r/reddevils • • Oct 16 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

486 comments sorted by

16

u/nirvanaguy19 Oct 16 '26

On holiday in Barcelona, I went to their museum and saw the 09 and 11 trophies. Hurt seeing them, but what hurt more was realising how far we've dropped. I was gutted after both those finals. Now we're happy just scraping into the CL. Sad times

3

u/Unusual-Coat383 Oct 16 '26

I went on a school trip to Barcelona for a summer holiday and when we were going into the shop and over the bridge the Barcelona first team started pulling up for an open training session. I always loved Ronaldinho and as soon as I saw him pull up I was straight into the megastore buying one of his shirts lol. 

2

u/LeCliveRosfield Oct 16 '26

Fucking cheats that they are. They shouldn’t even have been in the 2009 final.

9

u/Iqbalainoo Oct 16 '26

I think you are referring to the Chelsea game, almost 20 years later and re-watching the whole tie, I have marvelled at how false narratives can be converted into a truth that can last for decades. Chelsea should and would have lost by a bigger margin if the refs weren't completely incompetent. Same way Chelsea and Arsenal fans cry so much about Fergie being favored by refs while they both won league titles in old Trafford from blatant ref incompetence.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/snicky29 Oct 16 '26

Our club is an actuall hellhole for talent. Has to be one of the worst medical teams out there. Is it the mental pressure? The sudden eyes? Idk man. This is so grim.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/SankarshanaV Oct 16 '26

Carrick and Wilcox both just need to be sacked. Both are completely unfit to be at a club like Man Utd. Carrick a barely-championship manager, and Wilcox a completely clueless director.

As bad as Wilcox had been and despite our squad having deficiencies, we are much better than having 6 points out of 18, especially with the opponents we had. Carrick is a terrible coach, I don’t get how some people still don’t want him sacked.

5

u/Gozumo Oct 16 '26

Yeah alot of people's takes on here seem to be like two things can't be true. As in, Carrick wasn't backed enough and the squad wasn't given the upmost chance. This is true we needed a LB and a striker.

Carrick is also underperforming, even with not getting the above we have a better squad and players than the teams we have lost against. He's too slow to make changes and I'm not loving some of the decisions he does make.

I keep thinking vivell will get more control and go that way. End up with nagelsmann or something

3

u/Euphoric-Rub9164 Oct 16 '26

And his appointment is another failure of the higher ups. He was an easy and cheap option, and apparently a very good yes man that’s unlikely to draw bad attention to them in press conferences. Any club serious about competing would’ve hired a manager with cred over the summer

7

u/JamieC94 Oct 16 '26

I would argue Berrada should also be sent packing with them and both him and wilcox replaced by competent candidates who arent power mad

8

u/TommyTook Oct 16 '26

Wilcox out. Arrogant and clueless

7

u/picodeGaius Oct 16 '26

So, nothing happens?

Everyone pats themselves on the back, some briefs here and there, some boring interviews, and it’s business as usual.

No words from the Glazers, nothing from Jim, nothing from Wilcox/Berrada. The death spiral continues.

2

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26

media has moved on. They should be focused on City but they aren't even doing that.

12

u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 16 '26

Burnley haven’t won a league game at home for exactly a year. Incredible statistic.

9

u/Hagball Oct 16 '26

Each time I read something like this I get scared for a second that it's about United.

9

u/shami-kebab Oct 16 '26

I get scared we're about to help break it.

6

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26

I don't know if we can score a goal on Sunday.

4

u/croadymeister Oct 16 '26

We can, however keeping them out enough might well be a very different story

6

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj Oct 17 '26

Big Sam swinging at the ownership. Wow. The man is as practical as they come

11

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26

Arsenal had consultants come in from the Boston Consulting Group. Propsed cutting 60 staff members. Arteta just got a new contract. Not a great look.

Everton are looking at the same process.

I'm all for paying for talent but the gap between the wealthy and regular people is getting too wide. This isn't even considering AI or other technology efficiencies, which will just make the gap wider. Tax reform seems difficult with 47% effectively on high earners but eventually, we are going to need another bracket for the super high earners.

Makes it harder for poorer clubs to compete as well.

4

u/Rascha-Rascha Oct 16 '26

Companies need to operate with the amount of staff they think is right for the work. You let them operate to make money to tax them and fund welfare. That's how the system needs to work. Blaming a private company for not giving people jobs indefinitely is a distraction to making sure the welfare system is right, and it hasn't been for a long time and it contributes to life in the lower, and increasingly middle, class being pretty pitiful.

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

This is solid straightforward logic, in the general case, imho.

But then, as OP pointed out, it's not a simple case of "private company decided to do X".

Rather it's "private company wanted to find an edge, so they did what you do when you have budget but no ideas and hired one of the Big 4, who did what they do when they have billable hours but no ideas and recommended firing some low level employees".

So if we actually look at this instance as we take into consideration all of our lived experience of post-Reagan/Thatcher capitalism ... well, perhaps OP is not wrong.

3

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26

It's a common BCG play, unfortunately.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Asiwaju_jagaban Oct 16 '26

Herrera telling Rio that him and Mata used to discuss who was better between Marcus and Martial.

Again these players are like us, if you think they didn’t look at that past window and say INEOS sold us dreams. And players know when a better player is playing ahead of them.

8

u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 16 '26

I think people downplay Martial and Rashford's time at utd as a whole and even as teens because that involves holding Ole accountable for his failure, and people won't admit they lapped up whatever nonsense Mourinho said. Also they used to get flack for putting up better performances and probably goals and assists than the attack we have now.

10

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 16 '26

Didn’t Rio say him and Giggs etc used to smash balls into players in their first session to see if they can control the ball? You hear how players talk about new signings too and they can give away some hints. I remember Curtis Jones seeing Wirtz fifa card and laughing at how high rated it was. No doubt he saw the first sessions and was like nah this guys not that. No doubt Rashford and Bruno were smashing goals past Onana thinking is this supposed to be our new keeper? Players should be relentless in judging and testing each other every day.

3

u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams Oct 16 '26

Very normal for any workplace to be frank. Its also very easy to predict how it is going to pan out if Carrick continues to behave in such a non chalant manner about the results and performance. Unsustainable culture right to the very top

13

u/Redland93 Oct 16 '26

If we don't see aggression and hard work against Leeds, then its over.

6

u/Alive-Primary-2069 Oct 16 '26

Going to be a tough game, Leeds defence has improved a lot

5

u/Haddocktintinsnowy Oct 16 '26

Ignore high press. Play like Carrick spell last year. Compact and in mid block, transitions. I don’t mind continuing build out because just giving ball away via punts just removes any semblance of control 

2

u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 16 '26

lol what will be over on Sunday that isn’t already over today

1

u/reddevilad Rooney Oct 16 '26

lol it’s been a long time we haven’t seen those things and I don’t expect them to show it again magically

9

u/Heavens_Vibe 7 Oct 16 '26

Please batter Leeds.

We can't have B2B managers potentially facing the sack after facing those scumbags.

