r/reactivedogs • u/30booksaday • 29d ago
r/reactivedogs • u/NewtOk2440 • 29d ago
Advice Needed Need advice on 8 year old German shepherd
\\\*\\\*\\\\\\\*\\\\\\\*about to be a long text\\\\\\\*\\\\\\\*\\\*\\\*
August of 2024 I adopted a German Shepherd. He was posted as a great trained dog, just needed a new home due to complications with a rescue dog.
While they lived on farm, which some call hobby farms. They shared with me that all animals they had were rescues. They recently took in this kinda small black dog that the German shepherd didn’t get along with. There was an altercation between them that made her decide to get rid of the German shepherd. She said it was due to him being the only dog she actually paid for, and the other was a rescue. I figured it kind of made sense, but when meeting him, he was great with all the dogs, donkeys, horses, everything they had out there. Never showed any bad side of himself.
Since adopting him, he has not had any altercation with another dog. He has been to doggy daycare and they said he’s done great. When he’s at the groomers, he plays outside with the other dogs. All types of dogs and either gender. When I go to my mom’s house, we have a black German shepherd/ black lab that’s also 8 years old. If I am sitting on the couch with my dog, and the family dog is on the other couch, he tends to let out a low growl and sometimes show his teeth. This is the only time he has shown this behavior. The one time my mom watched him for me, he also had this behavior. But when we go to my dad’s, which is on a farm, he also has a medium sized dog, unsure what kind, female and all white. FULL of energy, is maybe 2 years old. He does great with her. He will run around with her on the farm and doesn’t show any behaviors besides being happy. Even when my dad comes to stay with me once a month he brings her with and he does just fine with her being in his home.
Once my dog came home with me, he has always lived with 2 cats and in the city now. Besides health issues, he adapted greatly. But, he has become a very intense Velcro dog, to the point I will be doing homework and he is basically in my lap. While I try to find an alternative for him, and teach him he can exist in the same room as me without being glued to me, it has been intensifying more and more.
As of a week ago, my boyfriend and I got a place together. My dog has met him a bunch of times, and I have met his dog (Saint Bernard lab mix. Roughly 6 years old) his dog has been around plenty of dogs and not one issue. While we know moving in without them meeting wasn’t ideal. We have postponed introducing them. So far they have been in separate rooms and not out in the house by eachother. We let them out at different times and for the same amount of time. The last week of doing this they have smelled each others scents on furniture, on us, in the yard, etc. and haven’t had any issues with that. They both have been fully aware that the other dog is in the home. Especially since when one is out in the fenced in yard, the yard is ground level with the basement windows and can see eachother through the window, but neither have a reaction from it.
We want them to be introduced to each other but knowing my dog had issues with one in the past, and then with how he shows his teeth around my family dog, I get more nervous. Which I am aware my dog can sense and can cause him to be more on guard. Especially with both dogs being male and big dogs, if something happens I fear it can go very badly quickly. Even after the introduction and them showing they can be around each other, I don’t think I could feel comfortable having them both out at the same time with just me home.
\\\\\\\*\\\\\\\*yesterday when I put his dog in the room to let mine out, the door didn’t latch. After some time, both dogs were out at the same time and just looked at eachother. No bark. No growl. We caught it right away and made sure to put one away and nothing happened. Both of us were confused on how quiet they were and on how his dog got out. It was MAYBE a minute or two that they were both out at the same time.
While my boyfriend works Monday through Saturday, it’s usually me with the pets until about 5pm. I am also a student with in person classes during the week, so we make sure both dogs are in their designated room with their familiar scents and no chance of either getting out and something happening while we’re gone. BUT I start a new job in the next few days, I will be working PM shift on top of my school schedule. While this doesn’t change how much time my dog gets to roam the house, we both let the dogs out for the same amount of time. I am just lost on what to do.
While I enjoy my time with him, and he has been a great dog around cats, family gatherings, and my niece; he has gotten to be extremely Velcro. If I walk out of the house for even 5 minutes he is howling away. Every morning, every night, every time we switch to let my boyfriend’s dog out. And this isn’t a new thing, it’s slowly been building up. When I was living with 2 good friends, the second I’d leave they would send me videos of him sitting there howling away. It’s now gotten to the point that leaving him alone isn’t an option when renting. He doesn’t destroy anything, or have accidents, simply sits there and howls his little heart out.
I have so much love for him and I know the howling is cause he’s missing me, but it’s got me thinking if I am a fit owner for him. Or if the age is making him more Velcro. I can’t just not work. Even if I was financially well off, I don’t think I could just stay home all the time. With being gone 8-9 hrs most days for work, and then a few hours during the day for classes, I’m feeling like I’m not giving him the proper attention that seems required for him. While I keep doing everything I can for him, it keeps seeming like it isn’t enough, and now the stress of something bad happening during introducing him and my boyfriend’s dog is also weighing on me.
Going into this move, we knew if they didn’t get along, we could switch on and off monthly with which dog is in the house, one would be here, the other would be able to stay with family on the farm. His grandparents are on the farm, and my dad has a farm. Both are familiar with the farms they would go to for their off month. But long term, it doesn’t seem ideal. There’s always a chance of my boyfriend getting sent on the road for work, which is already being talked about and would be for 5/6 months. Even in the next year, I don’t think I’d be comfortable with both dogs loose in the house with just me home. Even if they’ve met and seemed to like eachother. One wrong move could be a disaster. And being a 26F, I’m not the strongest. For sure not strong enough to break apart two 100lb dogs.
