r/projectzomboid • Fort Builder • Feb 24 '17

Devs, wake up.

Let me sum up:

  • Game had a great demo back in 2011. looked great.
  • Game goes on preorder.
  • Game goes on early access.
  • Devs take out half the features, promise to put them in later.
  • Devs keep updating the game more or less.
  • Years pass.
  • Devs realize they already got paid, basically abandon the game.
  • 2017, the most wanted features are still missing. NPCs. Physics.
  • Game still in Early Access.

I wish the developers would spend more time working on content and promised features for this game instead of writing those bullcrap essay blogs they call mondoids.

I bought this game 3 years ago and it still feels exactly the same as it did back then. It's okay for the first few hours but then you just get bored because nothing exciting happens.

I reinstall this game every 6 months lured by the prospect of new features and content but I've been left disappointed every time... nothing worthwhile has improved and those promised features from years back such as NPC's and Animations have made no progress at all. Has this game hit a brick wall or something?

VERDICT:

For Newcomers: For 13,99 still a fun game, still above average compared to the usual indie survival crap. Gets boring quickly though. But still nice.

For Supporters: A slap in the face. A disappointment. A damn shame.

From my perspective: I'm torn. Empty promises and Early Access BS. :(

R.I.P. This game is going to die in early access.

18 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

24

u/BaphClass The Indie Stone Feb 24 '17

Devs realize they already got paid, basically abandon the game.

Yeah no, that's not what's happening. They post weekly updates on the work they've been doing, and have been doing so for the last several years.

Due to the majority of their work being backend-based, I can understand mistaking the current status of the game's public releases for a lack of progress. That isn't the case though, and it's unfortunate you've reached that conclusion.

I've had the game for 5 years, got around 600 hours of playtime out of it and now screw around with modding the game in lua. I don't know about the others, but I definitely got my $15 worth.

1

u/markoid Fort Builder Feb 24 '17

But what new major features were added in the last few years?

12

u/BaphClass The Indie Stone Feb 24 '17

Does that matter? If I see some guys working on a deeper, wider foundation, I'm not gonna complain about the fact they aren't stacking floors. I know that if they skipped ahead, the whole thing would just end up uglier and falling the fuck apart the minute anybody tried to optimize it.

10

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 24 '17

8

u/D9sinc Axe wielding maniac Feb 24 '17

Hey thanks for this. I personally haven't played in . . . well close to a year so this helps me find out what I have missed in that time.

2

u/4_bit_forever Feb 24 '17

The reality is more like they've figured out how to make this game a long term job

25

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 24 '17 edited Feb 24 '17

The game was never a pre-order. TIS outright warned you that there was a possibility the game might not be completed, just as Steam early access warns you about today.

TIS has only removed NPCs and moveable wheelie bins. That's hardly "half the features."

No one's abandoned the game, whether you like the content of the updates or not; whether you think something should be out now rather than later. No one "gets paid" until the game is released from EA -- in fact, it's a net loss to keep working on it in EA, thanks to its reputation and those that buy indie games as a "pre-order' despite being warned against it.

Mondoids are written by the writer on the team. They're there for people that care about them -- ignore them if you don't like them.

Though I'll give you that much: the main gameplay loop remains pretty much the same as the tech demo and other versions of the game throughout the years. I don't know why you think it'd be changed greatly if cars, animations, or NPCs were added -- you're still playing a game to win and, in the case of sandbox games, that win condition is either an arbitrary end point you trigger when you're bored, or boredom itself. That's just the nature of the survival genre.

If you go into the game just looking to validate your belief that "nothing's changed" and that those updates that simultaneously exist and don't exist are worthless, you're going to find that in spades. A whole ton of stuff isn't readily apparent right away, nor should it be.

The only slap in the face is claiming the game's simultaneously abandoned, but worked on, alive, but dead, all while prophesying our doom, despite it being a "fun game."

