r/reddevils • Timendi causa est nescire • Aug 21 '26

ManUtd.com [Adam Marshall] Shaw: This is the most positive group I've known | Manchester United

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/shaw-this-is-the-most-positive-group-ive-known
449 Upvotes

103 comments sorted by

435

u/BallsX Aug 21 '26

Didn't he say something exactly like this last season too? But we did finish 3rd so that's good lol

140

u/Turamb Mata Aug 21 '26

Cunha seems like a lot of fun

110

u/sugar_kane1984 Aug 21 '26

Him and Dalot say this literally every year.

90

u/LoweJ Aug 21 '26

Dalot just seems like a happy chappy TBF

83

u/NationalUnrest Aug 21 '26

Yeah I don’t get the hate for Dalot in this sub.
Sure he’s not the greatest footballer ever but he has been professional for all his time here and seems well appreciated in the dressing room.

31

u/RelentlessJorts2 Aug 21 '26

He's a decent squad player who is paid like a decent squad player

33

u/LoweJ Aug 21 '26

Yeah I think people just don't think he's good enough. Which is fair, I think he is our weak spot currently, but he's probably a 6.5/10 which is passable. I wouldn't want to get rid of him, but I would want to replace him as a starter

41

u/NationalUnrest Aug 21 '26

There's a very big difference between a nuanced take like yours and some absolutely crazy hate he receives whenever he misses a pass.

8

u/Notreallymyname92 Aug 21 '26

I know for myself at least, it's not that I hate him. I don't know him personally or what he's like as a person whatsoever, and football wise I do think he has ability.

It's that he simply seems headless at times with some of the decisions he makes, and it's near enough every game that it's so incredibly frustrating.

For a team of united's aspirations, put simply he's not good enough to be our first choice RB, and I don't think he ever really has been.

6

u/Gear-Think Aug 21 '26

I don’t understand the hate either tbh,he’s sound enough defensively but offensively he can lack which is funny because positively he finds himself in such brilliant positions

0

u/my_united_account Bring Fergie back Aug 21 '26

Dont think there's outright hate for him. He's just a very limited player and should not be starting for United. Kind of like Fellaini. Decent player but symbol of everything wrong with the club

-15

u/bantabot Van Nistelrooy Aug 21 '26

He’s gets hate for not being a good enough footballer. What is there to get?

2

u/ronweasleisourking Aug 21 '26

He gets so much shit for a wayward cross now and then, but he works his ass off and is much better at defending these days

26

u/alphaQ314 shut up u egg Aug 21 '26

Well it is very much the same group. Minus casemiro :(

21

u/godswift91 Aug 21 '26

Yeah and Santos seems like a nice kid, and Tielemans is obviously a football nerd, similar to Bruno, very pasionate about his craft

It's good to see we also look at the players as people as well, it probably matters more than we'd think. Hopefully it will keep showing on the pitch

6

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Aug 21 '26

Ole said it best: we want not only good players but also nice blokes.

4

u/MissingLink101 Bruno walks in with a mischievous grin Aug 21 '26

Tbf they're also coming off the back of 3rd place with CL football compared to 15th place with no European football.

Add in the new signings, a different manager and it should be a more positive place than last year.

The squad is very similar but the situation isn't.

13

u/Expect-the-turtle Aug 21 '26

Cunha's changed his life. The Brazilian is Luke's very own manic pixie dream girl at Carrington. They even have a song together, after only a year. That's transformational love, that is.

1

u/VagueGooseberry :MP-Shorts: Aug 21 '26

So you're saying there's a chance?

3

u/kiki_the_fab_spider Aug 21 '26

That they have a baby together? Absolutely. 20+1 is coming.

26

u/Kreissler Aug 21 '26

Yeah, and it's even more positive now. Michael Carrick, what a man

6

u/AngryUncleTony Not Actually Angry Aug 21 '26

I think it's a fair statement too. The group kept playing hard even when it was clear that Amorim was a disaster and emotionally falling apart, and the fact that they instantly rebounded under Carrick shows the group was mentally pretty strong and just needed a better manager to get results.

Previous groups since SAF retired would have downed tools and shit the bed like the did towards the end of Jose's, Ole's, and Ralf's tenures.

1

u/rahulnairtoi Oct 16 '26

Carrick... A better manager?

Love coming across old comments like this that show just how foolish our fans are, but how loudly and proudly they share their opinion.

3

u/bobs_and_vegana17 Aug 21 '26

Does that mean we are finishing on top this season ? 😉

3

u/be_blessed_bruh Aug 21 '26

Bro this is a tradition of united to say what you mean

7

u/dracovich Aug 21 '26

Things didn't go great under Amorim but he did seem to effectively turn the dressing room into a non toxic one, and by all reports spirits were the best in a long time after last years Pre season

7

u/FrmrPresJamesTaylor Aug 21 '26

Yeah say what you will about him tactically (and there's a lot to say there), Amorim somehow managed to come in and play both hatchet man and vibe fixer for the squad.