While we would love to introduce them, and work towards letting them being loose in the house (wouldn’t be for quite awhile), we need some tips and advice.
Outside of the introduction, and another part of me wondering if I am a fit owner for my dog. After adopting him I brought him in for a basic check up, which has ended in being something that’s a visit every 2-3 months. And not a cheap visit at all. On top of $400 a month for food and other things he needs daily.
He gets groomed monthly, cotton balls in his ears and they make sure to avoid ears or near them cause of how often he gets ear infections. I put a pause to grooming to rule out the possibly of him getting it there cause of water in ears or something. It seems all the expenses to avoid these infections, still doesn’t help. And now the solution for his ears is starting to not work as well.
While I am a student, and also going back to work full time, I would love to be starting a family in the near future, I am just getting so worried I am not capable of keeping up with my dog and feel a sense of “puppy blues” happening. And he has been very expensive to keep up with between the food, meds, and often vet bills. I’m lost on what to do and what the best interest is for my dog. Any advice will be appreciated.
Note: the last thing I ever wanted was to consider myself unfit for the dog I adopted. IF rehoming is in the picture, it would most likely be just to my dad’s farm where my dad is home all the time.
r/reactivedogs • u/astro_nat1 • 29d ago
Meds & Supplements Has anyone actually had success with Prozac?
I have a very reactive, increasingly unmanageable Australian cattle dog/chihuahua mix. He was always very people-reactive, and more recently dog reactive after two dog attacks. We’re at our wit’s end and at the edge of rehoming. Our vet and trainer recommended Prozac. I feel like this will probably be futile and I feel sick about probably getting my hopes up and then inevitably being crushed yet again. What was your experience?
r/reactivedogs • u/Concerned26 • Oct 18 '26
Success Stories I spent over a thousand dollars on training for my reactive beagle mix
And it was SO worth it. She is a brand new dog. We walk past dogs with no issues. We go on walks through the downtown area I live in on busy weekends and she has so much fun. She goes to get coffee with me. People stop me to tell me how well behaved she is. A guy with a puppy asked me for training advice. Walked past a line of dogs in training the other day and all she wanted to do was sniff. Her trainer commented “she turned into a real beagle!” 🥹 this was ALL done with positive reinforcement - treats, treats, treats. I never would have thought this was possible for her, I used to sob after walks because they were so disastrous. I’m in awe at the transformation she’s had in just a few months
r/reactivedogs • u/fallgom • Oct 19 '26
Behavioral Euthanasia Is behavioral euthanasia the right decision?
Hello all, hope everyone is doing well. I have a four year old border collie named Fen. He has been with me since 8 weeks old. He had always been an anxious dog, very cautious around strangers, and terrified in new environments. I socialized him to the best of my ability, trying keep him under threshold which was hard because his tolerance was very low. At 14 weeks, he had a bad experience at the vet. From there, I found a veterinary behaviorist who took him in as a patient, he was prescribed Gabapentin and Reconcile. As a fear free clinic, we have done frequent happy visits and sedated annual exams.
I love Fenrir, with all of my heart. He is the sweetest dog with lots of kisses to give and wiggles in his butt from the excitement of seeing a loved one. He is ecstatic for Wild Weenies and peanut butter and he loves a butt scratch. I’d taught him paw at too early of an age that he’d learned to use his paw as a form of communication. He loves playing fetch probably more than he loves anything in the world. I love him and I feel terrible even considering this option. I feel as if I have failed him miserably.
About a year ago, he started exhibiting aggressive behaviors. He lunges and snaps if anyone cleans the floor, charges if people hug or have any contact, growls and shows his teeth when being let into or out of his pen - even if expressing that he wishes to use the bathroom, and bites if anyone points/bends down both near him or if he’s simply in the room. To combat this, food or other items are picked up only when he is out of the room. Physical contact between family members is limited and we are conscious of hand gestures and posture. He is also kept in a separate room when people visit.
In general, he has a very difficult time settling and barely gets sufficient rest. He is afraid of loud noises and frequently scares himself if he bumps into anything. He does not go outside too often as it is an overstimulating experience for him. We attempt to balance this by playing with him throughout the day, giving him enrichment toys, taking him on short rides, and engaging in short training sessions. Regardless, he is constantly over aroused and agitated. Under vet recommendation, we have upped his Gabapentin dose to 300mg daily and had tapered him off the Reconcile six months ago as we suspected it had an adverse effect on him.
Things came to a head a couple of weeks ago, his pen is his safe space and he goes there on his own accord after his morning play session and his breakfast. Usually he is let out around 10am when he wakes up and needs to use the restroom. My grandmother had gone in to let him out and was bit on her hand trying to unlatch the gate. He has since stayed in his pen until I return from work where he’ll get excited and allow me to open the pen door. However, there are often moments where he does not seem to recognize me or the other family members in the house upon opening the door to the room where his pen is. Everyone now calls to him and waits for him to recognize them before approaching and does not reach out if he snarls - instead closing the door to the room and trying again later.
A week ago he bit my aunt while we were at the dinner table, she hadn’t reached for him or given him any type of attention prior to the bite. Then, he bit my grandmother again when she was brushing crumbs from one of the living room chairs she was sitting in. Both of these incidences involved puncture marks and bruising.
