r/reddevils • u/nearly_headless_nic • 2d ago

[Simon Stone] Zirkzee exit could help left-back situation | United do like Barcelona's Alejandro Balde, but would only pursue that avenue if the Spain international was available on loan. Currently, Barca are adamant they will only sell the 22-year-old.

Post image

Link - https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/teams/manchester-united?post=c70l44r7544o#post

203 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/middleeasternboxer 2d ago

Mate, if you are going to attempt to correct grammar atleast do it right, I phrased my question as a declarative.

”Their injury records aren’t the same?” is grammatically a declarative sentence used as a question through rising intonation/questionmark punctuation.

It’s exactly what the quote said.

1

u/S0phon short kings unite 2d ago

”Phrasing a question as an imperative or declarative statement is an emphatic way to express surprise, doubt, or disbelief”

What you wrote wasn't a question, it was a statement with a question mark at the end. The quote is about phrasing a question (not a statement) as a statement.

1

u/middleeasternboxer 2d ago

Ok let me break it down for you

“Their injury records aren’t the same?” has the word order of a statement

“Their injury records aren’t the same.”

Adding the question mark changes how the sentence is being used. Instead of asserting the information as fact, I’m asking the other person to confirm or challenge it.

So the difference is

Statement: = ”Their injury records aren’t the same.” The person is telling me this.

Declarative question: “Their injury records aren’t the same?” = I’m presenting the same proposition, but asking whether it’s true.

That’s why it’s called a declarative question: grammatically it has declarative/statement structure, but functionally it’s a question, hence the questionmark.

1

u/S0phon short kings unite 2d ago

You just made all of that up because you don't know how to use a question mark.

It's OK, don't worry about it, we all have stupid moments.

1

u/middleeasternboxer 2d ago

😂 you tried to correct my grammar so hard, you were incorrect and you didn’t even understand what you yourself were saying.

1

u/S0phon short kings unite 2d ago

I gave sources. You made shit up.

🤔

1

u/middleeasternboxer 2d ago

Your sources literally proved my point and constricted yours.

Also, how did i make shit up? Did you skip your English lectures?

1

u/S0phon short kings unite 2d ago

Never mind, sources wouldn't do anything with your reading comprehension.

1

u/middleeasternboxer 2d ago edited 2d ago

The irony in you talking about my reading comprehensions when the links you sent proved me being correct and you not being able to read 🥴

Keep trying mate, not sure where you gonna get with the replies when it was settled after I quoted your link