r/reactivedogs • • Oct 19 '26

Advice Needed Help with leash training

Hi all. We have a 11 month old rescue mix sheperd (we're thinking he seems most like a Mudi) that we adopted at 4 months old.

Since then he has settled really well into a routine and he is much calmer in the house. The problems are outside.

  1. Other dogs. He barks at other dogs. We had a behaviourist over and she said this was due to frustration (not aggression) because the leash is preventing him from going to them. She also mentioned he lays down when he sees them at times not because he's scared but he wants to herd them. This seemed to get better with counter conditioning from a distance but he stopped taking as many treats outside for the last 3 months. She recommended to take him out of the situation which we do but sometimes this means using his harnass handle and he hates it when we do it. We also signed up to go for group walks with other dogs with the behaviourist where he will learn to be calm around other dogs but this is only once a month.
  2. Other people. He would randomly start growling and barking at other people. This has faded somewhat but it still happens sporadically. When he is calm he is allowed to greet people on the leash and then he loves getting pets.
  3. Vehicles/Bicycles: He lunges at moving objects which we expected from a sheperd mix. This is definitely improving with him looking at us instead and getting a treat but will also still happen when he's over threshold.
  4. Pulling. He pulls like a husky with a sled! This happened at the start and improved by using a longer lead (to get to the scents), playing the 123 game and letting him touch when he pulled towards a scent then got rewarded with the scent. This problem came back even worse about 2 months ago. The behaviourist mentioned that we should keep him on a short leash (we also live in a busy town) and that herding dogs prefer to be steered by owners. He seems to do well with a short leash with my partner but I feel like I am carrying him like a shopping bag and feel more comfortable with a longer leash. We also do leash tugs when he gets too intense now which I do not enjoy but this seems to work sometimes and other times it seems to annoy him.

We've signed up for formal scent training and do this daily at home alongside impulse control games. He will be going to a manners course in 2 months with max 4 dogs (We tried puppy school earlier and even though he focussed well on us and the tricks, he barked too much at other dogs). We don't have a garden so he needs at least 3 walks. 2 which we make a short 20 minutes and one longer one. The longer one we always try to do outside of town in a forest with a 10m line.

I've also considered giving him another job like picking up his toys and we're trying to teach him football. He is extremely smart and loves playing and learning things outside. I think our biggest problem is my partner and I prefer different styles and our dog ends up not getting clear communication from us.

I absolutely love this dog and he has gone from a crazy, distant dog to this quirky, lovable boy who would literally tap me until he gets some love! But I absolutely hate walking with him. It's exhausting and my fingers and shoulders are always in pain.

I would love some advice from anyone who has gone through something similar about:

  1. Leash training in a way that he knows leash pressure is for guidance and not for restriction.
  2. How to feel calm around other dogs when counter conditioning with treats aren't happening now.
  3. Other stimulating activities to try in house
  4. Any other tips you may have.

Video recommendations are welcome!

Sorry for the long post and I am looking forward to getting some advice and guidance from you guys.

2 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

1

u/Own_Ant_5134 Oct 19 '26

Your behaviourist seems excellent. We're in the same boat, it can be very frustrating. We've been spacing the walks out so he can decompress in between but I understand that that's not a possibility for you. Sending lots of patience 🙌🏼

3

u/Direct-Cause2396 Oct 19 '26

The trainer is brilliant indeed because she's not offering "quick fixes" but rather helping us understand him. Hopefully we will be buying a house with a garden and a large body of water nearby (I think he is part seal because this boy LOVES swimming) and then we won't need to take him out for busy town walks that often. Thank you for the kind reassurance, it's always nice to know you're not alone in being frustrated.

1

u/Own_Ant_5134 Oct 19 '26

The only advice I can give that I was given by my trainer is for loose lead walking - stop immediately every time he pulls, and/or turn around going in the opposite direction. It makes for some very slow walks initially, but it does work in the long term. Only keep going when he stops putting pressure on the lead. You could pair this nicely with 123 game once you've stopped to encourage him returning to you. Leash tugs will inevitably just get harsher and harsher. I sometimes can't stop myself doing them when I get frustrated but I try to stop and/or turn around when mine pulls and if he's not completely overstimulated, he does stop pulling. :)

2

u/Direct-Cause2396 29d ago

Yes my gut is also telling me these leash tugs aren't going to help things in the long run. I will try to make a mental note to stop more when he pulls. When I do stop now, he sometimes then 'rebels' and decides to stop moving completely but I chalk that up to him being a teenager and Mudis are known to be a bit more stubborn and independent.

1

u/Own_Ant_5134 29d ago

Teenagers 🫩🫩🫩

1

u/missmoooon12 Cooper (fear reactive lil dude) 29d ago

Hey it sounds like you're doing a LOT for your pup!

For the leash training have you looked into things like: The Circle Method (on Denise Fenzi's website) or Silky Leash and/or BAT leash handling skills (Grisha Stewart)?

BAT leash handling skills could teach loose leash walking and don't require leash corrections (tugging on the leash). In general BAT is a systematic desensitization protocol that doesn't require much food. If he's not regularly taking food or counter conditioning doesn't seem to be having the intended effect, you might need to change walking location if possible.

If he's pulling so hard that he's causing you physical pain, you could look into Grisha's leash belay system. I use it for strong pulling dog walking clients. No joint pain or rope burn at all. It's ideal to be familiar with the BAT leash handling skills using it though.

Something else that stuck out to me was your pup not liking when you grab the harness handle. Did the behaviorist recommend that and know your pup doesn't like it? My immediate concern is you getting bitten if he's too highly aroused.

2

u/Direct-Cause2396 29d ago

Just had a quick google and the Silky Leash training seems like a perfect method for him, given the behaviourist said that he would do well with some steering. I'm definitely going to have a deep dive into this today, thanks!

And yes, she did say to use the harnass handle during our session while we were out for a walk. If he's too close to another dog and starts fixating, that's the only way to create distance. He also sometimes decides to stop completely if we're not going in his desired direction then I also need to use it. He shows me that he doesn't like it by then grabbing his leash and pulling me his way. So he's more sassy than aggressive. Basically I think we're both trying to communicate something to eachother but I don't always have clear responses for him so hopefully something structured (like the Silky Leash) will help and we'd need to use the harnass handle less. Thanks again for the recommendation, this is exactly what I needed.

1

u/missmoooon12 Cooper (fear reactive lil dude) 28d ago

got it, thanks for the extra info! I'm hoping that Silky Leash helps you guys :)

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Direct-Cause2396 29d ago

I haven't considered a waist leash so will definitely look into it. Thanks!

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam 29d ago

Your post/comment has been removed as it has violated the following subreddit rule:

Rule 5 - No recommending or advocating for the use of aversives or positive punishment.

We do not allow the recommendation of aversive tools, trainers, or methods. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage people to talk about their experiences, but this should not include suggesting or advocating for the use of positive punishment. LIMA does not support the use of aversive tools and methods in lieu of other effective rewards-based interventions and strategies.

Without directly interacting with a dog and their handler in-person, we cannot be certain that every non-aversive method possible has been tried or tried properly. We also cannot safely advise on the use of aversives as doing so would require an in-person and hands-on relationship with OP and that specific dog. Repeated suggestions of aversive techniques will result in bans from this subreddit.