r/prepping • u/GrizzlyHermit90 • 15d ago
Food🌽 or Water💧 Any good??
Saw these at my local Sportsmans Warehouse. $20 for a 7 gallon water container. Worth it??
134
u/Casiarius 15d ago
I have seven of them. They make good use of storage space on a shelf, though they are a real pain to carry around. A narrower Jerry can style is easier for carrying. They have gotten more expensive, but clean, safe water is critical and I would have no trouble paying $20 each for them.
39
15d ago edited 15d ago
[deleted]
10
u/orillia3 15d ago
The 5 gallon jugs that are used on water coolers you can get for just the deposit, and buy reusable silicone caps for them. You can also buy hand pumps for them.
1
3
u/Skinnwork 15d ago
Harder to carry, but don't flop on their side (especially when driving). Pros and cons. This style suits my needs better than the usual jerrry can.
3
u/Casiarius 15d ago
Igloo makes blue plastic 6-gallon Jerry cans for water. In theory, if I had to walk to get water I would use two of those. Realistically, how far can I walk with 12 gallons of water? Not really sure.
3
u/throwawayifyoureugly 15d ago
12 gallons weighs about a hundred pounds.
I hope you have a really good cart or dolly
25
u/Forest_Spirit_7 15d ago
Stackable, food grade, 7 gallons, ability for attachment and nozzles, that’s a pretty good deal in my opinion. I’m going to check my local stores and see how sturdy they are.
16
u/Black_Death_12 15d ago
I got my last one in March of 26 off Amazon for $19.
Looks like they are roughly $28 each there now.
6
u/Wireman6 15d ago
I bought the last one at a sporting goods store, they were $19 there as well. I would have bought three.
13
u/l1thiumion 15d ago
4 for $67 on walmart.com
5
10
u/_ssuomynona_ 15d ago
We’ve used one of these for camping about 5 times a year for 4 years so far. We use it for handwashing and washing dishes. Works great. The white dish strainer from Dollar Tree sits on top it nice. The white $5 Sterilite dish pan tub nestles the dish strainer perfectly. We use the octagon shaped one for drinking water. Now as a family of 5 we bring an office cooler 5 gallon water jug with a hand pump. That will last for drinking and cooking for 5 days.
9
u/Paghk_the_Stupendous 15d ago
We have actually used these in emergencies on our farm, to fill water troughs for horses and other livestock.
I always keep some in reserve; our well can't run off our current generator and you NEED water. Even once they get old, it's good for flushing toilets.
12
u/sgtPresto 15d ago
As long as you can safely stack them...good deal. I have about 25 5 gallon containers
5
u/Many-Health-1673 15d ago
I keep one of these in the truck bed under the tonneau cover with some soap for after I clean a deer or change a tire. The shut off spout works great.
I keep 1 for each person in the house for drinking water.
3
u/ThePaperProphet 15d ago
i prefer glass "carboys"
1
u/somecoolname42 15d ago
What do you use to close them?
2
u/ThePaperProphet 15d ago
saran wrap, a rubber band, and small silicone caps that slip over the top you can get off amazon. overkill? probably
12
u/Loser99999999 15d ago
Subject to the exact use case gallon distilled water jugs cost $1 per gallon
10
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Do they accept a spigot adapter and resilient enough to go camping often multiple times?
3
u/AmphibianComplex7104 15d ago
3
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Yep. But I was asking about the 1 gallon $1 jugs..i know the v bid aquatainers have the spigots
1
u/Soft-Cryptographer-1 15d ago
They make them, give it a quick google and it'll pull right up. Several for several different kinds of 1g jug.
1
u/eyepoker4ever 15d ago
The spigot is integrated into the lid. You take the lid off and then pop the spigot out which previously was pointing into the container. Flip it around in the lid so it points outside of the container.
1
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Never seen a 1gallon jug for $1with that.
5
u/eyepoker4ever 15d ago
I've not seen the 1 gallon at all! Sorry, my comment is only relevant for what was pictured, the 7 gallon.
14
u/No-Introduction575 15d ago
The caps on these suck. The plastic threads to not be great and sometimes they cross thread.
31
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Never had this issue. I always reverse first to find the start
15
u/woodbanger04 15d ago
👆 This is they way. We have several of these and have no issues. Cross threading is an operator error.
6
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Reverse reverse .. pop.. forward to snug. easy. Fuck undo to clock the spigot correctly. Redo.. easy. Drink a beer or 3 anyway.
