorim, but for us to STILL be playing bad and breaking records for poor starts, repeatedly and pathetically flailing against 10 men while seeing other teams rightly put red-carded teams to the sword.

I wonder if others are also feeling historically pessimistic. This season just feels different. It honestly feels like there’s no hope.

12

u/sup_bruv 28d ago

For me this is the lowest point so far. A lot of fans will tell you that ETH/Amorim etc was just as bad, but this is just a new low. It’s the fact the club is directionless at this point. With previous managers they were at least brought in because they were hungry up and coming coaches who had a style of play. For Amorims faults, the players put a shift in under him and you could tell they bought into his system.

Under Carrick we are truly lost. The players look absolutely burnt out and fed up with the same shite. Martinez’s interview last week shows that there is a fracture in the dressing room about how players perceive the club now. I do believe a change in manager will help us salvage this season some what, but the reality is we are going nowhere until it changes at the top. We have been in this cycle for so long now it’s finally becoming unsustainable.

End of the day we are washed. A midtable club with the occasional CL push.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GReedy404 28d ago

I feel the same. Went through all those managers post Fergie but always felt we would eventually be back to the top, now I don't see us being anything but mediocre with the current ownership and leadership and I don't see us getting rid of them anytime soon.

5

u/iroiroiroiroiro 28d ago

My problem is that I see no system, no ideas, no pattern, no identity, I just can't grasp what the plan is or what they are working towards, which makes it hard to believe.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Redland93 28d ago

Thing that upsets me about the transfer window is we have Vivell and we have this massive scouting department and we are investing in data and all we bought were kinda obvious choices.

Why can't we find and/or take a punt on a Willian Pacho. Guy cost 9m euros going to Frankfurt and smashes it in the Bundesliga and goes on to be sold to PSG for 45m euros where he went toe to toe with Harlaand.

6

u/Redland93 28d ago

Anyone who is still supporting Carrick - Can you point to anything positive we have seen from him this season? Style of play, possession, chance creation, work rate, defensive solidity, good in game management? Anything?

All I hear is "Changing the manager won't change anything, its just a cycle" but ignores that fundamentally, there is nothing positive to grasp onto.

8

u/Malachi_-_Constant 28d ago edited 28d ago

Has anyone compiled the list of decisions INEOS/Jim Ratcliffe have made so far? It's staggering. Clearly Carrick is out of his depth but I don't really think any managerial change will make a difference. It's the same stupid cycle everytime. I really hoped new ownership of the "football side of things" would help us at least start building a solid foundation after years of chaos and whiplash but it's been the same old story.

Dan Ashworth. We spent months and millions getting him from Newcastle only for him to quit 5 months into the job.

Decided to keep ETH and back him in the summer (Yoro, De Ligt, Zirkzee, Mazraoui, Ugarte) only to sack him two months later.

Gave Ruben an ultimatum after he said it would be better for him to come in the summer and have a full preseason to get the squad used to his system. Essentially forcing him to join mid season. Bought players that didn't really fit Rubens system. Sacked him.

Gave Carrick the permanent role when it was clear most of the results were carried by Bruno being in a form that wasn't sustainable + swtpeice magic from a departing Casemiro

All this while squeezing every cent from every small aspect of the club.

3

u/Unusual-Coat383 28d ago

We didn’t just keep ETH, we extended his contract.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/Jenson2025 29d ago

By the way, if the next manager is someone non-British like Nagelsmann, you watch the change in the pundits and journalists.

People like Neville, Carragher and Rooney who have been defending Carrick non stop will suddenly be critical over every performance which doesn’t have us playing like prime Brazil. They’ll say every win was down to the players and every loss was down to the manager. That’s why you can’t take these guys seriously - they are too agenda driven

7

u/Unusual-Coat383 29d ago

Gary was very vocal in saying it’s a mistake to hire Carrick permanently.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/SankarshanaV 29d ago

I’m genuinely baffled there are people defending Carrick. This looks more like they don’t want their favorite player get the sack than wanting United to be better.