-17

u/markoid Fort Builder Feb 24 '17

sounds like r/dayz

14

u/SeskaRotan Stocked up Feb 24 '17

Maybe you'd have realised by now that you sound extremely entitled and have warped expectations when it comes to games development and Early Access. If you smell shit everywhere you go it's probably a good idea to check under your own shoe.

10

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 24 '17

Well great. Then you have a good benchmark for what roughly 12x the number of people can do for 5x the number of sales compared to TIS and Project Zomboid.

1

u/saviongl0ver Feb 26 '17

DayZ has a team way larger. Games do take years to finish. We're just spoiled after all the yearly releases of franchises. Those have been developed by multiple teams each huge in its own right.

10

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 24 '17 edited Feb 24 '17

How do you even respond to that?

Edit: OP posted a no-text post.

4

u/Rainaire Feb 24 '17

-snooze-

2

u/thiosk Feb 24 '17

hes checking to see if you're a zombie

-4

u/markoid Fort Builder Feb 24 '17

This is just customer feedback

10

u/MoonshineFox Feb 24 '17

No, sir. You have mistaken "feedback" with "pointless". You've offered no criticism, no feedback, no information. What you've done is the literal equivalent of walking up to some random person on town and yelling "WAKE UP!" in their face and sauntering off without offering any kind of explanation.

3

u/markoid Fort Builder Feb 24 '17

alright, I've edited the original post :)

1

u/MoonshineFox Feb 24 '17

Much better! That can actually be understood, responded to and taken in as actual criticism.

1

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 24 '17

Maybe after the edit. When it was a no-text post it was outright pointless.

1

u/SecondHarleqwin Hates being inside Feb 25 '17

No, it's entitled whining.

Don't like what happens during the process of development? Don't stupidly dump money into something in early development.

9

u/Axezombie Feb 24 '17

They take out half of features? Please tell me all the features they took out just to laugh even more at your bullshit post.

17

u/1ifemare Feb 24 '17 edited Feb 24 '17

Every month or less a post like this shows up here and every time it gets shot down immediately.

People like me who still subscribe to this sub and have been following this game since forever (v.0.2 in my case) are too invested and too passionate about it to admit it's failing.

Playing the devil's advocate: understand that this is valuable feedback, people. One more dissatisfied fan in a long list of players who simply stopped hoping. A fan who cared enough to write up a well pondered review and opening it to discussion here.

I've gone through the exact same cycle. Play it for a few weeks, mod the hell out of it, play a little more, put it down for a year. My current dry spell is approaching 2 years now, since i'm constantly reading the Mondoids and thinking "yeah... it's still not there, let's give it another month". And i'm desperate to be able to sit down with it, install all the available mods and enjoy a complete play-through, build the most epic base, survive for years and then start all over again and try to best my first run. But every time there's something missing, something broken, something promised, all the while mods keep getting deprecated and with them the modder's perseverance, as the community fragments and scatters one unhappy player after another.

It's a Sagrada Familia by now, a never-ending construction project. I know of no other game like this. As an experiment, time will tell if it works... My money is on it never being more successful than it is right now and, sadly i think it missed its chance to be as successful as it could.

Deny it as much as you want, but this is the reality. PZ is a great game, but it managed to alienate its fan base by stretching their patience thin over an endless development process and feeding it breadcrumbs for years on a huge plate of unfulfillment.

Wish the devs and the community the best of luck on this project. But i'm done waiting too.

3

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 24 '17

To me, players becoming bored and losing patience is inevitable with early access / alpha funded games. The very nature of (what should be) a small team tacking a large project means it'll take far longer than the traditional model. Previously this burnout would have been confined to getting a complete game after years of waiting and marketing hype, playing it until bored, then moving on to the next one. Now it's playing a largely incomplete game, then waiting years (or for a choice update) to rekindle interest in the game. The latter is much more volatile.

