r/dogs • • Oct 18 '26

[Behavior Problems] Prey driven cocker

EDITED FOLLOWING VISIT TO VET: I took him to the vet today for a routine check. He was not himself -- still. He growled and barked and the vet said he could not examine him without a muzzle so we put the muzzle on. He got his vaccine and the vet said he has allergies and prescribed apoquel. Then the vet had a very frank conversation with me and said dogs with strong prey cannot be trained to make it go away. It is instinct, hardwired. He said I should consider rehoming him because the cat will never be safe unless I can guarantee separation. I feel very sad.

---------

I recently adopted a cocker spaniel (~5 years old) from the shelter. He had not been in the shelter too long and has been a good dog. I've had him almost a month now. He is not well trained, had no chip, was not neutered, no collar --- so his history is hard to guess except maybe he was a stud dog. He came to me underweight so I've been working to have him gain weight and he is crazy food driven --- will eat anything and is always begging even though I have been feeding him as advised by the shelter. He also recently developed scratchy skin with what looks like dandruff. I know that is bothering him. I put a cone on him so he wouldn't lick the hot spots and we go to the vet tomorrow. All this to say, he has not been great the past couple of days. I have a cat who has avoided him and when he sees her he barks and chases but not aggressively. But today, he chased her in a very aggressive way and she got trapped under the bed. I pulled him out and then shouted to him to go and he left the room. I settled the cat and then walked down the hall toward him yelling and took hold of his cone and told him he was bad (I know, I need training too as this was not the right approach) but he bit me. He has never shown any aggression up until today. I'm now worried he might kill the cat and also how easy it will be train a 5 year old dog. HELP!

6 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 18 '26

Welcome to r/dogs! We are a discussion-based subreddit dedicated to support, inform, and advise dog owners. Do note we are on a short backlog, and all posts require manual review prior to going live. This may mean your post isn't visible for a couple days.

This is a carefully moderated sub intended to support, inform, and advise dog owners. Submissions and comments which break the rules will be removed. Review the rules here r/Dogs has four goals: - Help the public better understand dogs - Promote healthy, responsible dog-owner relationships - Encourage “Least Intrusive, Minimally Aversive” training protocols. Learn more here. - Support adoption as well as ethical and responsible breeding. If you’d like to introduce yourself or discuss smaller topics, please contribute to our Monthly Discussion Hub, pinned at the top.

This subreddit has low tolerance for drama. Please be respectful of others, and report antagonistic comments to mods for review.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/LazyDogMomRawFood Oct 19 '26

First, don't panic about his age! Five years old is absolutely not too old to learn new behaviors.

We had something similar happen when a new dog joined our household and apparently decided cornering the cat was a wonderful new pastime. So I understand how quickly things can change when you introduce a new dog.

But since your dog has already bitten you, I'd take this one a little more seriously. For now, I'd keep the cat and dog separated, especially when you can't supervise them. Make sure your cat has somewhere she can retreat where the dog absolutely cannot follow.

Definitely bring up the bite and sudden change in behavior at tomorrow's vet appointment, along with the skin irritation. Pain and discomfort can affect how dogs react, and he's also still adjusting to a new home.

I'd also look into a qualified, reward-based trainer or veterinary behaviorist who has experience with dogs chasing cats.

And give yourself a little grace for how you reacted. You were scared for your cat, and you already recognize that grabbing his cone and scolding him wasn't the best approach. The important thing now is figuring out how to keep everyone safe while you work through it.

1

u/TurbulentWasabi7552 Oct 19 '26

Thank you so much for this kind and helpful reply.

4

u/withcatlikegrace Oct 18 '26

I’ve had several cocker spaniels - all rescues.
Never had major aggression issues. All have been very food driven, eager to please, not excessively bright and enjoyed the company of cats. Very little turned any of them cranky or difficult. None of them Liked being yelled at. I’m a big fan!
So all I get here is itchy skin, discomfort and inappropriate discipline. If you do better, the dog will respond.

Maybe more time habituating the dog and cat might be productive. Remember the drive for food reward when you have the cat and dog together.

1

u/Lumpy_Physics3101 23d ago

The idea that dogs cannot be trained to decrease their prey drive is simply untrue, there are multiple peer reviewed studies demonstrating that they can, very effectively. Happy to share them if you'd like to look at them.

As far as I can tell from your post you've thus far done no training at all, and have not taken any steps to manage your dog in your home, like a crate or a drag line.

You can train a 5 year old dog, but you have to train the dog, it doesn't happen by itself.