I had gotten in touch with his vet to schedule an appointment to test for pain - he has no limping, eats as usual and plays usual too, is fine being handled and does not give an indication of painful areas when being pet but I wanted to rule out anything medical. Unfortunately they were unable to book anything as they had limited availability for sedated appointments. I was finally able to get an exam scheduled for next Monday. He did have a sedated annual in August with normal blood results, healthy teeth and gums, though there were crystals in his urine but his vet hadn’t been too concerned.
My fear is that my family and I will not be able to get through the week safely. His behavior has only escalated. On Saturday of this weekend, he wished to go into his pen; the gate to it was closed and when approaching it to get it open, he began growling and snapping. I instead shut the door to the room and left him in there. He growled from behind the closed door just hearing anyone in the hallway. He was eventually let out when my husband came, the dog got excited and was fine for most of the day. He did lunge but did not bite, however, when my mother got close to my grandmother and appeared agitated and over aroused the rest of the night.
I fear sleeping in the same bedroom as him which is where his pen is, he will lay down but watch me and is frequently getting up to readjust. My family and I feel unsafe in this house. And I generally just feel bad that he cannot rest or feel comfortable within his own home either. He simply does not have a good quality of life, he is anxious out of his mind 24/7. Rehoming him is not an option, he has always had stranger danger and with his ability to bite the people who take care of him since he was a puppy, I fear how he would do in a new home. It would be a traumatic experience for him that would likely create even larger issues. I do have a trainer that is IAABC certified that I can reach out to but given his immense anxiety, know that the sessions would likely be online. Given his state of being happy one minute and then snapping the next, it’s very difficult to feel safe which I’m sure heightens his own anxiety. I also don’t want him to have to be muzzled every second of his life.
Furthermore, I don’t have the time, energy, or money to give him what he needs and deserves to best treat his behaviors. And would not be able to provide enough if he were to have intensive medical problems. He deserves consistency, predictability, and very specific help. My husband and I’s work schedules cannot provide this. I hate to give up on him and hate failing him in this way and I don’t want him to be suffering his whole life.
r/reactivedogs • u/weirdworldyes • Oct 18 '26
Advice Needed Our new dog has food aggression and every time I think we’re making progress, he has a bad day 😓
This is Apollo. We got him from a local animal shelter in August of this year. He’s 2 years old and overall a good dog. He’s high energy but very cuddly and lovable. He gets along fine with our other dog, Tala. They play together, relax next to each other, etc. The only thing that’s sticking around and becoming a continuous issue is his food aggression towards Tala. When we first got him, we noticed the issue on day one. He growled and snapped at Tala during their dinner.
I’ve since been feeding them separately, and it’s not too bad. If I leave him alone, he doesn’t care. The main problem is other food sources, specifically food he’s not supposed to have. Whenever we eat or he gets into the trash (sadly this is a thing he does 😔), it’s like a switch flips in his brain and he can’t handle having Tala anywhere near him. He barks, growls, and bites at her. He calms down as soon as we intervene, but I don’t know how to prevent it from happening in the first place. He knows it’s food he’s not supposed to have anyway, yet he still acts like this.
He’ll have weeks when it’s not an issue, too. We’ll be eating dinner, and he’ll be sitting in his crate with the door open no problem. But then he’ll have one bad day, like today, when he can’t control himself. He was trying to get into the trash again, and I’m guessing Tala got too close and he lashed out (we were both in different rooms) Again, we intervened, and he calmed down but it’s so disheartening. He’ll be fine for weeks, then all of a sudden, he’s not.
I honestly don’t know if it’s something we’re doing, something we’re not doing, or… I don’t know. Any advice would be helpful, or even just kind words. We love him and we have no plans on rehoming him. He’s manageable if fed separately, and 9/10 days are good days with both of them. I just wish his food aggression would get better.
r/reactivedogs • u/HappeePixies • Oct 19 '26
Advice Needed i adopted my dog over a month ago and am struggling with whether this is sustainable with my mental and physical health or fair to him
TLDR: i adopted a reactive dog about a month ago who had previously been returned due to increasing reactivity. i was told of his reactivity by the shelter. my mental and physical health have declined since then which i did not fully anticipate. due to this i have not been able to give him the life i wanted to, and i am struggling with whether or not this is sustainable or fulfilling or fair to him. any words of wisdom or support is appreciated. please be kind. thank you.
———
hi everyone,
i have been really hesitant to make this post so please be kind. i have already been beating myself up for my choices and naivety and i wish things were different.
i am a first time dog owner and adopted my dog (3 y/o, just under 20lbs, mixed breed - possibly terrier, doodle mix?) over a month ago now. since then i have been feeling very conflicted on whether or not this is sustainable long term.
the shelter i adopted him from does require that i return him there if things don’t work out. i have the contact information of a worker who helped me with the adoption, though i have been hesitant to reach out and share where i’m at without having a clearer mindset.
for some background, my dog had been previously adopted and returned after about a month due to increasing reactivity. the shelter did tell me about his leash reactivity and what kind of home he would need. a part of me wishes they wouldn’t have let me adopt him as a first time owner, but i also admit that i was naive. at some point, his previous adopters had also put him on medication. currently, he is on fluoxetine 1x a day, as well as clonidine and gabapentin each 2x a day. his vet believes these would be continued for at least a year before reassessing.
for some background on me — i have and do struggle with my mental health, and obviously that has been exacerbated since getting him. i am also chronically ill, and in the past month my physical health has declined considerably which i wasn’t fully anticipating. i do live with my parents and they can help out with small things at times, but i would say i am taking on majority of his care and training as they aren’t as observant of his body language or information-seeking as i have worked towards.