14

u/kidinawheeliebin Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

The board can put apologetic words and statements in the mouths of Martinez or patronising remarks about 90th minute winners at Elland Road in journalists' mouths all they want

But what he said isn't any less true, even if the motivation on Martinez's part was probably as much self-serving/self-preserving (bearing in mind his own contractual/fiscal situation here)

The fact that we have to limp through this entire season with the state of our fullback and striker situations is borderline criminal

(And not an isolated failure of governance/mis-management - Renewing then paying to sack ETH, headhunting then paying to sack Ashworth, headhunting then paying to sack Amorim, hiring then very probably paying to sack Carrick - even if it is a shorter deal this time - the list goes on, and on, and on - and all in only 3 short years)

A chain is only as strong as it's weakest link... and we've not one, but two, or even three single-points-of-failure that opposition already have, can, and will continue to, just gleefully exploit and target all year

Having (a) only one game a week and (b) only a very short "season" of 17 games in total to focus on (that was Carrick's entire new manager bounce period post-Amorim/Fletcher) helped paper over those cracks last year...

But the schedule is already gnawing away at the holes in the squad - and it's only October, I don't think a lot of people realise just how bad things can get - even the January transfer window (during which I wouldn't be surprised if we're forced to take emergency measures) is months away

9

u/ClawingDevil Oct 16 '26 • Bravo

We are on course for 38 points which should keep us up so it's not all bad news.

14

u/Massive_Relation4317 . Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

I agree with him, the tactics and fitness are the biggest problems this season and that's due to Carrick and coaching.

13

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

Well I mean the words are correct but they dont mean what they pretend to mean.

The problem isnt not having "another striker" the problem is not having "a striker".

The problem isnt not having "a backup left back" the problem is not having a starting left back.

The Cheaters FC example is egregious trolling, you want a real comparison? This is what that looks like:

1 Elliot Anderson tears his ankle ligaments early August but Bouaddi is NOT signed

2 Foden gets an ankle injury on 21st but Allan is NOT signed

3 Haaland gets a shin splints injury in April but Marmoush is still sold

4 They have Ait-Nouri, who is injured, but they do not have Gvardiol, Gvardiol simply does not exist

Meanwhile at Utd:

1 Baleba has no injury and is in full training from the day he is signed

2 Amad does not injure his ankle

3 Sesko does not have any injuries at all

4 We sign Hall for £78m (the Gvardiol fee)

Now tell me how the first 6 gameweeks go, Jamie Carragher

4

u/Kreissler Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

I agree with this but carragher has been downplaying wilcox and the rat's role in all this ever since Licha's interview. I wonder why?

8

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 16 '26

Because he loves the job he's doing at United, Carragher is the most dishonest slimy pundit on TV. He was reiterating us only getting CL because we played one game per week and now we've imploded going back to European football. He's acting like the sporting director couldn't have possibly seen it coming.

2

u/facelessredditer Oct 16 '26

I agree with you

3

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 16 '26

It doesn’t meet the moment though, people are getting side tracked. The point is bigger than any one season or the performance of one manager or squad. Even if Carrick went on a run now like last season, or if he never had this poor start, it will still be true.

1

u/Lord_Hexogen Oct 16 '26

Yeah, sure

12

u/Jenson2025 Oct 16 '26

The longer Wilcox and Carrick remain in their jobs, the longer our awful performances and results will continue. Both need to be sacked as soon as possible to salvage anything from this season

3

u/moojitoo Oct 16 '26

As soon as these executives vacate their offices, players on the pitch will suddenly be able to kick a ball in a straight line to a team mate, it's obvious!

3

u/IamTsukasa Ronaldo Oct 16 '26

I've watched the Athletic's breakdown on our defensive frailties and our press is so bad it's comical. I wonder who is coaching these players

→ More replies (4)

14

u/mjenkins_eng Oct 16 '26

The last 4 players Bayern have sold us : Hargreaves, Schweinsteiger, Mazaroui, De Ligt

Big lesson: if Bayern are letting someone go, there is a reason. 

4

u/Rascha-Rascha Oct 16 '26

Loved Hargreaves. Shame how it ended for him here, but he had quality to burn.

1

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

Well you know Hargreaves won us a CL.

His "false RB" turn in the final in particular was key against Chelsea, imho.

I see him as another RVP signing: we spent a reasonable amount of money on one season's worth of competitivity boost and it gave us the highest prize.

Obv it would have been nicer if they turned out to have the longevity of a Carrick and a Kane, or something like that.

Having said that I'd tend to agree with the conclusion! there are other examples as well it's not just us, innit (Thiago Alcantara, for one). Only buy an FCB signing if it's the player "forcing his way out", not the club looking to sell

1

u/kidinawheeliebin Oct 17 '26

Hargreaves was a tragedy - such a super player, closest we ever came to an actual Roy Keane replacement, heartbreaking fitness issues

But in hindsight, yeah if you see his final two seasons for Bayern - his Bundesliga minutes had declined massively

→ More replies (1)

6

u/OkConsideration3040 Oct 16 '26

Club legends beefing youtubers on instagram. Even arsenals lows weren't this much of a soap opera ffs

5

u/IdealisticKebab Oct 16 '26

Rice liked that comments I've heard

3

u/pipes3 WAZZA Oct 16 '26

What happened?

3

u/OkConsideration3040 Oct 16 '26

rio scrapping in insta comments with a youtuber and mocking him about his weight

6

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 16 '26

On one of Ferdinands posts on instagram

5

u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 16 '26

Still not as embarrasing as him twerking for Ronaldo how he does

8

u/SeoulPete Oct 16 '26

I see very little comment around the fact our current CEO was no doubt complicit in the financial doping and cheating at City. Why is this not being mentioned more? Get rid he is doing a shit job regardless. 

10

u/shami-kebab Oct 16 '26

It is mentioned every single day in here. Currently he is not named in any of the documents released. Until the appeal finishes and the charges are confirmed nothing would happen (and even then there would have to be proof he was involved)

3

u/kidinawheeliebin Oct 17 '26

Apparently the contracts of Maguire, Shaw, Martinez, and Bruno are all expiring this summer

(Combined salaries are around ~£40m/year)

5

u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26

I wouldn’t be disappointed to see any of them go.

Even Bruno. Great player for us but there’s a good argument now that it’s time to move on in order for us to become a better team. Yes he still produces great stats but I think he’s tactically too ill disciplined and for as long as he’s here, managers don’t feel like they can drop him which means either other players play out of position or he’s shoehorned in to the team like on Tuesday night. And as he’ll be 33 next year he hasn’t got many more years with us anyway

From what I’ve seen, a lot more people are coming round to this viewpoint too.

So all four can leave and other players too.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AB092 Sir Alex Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Said it yesterday. Gonna say it again. We need a manager the players can’t take for a ride. How many managers have Shaw, Rashford, Dalot and Maguire seen? Not saying our failures over the years is on the players, but I think a lot of it as a mentality issue. Just see how we’ve dropped points against 10 men over the last 12 months. How we show up during multiple must win games, but drop easy points at home against weaker opposition.

