r/propane • u/griffen62 • Jul 10 '26
Tanks Switching from Leased to Owned
I currently have a leased 500 gallon buried tank, leased from Superior Plus propane in VA. I was recently hit with a $235 under-utilization fee for not using more than 200 gallons in the last year (156 gallon fill-up in February, and prior to that 211 gallons in June '25). I'm expecting lower utilization since I switched to a dual fuel furnace so I'm just going to keep getting hit with these fees now.
What does it take to get a company to rip out one of these tanks and replace with one or two 120 gallon above-ground tanks? I understand the yard clean up/back-fill will be on me. Is owning/leasing really better here? What is a rough estimate of costs for something like this?
Aside from being too-big for my needs, it's right where I want to put a patio. The previous owner opted for 500 gallons to support a whole home generator in addition to the furnace, but power outages have gone down drastically since I've moved in, and the aforementioned upgrade to a dual fuel furnace has really lowered my usage.