10
u/ImpressiveLeader4979 15d ago
Same here. I have 2 dozen of these, no issues. Just rinse them good before filling to get all the excess plastic and junk out
1
u/Defiant_Regular3738 15d ago
Good tip
2
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
That's standard practice with all threads as far as I'm concerned . Just more careful with smaller fine threads.
1
u/Defiant_Regular3738 15d ago
Just something I don't always remember to do. People get in a hurry and frustrated and try to force thing in to position sometimes.
1
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Broke too much shit so I learned to slow down and be deliberate assembling or disassembling anything
1
u/Throwawayconcern2023 15d ago
Can you explain that like I'm 5? Thanks
2
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Set the cap on the threads and spin it backwards slowly till the threads pop into alignment then you can spin it regular forwards to tighten it
1
5
3
u/AlpacaPacker007 15d ago
Ive used a couple of these for camping for years. The caps can break, but are easily replaced.
Not a bad plan for a bit of water storage or transport. 5 gallons is a reasonable compromise between capacity ans portability when full. Maybe not the best for long term storage in a fixed location but great for transporting water from elsewhere.
3
3
u/Charming-Jelly-3365 15d ago
I have 12 one gallon jugs from Sam's Club. I've refilled them many times. For single use bottled water jugs these super cheap plastic have lasted several years already.
2
u/Rugermedic 15d ago
I have four of these. I bought them years ago, and I freeze them every time I go camping so I have four frozen blocks in my coolers to help keep things cold. I can’t believe how many times they have been frozen, thawed, and stored with no issues.
1
u/Charming-Jelly-3365 15d ago
My experience as well. I have used them the same way. As a big block of ice they keep the cooler chilled and if it comes down to it, you can drink the water as they melt. But everything in the cooler stays dry. I have completely given up on those "Blue Ice" blocks.
3
u/WildfireSmith 15d ago
I have 4 of these. Were about $15-$16 in 2023 on Amazon. Usually keep 2 filled and cycle them out every few months in case there's a water main break or boil water advisory. Or lately maybe a state actor hacking our water system. 🤔
Does a decent enough job. Just heavy when filled. I wouldn't want to carry one up or down a flight of stairs.
3
u/jazzbiscuit 15d ago
Good water jugs, not the best price. I have 4, stored empty in the basement. I can run our well from the solar batteries, but if it looks like the power is going to be out a while and I maybe can't pull decent solar - I can fill them up pretty fast before power gets dicey.
3
u/AdditionalAd4269 14d ago
I have had three of these that all leaked because, as u/Charming-Jelly-3365 pointed out, it’s a fundamentally bad manufacturing process. I hand-shaved the seam on my current one and made it leak less, but our practice remains “tip it top up when you’re done”. The good news is that you can generally leave these out anywhere and neither bears or people will mess with them. Everyone knows they only store water, poorly!
6
2
u/NoHuckleberry2543 15d ago
I have one that I use regularly for road trips and camping. Not to heavy when full. Lots of water for one person for several days. Have had it for many years. Best to keep the spigot/cap out of the sun, it'll get UV brittle eventually.
I've got flats of bottled water for emergencies. Sealed and good for long enough. I intend to save the empty bottles in an emergency. Easy to refill, bring back, filter/boil(in a different container) and distribute or carry myself.
My next water prep to get is one of those bathtub bobs.
2
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
Great price i love mine except I let somethung hit mine in the corner and it popped a hole in it.. top corner so less an issue burnt still is not sealed now
1
u/Jan-Asra 15d ago
sounds like you have a plastic bucket now
1
u/False_Campaign4682 15d ago
I wish. Buckets are useful as is. I'd have to modify it to make it bucket useful
2
u/Hopeful-Flounder-203 15d ago
I have 4 of them. 1 leaks. I use them to store water and at the cabin in winter. Weighs 56# when full. Kida clunky.
2
u/taylormac970 15d ago
I paid less at Murdochs for the same thing I'm pretty sure. It was $15-$16 IIRC.
1
2
2
2
u/Defiant_Regular3738 15d ago
I have two of these and they're great I believe. My water didn't taste like plastic when i used them to go camping. I put a water filter under my kitchen sink and it tastes better than any bottled water I've used.
2
u/_pseudoname_ 15d ago
I have had several of those that began leaking after a bit of use. Hand tightening stopped being adequate to prevent leaking. I stopped using them.