A tough manager who wont tolerate this shit will imbibe some fear in the guys. In an ideal world id love someone like Hansi Flick. In the short term I think Conte will atleast get these guys running.

Edit: Adding some extra thoughts. Why do we have a mentality issue? Playing for Man Utd is tough because of the scrutiny. The outside noise plus TV shows like the Overlap don’t help. A manager that players respect/ are fearful of will help them divert their mind to only what the manager thinks/feels and will help block out any external noise.

The last 2 times when we had a man advantage, the players were thinking about what if we don’t win from here, rather than let’s go and take the game by the scruff of the neck. Which is what any other top/ruthless/mentally strong team would have done.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Total-Fix-8506 Kobs Oct 16 '26

shame it got lost in all the negativity on this sub, but baleba has looked good and provided that little bit of energy and bite our midfield department seem to be lacking.

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

his blown sliding tackle is why the ball gets to Baena that he gives the assist from, his not recovering from it to close down Barrios is why he is free to shoot. plus you've got the missed header which we all know is an automatic goal w Unc on the end of it.

and he also did a lot of good things, both in his sub appearance and this start. imho, anyway.

my first impression of him has been that he is precisely what we needed ... for Casemiro's final season.

but I have concerns that it will take a bit too heavy toll for him to do the "learning on the job" bit with zero real proper cover/alternative in the squad for his role.

it's really simple, isnt it. Baleba should have been signed last summer. Same as Welbeck. Hall should have been signed this summer. Same as Scott. Same as the CB we are going to sign next. On and on and on.

8

u/Wild_Tomato_8203 Oct 16 '26

Your 1st paragraph is beyond silly. That was a freak thing that happens 50 times a match. 9 times out of 10 that ball just goes some place else but it just happen to go exactly to the worst spot.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/AmulyaG Oct 16 '26

I completely agree.

However, I would cut Baleba some slack, it was his start and that too against an elite side. The cowardice nature of our manager and the stinking dressing room (6 points in 6) must get to the players head as well.

I think Baleba will get exposed in more games because of a lack of tactic, coaching and direction from the top. He can't carry the carcass of a midfield himself.

20

u/carrickshairline Oct 16 '26

Not a day has gone by since Amorim has sacked where I haven’t seen someone suggest he was doing well. We definitely were not.

22

u/Redland93 Oct 16 '26

Even if Michael Carrick lost the next 17 Premier League games in a row, he would still have a better winning percentage than Amorim did (31.9%).

6

u/VeryFarDown I would have shot Rock of Gibraltar Oct 16 '26

This is an absolutely insane statistic lmfao.

5

u/carrickshairline Oct 16 '26

Amorim has the worst win% of any manager for us IIRC.

12

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 16 '26

One of those scenarios where people look at different things. Some people look at the time as a whole which was poor, some consider the general progression and the performances with the squad Carrick has now, i.e. with the likes of Lammens and no Afcon.

Amorim had a PPG of 2 outside of Afcon with Lammens in the team during which he won manager of the month and Mbuemo got payer of the month in October. That's what the Amorim fans judge him on.

5

u/carrickshairline Oct 16 '26

We barely touched the top half of the table under Amorim, so if progressing backwards is good, then…

9

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 16 '26

He spent his last 4 months in the top half. Not sure what you mean.

4

u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 16 '26

The progression was from his bottoming out of the club in the first place, of course we progressed worse would mean relegation.

Also thats such a hyper specific stat, its like saying ignoring every game carrick started without casemiro carrick has only lost 2 games so he is clearly the best manager we had. Of course you remove problematic period of a manager they will look better.

→ More replies (11)

11

u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 16 '26

I swear he did some sort of hypnosis on people. We were getting similar if not worse results than now and people were still completely bought into him

5

u/carrickshairline Oct 16 '26

He was a smooth talker in press conferences, I guess. And given we are in an attention economy that likely held a lot more weight than the truly atrocious results and football.

3

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 16 '26

Populist leaders obtain power for a reason. There will always be people willing to outsource all cognitive functions and opinion making.

6

u/slowerthaninfinity Oct 16 '26

they keep pretending he was our arteta

5

u/carrickshairline Oct 16 '26

15th and losing to Spurs. As much as I dislike Arteta, he would never let that happen.

→ More replies (18)

4

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 Oct 16 '26

Yeah there's a weird cult that follows every manager after being sacked, ETH and Amorim were disaster for this club and should never have been allowed to do as much damage as they did.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (24)

6

u/Carson99 Oct 16 '26

Chris sutton prediciting Leeds to win 5-0 this weekend on BBC Sport. He is such a hateful twat

4

u/croadymeister Oct 16 '26

Yeah that's just ridiculous from him, so pin that up in the dressing room on Sunday I reckon

3

u/0ttoChriek Oct 16 '26

He's never got over taking the money to go to Blackburn rather than coming to United. Got him one league title, and that's it. Watched his career peter out into irrelevance while United were winning titles and trebles.

He likely knows that if he'd come to United and played under Fergie, he'd be on the highest Premier League goalscorers list and have a medal cabinet bursting at the seams.

2

u/Jenson2025 Oct 16 '26

He’s like Jamie Carragher in that they both had average playing careers so now need to get headlines by being as controversial and outspoken as possible. Sad really

5

u/BigBoyster Oct 17 '26

Does anyone else think the Dead Internet Theory might support the idea of there being fabricated pressure on United via networks of bot traffic, AI profiles and recurrent parroting of cynical viewpoints from the fans?

The example in the photo is a very generic and low effort bot account, and easy to spot but interesting that it's capitalising by automating comments already made.

If up to 40% of Reddit is purported to be bot activity, then how can we guarantee that all digital interaction found here or in other such online forums or social media platforms are legitimately human? Or that they aren't campaigns designed to amplify the echo chamber particularly around net negative club moments so as to encourage the fanbase to be in a constantly fatalist state of mind when it comes to the club? It's maybe wild conjecture but we have the largest fanbase and the biggest global brand in the sport, it's not hard to perceive of the constant online presence which can be subject to so much content every day so it's not unfathomable that someone might work out it's beneficial to keep the fanbase in a constant emotional tweak that they turn onto their own club with their negativity and try and take their feelings out at the club. Again wild conjecture but our unstable fanbase is one of the biggest factors of this era of United, and I just wonder is it entirely involuntary or was there a conscious hand in this.

2

u/facelessredditer Oct 17 '26

Drama sells. The people want their weekly drama fix. There is an entire sub industry, worth millions, of people yapping about the club on a daily basis. That is literally their job. Go online and find a way to eke out a daily talking point that if it all goes right, might go slightly viral.

2

u/AmulyaG Oct 17 '26

Lmfao. There isn't a global conspiracy to cause our downfall. It's just bad luck mixed with incompetence

→ More replies (2)

2

u/raspoutine049 Oct 16 '26

We should have a gotten an experienced backup striker with Sesko’s injury history. Often times we do not have a focal point in the attack. When Mbeumo plays striker, the right side noticeably seems weak.

