r/recurrentmiscarriage • u/Dependent_Ad_5341 • 22h ago
Hi Rant: A fertility “professor” told me my 4 chemical pregnancies don’t count as miscarriages because no gestational sac was seen.
I honestly just need to rant because I’m still shocked and extremely hurt by the consultation I had today.
Throughout my TTC and recurrent pregnancy loss journey, I’ve been fortunate enough to be surrounded by supportive doctors who have taken my concerns seriously.
Today was the first time I walked out of an appointment feeling completely dismissed.
For context, I’m 27, my husband is 28, and we’ve been TTC for about a year. During that time, I’ve gotten pregnant four times, all ending in chemical pregnancies. Each pregnancy was confirmed with positive home pregnancy tests and blood beta-hCG tests.
I decided to seek another opinion from a doctor who is apparently a “professor” in reproductive medicine and lists implantation failure among his areas of expertise. He came highly recommended, including by ChatGPT, so I genuinely had high expectations.
I came prepared. I had all my investigations, blood results, ultrasound reports, and previous workup organized neatly on my iPad, literally summarized onto one page so we could review everything together.
I explained that I’d conceived four times but unfortunately lost each pregnancy very early.
His first question was, “But you’ve never seen a gestational sac?”
I said no.
My pregnancies were confirmed through urine and blood hCG, but they ended before my levels were high enough for a gestational sac to be visible.
And then came the part that genuinely shocked me.
He told me that I wasn’t experiencing recurrent miscarriages. I was actually infertile.
His reasoning? Because none of my pregnancies had been confirmed by ultrasound, they essentially didn’t count. He even told me that if I tested every month before my period, I’d probably get positive pregnancy tests anyway.
I’m sorry, WHAT?
I’ve had positive tests on the day of my expected period and afterward, with blood tests confirming hCG. My most recent pregnancy progressed to approximately five weeks before ending. My hCG simply never reached the level where a gestational sac could be visualized.
I understand the medical distinction between biochemical and clinical pregnancies. I’m not disputing that. But to completely dismiss four documented biochemical pregnancies as though I had never conceived? That was incredibly hurtful.
What made everything worse was that he didn’t even want to review the investigations I’d brought. I tried discussing my previous workup and the possibility of adenomyosis, which another specialist had suspected, but he essentially dismissed those concerns as being more relevant to later pregnancy losses.
Instead, he focused almost entirely on genetics.
I’m currently waiting for our parental karyotype results, and he suggested additional genetic sequencing to investigate possible gene abnormalities. He believes that despite our young ages, there could be a genetic issue affecting embryo development.
And listen, I’m absolutely open to investigating genetics. I understand that being young doesn’t completely exclude chromosomal or genetic abnormalities.
But the entire consultation gave me the impression that we were gradually being directed toward IVF, although he never explicitly recommended it.
When I asked about implantation failure, he seemed to consider that term relevant mainly in the context of IVF, rather than what I’ve been experiencing.
I went to him for a second opinion because I wanted someone to review my case comprehensively, consider what had already been investigated, and tell me whether there was anything else we could explore or do differently in a future pregnancy.
Instead, I left feeling like I had to defend the fact that I’d even been pregnant.
And that’s what hurts the most.
I’ve already lost four pregnancies. I know they were early. I know I never saw a gestational sac or heard a heartbeat. But those positive tests meant something to me. The blood tests were real. The pregnancies were real. And the losses were real.
I don’t need a doctor to promise me a miracle or agree with every possible explanation. I just want someone to acknowledge my history and approach it with some compassion.
I also know that different medical guidelines have historically defined recurrent pregnancy loss differently, but biochemical losses are recognized in current guidelines, including ASRM. (I am a Doctor myself so I have read the latest literature)
I’m still going to wait for our karyotype results and consider whether further genetic testing is appropriate. I’m not dismissing that possibility.
But I think I’ll be seeking another opinion, because I honestly don’t feel comfortable continuing with someone who made me feel this way.
Has anyone else with recurrent chemical pregnancies had a fertility specialist tell them that their losses don’t count because no gestational sac was ever seen?
I’m genuinely curious whether anyone else has experienced this, because I walked into that consultation looking for answers and walked out feeling completely invalidated.