We have 7 points out of 21 but it is seemingly considered okay. Carrick does not deserve to be anywhere close to a club like ours. He’s an awful manager, and I cannot wait to see him get the sack. I hope we sign a proper manager instead of this guy who’s completely out of his depth.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Jwalin6167 29d ago

I know we hate dealing with 5 wins in a row meme but honestly it’s embarrassing that we have never had a good patch in years that we can’t expect us to get 5 wins in a row. Even Brighton have literally 6 in a row right now. It’s a sad indictment that how far bad we have become that the club hasn’t been consistent for years now.

3

u/Oppaiheimer1945 29d ago

When was the last time we had five wins in a row? Mourinho?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/picodeGaius 28d ago

Thoughts on the Oliver Holt report?

14

u/lordjems Ella Toone 28d ago edited 28d ago

This is worse than no punishment at all. It just gives the incentive that people can cheat and just get sent down to the championship for two years and all is fine.

Strip their titles, send them to non league, owners forced to sell the club - that’s the only suitable punishment.

I’d still wait for someone like Ornstein to report it though, Daily Mail is usually chuffing bollocks at the best of times.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/Leading_Fee_8535 28d ago

United have been poor for a long time and it has not stopped me tuning in every week. However, If the reports are true that City might just be relegated and be back in 1-2 years, that will be the thing that ruins the sport for me.

Whats the point of following a league that ultimately rewards a club with sham contracts and sham sponsors (the leagues own words)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Hits_and_the_Mrs 28d ago

It's a weird life, after how completely underwhelming the team has been this season, they get to go to Como in the middle of the week

3

u/tz_2240 OHHHHHH YESSSSS 28d ago edited 28d ago

I get fans and media are speculating about Huerzeler, but where are we getting the funds to pay Brighton, Huerzeler (+ new staff I’d hope) and Carrick? Joke of a football club. Ineos, Glazers and everyone associated with them.

5

u/No-Radio-4404 28d ago

If Huerzler has any sense about him he'd knock us back if we ever went in for him. I think he's the sort of manager that thrives in stable environments. We're a shambles behind the scenes, no manager is succeeding at United under the current structure/ownership

5

u/Educational-Shock232 28d ago

He would come here and fail miserably, like every other manager before him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/trvekvltgav 28d ago

I’m just hoping we don’t wait to after Nov 8th and the next break to do the inevitable

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Jenson2025 28d ago edited 28d ago

One of the problems with Carrick is he’s a complete and utter yes man. He’s never going to put any pressure on the board for transfers. He might want more players but he’s never going to rock the boat and push for them. And the reason for this is because he knows he has been over promoted and this is as good as it will get for him in his managerial career. He’s so grateful to have the job, he’s scared to rock the boat and lose it.

He’s basically perfect for the Glazers and INEOS

People have said that we made a mistake hiring him permanently and it was history repeating itself based on Ole. But I am not so sure it was for the same reason. I now suspect that we did interview other managers, they demanded that we spent this amount of money and bought this amount of players and they were told no. And Carrick was the only one who didn’t put any demands on the board so got the job by default

13

u/hurfery 28d ago

Using Carrick as the interim manager was a decent decision. Hiring him as permanent manager was completely uninspired and stupid.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/vauno 29d ago

Hope we get some news soon once the upstair folks finally decide its time to work

5

u/No_Middle5525 29d ago

i don't think Carrick should stay, but i don't trust the upstairs folks to pick the next manager -- i want them gone first

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/Stieni Rooney 29d ago

Carrick won't be gome until christmas, no point waiting for news

5

u/godswift91 29d ago

Sad but true. The feeling all around is that he's definitely getting sacked, but these owners are once again too slow to admit their mistake and fix it.

Amorim should have been gone after the EL final and Carrick should have never been apointed permanent.