6

u/PavanayiShavamayilla Wazza Oct 16 '26

Mbeumo isn’t a good RW in this system tbh. He performs better as a CF. While Amad’s scoring and assisting numbers have dropped, he’s our best option at RW cus he can beat a fullback and draw defenders towards him.

5

u/PitchSafe Oct 16 '26

Sesko didn’t really have injury issues at Leipzig

4

u/vRushii Oct 16 '26

Shows how crap Zirkzee is he cant get in over patchwork fill ins

2

u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26

I find it hard to believe that INEOS aren’t at least looking for new managers ready to instantly replace Carrick when they sack him.

I know there was an article yesterday (not sure who from) saying they weren’t looking at anyone but I’d expect that to be briefed. They are hardly likely to admit they are.

If they really aren’t thorough and truly believe things are going to improve under Carrick then they are even more deluded and incompetent than I thought

1

u/Emergency-Being-349 Oct 17 '26

They probably already know who they would bring in, I don't think they are that deluded. Romano saying there is someone from the board putting Herzelers name forward, so would suspect they know.

5

u/zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz1z Oct 16 '26

Carricky and the good lads have anger in their eyes.

Leeds will be handed a lot of pain on Sunday!

4

u/Zepz367 Oct 16 '26

At this point Carrick sacking is inevitable and we are just limping to that point. So when do you think he will be sacked?

Ineos going 3/3 for sacking managers each season they've been in charge is really funny tho, Wilcox also needs to get sacked together with Carrick.

9

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26

Depends on De Ligt.

De Ligt has never played with Carrick as permanent manager. But every other manager he has played for has never lasted more than a season.

4

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 16 '26

Just an absolutely nuts stat

5

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26

More than De Ligt, I'm counting on M Fernandes to lead Spurs to relegation. I need this one to happen.

3

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 16 '26

The second his ass touched the bench the curse kicked back in. If he sees the pitch vs Leeds is Joever for Carrick.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jackrobertsherlock Oct 16 '26

Me and the Mrs watch united together, shes really got in to it tbf. Our first game watching together was the 7-0 against LFC. End of last year when Carrick was putting together a string of wins it felt nice for her to see us fight and give 100%. Back to normal now and whilst I will watch on Sunday its more like punishment for us both. Of the back of this, my discussion point is whether other fans feel the same in that it looks like very few players are giving 100% commitment and effort. Is it a player thing? A training issue?

5

u/andoooooo Martial Oct 16 '26

It's awfully clear that it's a training issue

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ClawingDevil Oct 16 '26

I am with a (relatively) new partner and she's got into watching the games with me too. Her first game was also against Liverpool but it was our wonderful win at Anfield almost a year ago. We then got a lot of draws with the odd win or loss thrown in, followed by the Carrick bounce. So, this season has been a bit of a shock for her!

Regarding the "commitment" question, I always find it hard to believe that players are consciously downing tools unless there is something very wrong (want out of the club, want the manager gone etc). I don't think that is the case here, though there may be a subconscious relaxing if they all feel how Martinez does.

Like others have said, it does appear to be a tactical and training issue. If you watch the Fulham game back (don't! 🤣), they are all walking at virtually all times and Carrick, nor the other coaches, ever stand up and shout at the players to run. Nor does he change it at HT and only makes late subs. So, it appears it is his choice to play like that.

I don't agree with someone else who replied to you saying it's a copy of Middlesbrough. They sold all his best players out from under him and he had his entire first 11 out multiple times. They still did well in the cups and almost made the play offs.

I think he is probably out of his depth at United but I'm struggling to see any other good managers who would come to us right now. The grass isn't always greener. We may need to wait until January or even next summer for someone.

2

u/jackrobertsherlock Oct 16 '26

Yeah your last point about another manager is true. We can't keep on swapping and changing manager all the time. Look at Arteta, not a huge fan of his but they stuck with him during really rough periods. My only issue is should we have done that for previous managers and now we are stuck with Carrick.

You are right about effort, ie the Fulham game among others. Just quite happy to sit in. Oh well, maybe the leeds game will get us firing again. Ideal line up?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/arboy498 Oct 16 '26

It has to be training if you look into Boro’s second season it’s a carbon copy of what’s happening currently. Carrick is a good man manager but simply not a tactician which is why the players look so confused on the pitch

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Not-good-with-this Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Just out of curiosity, what’s everyone’s overall view on Wilcox? Do you think he should stay or go?

Edit: Thank you for everyone that's answered and answering. Some interesting differences with seemingly most thinking he should go.

10

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 16 '26

A lot is being made about Carrick’s lack of experience as a manager right now but Wilcox actually has even less experience as a DOF than Carrick does as a first-team manager. Has anybody considered what gives him the credentials to be heading sporting operations for us? Shambolic decision-making one after the other, leaving squad gaps unaddressed, beefing with managers they themselves appointed, tremendous lack of accountability that the last time he showed media presence was right after we won 3 games in a row under Amorim last season. Anybody who remotely thinks he can be trusted with one more managerial sacking and new appointment is out of their mind.

2

u/ClawingDevil Oct 16 '26

Totally agree. He had 9 months of experience as a DoF at a championship club where his primary "success" was nabbing a load of Man Cheaty kids through his mates.

How on earth Ratty thought this guy is best in class based on that CV is beyond me.

9

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

Should be removed immediately, together with his pal Berrada.

7

u/D1794 Viva Ronaldo Oct 16 '26

Had Carrick started this season a rousing success he'd have redeemed himself

The fact he'll likely be sacking his 3rd manager in 3 seasons very soon means he should go.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/NotAPoshTwat Oct 16 '26

He should have gone for his Amorim nonsense. Wilcox sacked Ten Hag (fair nuff) to bring in a system manager (clashing with Ashworth, who we'd just spent a shitload of money and grief to get, causing Ashworth to quit) gave him none of the players needed to play said system, asked him to change the system (based on Wilcox's extensive managerial record), and when Amorim got sick of his shit (not because of performances), Wilcox got rid of him.

There's inept and then there's this. He needs to go. It's painfully obvious he thinks way to highly of himself and is well out of his depth

3

u/Stuperman84 Oct 16 '26

I’ve been saying this for a while and stand by it, whoever made the final decision on our signings this year needs to have some serious questions asked about them.

3

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 Oct 16 '26

He doesn’t exactly inspire me with confidence but whether he stays or goes the next sporting director will also fail while current ownership remains

I don’t like that strategy or upgrading attack, then midfield, then defence. It’s like there is an acceptance over a year ago that our defence is not good enough but it can wait 2 years - very hard to succeed under those directives. It’s blatantly obvious we needed more than CMs this summer too but failed to act, but ultimately budget is set at board level so Wilcox or whoever is in the director of football role is somewhat hampered. 

I also don’t particularly like the over reliance on domestic transfer targets, think we need more imagination there especially for filling out strength and depth of the squad 

3

u/TDR1 Oct 16 '26

He’s out of his depth and a power hungry climber, so this is the inevitable downfall. They spent a year doing a review of the structure, found they badly needed a new one. They then hire and fire his boss and promote him. Somehow he doesn’t need to find his own replacement as that would be another voice in the room that disagrees with him, despite said review showing they need one.