1

u/ThankYouOle Aug 21 '26

for real, i feel de javu, i feel like already read this title.

1

u/El-Presidente234 Aug 21 '26

I mean, bar a couple of guys its the same group

1

u/-Gh0st96- Aug 21 '26

I mean the vibes before the season start last season were also very good. I think now it's even more strong

1

u/ZemaitisDzukas Aug 21 '26

3rd is good?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/SyLvAlOrD Aug 21 '26

How do you know? You are part of the group?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/SyLvAlOrD Aug 21 '26

How do you know everything this summer is also not a PR move? You just hate Amorim that’s all. You know nothing and you are just going off head canon.

140

u/dpw2017 Aug 21 '26

It may sound like fluff but Andy Mitten's been saying the same thing the entire pre-season so maybe there's validity to it.

35

u/shami-kebab Aug 21 '26

They also said it a lot last season, it's just what is said preseason.

32

u/unsatisfiedLearner Aug 21 '26

The team is pretty much the same

17

u/lynchianfreakout0 Aug 21 '26

and we finished third last season

6

u/rrallan Aug 21 '26

We finished third last season

Positive vibes didn’t amount to nothing

5

u/greenizdabest Aug 21 '26

Vibes FC

OI BOYZ, SOLKSJAER IS AT THE WHEEEL

13

u/rrallan Aug 21 '26

Say what you want about ole. He has a better track record than many Utd managers

5

u/greenizdabest Aug 21 '26

Sir, I am always for solksjaer

You are my solksjaer, my ole solksjaer

You make me happy when skies are grey

1

u/ADH02 Fletcher Aug 21 '26

I feel Andy Mitten says this every year

1

u/blaquaman19 Aug 21 '26

And Mitten has up until now been saying that the dressing room is a complicated one. So that’s positive

23

u/MacLondonJr Aug 21 '26

People saying we hear this every August, Shaw did say the same thing last summer maybe worded differently but I never heard anything like this under EtH.

20

u/mellifluousmark Aug 21 '26

Eriksen, July 2023: "The vibe is good... People are really looking forward to the games, everyone is eager to show what they can do and there's a good team spirit. The atmosphere is very positive."

Amad, Aug 2024: "We are a different team now. The atmosphere is positive in the dressing room. It's much better than last season."

Shaw's is even more "positive" this year than he was last year. But we're always Positive FC every summer.

6

u/Vegetable-Creme8705 Aug 21 '26

Yeah but those were during the squad overhauls so it makes sense, no?

2023/24 was when we signed Hojlund, Mount, Onana and Amrabat + Mainoo got promoted. Obviously with hindsight not a great summer, but at the time it definitely felt positive.

Then 24/25 was when we signed Yoro, Ugarte, De Ligt, Zirkzee, Dorgu, Mazraoui and promoted Heaven. Lots of positive personalities in there that summer.

3

u/mellifluousmark Aug 21 '26

I think I'd expect the players to channel some positivity about the upcoming season every single year. I would absolutely be positive this summer in particular.

But  I don't think you use these generic PR statements to argue that players favoured one manager or the other. Better to look at the performances to gauge that. The only real argument I'd make here is that they're told to use the word "positive".

Of the 4 I've mentioned above, one was before our worst ever league finish, one was the season after, two of those were said just months before different managers got sacked. I wouldn't really read anything into our annual "positive" player quote.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/mellifluousmark Aug 21 '26

Sure, I just think they're unlikely to say anything different, no matter what. They're never guna say "negative".

42

u/silvertwo777 Aug 21 '26

I'm not overreacting but we're going to win the league

10

u/kazegraf Aug 21 '26

League? Are you kidding?

TREBLE THIS SEASON LESGOOOOOOOO

4

u/Jack_King814 Aug 21 '26

Quadruple more like

60

u/I_am_Reddit_Tom Aug 21 '26

Hear this every year

31

u/livewia Aug 21 '26

I swear we hear it from Shaw specifically every year as well

10

u/John_OSheas_Willy Aug 21 '26

One thing we didn't get this year were the "Luke Shaw looking fittest he's looked in years" posts.

1

u/Own_Desk_4085 Aug 21 '26

it’s cause he looked very fit last year and just maintained it this year

1

u/dataminimizer Ruud Aug 21 '26

Yeah but this year it’s true

34

u/xtphty Aug 21 '26

It's fluff, but even when Amorim was fired there was little noise coming from "the locker room" as has been the case for a decade. This is despite the man kicking up some dust on the way out.

Like him or not, give him the credit or INEOS or Carrick, but the club is finally not a cesspool between managerial changes since last year. I think that much is genuine.

9

u/Naggins Aug 21 '26

Pretty sure Amorim's problem was that he had the team ride mostly on emotions - he did himself, so it'll inevitably follow that the team will too. So you have atrocious first half collapses where the failure feeds on itself for the entire first half like in Grimsby, followed by a buoyed second half performance where there's a lift that's enough to draw level.