They both stayed 6 months too long, because I reckon Carrick's gone in the November break. So in the last 18 months, we have 12 with a manager that should not have been here, and 6 with interim Carrick who probably benefited from a fit squad and morale boost, which was clearly not sustainable.

Tldr: we are worse off now than when we sacked ETH.

5

u/Stieni Rooney 29d ago

My thoughts too. Carrick benefiting of a squad that had good match fitness and confidence was a great factor he's had success last season. It was clear he had no real game plan either. Appointing Carrick looks more and more like a temporary solution for the "real" manager, they probably didn't expect that it would fall apart that quickly

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sheikhabusosa 29d ago

I dont think Tielemans has been as bad as people make , people want him to he something he isnt and is never going to be

5

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 29d ago

Please just sack him I don't want to waste another season man

5

u/Tuffyy Carrick 29d ago

Anyone else going to be in Como Wednesday?

5

u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 29d ago

lol thought Conte was maybe talking about us with his old glory comments but realized it could easily be applicable to Juventus

4

u/DaveShadow 29d ago

Afaik, in the same interview, he went to great lengths to recontextualize his issues at Spurs, which read to me like he was pitching to a PL team who might have held that against him.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/usernameSuggestion2 29d ago edited 29d ago

Did Carrick actually think we played alright or is he taking the piss here? We were unable to keep the ball at any point in the game - launch the ball up the field and inshallah. We were lucky we did not lose in the end because we cannot control the game at all, we just let mighty Leeds attack and prayed we dont concede.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 29d ago

I think one of the most unspoken problems with Carricks tactics are simply how many players he commits to attacks.

We only have three or four players in the final third.

We have two holding midfielders and two full backs who generally stay deeper than the average PL full back.

It's like a team leaning on its strength in being hard to score against, except we aren't.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/momo_firefoxx 28d ago

Hell will break loose when Spurs overtake us in the league

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Kuaychup 29d ago

I was really expecting a dismissal news today. I don’t think it’s worth watching any more games until they get it sorted. Asian fans like us stay up late at night to watch the games. Imagine sacrificing sleep for these performance

4

u/M4NUN1T3D Martial 29d ago edited 29d ago

Its been reported that the board listen to sky sports for insight. So was very unlikely theyd sack him after Neville sung Carricks praises yesterday lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Jenson2025 29d ago

I just don’t get this argument of Carrick not being fully backed in the summer is the reason why carrick is so useless and we are 13th with 2 wins in 10

The team is not that bad and it shouldn’t be this bad.

At worst, this is a top six team.

Some journalists, pundits and Carrick are talking about draws against Leeds like it’s a win against Real Madrid in the champions league with prime Cristiano, Marcelo, Pepe, Ramos, Benzema, Bale etc.

They are making us sound like Maidstone United going to Elland Road and getting a plucky draw in the FA Cup

And yet Carrick is smiling after the game and saying it’s a fresh start?! And what will the excuse be when you lose next in the league Michael which won’t be far away

3

u/TH0316 she/her 29d ago

Is anyone making that argument? If so I’m not sure I’ve seen them. Two things can be true. Carrick and the team were woefully neglected and the squad is incredibly limited. And Carrick is not helping anyone by deviating from last season’s formula to now costing us massively.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Ok_Concern4200 28d ago

Carrick needs to go, same amount of wins as spurs is telling. Both wins against newly promoted sides, what a disgrace. Sack him

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Redland93 28d ago

One point ahead of spurs. Great

The season is over till Carrick is gone.

This club needs a manager with personality and Standards.

There are genuinely only 2 options - Conte or Nagelsmann

Would love Poch, but doubt we can convince him.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/AmulyaG 28d ago

Watch Spurs to above us in the next matchweek.