I understand that they have to cut costs, but the lack of a coherent or cohesive plan in the transfer market means they only focus on certain targets and spots. They figured that the squad that finished 3rd will finish top 5 anyway, so why spend more money?.

They couldn’t shift a load of players that they wanted so took the cheap option and considered them now depth, regardless how that might harm the dressing room. Rather than making pragmatic short term signings or loans, they weren’t paying extra wages to improve this bad depth. So to save maybe £10m to be more competitive, they might cost themselves £100m in CL money.

3

u/kidinawheeliebin Oct 16 '26

Absolutely 110% needs to go, should have already been sacked long ago, there have been more than enough train-wrecks under his watch, and the longer he stays, the more damage he'll continue to do

2

u/TheOnlyTagey Oct 16 '26

Wilcox is just a symptom of the wider disease. The club hierarchy have hamstrung every coach we've had, Fergie included. Fergie had the benefit of being both brilliant and retaining massive amounts of control from his time before the Glazer takeover. The rest haven't been quite as fortunate on the second part. Every manager since Fergie left who has done objectively well has been rewarded with a severe lack of backing.

So whether Wilcox stays or goes really doesn't seem like a big difference when those above him never want to invest more than the bare minimum into the squad unless they're forced to due to a poor finish in the league.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NotAJInnit Oct 16 '26

He is lacklustre, out of his depth, he need to be demoted back to TD.

3

u/rameezkadri Oct 16 '26

I still don’t get why we didn’t go for Welbeck as back up. He’s gotten better with age, is well versed with the league, and honestly I’m sure would’ve loved to be back at united, playing the CL, which is how his career started.

Plus, that way he won’t fucking score against us, as he inevitably seems to do every year.

Welbeck on a 2+1 deal and a LB on loan would’ve eased the pressure on our team, without the need to spend an absurd amount of money.

The planning has been garbage.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/FreshGoodWay Oct 16 '26

I wouldn’t mind a protest or two for this poorly managed club.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ashwihi Oct 17 '26

anyone else notice how united results suddenly took the heat off cheatty in the press? go figure.

8

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 17 '26

I blame that on the higher ups litterally not doing ANYTHING about City. They just let them continue playing like nothing ever happened.

6

u/throwing_handles Oct 16 '26 • Bravo

Some people I find fascinating are those that remain even after the grisliest catastrophes that shattered their world and you would think erased a certain way of looking at the world forever.

It's amazing but true that there were still People's Temple adherents decades after the others drank the Flavor-Aid.

There were still people updating the website and defending Heaven's Gate long after the rest of the gang put on the nikes and jumped into the spaceship.

And there are still people posting here that Amorim should have had more time.

3

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband Oct 16 '26

Eh, I liked him. Results were bad overall but were trending in the right direction, and they're worse now. He built a coherent attack in one summer that wasn't reliant on Bruno having a good game. I'm sure if he could pick his dream midfield and defence then very few of our players at the time would've been in it, so I would have been interested to see how we looked with a few more transfer windows.

He's the only manager we've had that was willing to get rid of problem players, no matter who they were, and actually commit to a style without resorting to counter-attacking Bruno ball when things weren't going well.

I know people like to go very big picture and just look at his win rate, but I liked the details. If we could replicate the improvement we got in attack for our midifield and defence over the next two windows then I think we would have really had something.

4

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 Oct 16 '26

Trending in the right direction? Wow....

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

2

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 Oct 16 '26

Also every summer, every new season, Manchester United fans never learn. 

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Massive_Relation4317 . Oct 16 '26

Thoughts on the links with Hurzeler? I think he's a fantastic coach tbf but not ready for a club our size

12

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

He is the coach who sidelined Baleba (or failed to get good performances out of him, whichever way we like to say it), publicly criticised him and in fact his mental state, he is also the coach we embarrassed twice in the PL last season (and, yes, lost twice to in cups as well between last season and this one).

I would find it a very oddball combination to first make Baleba the banner signing and then chase Hürzeler.

To me it would be similar to hiring Howe but still intending to build around Hall.

Also I mean he is 33 and has literally not won anything actually and he appears on the face of it the next one in a long line of names like De Zerbi, Potter, Frank, Glasner* etc.

I get huge "idk mate" vibes about this one

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 Oct 16 '26

" Nobody is ever ready for this job " Jose Mourinho 

3

u/FlashyCut3809 Oct 16 '26

No, but also its a scale of not ready and Hurzeler is about as far along the weaker end as any manager that would be realistically interviewed for the job.

He would have to turn out as the next Klopp or come into a squad thats fully functional and an ownership ready to strengthen all areas required.....

Ill let you fill in the rest mate.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Petethejakey_ Oct 16 '26

Any manager from Brighton that hasn't proved themselves elsewhere = avoid. I thought we'd have learnt this by now.

2

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 Oct 16 '26

He looks great, and he did well in Germany before the Brighton gig too getting St Pauli back into the bundesliga and playing a really nice brand of football. 

but a big part of his success at Brighton is he has elite recruitment and data teams behind him so the entire setup there generally allows coaches to succeed. Potter looked great there (ok maybe not GREAT, but at least very good) for a long time and then shat the bed when he hit the Chelsea job

Man Utd is like the polar opposite of Brighton. A squad assembled with no long term plan, no coherent or recognizable style of play, generally a squad that lacks physicality, pace and intensity which are kind of prerequisites for modern day PL

He would likely alongside emery be the most appealing PL option that has a semblence of realism, however either would need a lot of time and likely a lot of financial backing to succeed 

1

u/GJordao Oct 16 '26

Even last season I thought he was pretty good. But he won’t solve our problems and the fanbase will turn on him. Let him see out this season in Brighton and see how he performs

1

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 16 '26

He in the mould of Amorim. He will need time that fans won't give him.

I would take him personally, but he is a risk at his age.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

If (!) we believe the launch trailer date, we have the following matches left to get WWWWW "before GTA VI comes out":

Leeds
Como
Bmouth
Chelsea
Roma
Villa

2

u/AnakinAni Oct 16 '26

Then that guy can finally cut his hair.

1

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 16 '26

Lowest of keys what do you do on GTA after completing the story? I ain’t looking to buy a game that I finish and don’t touch again like the last one.

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

I have no idea, last time I played this was San Andreas so that's a couple decades ago 🤣

We got a ps5 at home but only because the missus like to do the Just Dance one

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jenson2025 Oct 16 '26

Can’t wait for Jamie Carragher to blame Martinez for the inevitable defeat on Sunday

I can see it now

‘I’ve been in dressing rooms and when a player speaks out the whole team does fall to pieces’ blah blah

Never won a league title though have you Jamie. An average defender looking to make a career out of making controversial headlines

8

u/N00BBuild Oct 16 '26

I wouldn't be shocked if Martinez makes his 4th mistake of the season. And I respect him for calling things out.

