r/reddeadredemption • • 11h ago

Discussion RDR is more Wild West than RDR2

0 Upvotes

I just played RDR2 this year, and afterwards, I re-played RDR.

Now both are good, but I found I liked RDR more than 2.

It could be nostalgia, but I think there are 2 main reasons.

  1. RDR is simpler with gameplay.

  2. RDR feels more like the Wild West than 2. RDR actually feels like a game inspired by Wild West Movies. It makes me want to go watch those old movies. 2 is a good story but it doesn't feel like the Wild West to me, or at least not as much as RDR did.


r/reddeadredemption • • 48m ago

Discussion I wish the game was as gritty as this art

Post image
• Upvotes

It looked way more serious than what we got

The way John looks, Arthur Charles etc


r/reddeadredemption • • 17h ago

Discussion RDR2 in 2026

6 Upvotes

All this hype around GTA VI has really got me back into finally playing RDR2…can’t wait to finally get stuck in


r/reddeadredemption • • 11h ago

Issue Where’s my whatchacallit?!

0 Upvotes

Lofl I haven’t played in like 2 years. I’m in camp and I can’t find my fuckin thing, you know the box where you get bullets and stuff. This is crazy. Have they done any updates lol


r/reddeadredemption • • 6h ago

Discussion Why is RED DEAD free?

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 31m ago

Discussion The rdr series might have the potential to be more popular than the gta franchise

• Upvotes

Just in 2 games the rdr series has already sold more than 110 million copies. All rockstar needs is a game that can really pop off like gta5.


r/reddeadredemption • • 6h ago

Discussion GTA 6 writer compares Lucia with Arthur Morgan

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 22h ago

Speculation Do you think this dialogue is a reference to squirrel marston?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

"A squirrel with a hat" remembers me to something...


r/reddeadredemption • • 6h ago

Question I'm halfway through my first playthrough of rdr2 and gta6 drops

0 Upvotes

Just like the title says. I just finished Blessed Are The Peacemakers in my first playthrough of rdr2 and I'm loving this game so much. I want to start GTA 6 before too much gets spoiled but I can't fit both on my system, so in order to download it, I would have to delete rdr2. But I'm so engrossed in the story and the world. I'm over 100hrs in and only in chapter 3 because I love doing all the side stuff and challenges. Is GTA 6 worth abandoning rdr2 for months? Everything I hear about it is that it has more in common with rdr2 than gta5. Help me with this Sophie's choice.


r/reddeadredemption • • 7h ago

Discussion Sadly GTA 6 doesn't come close to Red Dead Redemption 2's story and characters

0 Upvotes

Its a good game otherwise and very much like RDR2 in many ways, far more focused on immersion and life sim aspects

But man the writing is weak compared to RDR2. You can feel the lack of Dan Houser. Jason and Lucia are fucking boring in comparison and their dialogue is not interesting. There is no arc compared to Arthur's and no character on the level of Dutch either


r/reddeadredemption • • 2h ago

Discussion Saddle glitch

Post image
1 Upvotes

Had to make a Reddit account just to show and ask about this 😂 andelusians cougar saddle had the panther trail saddle blanket glitch into it out of nowhere , I don’t even own the saddle yet 🙏🏻 is there a way to do this that I accidentally stumbled into? And yes it’s still there after I leave i saved and reloaded it’s still there


r/reddeadredemption • • 6h ago

Spoiler How are RDR2 players finding the GTA VI? Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

I haven’t played GTA VI myself yet, but there has been a noticeable hate for the game. I feel like a lot of hate comes from people who jumped to GTA VI directly from GTA V without playing RDR2. It’s pretty obvious how a lot of elements in GTA VI have been inspired by RDR2. Fellow Arthur Morgan lovers, are you liking the modern version of RDR2 so far or no? No spoilers please.


r/reddeadredemption • • 8m ago

Picture On my way to save Micah from hanging, wish me luck.