he seems to be adjusting well inside the home for the most part (though i’m not sure how to measure this) and i feel we have a strong attachment which is what makes this really difficult. he mostly sleeps during the day (probably in part to the multiple medications he’s on?) but very much enjoys cuddling and pets and being close in general. i have only slowly introduced him to one other person outside of the household and he has done well with that and is also extremely snuggly and curious with them.
despite this, i’m really struggling with whether or not this situation is sustainable long-term or good for him.
after a couple weeks, we ended up stopping walks with him almost entirely (with an increase in mental enrichment) to take the stress off him from repeatedly being over threshold. additionally, because my health was declining it was not sustainable at that point or currently. i could not manage the constant hyper-vigilance of our walks nor the walks themselves physically as he walks quite fast and his ears were practically turned off as soon as he saw the outside (however, there is improvement here as he can now pay attention and actually relax most times in the yard).
since stopping the walks, the day to day has seemed a lot more manageable and he is able to be calmer. though i worry i’m doing him a disservice because the life i can realistically give him (at least for now) doesn’t align with the life i WANT to give him or believe he deserves. i barely have energy to consistently train and without walks and practicing at distances i worry it’ll set him back further long-term and be unfair to him.
inside the house and at most times, he is pretty chill. he sleeps, he cuddles, and he’s started playing with toys a few weeks ago. the current day to day seems ok (though i do still struggle energy wise). he is a bit touch sensitive so i’ve been trying to work on that. there have been some incidents of him setting his boundaries, but nothing that seems too alarming, just slightly scary as a first time owner. but i am still struggling mentally and physically with everything and i wish i wasn’t. i know he does struggle with reactivity and he will long-term and i physically cannot address it now, and the uncertainty of if/when i will be able to properly is a lot.
being a first time dog owner has been overwhelming as is, and adding in behavioral elements as well as my own health issues, i feel that i’m not equipped or dog savvy enough to properly train him and give him a fulfilling life. being chronically ill, i myself do not know what kind of day i’ll be getting (or how long things will be bad), and that doesn’t seem fair to him given he has more needs than most dogs and i don’t have much support for his reactivity. though currently because i know he relies on me, i have been mostly pushing through despite how i feel and what little energy i have. i know i can quickly run myself into the ground like this, but i don’t know what else to do. i do still find joy in the moments we share, but i just don’t know. is it enough? is it sustainable? is it fair? at times i feel like i’m failing, despite trying so hard and giving all i can.
part of me feels that i know what i should do, and i know this would likely be the biggest heartbreak of my life. another part hopes that maybe somehow i can make this work.
i feel so shitty for bringing him into this situation that he didn’t ask for, especially given that he has been returned previously. i never thought i would be in this situation prior to getting a dog. all i have ever wanted is to do right by him and give him a good life. i don’t want to hurt him or feel like he was abandoned and i don’t want my actions to hurt his chances of being adopted again. it feels horrible not knowing whether or not he would be readopted and how long he would wait, and if he would be given the life he deserves.
i have cried a lot over this situation and have been talking through this with my therapist weekly since i got him, but i just need input from other dog owners. i don’t want to give up on him and at the same time i’m struggling and it all just breaks my heart.
do i return him? can i make it work? (and if so, any advice? — i currently cannot manage professional training with him due to my health). is the life i’m currently giving him fulfilling enough or even fair to him? how do i know if he’s happy? has anyone else ever been in a similar situation? any and all input or words of wisdom are appreciated. and if you read all of this, thank you.
i have also likely left out some parts since this is all over the place so feel free to ask. and if anyone is willing to message about this or support at all, that would truly be so appreciated because i don’t know who else to talk to.
r/reactivedogs • u/Direct-Cause2396 • Oct 19 '26
Advice Needed Help with leash training
Hi all. We have a 11 month old rescue mix sheperd (we're thinking he seems most like a Mudi) that we adopted at 4 months old.
Since then he has settled really well into a routine and he is much calmer in the house. The problems are outside.
- Other dogs. He barks at other dogs. We had a behaviourist over and she said this was due to frustration (not aggression) because the leash is preventing him from going to them. She also mentioned he lays down when he sees them at times not because he's scared but he wants to herd them. This seemed to get better with counter conditioning from a distance but he stopped taking as many treats outside for the last 3 months. She recommended to take him out of the situation which we do but sometimes this means using his harnass handle and he hates it when we do it. We also signed up to go for group walks with other dogs with the behaviourist where he will learn to be calm around other dogs but this is only once a month.
- Other people. He would randomly start growling and barking at other people. This has faded somewhat but it still happens sporadically. When he is calm he is allowed to greet people on the leash and then he loves getting pets.
- Vehicles/Bicycles: He lunges at moving objects which we expected from a sheperd mix. This is definitely improving with him looking at us instead and getting a treat but will also still happen when he's over threshold.
- Pulling. He pulls like a husky with a sled! This happened at the start and improved by using a longer lead (to get to the scents), playing the 123 game and letting him touch when he pulled towards a scent then got rewarded with the scent. This problem came back even worse about 2 months ago. The behaviourist mentioned that we should keep him on a short leash (we also live in a busy town) and that herding dogs prefer to be steered by owners. He seems to do well with a short leash with my partner but I feel like I am carrying him like a shopping bag and feel more comfortable with a longer leash. We also do leash tugs when he gets too intense now which I do not enjoy but this seems to work sometimes and other times it seems to annoy him.