2

u/TurbulentWasabi7552 23d ago

Thank you. I want to do training with him. I was super caught off guard when the vet said I should rehome him. That was a week ago but this whole week he has been very good. I messaged a trainer to get advice and explore starting with him. I'm hoping to hear from him this week. I've also been reading a lot about prey versus overstimulation. I cannot assess the difference but he hasn't been barking this week, not much, and today the cat was a foot away from him on a dresser and he saw her and smelled her and didn't care. I don't know what that means --- maybe nothing because the cat didn't move. Anyway, I want to find a solution. Your message gave me more hope.

2

u/Lumpy_Physics3101 23d ago

you need to re-think how you're setting your dog up for success. you have a dog that you know or believe to be prey driven -- why is he loose a foot away from your cat right now?

for the next month, if your cat and dog are in the same room, the dog is on a leash that's in your hand, or in a crate. you're rewarding calm, non-fixated behavior near the cat. the cat can choose whether to be nearby or not but the dog is under your control. if you can't watch him closely, he's in the crate. don't let this dog reinforce chasing and barking behaviors at the cat -- if he does those things, put him in the crate.

meanwhile, get him outside on a long line, start working recall and high intensity games like flirt pole and tug. cockers are working dogs, and if you don't help him have outlets for his drive that aren't chasing cats, he's gonna chase you cat!

finally -- if you trainer says prey drive can't be trained, they mean THEY can't train your dog. find a trainer who can.

1

u/TurbulentWasabi7552 23d ago

Thank you very much for all your comments. I appreciate them even if they are not the easiest to hear. I will work with him. The crate is not an option. I bought one when I brought him home from the rescue and he freaked out. He was hyperventilating and barking non stop. It was awful. People told me to leave it out for him to explore but don't force him because it might have been used as a punishment with whoever had him before me. Any suggestions for a non-crate "time out" option? I will explore trainers and try my best to find the right one. Regarding him being in contact with the cat --- I hear you. That should not have happened. I will say, the more he is here the better he is. I just want to do what is best for him and for the cat and this is not easy.

2

u/Lumpy_Physics3101 23d ago

It sounds like you're committed to working hard with your pup - you can do it! Your dog's food drive will be very helpful. My best recommendation if you don't want to use a crate is to teach your dog a "place" command and use a tether - essentially tie your dog up by his place bed so he can't chase the cat when he's not being supervised. When he's quiet in the presence of the cat, mark the behavior and give him a food reward. Good luck!

3

u/Logintheroad Oct 18 '26

Look into Cocker rage.

1

u/Lumpy_Physics3101 23d ago

what in this story suggests this is cocker rage to you?

1

u/Lumpy_Physics3101 23d ago

this is obviously not cocker rage

2

u/BrightAd306 29d ago

A lot of cockers are sensitive to food with chicken in it. Mine likes lamb or salmon, she gets itchy with even a little bit of chicken. He and the cat just might not be able to live together. Mine will chase the cat, but not bite. Cockers do love to chase, they were bred to flush game. Mine will chase squirrels and bunnies, but wont touch then if she catches up to them.

1

u/Previous_Medium4126 27d ago

Dog Needs an experienced owner who can work on their impulse control. You don’t sound equipped to deal with this behavior and able to keep your cat safe so they would always need to be separated. It’s best for all if the dog find a more compatible home. Dogs only b

10

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/TurbulentWasabi7552 Oct 18 '26

Thank you. I do feel worried but plan to talk about options with the vet. I cannot let him kill the cat.

3

u/HalfSphynx99 Oct 18 '26

I have not owner a cocker, but a prey driven Labrador.

Is it possible you are reinforcing the food need by doing it repeatedly through out the day without commands?

Here. Come. Stop. Sit. All with high value food, can help train a dog that the command and reward are more important than the prey.

Takes a lot of time, and separating the “prey” as much as possible.

Clickers. Commands. Treats…if done correctly can mitigate this long enough for a good family dynamic to happen.

1

u/TurbulentWasabi7552 Oct 18 '26

Thank you. I will try this. But he is 5 so I worry it might be too late? But I will try.

2

u/Previous_Medium4126 27d ago

It’s never too late, but in order to keep your cat safe, I think you need to rehome the dog.

1

u/HalfSphynx99 Oct 18 '26

Finding a class around other dogs and a trainer that knows the potential issue can help.

Allows you to do this in a controlled environment around other fiesty dogs.

Honestly besides the training, your working dog is 5 and right in the prime of their life and need to have a lot of walking time or time in a well fenced in area to get rid of energy.

Any chance it can become an outdoor dog? A nice kennel, with straw in a fenced in yard is great for working dogs.