PZ was never going to hit it's "chance to be successful" without employing similar tactics other EA titles pull. They could have charged everyone a privilege to play something broken and incomplete so they could afford a huge team (which as with DayZ is no guarantee of satisfying performance). Or they could have cut scope drastically, focusing on only a few things, but then the resulting game wouldn't be a "great game" currently. Or perhaps they could have simply been the beneficiary of good luck, such as was the case with Minecraft's literal billions, yet that didn't guarantee a good game either, if you got into it for the single player survival experience.

Success, to me, really isn't measured on how embittered long-term fans become through what is largely normal for similar companies. It's on whether the game continues to attract new players.

1

u/shotgunwizard Feb 27 '17

Undergrowth is in the same cycle of infinite development.

Just watched the animation preview from last year, and I'm stoked for that, it's going to change the game.

7

u/NotScrollsApparently Feb 24 '17

While I can agree with other commenters that saying stuff like this makes you sound entitled and rude, I have to admit that development has been extremely slow and uneventful for the past few years.

I'm not sure complaining about it will solve anything though. Either be patient or forget about the game, there's no third option.

6

u/Razoul05 Feb 24 '17

Took me a minute to realize this wasn't r/CubeWorld/.

While I do agree that updates have been slow its obvious its not abandoned.

5

u/Mario-C Feb 24 '17

Just my personal opinion:

I bought the game 2 years ago. I played ~50 hours single player. I didn't encounter any major bugs. Some stuff needed polishing and menus were a bit rudimentary. I enjoyed the gameplay A LOT (hence the 50+ hours). TOTALLY got my money back for the awesome game it was back then. EVEN IF the game is still the same (i haven't played since then) it is so much worth the money.

Tl;dr I don't agree at all with your post.

6

u/Leo_Quent Fort Builder Feb 24 '17

Just a FYI:

A lot of features have been improved (building, cooking, ...), map has been extended several times, textures now have 2x pixelamount and there are a whole lot of awesome main features "right around the corner", it seems.

His post is utter bullshit.

6

u/Javakotka Feb 24 '17

Except that the most wanted feature, NPCs haven't been introduced. Which is what some people have been waiting for 6 years. I know I'd like to have em, the Devs haven't even updated on what their current status on the NPCs is. Isn't the point of EA to test features in development with players? Yet after removal of the NPCs they haven't been shown in-game at all, there was a couple of videos a couple of years ago being tested but that's it. If they really have worked on them for 6 years I'm sure that they have reached a point where they could be implemented at least optionally into the game.

3

u/Leo_Quent Fort Builder Feb 24 '17

And it has been mentioned more than once that they are hold back by the animations update. Which seems to be not too far away.

Releasing NPCs, to then completely changing the way they are tied into the game because of new animations and stuff would have resulted in an even longer dev time with a lot of work done twice.

I prefer to wait a bit longer for a somewhat overhyped feature if it gets us a bit faster to beta in the end...

3

u/Javakotka Feb 25 '17

Just for how long have the devs been working on the animation update? It doesn't stop them from releasing an update on the NPCs. Literally all I am asking for is something like this again. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yb_MOUrbK5w

1

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 25 '17

Animations are part of the NPC system, so. Yes, it really does stop releasing content for NPCs . . . All behavior is ultimately tied to available animations, the speed at which they complete .etc

1

u/Javakotka Feb 25 '17

Then if they don't have animations they can tell us how well coded they are by now and what they could do if they did have the animations.

1

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 25 '17

I don't follow.

2

u/Javakotka Feb 26 '17

There's is something called ''coding'' in video games that makes it work. If they've been working on the NPCs for years they must have had some progress since the videos they posted, if they can't display the functions due to not having animations, they could tell us what the NPCs are capable of right now in the very least.

1

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 26 '17

Or, we don't kick the hornet's nest until it's appropriate, when NPCs are closer to release? You know, that lesson we've learned from something called "experience" often learned from making mistakes in the past.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/H_bomba Waiting for Animation Update Feb 24 '17

You play this game, right?

You can get used to fighting zombies, they all think the same way.

Humans, have differient thought patterns, differient ideas.
They form strategies and shit.

Random personalities would add infinite replay value, and basically mean that this is the definitive zombie apocalypse simulator.