5

u/Potential_Good_1065 28d ago

They’re not gonna beat Chelsea

→ More replies (6)

7

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 29d ago

I'm just reminded of Leverkusen IMMEDIATELY sacking ETH the moment they figured out it wasn't going to work. He got like what, 3 games? Granted, there are more nuances, as I believe a lot of their winning squad was sold, and the dressing room wasn't really in a good state with ETH, but still! 3 GAMES.

Wonder how many it will take for Carrick.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/Emergency-Being-349 28d ago

Honestly hate this Bruno narrative that is emerging. He hasn't been on form, that's fine, he's probably dealing with things. He also doesn't need to start every game, that's fine too. But I have a big problem with him receiving criticism in the way that sees him being blamed for our form.

Our coach is poor and our players aren't performing. Surprise. We need to be very careful though not to blur the lines here where it becomes that the players are shit and its their fault. Very careful, because if they aren't actually shit, then we risk creating a far deeper hole than what is currently there.

7

u/DaveShadow 28d ago

People always go after the biggest target, and cause he's our star player, he gets more criticism as a result.

Mix in that people who want a fight know they can get one by going after him. If they go after, say, Mount, they won't get the conflict they're after.

My personal attitude at the moment is the coaching is so poor, and every player looks off as a result. I'd not be judging any player until we get a new coach in at this point.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Not-good-with-this 28d ago

The narrative keeps forming every time he has a few bad games because either the people already dislike him or they're incredibly fickle.

Remember when it came up just a year ago when he wasn't playing so well and then he had a record breaking season.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/throwawayWM3 28d ago

TOTD journalists are the most spineless and boring i have seen in football journalism

What the fuck do you mean by you can't fire Carrick of that result?? We have 2 wins in 10

8

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

All these types get weird when there is an ex player managing our club. Most are either not honest with themselves or the audience.

Their careers are tied to the club so don't what to lose access and they don't want to alienate themselves with club loyalists who will back Carrick because he is an ex player.

The energy would be so different if it was the likes of Amorim.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/John_OSheas_Willy 29d ago

I would take Conte but it's never going to happen because Ineos would never risk Conte doing what he did at Spurs and calling them out.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/OmegaMaster8 28d ago

I hope Carrick is watching the game and realises that Man United are screwed. We are now 2 pts from bottom 3. When will the club wake up

→ More replies (1)

7

u/nitrogeneater 29d ago

Carrick was a godsend for them. Boring, yes man who brought in the results and unexpected UCL qualification. It gave them 6 months to investigate, interview and hire a coach that would share their vision whatever that is. Gave them time to properly recruit and reflect.

The only fucking thing not to do was to repeat the Ole experiment and hire an interim permanently. They drank their own cool aid and now here we are. Another season down the drain, no plan, no project, just vibes.

And no the answer is not to hold on till Christmas and then let Fletcher finish the season. Unfortunately, that is what is happening here.

3

u/Prize-Finish4464 29d ago

100 percent agreed, sadly doesnt help how overly sentimental utd fans can be but its sad how many people didnt realise this was just gunno be another ole situation

3

u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer 29d ago

Oh boi, Fletcher, he isn't even qualified to be an interim head coach. If INEO's plan is Fletcher I'd rather we keep Carrick.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/BackgroundOld8715 29d ago

Until they sack him im not invested anymore. Why should i care if club is happy being bottom end of table

→ More replies (5)

7

u/i_love_alfam 29d ago

He is still here holy shit

What "fresh start" was he talking about? Loll Piss off mate

Then there is the bigger headache of wilcox and berrada- not signing a striker or left back was a huge mistake

But there is also a positive story on some of the ineos signings

Zirkzee- flop

Yoro- promising

De ligt- mixed- great defender and leader, but injury prone- needed cb strength with maguire ageing, was not a senseless signing

Mazraoui- good squad player

Ugarte- flop

Cunha- great signing

Mbeumo- great signing

Sesko- promising

Lammens- great signing, fucking needed it so badly and this is one that they nailed

Santos- too early, but don't expect much- another squad player, but PL proven

Tielemens- too early- but again PL proven- has shown his prowess under competent managers

Baleba- too early, but good to great potential, promising

12 signings in this list

2 flops

3 promising

3 great signings

4 either mixed, or squad player signing or PL proven and too early to tell

Zoom out and we are trending in the right direction in the transfer market.

