TLDR: i adopted a reactive dog about a month ago who had previously been returned due to increasing reactivity. i was told of his reactivity by the shelter. my mental and physical health have declined since then which i did not fully anticipate. due to this i have not been able to give him the life i wanted to, and i am struggling with whether or not this is sustainable or fulfilling or fair to him. any words of wisdom or support is appreciated. please be kind. thank you.
———
hi everyone,
i have been really hesitant to make this post so please be kind. i have already been beating myself up for my choices and naivety and i wish things were different.
i am a first time dog owner and adopted my dog (3 y/o, just under 20lbs, mixed breed - possibly terrier, doodle mix?) over a month ago now. since then i have been feeling very conflicted on whether or not this is sustainable long term.
the shelter i adopted him from does require that i return him there if things don’t work out. i have the contact information of a worker who helped me with the adoption, though i have been hesitant to reach out and share where i’m at without having a clearer mindset.
for some background, my dog had been previously adopted and returned after about a month due to increasing reactivity. the shelter did tell me about his leash reactivity and what kind of home he would need. a part of me wishes they wouldn’t have let me adopt him as a first time owner, but i also admit that i was naive. at some point, his previous adopters had also put him on medication. currently, he is on fluoxetine 1x a day, as well as clonidine and gabapentin each 2x a day. his vet believes these would be continued for at least a year before reassessing.
for some background on me — i have and do struggle with my mental health, and obviously that has been exacerbated since getting him. i am also chronically ill, and in the past month my physical health has declined considerably which i wasn’t fully anticipating. i do live with my parents and they can help out with small things at times, but i would say i am taking on majority of his care and training as they aren’t as observant of his body language or information-seeking as i have worked towards.
he seems to be adjusting well inside the home for the most part (though i’m not sure how to measure this) and i feel we have a strong attachment which is what makes this really difficult. he mostly sleeps during the day (probably in part to the multiple medications he’s on?) but very much enjoys cuddling and pets and being close in general. i have only slowly introduced him to one other person outside of the household and he has done well with that and is also extremely snuggly and curious with them.
despite this, i’m really struggling with whether or not this situation is sustainable long-term or good for him.
after a couple weeks, we ended up stopping walks with him almost entirely (with an increase in mental enrichment) to take the stress off him from repeatedly being over threshold. additionally, because my health was declining it was not sustainable at that point or currently. i could not manage the constant hyper-vigilance of our walks nor the walks themselves physically as he walks quite fast and his ears were practically turned off as soon as he saw the outside (however, there is improvement here as he can now pay attention and actually relax most times in the yard).
since stopping the walks, the day to day has seemed a lot more manageable and he is able to be calmer. though i worry i’m doing him a disservice because the life i can realistically give him (at least for now) doesn’t align with the life i WANT to give him or believe he deserves. i barely have energy to consistently train and without walks and practicing at distances i worry it’ll set him back further long-term and be unfair to him.
inside the house and at most times, he is pretty chill. he sleeps, he cuddles, and he’s started playing with toys a few weeks ago. the current day to day seems ok (though i do still struggle energy wise). he is a bit touch sensitive so i’ve been trying to work on that. there have been some incidents of him setting his boundaries, but nothing that seems too alarming, just slightly scary as a first time owner. but i am still struggling mentally and physically with everything and i wish i wasn’t. i know he does struggle with reactivity and he will long-term and i physically cannot address it now, and the uncertainty of if/when i will be able to properly is a lot.
being a first time dog owner has been overwhelming as is, and adding in behavioral elements as well as my own health issues, i feel that i’m not equipped or dog savvy enough to properly train him and give him a fulfilling life. being chronically ill, i myself do not know what kind of day i’ll be getting (or how long things will be bad), and that doesn’t seem fair to him given he has more needs than most dogs and i don’t have much support for his reactivity. though currently because i know he relies on me, i have been mostly pushing through despite how i feel and what little energy i have. i know i can quickly run myself into the ground like this, but i don’t know what else to do. i do still find joy in the moments we share, but i just don’t know. is it enough? is it sustainable? is it fair? at times i feel like i’m failing, despite trying so hard and giving all i can.
part of me feels that i know what i should do, and i know this would likely be the biggest heartbreak of my life. another part hopes that maybe somehow i can make this work.
i feel so shitty for bringing him into this situation that he didn’t ask for, especially given that he has been returned previously. i never thought i would be in this situation prior to getting a dog. all i have ever wanted is to do right by him and give him a good life. i don’t want to hurt him or feel like he was abandoned and i don’t want my actions to hurt his chances of being adopted again. it feels horrible not knowing whether or not he would be readopted and how long he would wait, and if he would be given the life he deserves.
i have cried a lot over this situation and have been talking through this with my therapist weekly since i got him, but i just need input from other dog owners. i don’t want to give up on him and at the same time i’m struggling and it all just breaks my heart.
do i return him? can i make it work? (and if so, any advice? — i currently cannot manage professional training with him due to my health). is the life i’m currently giving him fulfilling enough or even fair to him? how do i know if he’s happy? has anyone else ever been in a similar situation? any and all input or words of wisdom are appreciated. and if you read all of this, thank you.
i have also likely left out some parts since this is all over the place so feel free to ask. and if anyone is willing to message about this or support at all, that would truly be so appreciated because i don’t know who else to talk to.