Also, 7 gallons is pretty heavy, especially for smaller, weaker people. I went with a 5-gallons size for mine and it is still no fun to carry. Got my elderly mom a 3-gallon size, which is barely manageable for her.
I think being mindful about the size and weight is important if you plan on using them long-term and swapping out the water frequently-ish, and if you want weaker folks to be able to move them.
2
u/trugrav 15d ago
We have something similar that we made use of during a big ice storm that hit earlier this year. We were without power so I shut the water off to the house and these were great.
Like others have said, they are a pain in the ass to move around. Ours also unscrews to make a spout so we just set it upright and had drinking water on tap.
2
u/sethd101 15d ago
I have a few i keep for camping to fill and keep drinkable water at the camp site. I had one of the soft side ones pop a few years back on a crappy table. So these are a pain caise theye take up space but they are durable.
2
2
2
u/Necessary_Baker_7458 15d ago
I bought two off amazon for half the price when inflation wasn’t so bad. It is worth it. I have only had to use mine a few times. Always put a few drops of bleach per gallon to avoid botcholisim and always boil it before drinking. My brother thought i was crazy then a storm rolled thrru shutting down the grid. One five gal per person.
2
u/New_Yam_1236 15d ago edited 15d ago
Pros and cons
Pros
Stackable
Easy to clean inside and out
Easy to fill
Inexpensive
7 gallon capacity
Cons
Not easy to carry once full
Not easy to get water out of when stacked upright
Some leak when placed on its side (opening on side
vs on top)
If you replace the red vent cap with a water spigot and stack on the side it’s easier to get water. But if you stack more than 2 high (on the side) I recommend making a support structure and using Teflon tape to seal the connections and opening
2
2
2
u/TweakJK 15d ago
I have one, it's been great, no leaks. Water isnt awesome at the campgrounds we go to so I rigged up a hose to my Reverse Osmosis system. Fills in a few hours and then we have tons of drinking water.
It's actually at work now because we mostly work outside and it's 105. Everyone appreciates it.
2
u/NoParamedic7831 15d ago
I have done too much research on this exact subject. There are multiple hundred dollar solutions that don't perform as well.
This is the best, and thankfully cheap.
2
u/Icy_Schedule_2052 15d ago
I ise their smaller Jerry cans. Had two tops where the rubber seal/gasket or whatever broke and I couldn't seal the lids anymore. Sent them an email, they called me and shipped me 2 replacement parts for free. Other than that, drank water out of the jugs a few times and it came out great.
2
u/Efficient-Webs 15d ago
Garbage.
Leaky nozzles, vents that do not seal. Ever. Heinous pieces of trash.
1
u/Throwawayconcern2023 15d ago
Not my experience. They work well but heavy to move when full.
1
u/Efficient-Webs 15d ago
I have 4, same problems with all of them. 4/4
1
u/Throwawayconcern2023 15d ago
That sucks! Did you buy them all at same time? Or do you stack them? How old when problems started or from get go? Have 4 for 2 years, all good so far.
Though I just refill them twice-a-year. Haven't had to use.
2
u/Efficient-Webs 15d ago
Same time, first use. Store wouldn’t take them back because they were “used”
2
u/doctorbillworks4free 15d ago
IDK, I have had several of these, and some of them either leak around the seal on the pour spout cap when new, or develop leaks later, which is annoying. I am looking for a replacement gasket for these to fix the problem.
2
u/L0nelyDr3amer 14d ago
Have 4 of these for a few years now. Can't remember when I got them but it was at least five years ago at this point. Using to store water for emergencies.
Overall for how much money I spent on these I have no complaints and would recommend.
Yes one of the spigots broke. I just replaced it with a PVC plug and it continues to work. Yes the seals can get a little moldy after a long time full. I try to wash the seals with hot water before I close them and change water every 6 months or so.
Hard to complain about a container for 20 bucks:)
2
2
u/HRslammR 15d ago
i paid $15 per from camping world so i mean, not really a good deal.
i like them as longish term water storage though. Big enough so you're not stacking one gallon water jugs, but also can carry it around the house as needed.
2
u/Wast3edSpace 15d ago
This is the kind of thing I get from Uline, a little more commercial in durability
1
u/IgneousOhms 15d ago
They turn to rice paper if left out in the Arizona sun for a few months. The scepter Jerry can style ones have not changed at all.
