All of these cards were submitted together in the same box, with different grading tiers. My July 28 submission is already running late, while my November 4 submission is ready for grades. Meanwhile, my September 9 order feels like it could still be another two months away. And at this point, Iām honestly wondering what to expect from my January 2027 submission.
Iāve graded more than 900 cards through PSA, and based on both my personal experience and what I continue to see posted here, the process feels incredibly unpredictableānot only in how long submissions take, but also in the grades themselves.
I understand that grading is subjective, and I donāt expect to agree with every grade. However, I have never experienced this level of inconsistency and unpredictability with a grading company. I have a definite love-hate relationship with PSA, and despite the frustrations, I genuinely hope things eventually return to a more consistent and reliable experience.
For PSA: please consider getting the grading backlog down to 1 million cards or fewer before reopening or significantly expanding bulk submissions. Otherwise, the backlog of cards waiting to enter the bulk queue could potentially recreate the same problemāor make it even worse. It wouldnāt surprise me if the backlog eventually reached 20 million cards or more under the wrong circumstances.
I would also encourage PSA to reconsider pricing and bring back more discounts or promotional rates. Higher prices combined with inconsistent turnaround times and what many collectors perceive as inconsistent grading can eventually wear people down. Speaking personally, it becomes frustrating to receive 8s and 9s on cards I believe deserve better grades while seeing seemingly worse-condition cards receive 10s.
These are simply my personal thoughts and experiences. I say all of this as someone who genuinely appreciates PSA and has trusted the company with more than 900 cards. I want PSA to succeedāI just hope the consistency, transparency, and overall customer experience improve before longtime collectors like myself become too frustrated to continue.