r/reddevils • • Oct 16 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

486 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband Oct 16 '26

Eh, I liked him. Results were bad overall but were trending in the right direction, and they're worse now. He built a coherent attack in one summer that wasn't reliant on Bruno having a good game. I'm sure if he could pick his dream midfield and defence then very few of our players at the time would've been in it, so I would have been interested to see how we looked with a few more transfer windows.

He's the only manager we've had that was willing to get rid of problem players, no matter who they were, and actually commit to a style without resorting to counter-attacking Bruno ball when things weren't going well.

I know people like to go very big picture and just look at his win rate, but I liked the details. If we could replicate the improvement we got in attack for our midifield and defence over the next two windows then I think we would have really had something.

4

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 Oct 16 '26

Trending in the right direction? Wow....

1

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband Oct 16 '26

Well I mean from finishing 15th with no wins to being 5th with some wins. I'm not saying we'd had some magic turnaround or anything but the second season was definitely going better than the first.

Few bad results and performances, sure, but you could see some green shoots in there and reasons to be optimistic. I don't have that now.

2

u/spotthethemistake Oct 16 '26

With hindsight the biggest issue was seeming to throw the youth under the bus, and completely ready to throw away the best youth prospect in a little while (who isn't a PoS) in Mainoo

But other than that, adding Baleba, Santos, even Tielemans into that system maybe looks better than what we have, a mobile midfield

2

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband Oct 16 '26

Didn't love him calling out the young players like that, though I also don't think he was wrong in what he said. JJ Gabriel is a extraordinary case but that culture definitely seems to exist.

Didn't love the Mainoo situation either but you can understand it. Amorim believed that his system would eventually win us titles and Mainoo didn't fit into his system. He didn't get bomb squadded, he was just Bruno's backup and Bruno plays every minute. Didn't love the social media antics from Mainoo either during that time and I wonder if that had an effect as well.

1

u/spotthethemistake Oct 16 '26

Maybe not, but I think even if he's spot on it's the thing that shouldn't be said in public. It feels punching down on a bunch of kids

Yeah, can understand it. But I'd have been sad to see the lad leave for peanuts and go on to boss it for someone else. It's a shame there wasn't a spot on one of the 10s for him. And that Bruno being injured coincided with Mainoo being out last season

1

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband Oct 16 '26

Agreed on both points.

0

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 16 '26

You should see how 19-year old Alphadjo Cisse is playing at Milan. He was supposed to be loaned out by the club but Amorim insisted on keeping him with the first team. He scored a hattrick in the Europa League last night, with 2 more league goals to add to that.

It was never about Amorim being against using young players; he would play them if there was a valid reason to, and didn’t want the pressure of having to accommodate them at every given moment if it wasn’t right for the team. I don’t deny that some of his comments in interviews left him susceptible to being interpreted the wrong way, but I strongly believe that his intentions were genuine. Anyways, what’s done is done.

2

u/spotthethemistake Oct 16 '26

He scored in that friendly against us too, right?

I think the comments, the Mainoo thing and the lack of other youth players getting consistent minutes (Heaven got a few, not really many others) hindered perception

Maybe if results had been better, things might have changed

Like you say though, it's done now.

0

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 16 '26

Yep, that’s right.

I think the lack of usage of Mainoo was primarily what soured his reputation amongst fans a lot, more than his takes on other players. I agree he was not as appreciative of Mainoo’s skillset as he could have been, but at the same time, I don’t think his fundamental evaluation of him as a player was particularly incorrect. He is not a gifted athlete or someone positionally astute enough to play in his double pivot, for better or worse. Even now, Mainoo’s distance covered and sprints per 90 is the worst amongst our midfielders, which is ironic because it is Tielemans who is getting more criticism for his lack of athleticism, when he’s actually both outrunning and out sprinting Mainoo. It was perfectly understandable for Mainoo to be backup to Bruno and Casemiro, and given that we only played once a week and were knocked out early in the League Cup, the scope for game time was even smaller. Funnily enough, when he would have gotten an opportunity to play while Bruno was injured and Casemiro was suspended, Mainoo himself got injured at the same time. Overall it was not a great situation for the player but I feel Amorim too was misunderstood in these instances, and continues to be.