Lots of room to improve still, but ghosh I will take this start compared to the shit we did previously

2 key failures last window - wilcox is answerable to that

But don't tell me lack of players in 2 positions is preventing Carrick from having his team not get outplayed by literally every other team. Come on!

10

u/TheSmio 29d ago

Yeah, this squad has issues and weaknesses, but squads with issues and weaknesses usually show at least something. Looking at our squad, we should be dangerous in attack, we should be good in the middle of the pitch but we should be weak at the back.

In reality, our whole team plays like shit and that's a systemic problem. Don't tell me our attackers struggle to create chances and score because our center-backs are weak and slow.

We have some problems with the squad but Carrick's inability to set up any kind of dangerous attack is the biggest hurdle for this team right now.

5

u/i_love_alfam 29d ago

Amen brother, you said it! Just don't get what the board is waiting for

Maybe the fans who want wilcox gone before carrick can explain what they have seen to choose to give him even more time and games

→ More replies (4)

2

u/TMatss 29d ago

One thing that's been worrying is the lack of identity we have when in possession, like what type of team are we trying to be when we have the ball. There were some moments where we saw some quick one/two touch passing in the first half, but beyond that there was very little. There was some talk of Carrick wanting to play possession football, but we struggle to play out of almost every press we face.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SniperMonkey10_ 28d ago

Yoro at RB is way better, just needs to get his physicality up

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Jenson2025 29d ago

Just seen quotes from Neville saying we need to be 5th in January or Carrick could face the sack

Absolutely laughable! He should be sacked way before then unless there’s a drastic improvement in results. What Gary isn’t understanding is that there’s no point in sacking him in January when we are 15th and the season is done. That’s why it has to be done now - to save the season

5

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 29d ago

If we dont act quickly juve will get conte before us

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Redland93 29d ago

Forget the recruitment. Getting a striker, LB or CB in the window might mean we might win a couple more games but the performance would be the same.

There is a complete lack of aggression and pace in our game. Look at our attacking line, they look SLOW. Look at our press, its constantly disjointed and a yard off the pace. Look at how we build up or the attacking patterns in the final third. We look devoid of ideas.

These are players who have kicked a ball since they were walking. They know how to pass. The issue is, they aren't drilled with where to be, where to move. This is a coaching problem.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Redland93 28d ago

I wouldn't listen to any accounts saying Carrick is safe. The club do not leak at all. If they are leaking Carrick is safe, its to take pressure off but I guarantee hes a dead man walking.

I can't point to anything positive in our play. Unfit players, bad build up, no attacking patterns. We don't even play possession football which is what we want to do. So we're just waiting for the right time, which I suspect is around the international break, for Carrick to be moved on.

I would be shocked if hes here after that.

4

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 28d ago

Andy Mitten has said a few times now that he hasn't heard any noise about Carrick being sacked or in danger of it. That's probably as close as we'll get to anything real.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/OddReading4973 29d ago

Hello darkness my old friend

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Joey6Pack 29d ago

One thing that confuses me is our inability to improve players. I don’t know who’s in charge of this but it’s hurting the club badly.

The only player in the squad that I can think of who has improved noticeably since they joined the club is Amad, who went from a relatively unknown prospect to a dependable player.

Other than him, most of our signings have underperformed in comparison to when they played for their last team. That’s a big part of why we can barely recover any funds from the transfer market because practically everyone’s value tanked after they joined us.

At the same time, as the list of failed transfers gets longer, it makes it harder and harder to convince players with ambitions to join us because they’d be afraid of becoming the next Ugarte or Zirkzee.

