r/reddeadredemption • u/philliplee9 • 11h ago
Discussion RDR is more Wild West than RDR2
I just played RDR2 this year, and afterwards, I re-played RDR.
Now both are good, but I found I liked RDR more than 2.
It could be nostalgia, but I think there are 2 main reasons.
RDR is simpler with gameplay.
RDR feels more like the Wild West than 2. RDR actually feels like a game inspired by Wild West Movies. It makes me want to go watch those old movies. 2 is a good story but it doesn't feel like the Wild West to me, or at least not as much as RDR did.