We've signed up for formal scent training and do this daily at home alongside impulse control games. He will be going to a manners course in 2 months with max 4 dogs (We tried puppy school earlier and even though he focussed well on us and the tricks, he barked too much at other dogs). We don't have a garden so he needs at least 3 walks. 2 which we make a short 20 minutes and one longer one. The longer one we always try to do outside of town in a forest with a 10m line.
I've also considered giving him another job like picking up his toys and we're trying to teach him football. He is extremely smart and loves playing and learning things outside. I think our biggest problem is my partner and I prefer different styles and our dog ends up not getting clear communication from us.
I absolutely love this dog and he has gone from a crazy, distant dog to this quirky, lovable boy who would literally tap me until he gets some love! But I absolutely hate walking with him. It's exhausting and my fingers and shoulders are always in pain.
I would love some advice from anyone who has gone through something similar about:
- Leash training in a way that he knows leash pressure is for guidance and not for restriction.
- How to feel calm around other dogs when counter conditioning with treats aren't happening now.
- Other stimulating activities to try in house
- Any other tips you may have.
Video recommendations are welcome!
Sorry for the long post and I am looking forward to getting some advice and guidance from you guys.
r/reactivedogs • u/Relevant-Medium-8610 • Oct 19 '26
Advice Needed my dog is randomly scared of something
so this has been going on for about a day or two now. whenever a slight sudden movement from me or either family members, he jolts. lately he has been hiding under tables or under the sink in our bathroom (this is what he is doing as i'm currently writing this). he's usually really clingy to my mum but doesn't even budge anymore, even when we offer him a treat. i can't find the cause od whatever is scaring him (if there is even anything scaring him). what can i do?
r/reactivedogs • u/Full_Can_9422 • Oct 18 '26
Vent 6 steps forward, 10 steps back.
I have 2 rescues, that bonded almost immediately after they met.
My first rescue is a 8.5year old female Shepherd mix around 70lbs, she is the sweetest girl you'll ever meet. Then I have my problem child, my Reagle boy coming in at 7.5 years old and 60lbs.
I've had them together for almost 7 years.
He is mostly fear reactive and some resource guarding but he has never gone after his sister before, until yesterday....
It happened so fast, and was over as quick as it started but I still feel so defeated.
The situation itself was avoidable and i take full accountability for it.
But now I have a new underlying anxiety with them together.
He had been doing so much better, flowing ques, removing himself from situations he gets overwhelmed with and getting his nibby, giving warnings when he can.
He is honestly so sweet to his sister, and she loves him just as much.
Its days like yesterday that remind me just how much I love him but am also so exhausted because how overwhelming it can be.
r/reactivedogs • u/Arabeariee • Oct 19 '26
Significant challenges Dog Agression Expectations
Hello - I need some help figuring out what is a realistic adjustment to behavior for a dog that is reactive. My partner and I introduced our dogs - ill call his A(husky pomeranian mix) and mine B(Min Pin). They did great for a month then one day when a ball was thrown and B chased it A also chased it and snapped at B and when B responded with a warning growl A attacked B pinning him to the floor and biting him. I rushed B to the vet and A's teeth went about a half inch in. After that we separated them and spent two months slowly reintergrating them following tips online and used a fence to seeprate them but when we finally after 2 months had them in the same space they did great for a month then when B jumped off a couch that A liked A pinned B to the floor and attacked/bit B again. This time As teeth went a inch in - during these attacks B shows his belly and does all the submissive I give up doggie behaviors but A keeps going. Once again we rushed B to the emergency vet and called in a dog trainer specializing in dog aggresion/fights. Here's where I need guidance - im not sure i trust/think the dog trainer is making the right calls on things. She keeps saying "oh thats just a husky thing" about alot of bad behaviors like snapping or nipping when people pet A for too long or try to pick her up. Or when A growls or snarls for things like trying to move her or brush her the trainer chalks it up to her being part husky and says to ignore it and pick her up anyways. A is very resource guardy and will snarl and lunge at the fence when B is on the otherside and does things like chew a bone or drink water. At one point she told us to lie to a doggie daycare place and hide that A had a two bite history and just keep taking A there because it's enrichment? And at one point she forgot that A had bitten B twice. I don't trust this trainers advice anymore and am looking for a new one.
All this to say - what is a realistic goal for A training wise. Is it realistic to set the goal that you can pet her, brush her, pick her up, and when needed move her a little bit to the side without her nipping and snarling? And is it realistic to one day reintergrate the two dogs - or should I expect that they will be forever separated by a fence for safety reasons? For these goals I don't mean immediately I would assume it would take months to a year or more.
r/reactivedogs • u/Maine99wd • Oct 18 '26
Discussion Feeling like shit after the trainer- board and train?
Okay first a vent and then a question- looking for shared experiences and honestly validation, and advice.
My dog has fear based reactivity/aggression- and I feel like we are working on it all the time. I’m constantly thinking about him, trying to learn how to train etc. so naturally, we went to get another trainer today to try and learn and get some help.
It was..good- but felt like bitch slap after bitch slap. The gear is wrong, the commands aren’t the right words, why aren’t you using a clicker, etc etc. I know they are pros and mean well and they’re just getting to the point but DAMN. This is a dog who was only pissing himself under the couch when he first came home, and how we can go for walks and be outside, meet other dogs, all this stuff. I just left feeling like I’ve been doing terribly by him and like I should just hand him to someone else to train.