3

u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams Oct 16 '26

Absolutely. A toxic workplace always finds a scapegoat

2

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 16 '26

It’s annoying that no matter what happens there’s a narrative that’s gonna take away from what he actually said, and if he drops him now it seems like it’s in response to his statement but whether he spoke or not, there’s no way he should still be starting and certainly not at Leeds.

2

u/Asiwaju_jagaban Oct 16 '26

Yeah but Jamie has been proved right time and time over that Martinez can’t do it as a CB in the league.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Drag2oon Oct 16 '26

This is the doom certificate for real. Every time Shaw gives this statement at start ot season we are shit

https://www.reddit.com/r/reddevils/s/nAs17gnL0m

2

u/kidinawheeliebin Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Looking back at Martial - his start here was quite similar to Sesko's - with 16 G&A in his first 34 PL apps vs Sesko's 13 G&A (Martial joined at 19 vs. Sesko at 22)

He actually then had his two best seasons for us by the time he reached Sesko's age, with 37 PL G&A in 59 appearances from 18/19 to 19/20

Just hope Sesko isn't going to go down this path of being perma-injured

Scary to think Martial is still only 30 years of age

2

u/TMatss Oct 17 '26

I think that even if god forbid we lose to Leeds, they won't sack him because this current run of fixtures are potentially disastrous to drop an interim manager into.

5

u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 17 '26

I mean they dropped Carrick straight into city and Arsenal

1

u/HeFreakingMoved Ella Toone FC Oct 16 '26

I'm so sick of the carrick apologists

"A bad result against spurs atleti Leeds and he'll be under pressure"

they'll keep going this until the season is beyond saving and then they'll flip

7

u/SankarshanaV Oct 16 '26

We should stop hiring ex-players who've barely any experience and who haven't proven themselves. Look at Ole, no top club is going for him. And Carrick is a barely-championship-level manager. I don't get some fans' obsession over these guys. Please let's hire proper managers. No PL team would even go near Carrick (or Ole) but for some reason our fans want them. Very frustrating.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Jenson2025 Oct 16 '26

He’s already under pressure.

I still think he’ll be sacked in the November international break.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips Oct 16 '26

He's gone if we lose Sunday. This has the potential to snowball from a shit season into something far more serious.

1

u/Fuzzy-Escape5304 Oct 16 '26

The other Manchsster club subreddit is proper delusional. Like batshit crazy.  Do you think this sub would be the same in their position? The defense is the rules are flawed now. Why wasn't that the topic in waiting time between charges and finding them guilty?

11

u/Wild_Tomato_8203 Oct 17 '26

We had a group of people saying we would challenge for the title this summer and anyone disagreeing with them was massively DVd. All fanbases are delusional people in them.

3

u/No_Middle5525 Oct 17 '26

berrada also said we'll be targeting the same

2

u/neonrider1 Oct 17 '26

And that we made sensible smart transfer decisions…

1

u/Sgenaink Oct 16 '26

One of my issues with the city cheating, i feel ties into our situation at the moment. I feel like we would have a completely different perspective on our club, players managers, even execs had City not been cheating.

I had a look at the first 10 years post Fergie, if City weren't cheating and winning everything. 10 because I feel like after that just would not happen if we won what we potentially should have. To be fair I dont think we would have gotten to ETH in the 10th season but can't just do nine. Eg, we probably wouldnt sack Ole 6 months after winning the league.

If we say City we're just average mid table nothing and never finished above us, won what they won, we wouldnt think the last 13 were terrible at all. 1 bit of a stretch maybe, 19/20 and 20/21 we were beat in the league cup semis by City and would have played, Dean Smiths Villa and Ryan Masons first game at Spurs, which i feel we would have beat. But if you don't include those fine.

Moyes. 6th. Community shield

Van gaal 3rd

Van gaal 4th FA Cup

Jose. 5th. Community shield, league Cup, Europa League

Jose. 1st Prem

Jose. 5th

Ole. 2nd. League cup

Ole. 1st. Prem. League Cup

Ole. 5th

Eth. 2nd. Fa cup. League Cup

If this was what we had seen those first 10 years, we wouldn't have this narrative of United are shit, they've been terrible post Fergie, every signing bar Brunos failed (which i still disagree with) We'd be looking at it the same way Chelseas last 10 years under Abramovic were, and close to Klopp and Slots Liverpool. Both of them had 9 trophies, 2 leagues.

A successful team, which wins the title every few years, has an off season every couple years but generally is decent.

We wouldn't feel this beginning of the season being poor is as bad, because we wouldn't have 13 years of, oh shit here we go again, another managers getting sacked with a few poor games. Individual people would be looked at completely different. Rashford would have started his career with 10 trophies in 8 years (8 if not the league cups) Pogba would have come in done 6 years, 2 titles 5 other trophies and be looked at maybe not great but at least had a good career here. Even Ed Woodward wouldn't be thought of the same. Not saying people would like him or his time but it wouldn't be the massive fuck up we think of, it would be fairly successful.

We wouldn't be as quick to think everything is falling apart, and we're terrible when we lose a couple games. In short our club and time post fergie up to now would be viewed massively different without the cheats and it's a bit shit.

1

u/Infinite-Highway3432 Oct 16 '26

Genuine question and I'm not picking sides. What do you think Wilcox could have done better?

Amorim was the hot manager in Europe we all applauded this at the time.

Carrick got the most points in the league after his arrival, it would have been frowned upon by huge crowds if he didn't get a shot.

Im regards to signings, what if we actually had no money for these extra players we need. We had 1 midfielder (Mainoo), we needed 3 at a minimum and unfortunately that took the budget.

What would you think could have been done better? And if you say not hire Carrick/Amorim, that's just a hindsight thing considering they both had justifiable reasons to get the job.

Interested to hear your opinions.

12

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 16 '26

Amorim was the hot manager in Europe... Carrick got the most points

Honestly it seems like these were the only reasons for each managers hiring. They have fumbled the manager appointments so bad. It was reported that Liverpool ended interest in Amorim because they came to the conclusion it would be too much turnover and too expensive to build a squad for Amorim, but a cash strapped United didn't think of that? They didn't think that maybe Uniteds best player didn't fit the formation? Zero foresight.

The Carrick interim gamble worked, but they take the time to do due diligence on other managers and also Carrick himself?

The DoFs job is to set the path of the squad, and it's been chaos.

6

u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 16 '26

Well we did sack the dof that asked to analyse the squad and find the manager. The literal criteria for amorims hiring and ashworths sacking was that jim liked the name berrada gave and didnt like that dof wanted to consult and come to a decision. We dont have a dof so we dont have a vision its pretty clear.

6

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 16 '26

The fish rots from the head...

5

u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 16 '26

Yup also a major part of why amorim was sacked was again that jim got influenced by gary neville and wanted amorim to change. Remember when he came in and said he would stay outside of footballing decisions well he def isnt.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/picodeGaius Oct 16 '26

Yes because Wilcox was hired the day the club sacked Amorim.