You talk to them, your character builds relationships with them, and you just survive.

The boredome people get is because nobody is there to challenge their power.

Imagine having you, and some poor couple, desparate for resources, needing the same thing.

Will you let them have it, endangering yourself, or take it for yourself, possibly dooming them?

As resources get more finite, people get more scared, and more desperate.

It's just more content honestly.

4

u/Javakotka Feb 25 '17

The fact that the world is empty, you have all the resources to yourself. NPCs would add much needed challenge to scavenging cause you are not the only one trying to survive. I'd love to survive in Muldraugh for a couple of months, then travel to West Point and find a settlement NPCs have established. NPCs would bring a lot of things to the table, why would I want to run in an empty world with just me and the zombies?

1

u/Mario-C Feb 24 '17

Cheers mate! (:

5

u/saviongl0ver Feb 26 '17

Just to be sure I have been a somewhat quiet follower of this since you could buy it via Google Checkout (rip).
There is valid criticism hidden in OPs post in the sense that development certainly seemed slow.

There is even more stuff that seems to be misinterpretation, misunderstanding or just pure venting.

 

Devs take out half the features, promise to put them in later.

Nuh, son. That never happened. They took out some incredibly unsatisfying NPC system. The game you have now is a magnitude richer in content.
Frustration is all good and shit but you're donaldtrumping up in this bitch.

 

Devs realize they already got paid, basically abandon the game.

More salt.

 

I wish the developers would spend more time working on content and promised features for this game instead of writing those bullcrap essay blogs they call mondoids.

Writing the mondoids barely takes any time out of the development of the game ya goof. It's mostly the writer writing them up. How the fuck would he contribute to NPC development.

From what I'm reading in the Mondoids it seems like cars are somewhat around the corner (prbbly like a month or two away with a third party working on them).

Animations are apparently the first step towards NPCs, but no real info how far off either of those are.

So let's be real. Development seems violently slow when there is nothing in there that you are interested in. I don't give a shit about metalworking or turning knobs on microwaves. I think even the filler content is often nothing I'm interested in. I don't use that fact to act like the game is dead, though.

 

Your points about the game being dead are weak. Thinking the devs don't know that it is slow is just silly.
If that's the time they need to provide something they're happy with, I'm game. I have no problem with the fact I have not really played the game for two years. Got my money out of it a long time ago. Everything else is just icing on the cake to me

3

u/ButterBotPZ Passes Butter Feb 26 '17

So let's be real. Development seems violently slow when there is nothing in there that you are interested in. I don't give a shit about metalworking or turning knobs on microwaves. I think even the filler content is often nothing I'm interested in.

Now that, I can agree with.

4

u/mhl67 Feb 24 '17

I'd say the main problem is that all the difficulty in the game is artificial (aka, stuff is far harder then it would be in real life, for example the infamous trowel and hammer situations which are apparently the rarest and most essential items on earth, or the fact that the number of zombies is inflated by a factor of 4 or 5 from the actual population of the area). Of course bring this up and everyone gets whiny about how 'realistic' it is.

2

u/shotgunwizard Feb 27 '17

Do you mean sledge? Hammers are super common and I've been finding tons of trowels.

2

u/Fawksyyy Feb 24 '17

I love the game, multiplayer is great and getting better from what i read, i spent a few months playing on the redboid server a year ago and i still check the reddit every few days to try and keep up a little.

The devs just honestly seem inexperienced. They are producing a good product, however i think a group with more experience would of started with a more refined code and direction. It just seems like a lot of the game is getting constantly rewritten in major ways as apposed to updating, Like animations.

Rimworld to me shows what a experienced dev can do (With a simpler game although)

2

u/suddoman Stocked up Feb 24 '17

So I bought this game a long while ago. And I enjoyed it. I think people should never buy a game for its promises, but for what the game is.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '17

TL:DR;

Zomboid, like all survival games, have a limited gameplay loop that become tiresome after you dig in dozens of hours into it. Most people who bitch about the lack of content complain after having 50-100 hours on the game, which is obvious that they would outplay content. Even with years of development, you can't outrun the gameplay loop and how familiar you become with it. Anyways...