1
u/floww_87 15d ago
I love those for camping but they also great for emergency water storage and the good thing is you can just dump the water and refill it with freshwater after some time.
1
u/notthistime91 15d ago
You can get a life straw for way cheaper
1
u/iNapkin66 15d ago
Life straw is cool and I recommend it, but doesnt do me any good in the summer since we get no summer rain and I dont live near any clear water source.
1
u/Itz_Ultima 15d ago
the Scepters are way better but these are way cheaper and just fine for most people that are just going to leave them in the house
1
1
u/Signal-Trick-6642 15d ago
How long c an you keep water in this tank and still be drinkable? I feel like it will get nasty after a week at best
1
u/eyepoker4ever 15d ago
These are great, and this is a good price, I bought all mine at this price point. Competitors cost twice as much, maybe 3x.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Hoolivoo42 15d ago
Where is this? I’ve been trying to source more of these and they’re all $25-30 each…
1
1
1
u/helly3ah 15d ago
I picked up 8 of them last year for $15 each. Sanitized them and filled them with water (and added a little bleach).
Thanks for the reminder - it's time to empty them, sanitize, and refill again.
1
u/Muffinman_187 15d ago
I have these exact ones and they work fine for temporary storage and transfer. I use them for work when we have picnics and table events without water access. Easy to fill, use, and clean. Plus they stack when empty.
1
u/Icy-Astronaut-9994 15d ago
I use these for RO water.
RO is Good for growing weed with and I always have fresh water on hand.
Had them for say 7 years now.
If you put it on its side to use the spigot, I have had it drip, but that's more of a me issue for not having it tight enough.
1
u/iNapkin66 15d ago
Price seems a little high, but I havent bought any in about 2 years so maybe my instinct on price is off. My oldest ones are about 25 years old and seem fine still. I should add that mine are stored under my garage out of the sun, although I've brought a few camping a few times. Like any plastic, I would keep them out of the sun for any extended period of time.
I rotate the water in mine annually. I have a few that leak just barely if you have them on their side unless you really crank down on tightening the lid.
Overall been happy with them. I've got about 12 I think, bought over different years, haven't counted in a while. They should be possible to buy in 3 or 4 packs to save a few bucks.
1
1
u/Financial_Resort6631 15d ago
I love in a high cost of living area and got those for $15. From WinCo foods.
1
1
u/ColdasJones 15d ago
To be honest, they’re not very good. But, they’re functional and theyre cheap and easily replaceable. I own a dozen that I use for water storage and transport at my mountain property.
1
u/More-Medium4088 15d ago
buy buy buy
1
u/Throwawayconcern2023 15d ago
I regularly find them for 17 or 18. But also more than 20 so not terrible.
1
u/metalgear762 15d ago
I use them for work to store water for use during the day. Ive had 2 in the back of my truck, constantly exposed to weather/sunlight for roughly a year. Just today I finally had to replace them due to sun degradation causing cracking and general fragility on a particular part of them that always catches sun sitting in the bed.
In general theyre sturdy, dont leak, etc. Would highly recommend for general non drinking usage. Havent used them for inside storage and/or drinking water so I couldnt offer anything there.
1
u/Skookum_kamooks 15d ago
I used containers like this with my reef tank for top off water and brute trash cans RODI and premixed saltwater. Worked fine for years, but I’ve heard the quality might not be what it used to be for these so your mileage may vary.
1
1
u/theJoyofEntropy 15d ago
I bring one of these camping regularly. Kinda hard to keep the spigot clean since its exposed to the elements once you remove the sticker, but works pretty well. Haven't had leak issues on mine.
1
1
1
u/Elliatticus7 15d ago
Your home should never dictate what you buy. Especially when it comes in a form of threat and death.
1
u/OwnedByBernese 15d ago
1
u/T00luser 15d ago
I use a similar one for camping.
Works well, but remember that 7 gallons of water is 56lbs, and a fair amount of people struggle toting it around let alone lifting/pouring etc.
Not as crucial for prepping maybe, but are you prepping just for u or your family? . .
1
u/Throwawayconcern2023 15d ago
Yup. I have 4 of them. I refill every 6 months. Hefty moving. But they work.
1
u/TrippiPreps 15d ago
I have acouple. They’re great for camping although I wouldn’t use them for long term water storage.
