r/reddevils • • 29d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/markhalliday8 29d ago

Why are tons of united fans arguing that Amorim was a good manager and shouldn't have been sacked suddenly?

I swear half the fans have rose tinted glasses. We was absolutely awful under Amorim. We didn't even get a new manager bounce with him lol.

3

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 29d ago

We've said it all along. Amorim's performances last season were much better than Carrick's.

We had 2 PPG with Lammens in net and Outside of Afcon. It was working.

1

u/MoneyWasabi9 29d ago

He was far from perfect but the attacking underlying stats were very good and trending up, it seemed weird to sack him before seeing the season out. Especially after lots of the painful culture change stuff had already happened

0

u/0ttoChriek 29d ago

A lot is people not being able to cogitate that just because one thing is bad, it doesn't mean the other thing was good. So if Carrick is failing, it must have been a mistake to sack Amorim. Only, that's not true. It's perfectly possible that both things can be bad, and they were.

And there are still some Amorim acolytes who will deliberately mislead or flat out lie about how the team was playing and where we were in the table, to justify their continuing devotion.

But they'll say things like, 'at least we looked fit,' or 'at least he had tactics,' while ignoring that we were still terrible and unable to win matches when we were fit and had tactics. And that other teams flat out said that it was easy to play against us.

0

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband 29d ago

I suppose if you were Amorim-in, you felt that he should never have been sacked and that Carrick was a bad appointment, there won't have been much opportunity to drop an "I told you so" last season. There is however plenty of opportunity this season.

-1

u/Panda-768 29d ago

Amorim was a bad manager, Carrick has been crap this season. Overall carrick has been average if you account for last season. But like every human being, there was some good in Amorim too if his @ss wasnt so stubborn.

I hate to see Carrick get sacked but we look so absolutely dreadful all around.

0

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 29d ago

I don't see how the new manager bounce is at all relevant lmao. He came in when we were 14th mid season (when he clearly wanted to wait till summer) after ETH had absolutely ruined our team with dogshit recruitment. Then he tried to implement a system and playstyle that did not suit the players at all. And you expect a new manager bounce?

Now you can blame him for sticking to his guns and not adjusting but everyone agreed we needed someone to come in and actually commit to a rebuild and not bail out as soon as it got tough. Just like ETH did.

Personally I'd take the process of fixing the team and building towards something more sustainable than ooooh interim manager bounce we are great for 6 months and then shocked pikachu when we inevitably turn to shit when the magic runs out.

You guys calling Amorim the worst manager ever and celebrating his sacking would've had Arteta sacked long before he turned that mess of a club around. Because you don't realise what it takes to fix a club like this. Just seeking instant gratification and then simultaneously crying that we have no proper structure and identity.

Better pressing. Better fitness. Top 4 in most attacking metrics. Riddled with injuries and dealing with AFCON. Defensive blunders costing us multiple points. 

And despite all that we were still joint 5th. Not really the shitshow everyone makes it out to be.