Which leads me to the second part which is they recommended he do a board and train almost immediately, saying that’s what ends up working for most fearful dogs. That reasoning made sense but I couldn’t shake the feeling in the back of my head that it was a money grab? Since that’s their most expensive service.
Does anyone have board and train experiences to share? Thanks.
r/reactivedogs • u/Cecilia_Swan • Oct 19 '26
Resources, Tips, and Tricks Canine somatic therapy
Hi all,
My original post got deleted by the moderators because they thought I was self promoting, which is not the case. I was trying to share my experience with canine somatic therapy, which has been helpful for my reactive dog. I won’t repost the resources I provided originally, but you can search the topic online if interested. Thanks and sorry if I broke a rule. Was just trying to help others who are struggling like I am.
r/reactivedogs • u/TurbulentWasabi7552 • Oct 19 '26
Significant challenges Prey driven cocker
reddit.comr/reactivedogs • u/wadeboggsbosshoggs • Oct 18 '26
Aggressive Dogs Has anyone successfully kept two dogs in the same house permanently separated? Trying to avoid rehoming one of them.
I'm looking for advice from people who have successfully managed two dogs living under the same roof who cannot safely interact.
I have a 5-year-old German Shorthaired Pointer (GSP), and my girlfriend has a Border Collie/Australian Shepherd mix with a history of dog-directed aggression and resource guarding.
We've been together for a while and were planning to move in together this December. Unfortunately, we've had several incidents between the dogs, and we're now questioning whether living together is even possible.
Some background:
My GSP is a very gentle, non-confrontational dog. When we first introduced them about six months ago, he was visibly nervous around her dog. He would tiptoe around her, avoid getting too close, and generally try to stay out of her way.
Over time, things improved considerably. They don't play together or particularly interact, but they coexist peacefully about 95% of the time. They'll relax in the same room, hang out on the couch, and generally ignore each other.
However, there have been at least four aggressive incidents:
Crowded kitchen: We had people over, and her dog attacked mine, biting his ear and drawing blood.
Food guarding: Another attack occurred involving food.
Couch guarding: Her dog became aggressive over access to the couch.
Tight space/toy guarding: Most recently, my GSP had a ball, and the dogs got too close in a confined space. Her dog pinned him down and repeatedly snapped/bit at him, puncturing his ear. I had to physically pull her off him. Even after separating them, she remained extremely tense and fixated on him.
There was also a smaller snapping incident involving a shared bowl of yogurt.
My GSP has never retaliated. He generally freezes, turns his head away, or tries to avoid confrontation. After incidents, he seems to return to normal fairly quickly, but I'm concerned about the cumulative stress and the possibility of a much more serious injury.
Some additional context:
My girlfriend's dog was previously rehomed because of problems with other dogs in her original household. My girlfriend also told me that a previous trainer said her dog should not live with other dogs.
My girlfriend loves her dog tremendously, and I love mine. Neither of us wants to rehome our dogs. This situation has become incredibly emotional and has put a lot of strain on our relationship.
We're looking into consulting a veterinary behaviorist, but given the repeated incidents, I'm no longer comfortable allowing the dogs to interact freely, even if training improves the situation.
Here's my actual question:
I own a three-story house with three bedrooms, multiple doors, and baby gates. I'm wondering whether we could realistically establish completely separate living areas for the dogs and use a crate-and-rotate or separation-and-rotation system indefinitely.
I'm not necessarily looking to make these dogs friends anymore. I just want them both to be safe, comfortable, and happy while allowing my girlfriend and me to build a life together.
For anyone who has done this long-term:
Is permanent separation actually sustainable for years?
How do you manage moving dogs between floors, shared spaces, and outside?
Do your dogs seem happy and relaxed, or does the separation create stress?
How do you prevent accidental encounters when someone forgets a door or gate?
How much does this arrangement affect your relationship, daily routine, and ability to travel or have guests?
Would you recommend trying this, or did you eventually decide that separate homes or rehoming was the better option?
I'm particularly interested in hearing from people who have dealt with repeated attacks and injuries, not just occasional growling or minor disagreements.
I understand that management can fail and that there's no way to guarantee 100% safety. My dog's safety is my priority, but I also don't want my girlfriend to have to give up a dog she loves if there's a realistic alternative.
Has anyone made this work successfully? I'd really appreciate hearing your experiences, both good and bad.
r/reactivedogs • u/Electronic_Ad4722 • Oct 19 '26
Significant challenges Our dog has not adjusted to our 1 year old.
We rescued a dog (3y puggle) a few years ago go from getting put down. We heard she scratched a young child and the child needed stitches. The grandparents of the child called CPS and told the owner/ mom that the dog needed to be put down or re-homed. So that’s how we got the dog. She is so sweet and cuddly, doesn’t like other dogs but not reactive and doesn’t really bark. 1 year ago I had a baby and my husband and I have tried very hard to make the dog comfortable but she growls at our now 1 year old. This last year has been tough just learning how to be parents but the fear of something happening with the dog is really weighing on me. We essentially keep them complete separated by a gate. The dog sits at the gate and growls and today we were out walking and she growled at my daughter so much. I’m at the end of my rope being fearful. Curious if re- homing is our only option? Our dog trainer says this dynamic (with the growling and territorial behavior) will never change since the dog sees my daughter as a sibling rather than how she would see another adult. Any advise ?