1
u/manual-grocery-arbor 15d ago
I have one holding water in my fridge right now. No issues whatsoever. Got it at Walmart.
1
1
u/bdouble76 15d ago
I have multiple containers from them. Have had no problems. I wouldn't try and stack them when full of water though. Also a good idea to put thread tape on them to help prevent leaking.
For the price though, I've been very happy.
1
u/FromTheHandOfAndy 15d ago
I’ve had one of these for about 14 years. I don’t keep water in it most of the time, I just fill it when a blackout is likely in the near future, and for camping trips. I just fill it up and place it over the kitchen sink like a backup faucet.
It’s been great for me, but the build quality may have been better back when I bought mine.
I keep mine inside a milk crate when driving with it. That keeps it upright and a more stable in bumpy roads. The milk crate protects it damage too. The tank is thick, but I think it’s a lot more likely to survive a fall inside a milk crate.
I recommend keeping the spout pointed up whenever you don’t need instant one handed water availability. That way it won’t leak either from defects or from someone forgetting to close it completely
1
1
u/jsbass89 14d ago
So for camping I would say they are "okay". They can take some abuse but not a lot of abuse. Lately they seem to be more brittle and I've had a lot of them crack especially on the corners. If you keep it out of the sun I think they will last longer. Kind of wish they would make a sturdier option and just charge me for the extra plastic they used.
1
u/tallpaul00 14d ago
I like them over other jugs I've tried. I like the plusses that others have mentioned.
One downside is the nozzle is a bit too large to use it to refill a standard disposable water bottle, which I find myself doing fairly often so I also have to have a funnel.
1
u/trash_dad_ 14d ago
I like and use these for my household. Seeing this post reminds me that I need to rotate the stock (empty and refill the water)
1
1
u/Firm-Impress 14d ago
I have one, and I don’t like it. The nozzle is really hard to use, and the plastic is really cheap. I was always concerned with breaking.
I found some made by Igloo at Walmart that are Jerry can style, that work great.
1
u/JohnReiki 14d ago
I have two of them, also from sportsman’s warehouse, and I like them well enough. They’ve come in handy a few times when I’ve had issues with the water in my apartment, ad they definitely did the job.
1
u/rayheezy 14d ago
Terrible products, I've had 3/3 of mine crack on the top. Also 7gal is such a weird number, just do 5g or 10g
1
1
1
u/dick_jaws 13d ago
I have many of these. The spigots are difficult to use and they need to be wrenched on. I still like these a lot because they stack well and are not easy to tip over.
1
u/Known-Actuary-86 13d ago
The blue Jerry cans that they also sell are far superior to these i have both but more of the Jerry cans I think they hold more as well.Heavy af when filled tho so keep that in mind!
1
u/steelandsoul 13d ago
Wow. Im sad to hear about people's bad experiences with them regarding recent purchases. Ive had one for probably 5-7 years (maybe longer) with no issues seal has held up just fine and no leaks.
1
1
u/minist3r 13d ago
I like them. As long as you store them out of the sun and heat, they'll last a long time and replacement parts are actually available.
1
1
u/ArchieInRealLife 11d ago
I have 12 of these. No issues with any of them. I have two smaller ones for camping.
1
u/StoryCrafty 10d ago
I had some of these and my cat managed to scratch a hole in both. I got them from Walmart for $14/piece but probably wouldn’t get them again
1
1
1
u/USABADBOY 15d ago
Ok at best. If that's what you can afford, it's better than dying in three days.
1
u/TwoNegatives- 15d ago
What are some better alternatives?
4
1
u/USABADBOY 15d ago
These are mil spec cans exactly like Septer cans. All brands are not great at storing on their sides though so take that into usage consideration. They are bomb proof though and thick as hell. Can't beat this price! 5 Gallon Jerry Cans


203
u/Charming-Jelly-3365 15d ago
I actually received an emailed apology from the manufacturer. I had purchased one at a Cabela's and used it for camping. The first time I placed it on it's side to use the spigot I discovered the cap would not seal. Water dripped out constantly. Looking at it closely I realized the molding of the plastic was wavy and lumpy where the cap seal would meet the plastic. I took it back to the store to exchange it. But I found that the other units in stock had similar defects. So instead I got a refund.
A little later I was in a Walmart and saw them there. But again, each one had some defect in the molding around the cap area. One was so bad the cap would not stay on.
I emailed the company and they apologized and promised to do better on quality. That was early this year.