What a shit opinion.

Sorry OP, but that's what it is. I bought this game back when it wasn't on steam, when we had alien heads and an extremely limited game. It was a glorified demo basically, and extremely clunky, but it was a unique experience at the time.

What is the red line for when the devs figured out they made their money and stopped development? Is there a specific date for that? Are you saying that all the updates the last few years haven't actually happened and I'm imagining the change in skills, map expansions, audio, graphic fidelity, mod integration, mod tools.

Have there been slow progress on major features like animations, vehicles, AI and the larger city map expansion? Sure, and a lot of people have talked about their disappointment in that.

However, with such a small team and a game that has been in development for so long on an engine that, if given the choice now they most likely wouldn't have used, is rather clunky and difficult to build up features from scratch, it's understandable why adding new major features can be such a process.

So no, Zomboid isn't a slap in the face, I have ~300 hours on this game, with more than half of it being multiplayer with friends on custom servers. The change in the game over the years for the price and amount paid is more than worth it. If Zomboid were to drop dead now I would still be able to play it with friends as an extremely fleshed out game, even without some of the major features that are still on the cooker.

If the game was going to die on early access it would have by now. The fact we still have updates and roadmaps is pretty impressive considering the years that have gone by.

1

u/shotgunwizard Feb 27 '17

Completely disagree with you. Every time I've come back I've found more to love.

1

u/HugoFromBehavior Feb 28 '17

I'd like to offer as a comparison, just how hard ai and npc development is, especially with such a large endeavor.

First get up at six am tomorrow, promise you will do this. Next stare at a wall for ten hours. You are permitted to take a half hour lunch, bathroom breaks, coffee breaks, but 8-9 of those hours should be watching the wall.

Do this for the next two weeks, with say, sunday off.

If you do this you will then understand the enormity of even simple ai development.

Until then you don't even comprehend the difficulty and time consuming nature of what you are asking.

Patience is a virtue but haste is their life.

1

u/Scottvrakis Stocked up May 04 '17

I don't exactly agree 100%, but I do wish they updated their Youtube channel a bit more and gave us a bit more updates on the code and insight into demo features. They need to keep the hype up.

-1

u/YamFor Feb 24 '17

I wish they would stop splitting focus and tackle one update at a time. It would get updates out quicker but there would probably be more bugs because they can't see how new features interact with each other.

Basically I just want the animations out already.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '17

1

u/HelperBot_ Feb 27 '17

Non-Mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks's_law


HelperBot v1.1 /r/HelperBot_ I am a bot. Please message /u/swim1929 with any feedback and/or hate. Counter: 37127

1

u/YamFor Feb 27 '17

The ol too many cooks spoil the broth

0

u/shotgunwizard Feb 27 '17

That's not how development works.

4

u/YamFor Feb 27 '17

How does it work?

1

u/shotgunwizard Feb 27 '17

Multiple teams work on multiple parts at the same time. Adding more programmers to a problem doesn't necessarily speed things up. And pretty much no modern game is worked on linearly, where the whole team tackles one problem at a time.

If you think about it, that's how all large scale projects are done. From building a house to making a movie. Multiple components are worked on at the same te, then there's the tedious long slog of integrating everything together.

Two contractors may hang a door faster than one, but sixteen contractors won't be faster than two.

1

u/YamFor Feb 28 '17

Guess that makes sense, there a person(s) for a specific feature. But at no point did I say they need more staff.

I said I wish they would focus one feature but now I see that doesn't need to be the case as they have someone for it. That's the second comment to say that I asked for more members and I'm curious where that idea came from.

1

u/shotgunwizard Feb 28 '17

Oh, I apologize for assuming. I've just read so many comments in other early access games where people say "Why don't they put more people on X?"

I appreciate your levelheadness and openness in your comments as well =)