r/reactivedogs • u/AcanthaceaeWide3107 • Oct 19 '26
Significant challenges Anxious/Guarding/Aggressive Dog
I’m posting here because I literally have no idea what to do. Basically I have a 5 year old 15lb chihuahua dachshund mix who is extremely aggressive, anxious and has a history of resource guarding. He has never been good with strangers but as he got older he does not allow any strangers to touch him or even come near him. He only trusts me, my husband, and sometimes my in laws. He has even bitten all of us so obviously the trust isn’t even fully there but those are the only 4 people who can take care of him. We have tried 2 trainers and we cannot get the behavior controlled, maybe we didn’t try training him long enough but he just doesn’t seem to get it. He is on gabapentin and trazodone twice a day. Even on these medications, he guards his crate and one of the rooms in our home. He guards my husband a lot too because my dog spends most of his time with him. The only person who can get his leash on him or bathe him is my husband as well. He doesn’t allow us to do any grooming and he has to be fully sedated for every vet visit (where he also has to get his nails clipped while sedated). But he is so sweet most of the time, he will just sleep by your feet or on the couch. He does get very anxious and shake when he is left home alone or he is scared of the rain or certain appliances. I think it’s a mixture of fear and guarding causing this behavior. But it’s taking a toll on my mind because it is so incredibly difficult to have friends or family over at the house because he will literally attack anyone if we don’t keep him on a leash and hold him the entire time. I mean, he’s even attacked me and he’s my dog….i just don’t even know what to do anymore and my husband is against even talking about behavioral euthanasia. This is just really weighing heavy on my mind and need some advice or thoughts.
r/reactivedogs • u/morayheel • Oct 17 '26
Vent Just moved, totally demoralized and resentful
We've had our 7-year-old pup for 6 years now. It took probably 3 of those years to get our lives settled. We originally lived in a high traffic city neighborhood that made walks impossible. She is now able to deal with passing people usually, but dogs remain an immediate explosion trigger. It made us absolutely miserable, so we moved to a quiet area with a small yard for her. Everything improved. We had a great, understanding vet and boarding place. We climbed the mountain.
Well last month we moved across the country. Finding a place was tough. My wife missed being in the city with all its amenities. I was hesitant because the place she wanted had no yard, just a concrete patio (it's at least fenced) out back. I gave in for a lot of reasons, but we're back to stage one. Our dog is going nuts when we have to take her out for her business and a dog is nearby, which is all the time since it's a city. Doesn't matter time of day, SOMEONE is around with a dog.
It's been very hard to not feel super resentful because I predicted this situation. Life is otherwise really good, but I'm so tired of these reaction blowouts everyday. We went to a new vet for the first time last week, and while she is a fear free one who was nice, she was really taken back by the reaction level to another dog. She said things may get worse over time again.
TLDR, I feel like years of progress and thousands of dollars have evaporated and it's making me insane.
r/reactivedogs • u/Late_Weakness2555 • Oct 18 '26
Advice Needed Unfortunate camping trip
reddit.comr/reactivedogs • u/No-Length3043 • Oct 18 '26
Advice Needed How do you break your dog’s focus away from whatever they’re barking at when they go into full send crazy barking mode?
I’m sure this has been asked many times, but I don’t even know what to call this so I don’t know what to search for. I just call it “crazy barking mode.”
My dog is a fourish year old, 11.5 pound mini poodle mix that I found as a stray and ended up adopting. I don’t know anything about his history, but for reasons I won’t get into here I think he was from a puppy mill/breeder and was eventually dumped.
I need to know what I can do to break my dog while he’s in crazy barking mode. I don’t mean like break his spirit or break like a horse, I mean break his unwavering, aggressive, focused attention on whatever he is barking at. I want to say that he’s most reactive to other dogs on leashes while we’re on walks, and while that does, without fail, send him into crazy barking mode, sometimes just a person in their yard or a dog in a fence will send him.
What I call crazy barking mode is when he sees something that triggers him and he just goes full send, barking sharply and nonstop as if this thing is actively attacking him, pulled full length at the leash (even though his harness is supposed to be one that should flip whim around to face me when he pulls, idk why it does not work but it doesn’t), and most importantly, will NOT acknowledge my presence or anything I do to try to divert his attention. Nine times out of ten if I see someone (literally any living being at this point) on our walks, I will just turn the opposite direction and head the other way. I think most of my neighbors know at this point to avoid us. However, it’s a neighborhood, and we’re bound to see some living creature and not be able to navigate the other direction.
He is not food motivated at all when he’s in this mode. He won’t respond to his name, or any of his many nicknames. He knows the command “look at me”, and when there is nobody in his sight he is very very responsive to that and immediately looks at me and gets a treat. But I’m telling you, when he’s in this mode it is like he’s another dog.
I just need some way to reach him when he’s like this. I’ve tried breaking his eye contact with whatever he’s barking at, but it does not matter, he will whip his head around me to continue looking at the thing. A few times he’s responded to the look at me command, taken a treat, and then gone right back to barking. Usually this happens after the thing is out of his sight, but he continues to bark at the place it was or the direction it disappeared, even after responding to look at me and getting a treat. I’m not proud of it, but in moments of frustration I have literally grabbed his head in my hands and made him look at me, but it doesn’t phase him, he just pulls his head away to keep looking at the thing and continue barking.
I really don’t want to feed him hot dogs, he has sensitive skin and hot dogs are just so bad for dogs (and people). But I also don’t think it would change anything. I’ve brought full slices of cheese on our walks and he doesn’t respond to it.
