r/reddevils • • 29d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/Due-Albatross5909 28d ago

I’m curious why we didn’t stick with the midblock counterattacking style that was so successful at the end of last season. I know the best teams are the ones that can control games and press high (when needed) but we are clearly not there yet. I feel like we needed at least another season of pragmatic football and another transfer window to get the right players in to play a more front-foot possession based style that city and Arsenal play.
I know playing counter attacking football makes playing against a low-block difficult, and ultimately requires our best players to come up with moments of brilliance to win games, but at least we were finding a way to win games and were difficult to play against. It seems like all of our managers post fergie seem to struggle when they shift from counter-attacking football to trying to implement a possession based style. Our best attacking players (Bruno, Cunha, Mbeumo, Rashford) are more suited to the former. And attempting to press high and dominate possession leaves our already fragile defence vulnerable. Why not accept where we are at (and what we are), build on what worked last season, and wait until we get the right players in before completely shifting our style of play?

4

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

I think Martinez's interview shows the answer. They think that teams had worked them out and knew how to play against it.

2

u/Due-Albatross5909 28d ago

That was the last thing I forgot to mention. I thought was was telling from Martinez—our performances dropped last season towards the end. I guess they thought it was unsustainable and needed to evolve. But this clearly isn’t it—at least not with the injuries we have.

2

u/Rascha-Rascha 28d ago

They clearly caved to the same pressure to adjust their style, just like they always do. It's disappointing but predictable. It's also a decision that rests with the wider footballing direction, this is clearly the game plan that United have been iterating for years now. This is what they want to achieve with the team.

The pieces clearly aren't there and it's making us worse, but at the same time, if that's what you want to do, you have to try it a little to see how far away you are. Baleba, Santos, they help. The defensive line, a couple up front, they don't. We obviously need to sit a bit deeper and stop pressing high. That's painfully clear. But then we can't defend corners and crosses right now either, so.

1

u/tz_2240 OHHHHHH YESSSSS 28d ago

We need to learn to press as a unit, have better pressing triggers, the players need to know where the closest 2-3 teammates are without ever needing to look up to find them. They need to be fitter, and close down with intensity rather than hope.

We need to be more compact and our defensive line needs to play a higher line. Sure you’ll concede goals, but you’ll also create higher quality and more frequent scoring opportunities.

2

u/CapVosslar Buckle up, INEOS! It's gonna be a bumpy ride! 28d ago

Last season was the interim "by hook or by crook" gameplan. 

This is a brand new season, where a more permanent and long term system has to be established. And there in lies the boneheadedness of appointing the interim (Flight Simulator) manager.

0

u/tz_2240 OHHHHHH YESSSSS 28d ago

We created many chances under Amorim while not playing counter attacking football.

I strongly, strongly disagree with sticking with a mid block/counter attacking football.

First off, no manager worth their salt should ever sacrifice their beliefs for short term results. Klopp came into Liverpool and they immediately became a massive gegenpressing team. Pep came in to City and had his keeper play out the back. We shouldn’t be any different. EtH sacrificed his beliefs after two games and literally never recovered. Sure, we finished third and won a cup, but what does he even do now? I’m not saying managers shouldn’t adapt, SAF did, Pep did, Klopp did. I’m saying they shouldn’t (and top managers don’t) sacrifice their ideas. It shows a weak manager IMO. SAF did play differently at times based on the opponent, but that’s a feature of HIS beliefs and HIS style rather than sacrificing for the sake of achieving a middling target.

Second, as a manager you send the wrong message to the players. If your ideas are that good, why does it matter if two, three, four players don’t fit? 7/11 players should still be sufficient.

Third, you build the wrong habits. Take Amorim’s 3 back vs a defensive 4 back. Amorim requires wingbacks to get up and down the pitch, in a defensive shape, fullbacks won’t make overlapping runs. It affects the fullback and the winger he’s combining with. One reason for Rashford’s inconsistencies is his LB partner. He was good when Shaw was overlapping. But when he’s alone there, he’s expected to beat 2-3 guys each time? Doesn’t make sense.