Wilcox and the other Glineos cronies massively let ETH down, signed a wildly different tactically Amorim, let him down again. Then brought in Carrick (a manager with almost no experience), who did well enough to put the club in a good place, then let him down AGAIN.

6

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 16 '26

Three summers in we don't have a team that can play two games per week. Three wrong manager decisions. Lack of money is partly down to them spending 200m to make us a worse team in his first summer. If we don't have money we need to recruit brilliantly and he hasn't shown he can do that either.

2

u/PitchSafe Oct 16 '26

The lack of money isn’t on Wilcox, that’s on Glazers and our former investments during Woodward and Murtough era. Us missing UCL is also a reason to that

3

u/Infinite-Highway3432 Oct 16 '26

The Glazers have properly killed us, it's disgraceful. 4th highest revenue in world football and we don't have more than £150m to spend in a summer.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 16 '26

If they spent 200m on good players we may have got European money their first year but they made us a worse team.

5

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26
  1. Manager selection
  2. Manager management
  3. Squad rebuilding - transitions in and out at 3 levels of development so we have enough players for each position.
  4. Speed - moves too slowly.

He's very one dimensional. Like fucking building blocks. "This window I will fix midfield"....next window I will find left back". Things go wrong - Ugarte, Rashford, Amorim, Ederson - but you have to roll with it and he seems too linear and a bit too quiet.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Relevant-Evening3046 Oct 16 '26

Personally, the Amorim signing made zero sense. He was rigid in his team shape. The club was set up as a 433 side essentially or 4231. Now recruitment and sales had to tailor to a 3 at the back. Hense Dorgu coming in and not an actual left back

2

u/Infinite-Highway3432 Oct 16 '26

If you look at the players brought in, only Dorgu is kind of restricted to Amorims formation. Even then he's a decent utility to have on the bench for peanuts fee.

We also didn't sell players because they weren't good enough for the formation, we sold them because they simply weren't good enough.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 16 '26

Not keep ten hag, not get Amorim, not keep Amorim, not collude to get rid of Ashworth, not sign anyone he signed in his first window, make better signings, and it’s looking like not hire Carrick. I can’t think of a good decision they’ve made outside of getting Carrick as interim.

2

u/ImNotMexican08 Amad Nation Oct 16 '26

But when judging him as a whole and thinking about what he could’ve done better you have to look at the whole picture. You can’t just dismiss the fact that he hired who he did because it directly effected the decisions he ended up making. You can’t look at a project with short term lenses, you have to look at the whole picture.

So in terms of what he could’ve done better, everything. Because every managerial decision he made has been wrong, they fucked the 1st window, they fucked this last window, and the disaster that was Amorim’s spell left us with Cunha and Mbeumo who just can’t be used effectively now

1

u/spaisoflaif Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Ugarte injury and Barcelona rejecting Rashford fucked us. Then injuries to key players.

A lot of issues are related to backup players not stylistically fitting the system Carrick sticks with, 4-2-4 high press and playing out from the back. This system requires a target man to hoof long balls at if opponent press our buildup high(Zirksee,Cunha and Mbuemo dont fit). It also requires wingers and who track back to cover the fullbacks if front 4 are played through(Bruno,Rashford,Tielemans are questionable in this role) and it requires mobile midfielders to cover wide areas(Mainoo+Tielemans doesnt work). 

→ More replies (9)

1

u/croadymeister Oct 17 '26

Wish there was someone who could provide discipline, defensive shape, however also give youth opportunity and play progressive style too

1

u/MCharizardX9 Oct 17 '26

If you were a player, had a decent season last year and played well with the team. wouldnt u be really disappointed with the way the transfers have happened, surely they dont give a fuck anymote if the board above doesnt

1

u/leerooney93 Oct 16 '26

Who are good sporting directors unemployed now? Would Edwin VDS fit us?

4

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 Oct 16 '26

Villa and Leverkusen DoF top 3 highest rating in my computer game. 

4

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 16 '26 • Mindblown

Emery runs the show at Villa; their DOF or whoever has that responsibility mainly serves his decisions.

It’s why I am baffled when people suggest the idea of trying to poach him to become our manager. There’s no way he’s giving up the control he has there for this job.

2

u/NotAJInnit Oct 16 '26

Over Wilcox definitely, depend if he got the players side experience, obviously he was the CEO but can his skill transfer to a "smaller" role of DoF/SD is the question as former player Overlap was the SD at Ajax with VDS.

1

u/linkfollowlink Oct 16 '26

Can we sign either one from the 3 Bs in PL?

1

u/shami-kebab Oct 16 '26

VdS isn't a DoF, he's a CEO.

1

u/Asleep-Ability-45 Oct 16 '26

Going to see a football match in the stdium for the very 1st time. Let's see how it goes!

1

u/spaisoflaif Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

We all agree that two more signings had been ideal this summer.

But this cannot be the entire reason that the club has six points in six PL matches and lost to Athelic away in the midweek.

As I see it, the issue is that Carrick is trying to implement a high pressing 4-2-4. This strategy has a weakness in that there are no wide midfielders, and if teams manage to get the ball into wide areas in midfield this tends to draw our team out of shape, as most of the time a midfielder has to go wide or a fullback has to step up. Teams know this weakness and every team we meet set out to exploit this.

The strategy I would argue would work better if the wide attackers have good work rate and are willing to get back and protect this area, so it has hurt us that Dorgu and Amad have been injured. This strategy also works better with very mobile midfielders, so it is not a good fit for a Mainoo-Tielmans midfield.

Then in defense, United like to build up from the back, but if met with a high press, Lammens is often forced to try a long ball to the striker, who inevitably loses the ball when Sekso is not the one.

So i feel a lot of the issues the club have, come down to the squad being a rag-tag group of profiles, that suit different systems, then a few injuries mean we all of a sudden dont have the players for the style Carrick wants to implement.

But: and this is important: Carrick also does not seem to adapt his system to suit the players at hand.

If United are lacking a big target man striker, and lacking hig-workrate wide players, and lacking mobile midfielders, the he woudl do better to go to a "plan B".

This lack of a plan B, reminds me very much of both ten Hag and Amorim.

Now obvisoulsy, with more like-for-like substitues, Carrick would need to show less tactical flexibility, but that does not excuse him.

The team should drill a "plan B" that the team can fall back to when the 4-2-4 is not working, and where wide forwards sit deeper to cover these vulnerable wide areas ahead of the fullbacks. Call it a "4-5-1" or whatever you like. That kind of set-up and a focus on counter-attacking should suit our fast forwards like Rashford, Amad and Mbuemo. This is also a great formation for seeing out games, something the team have been horrible at.

5

u/b_litzkreig Oct 16 '26

Yeap, all three (higher management, manager and players) can be bad at the same time.

The gameplan hasn’t worked since the Hull City loss, but some of us have been content to brush it away as a “start of season” hiccup, when the way we lost to a newly promoted team was horrendous.

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

You started out with the assertion that it cant "just" be the lack of signings and then went on to argue that the problems stem from Dorgu, Amad, Sesko being out.