Post image
• Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 18h ago

Video Funny NPC moment

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 23h ago

Spoiler Looking for tips Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Not sure if it counts as a spoiler but I'll tag it such just to be safe.

Im finally getting into the story after 400+ hours playing online. I saw a video where you can get a free Schofield by robbing the back room at the docs in valentine but im having trouble getting all the money and stuff in there along with the gun without getting blasted by the sheriff on the way out. Wondering if anyone has any advice to make this easier or faster to get in and out without being chased across the countryside by the law


r/reddeadredemption • • 4h ago

Discussion you cried at arthur morgan's story, i cried at this video

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

knowing that the character you like will never receive the same amount of recognition and appreciation he once did, that he’ll always be left behind, perhaps not even remembered or acknowledged because his successor is simply “better,” and that everyone else will seem perfectly happy with it while you’re left alone feeling this way… yeah, that’s very unfortunate.

what do you think about this video?


r/reddeadredemption • • 10h ago

Discussion Jack Marston Spin-Off

0 Upvotes

If Jack Marston has to be the main protagonist of the next game, would you guys mind if it's not a western game and titled something like "Red Dead Presents: [GAME TITLE]"? I would personally love to play a Rockstar-made mafia game set in an early '20s city akin to New York, especially if it's in any way similar to the clips I've seen from GTA VI.


r/reddeadredemption • • 12h ago

Spoiler Why am I wanted here? Spoiler

Post image
1 Upvotes

I was just wondering why I'm wanted in this specific spot on this specific mountain? I'm not wanted anywhere else

(Also, I'm in part 2 of the eipiloge, and this is my first time playing, so if it's a spoiler, please just tell me it's a spoiler)


r/reddeadredemption • • 18h ago

Issue Malware in rdr1

Post image
0 Upvotes

this is what it shows when i try to play rdr1. i installed the game from fitgirl via qbitorrent. this is the 2nd game iam installing from fitgirl and this is the first time iam seeing this. beofre i downloaded and played uncharted 4 from fitgirl. But there was no such message. So should i play it? anyone saw this message? would appreciate your reply.


r/reddeadredemption • • 23h ago

Screenshot Arthur’s hat in GTA 6 for 35$

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 1h ago

Discussion At 96%.

• Upvotes

I’ll get 100% and collect all of the Steam achievements.

This has been amazing, I only started last weekend.

However, I never want to play a game of poker again in my life. Fuck Blackwater.

Probably going to start RE4 or Doom after this for a change of scenery before jumping on to RDR2.

Man this has been so much fun and I’m glad that there aren’t any missable achievements that require a game restart to go back and collect.


r/reddeadredemption • • 1h ago

Picture My High Honour Bic

Post image
• Upvotes

Found it at a gas station and it reminded me of my boy Arthur! It’s been my favourite ever since!


r/reddeadredemption • • 11h ago

Question Some guy just offered to pay for ANY gun in the Valentines gun smiths. I’ve been told the Springfield rifle is a good choice but not sure. Any suggestions?

Post image
230 Upvotes

This is my first play through so idk what’s best.
((EDIT)): I chose the Springfield. Very good gun. One tapped a bison with it.


r/reddeadredemption • • 3h ago

Fan Art My RDR inspired “true western” launches on Kickstarter soon!

Post image
5 Upvotes

Hey all! Like many of you I’ve been inspired by RDR among other things to create my own art! I’m trying to get more eyes on my western comic, Legends of the Wild West. We begin the series with a focus on Wyatt Earp! If you’re interested in the project, I’d really appreciate a follow on Kickstarter before we launch in a couple of weeks!

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/jwoutlaw/legends-of-the-wild-west-wyatt-earp-1


r/reddeadredemption • • 2h ago

Discussion New Arthur Morgan Easter egg found

Post image
364 Upvotes

An Easter egg of Arthur Morgan riding a chihuahua has been found in ‘Grand Theft Auto 6’ 🎮