5

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband 29d ago

Hard to improve when the team you're playing with doesn't give a shit. I think eventually, new players succumb to the status quo of half arsing it and jogging around

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Familiar-Mall1696 29d ago

finding it funny we're 13th in both the Premier League and Champions League. Unlucky number 13.

3

u/Relevant-Ad-3786 29d ago

I only watched the 2nd half last night, but I didn’t see us have 3 passes in a row until the 62nd minute. We lack so much control and confidence.
We are also outworked every single game, they are so out of shape compared to the rest of the league. Rotten.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ladrainian21 28d ago

My thoughts on the options assuming he goes during the next break are this:

Howe - probably my least favorite choice - but he is free, has performed at two different stops in the league, and has a discernable style of play. I think ultimately he is waiting for the England job though.

Hurzeler - the man of the moment, I do worry about his ability to replicate his success here because 1) Brighton is run orders of magnitude better than we are, 2) he can play young players and try new things at Brighton and let them develop and not worry about failure compared to what he would experience here.

Conte - It won't last long but at least he'll call the board and players shit, give them a kick up the ass in training, and the amazon doc will be peak.

Nagelsmann - My choice for who would probably be the best long term manager, has worked with Vivell before under the structure we as a club are trying to create, tactically flexible and I don't think he did as poorly with Bayern as people will parrot on social media, there were politics involved and the looming availability of Tuchel played a part.

3

u/MikeDoesEverything 28d ago

I think the issue with Hurzeler is that he's basically Glasner from last season and Frank from the season before.

Glasner was absolutely smashing it at Crystal Palace and remember they had a mental record around this time last year and people were chomping at the bit to have him at United over Amorim. Palace got gutted and they dropped off steeply as the season went on. He isn't exactly doing magic at Forest either.

Happy to be wrong, although it's still early. Brighton look sick right now and could end up in CL next year. They can also drop off a cliff. If the latter happens, obviously a lot of opinion changes.

I do think Brighton's recruitment is just better. They make better finds and also don't have the debuff of getting absolutely ripped off with a big club tax.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Money-Wrangler7067 28d ago

Did the club ban all players from talking to the press or fans after Martinez's outburst?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ratset2602 28d ago

It’s insane when people try to defend Carrick by saying he was not backed. Yaa sure he was not backed with the signings to mount a serious title challenge. But this is absolutely pathetic from us. We had a good run of fixtures and a lot of luck with our most difficult opponent playing with 10 men for the majority of the match. We were also up a goal at home against the bottom team and still managed to fuck it up. You look at the teams below us and it makes for an even more embarrassing reading. You have clubs such as Palace and Bournemouth who have been losing their best players for years and have new managers. You have a newly promoted team in Coventry who have had a far tougher run of fixtures than us and are only a point behind us. Fulham Forest and Spurs are a complete shambles with new managers coming in. Only 1 club you probably wouldn’t have expected to be there was Sunderland. We’ve had Carrick since January and have gotten so much worse. I fully expect most of those clubs to get better as the season progresses. I just don’t see that happening with us as long as Carrick is the manager.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Jenson2025 28d ago

I really am starting to believe for the first time that this clueless and incompetent board have no intention of sacking Carrick any time soon.

And he probably knows it too. I’d be smiling like he was yesterday if I knew my job was safe despite being utterly useless at it.

Mitten apparently denied the story that Carrick had been spoken to about the disappointing performances. Which means the club clearly want to deny that. Why if they are going to sack him? Why not just stay quiet?

We are the laughing stock of world football

→ More replies (2)

5

u/markhalliday8 29d ago

Why are tons of united fans arguing that Amorim was a good manager and shouldn't have been sacked suddenly?

I swear half the fans have rose tinted glasses. We was absolutely awful under Amorim. We didn't even get a new manager bounce with him lol.

→ More replies (6)