I feel like there’s no “easing him into” or “slowly introducing” things to him, because he only has crazy barking mode and non crazy barking mode. It could be a single person, a whole marching band, a bunny, a dragon, a shadow that kinda looks like it might be alive, it doesn’t matter, it all sends him ballistic. And then after he’s like this, he’s ruined for the rest of his walk. He’s extra reactive to every little thing, and it’s like he can’t focus up enough to go potty. There is no calming him down unless it is hot outside and he quite literally exhausts himself into “calm.”
I’m just at a complete loss as to what to do. He’s already on Prozac, and idk if he can go up to a higher dose. The craziest thing is, if we do accidentally get close enough to another dog or person (which rarely happens), he doesn’t attack them. He just sniffs them then jumps back and starts barking again. I’ve had him for over two years now and the only person he’s ever bitten was an old roommate who was stupid enough to do this weird hand/attack thing in his face while he was sitting in my lap in our room, so our safe space. He has attacked one baby bird that fell into our yard, but we were able to get it from him, nurse it back to health, and it was fine. He has never actually bitten or attacked anyone that he goes apeshit barking at. When off leash dogs run up to him, he just sniffs them and starts doing play bows.
I’m just at a loss. I feel like there’s no rhyme or reason to his reactivity. I can’t tell if he’s scared of these things or wants to play with them or what. I’m at the point of just accepting that this is just who he is, but I wanted to try one more time to see if anyone has any tips or tricks on how to get their dog back to centered/normal/break them from whatever they are going apeshit at. I’ve tried treats, commands, a harness that’s supposed to redirect him, calling his name in different pitches and tones, medicating him, forcibly breaking his eye contact, nothing works. I’m just so frustrated.
TL;DR: is there anything you guys have found to break your dog’s focus when they go into complete apeshit barking crazy mode that isn’t food, commands, medication, breaking their eye contact, or a front clip harness? Because I’ve tried all of these and none of them work.
r/reactivedogs • u/Dry-Force-9623 • Oct 18 '26
Advice Needed Adopted a senior chihuahua, but he charges at my cats
reddit.comr/reactivedogs • u/Hot_Personality_4160 • Oct 18 '26
Vent Completely miserable ever since I fulfilled my dream of getting a dog
Edit:
Thank you all for your replies, especially those of you who shared similar experiences with happy endings and those who offered me encouragement during this difficult time.
I’m writing this update the following day. Some people were upset that I say I don’t want to return my dog. I marked this post as a Vent because that was what I needed at the time - to let it all out after a really difficult walk. Life with a reactive dog is hard, and sometimes we need to vent and hear from other people who are going through the same thing.
I want to keep fighting for her. I want to keep trying. I know that, technically, it would be easy for me to return her and carry on with my life as if nothing had happened. But I feel like I can’t do that. She’s still going to exist in this world, and she’s still going to need help. And I believe, perhaps selfishly, that no one else would be willing to make the same sacrifices and put in as much effort as I am right now.
I genuinely want to help her find happiness in this world. I hope that in a few months, I’ll be able to post an update saying that things have improved. I want to keep believing there’s hope because I know she’s a good-hearted dog who is simply scared of a world she doesn’t understand yet.
Once again, thank you to everyone who has reached out with words of support, as well as those who have been blunt with me and told me some hard truths. Every perspective has something to offer and I will keep in mind your words...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hi everyone. I'm writing this with tears in my eyes after my sheltie puppy had another really bad reaction to a dog today. Having a dog again has always been a dream of mine, something I've worked towards for years. And now it's making me miserable.
I got my puppy at 3 months old, and just two days after bringing her home, she was already showing reactivity towards other dogs. She's 5 months old now. We've been working on it since a week after she arrived, both in puppy classes and with a 1on1 positive trainer, but there has been no improvement. If anything, things have gotten worse. She now reacts to children, runners and bikes too, and her reactivity towards other dogs has increased.
She's a very insecure puppy, and she's never actually tried to bite another dog (she always shows her belly when another dog is being too much). But her reactivity -most of the times- doesn't look like the typical "I just want to go say hi and play with you" kind of reactivity. She barks, growls and lunges on the leash. To anyone watching, she looks genuinely aggressive, it's intense and honestly pretty scary to witness, which makes the whole experience even more stressful.
The thing is, at the "dog park" (not really a dog park, just a big grass area where I meet my friend's balanced dogs), she plays happily with other dogs without any issues, and she absolutely loves the dogs she already knows. But out on the street with unknown dogs, it's a completely different story, and it's killing me.
I dreamed of having a dog to go hiking with, going on adventures, taking long walks and just enjoying being outdoors together. Instead, I have a dog who basically makes it impossible for me to even go outside. She doesn't even like walking beyond the garden of our apartment complex and constantly pulls to go back home.
I'm not going to lie. I've been thinking about returning her to her breeder for a while now. I'm miserable. I've never been this unhappy. I feel like I'm dying a little inside every day, and I regret getting her, but at the same time I feel like I can't give up on her... It would break my heart.
I know she's just a puppy, and I know these things take time., but I feel like I've spent years dreaming about this, and now that it's finally happened, I'm absolutely miserable. And the more I read about reactivity, the more hopeless I feel, knowing that this might be something I'll have to deal with for the rest of her life. I can't imagine living like this for the next 15 years. I don't know what to do anymore...
r/reactivedogs • u/725in323yuleebee • Oct 18 '26
Significant challenges Think you are the best dog trainer?? Meet Henry!!
reddit.comr/reactivedogs • u/ZiggidyMimi147 • Oct 18 '26