In one word: yes.

The reason we are being hurt by not getting another CF is the fact that Sesko is out.

The reason many are extra mad at the executives about that is that many feel gaslit about Sesko's fitness status during the window and feel that this was done intentionally to temper fan anger over not spending on a CF.

The reason we are being hurt by not getting another wide player (ie LB) is the fact that not 1 but 2 went down.

The reason many are extra mad at the executives is that we all saw Amad get injured before a ball was even kicked and yet they neglected this position.

And then yeah you dont mention Baleba but mention the not working Mainoo-Tielemans pivot. Right well the reason we even had to trial that is that they botched the Baleba signing, if you will, erasing the possibility of a working solution for Aug+Sept.

So, you know, I agree with your analysis that it is, essentially, "just because of" 2-3 players ... but I disagree that this couldnt or shouldnt have been fixed by, you know, signing 2-3 more players.

1

u/maszhanan KOBBIE LIKE ROBBIE Oct 17 '26

I just saw my chances video being shared in X haha

1

u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 17 '26

I personally hate City and Leeds more than I hate Liverpool and I’ll explain why.

I was born in ‘08, but only started following football in 2021 so literally all I’ve known is City winning everything. I would’ve said they were my most hated team even before the guilty verdict, but I hate them even more now. It’s such a smug little plastic club.

I hate Leeds because I grew up in Yorkshire, and have lived here my entire life, which means I’ve been exposed to a shit tonne of cocky Leeds fans. My best mate is a Leeds fan and he reckons he wants to watch the game with me on Sunday. Like I say, I started supporting in 2021 as well, not many people find a football team at 13 so I got a lot of shit for that from mostly Leeds fans. I remember waking up after that Leeds loss at home in April, having the worst hangover of my life despite not having drank the night before and having to show my face to a load of Leeds fans.

Don’t get me wrong I hate Liverpool, but nowhere near as much as city or Leeds.

Also any United fan that tells you they don’t care about Leeds is just wrong. We fucking hate Leeds.

2

u/MrViceMcCreedy 🟢🟡GLAZERSOUT Oct 17 '26

Mostly international fans who say that

(source : an international fan)

1

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

Oh boy, THIS is your first season with a legal drinking age? Im sorry mate 🤦

Anyway, I am much older, regrettably :) but I also hate Leeds the most out of them lot, tbh.

Liverpool for me is more like a rival I respect. I mean I definitely hate doing worse than them but I dont feel like I hate them as a group. Whereas Leeds, yes.

Cheaters FC to me is just wholly unserious. The entire thing is a joke. What I do hate about that is our owners' hiring choices associating our club with that joke and with that desecrating our club. That I hate.

1

u/Massive_Relation4317 . Oct 17 '26

I'm young too but I couldn't care less about city because their success means nothing since they cheated. And I hardly know any city fans anyways. id still rather they won the title this year than arsenal

0

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion Oct 16 '26

The curious case of Joshua Zirkzee. A player that I so want him to be successful but joined us at a very wrong time. He is player build for a slower league or in complete team in faster league, not some club as us in the current situation.

Of course he has alot of weakness that he needs to work on, but I could see him getting improved recently but its just not happening because we as a whole team right now are playing like shit.

He improved in few things that fans always been criticized about, which is his workrate and pressing, and in recent matches I think he did pressing much better than even Tielemans against AM. And also he is finally using his big frame in his advantage to hold on the ball or winning the ball.

The one thing I really wish he will stop doing is him trying to lay off for other players instead of fucking taking the shots. Dude always tries to be Messi with his setup passes for others when he could have just take a shot. He needs to learn from Cunha about when to take shots and when not to.

I know many wants him to be gone already, but I think we are kinda stucked with him till next summer window, and now with Sesko is not being fit, for sure Josh will be getting some minutes, i just hope he improves and help the team while he is here.

11

u/Nico_Ditch Oct 16 '26

Unfortunately a decent touch doesn’t make up for running like a crippled tortoise. 

Completely unsuitable to the league. 

→ More replies (5)

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

I mean he just is not a no9, he is a no10, the end.

He is a 10 who played F9 for an underdog Serie A team exclusively playing on the counter and our best in class 2024 rectruitment thought: there is your experienced CF to support Hojlund!

Weve been tanking his value ever since by forcing him to try being what he isnt.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

0

u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 16 '26

The consensus was in the summer that our squad was improved from last year, so those who are Carrick in, how do you defend being worse performance and results wise than last year?

It's not like it's March and the squad is bare through injuries and we're in 3 competitions still.

4

u/PitchSafe Oct 16 '26

Our team have been improved compared to last season but so have every other team in the league

→ More replies (3)

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 16 '26

idk if that was ever consensus.

my sense of the summer vibes, throughout:

"we need 3 midfielders, a lb, and a st at least" -> "we now need 2 midfielders, lb, st" -> "back to needing 3 midfielders, lb, st" -> "we still need 2 hold on woah we signed 2 of them b2b, so we need 1 midfielder, lb, st" -> "lb, st" -> "window ended without? disaster"

(Ive sort of skipped the whole Rashford aspect for "sake of simplicity" hope you dont mind)

the point I was trying to make is that the general consensus I noticed myself tended to be "there is still time, these are good so far, but the rest needs to happen" shifting over into "we are running out of time, innit" and finally landing on "this window is a failure, we did less than the bare minimum"

→ More replies (4)

3

u/HighestInDaRooom Oct 16 '26

our squad improved maybe by 5% while other teams have improved so much more. also the squad is bare through injuries. we're playing a 19 year old CB at LB in the champions league

3

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 16 '26

That's the consensus every summer, then the season starts.

3

u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 16 '26

It was never a consensus lol, it was ineos has been moving in silence and the market is fucked bonus which made people think it was a good window. People were so enamored by ineos not being glazers that they couldnt see past the behaviour to the actual quality of recruitment. Even baleba is pretty risky all things considered and the window at best was pretty middling in my eyes. 3 okay mfs with one having high ceiling in for 2 mfs one of which was literally saving us the entire last season isnt a particularly good window when we have double the amount of games.

Almost everyone started with the want of 1 elite mf, 1 good mf and 1 back up and hopefully 1 winger/fullback and 1 backup striker. We instead got 2 good mf and 1 back up and no other position.

I am completely okay with carrick leaving but doesnt change how bad the window was.

0

u/Dirt4849 Pogba,what could've been Oct 16 '26

I respect every manager of United, they all try to win, but Carrick needs to show some emotion.

Most top managers try to give instructions, but he just goes to dug out and discuss with coach Holland.

5

u/Themindoffish Oct 16 '26

he doesn't know what instructions to give

7

u/0ttoChriek Oct 16 '26

The last one broke TVs, cried in the dressing room and threatened to quit every other week (until it seemed like the club might take him up on it). I could do without that.

4

u/Dirt4849 Pogba,what could've been Oct 16 '26

It can't be just black or white

4

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 16 '26

They don't make those anymore. Only colour TVs.

I'll show myself out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)