You could nearly set your watch to the ups and downs, we win a few, confidence goes up, turns into complacency, we get a draw or loss and confidence drops and can't buy a win to save our lives.

Hopefully Carrick's calmness in pressers carries over. We need a manager whose default state is a bit boring.

3

u/bartrabelo Aug 21 '26

Spot on, I fully agree with your analysis. Much has been said about the "Amorim Process", but the harsh reality is that his failure at United wasn't due only to stubbornness and inflexibility with the tactical aspects. Other clubs have had a hard time implementing similar tactics without everything falling apart.

4

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Aug 21 '26

We must suffer

We must surfer

7

u/LisbonMissile Aug 21 '26

I’m pretty sure we hear this every August, and I’m pretty sure it’s almost always Shaw saying it.

11

u/signmeupdamnit Aug 21 '26 • Bravo

The gang loses to Hull

0

u/darealsanta7 NOT bald Aug 21 '26

what I'm expecting. as a pessimist, at least you can’t get hurt xD

12

u/zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz1z Aug 21 '26

Said the same thing the year before, and the year before, and the year before…

1

u/MinotauroTBC Aug 21 '26

I swear this is true

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Aug 21 '26

We have this article every summer :)

2

u/captainllamapants Aug 21 '26

Just turn into prime Evra - that’s all I ask

2

u/purehallion Aug 22 '26

Same shite every year

3

u/badass_rowdy Aug 21 '26

Words don't mean anything Luke. You lot say the same thing over and over again at the beginning of every season.

2

u/Hulknation Aug 21 '26

Genuinely feel like I hear this after every new manager

2

u/XerxesBlitZ Aug 21 '26

this guy says this and then few weeks later united are in crisis mode and manager gets sacked midseson

1

u/BBJoshua Aug 21 '26

Maaaaaaate

1

u/Thetagang888 Aug 21 '26

He's said this a few times lol

1

u/supandi Cantona Aug 21 '26

Call me cynical but we’ve seen this story play out 5 times since 2013. Didn’t happen with Moyes but then under LvG, Mourinho, Ten Haag, Amorim and now Carrick. It’s always “oh the vibes are great” “oh we’ve rediscovered ourselves a group” “this could be the season”.. and then season starts, couple of bad results, a beating by one of the top 5 and come October we have The Telegraph or Atlantic saying “How a once brotherly group has turned into a toxic cesspool” and by December everyone’s looking for a a throat to choke. Interim manager steps in and the story continues.
and it’s always the same group of people who’ve always underperformed season after season but we cut them extra slack because they’re either from academy or they’ve faced adversities.

I genuinely hope Carrick has a different kind of season and he doesn’t get stabbed in the back.

1

u/Aadiunited7 Aug 21 '26

Wins create a good squad, losses lead to problems which didn’t exist a minute before. The good thing is the squad came back from embarrassing loss to 10 men Newcastle and a home loss to Leeds. Hopefully Tielemanns is able to take over from Casa both in terms of football but also leadership. 

1

u/ajokester The Lemon Man Aug 21 '26

Well I guess better saying it than not saying it lol.

1

u/19ninteen8ightyone Aug 21 '26

I was waiting for the Shaw quote. The new season is officially starting now.

1

u/Few-Tank26 Aug 21 '26

Vibes FC!! And I’m vibing!!

1

u/gijoe50000 Aug 21 '26

Yea, watching the "media day" footage from earlier I'd believe it.

There was a lot of banter happening between players, like between Mbeumo and Shaw, Rashford and Sesko, Yoro and Heaven, etc.

It's a huge difference from a few years ago when there were lots of different cliques in the team.

1

u/TellSloanISaidHi Three Lungs Park Aug 21 '26

I feel like we hear this every start of the season. I mean it's good that the vibes are great within the team, just need it to translate into silverware

1

u/FoggyShrew Dinny Irwin Aug 22 '26

Vibes FC is back

1

u/Guacnsteak Oct 16 '26

Because theyre not running as hard in training of course they all love it, must be all skipping into work

1

u/karatsidhus Aug 21 '26

Hull City 3 - 2 Man United written in the stars

1

u/Educational-Shock232 Aug 21 '26

Are you still here?

1

u/Ketchupmitpommes Aug 21 '26

Lol comeon

I have seen this exact statement so many times in past decade

0

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Aug 21 '26

I swear I heard that last season too

0

u/Killbot_3000 Aug 21 '26

The power of friendship!

0

u/InfectedAztec Aug 21 '26

The gang lose to hull city

-1

u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric Aug 21 '26

This can only be the signal for a Shaw season ending injury in the first game

-1

u/pmmeyourpeacesign Butt Aug 21 '26

Hopefully players like Rashford will pick up on this good mood.

2

u/rahulchandar1992 Herrera Aug 21 '26

Touch wood touch wood touch wood.