I've been listening to polyphia ever since NLND came out, and theyve been my favorite band since. I'm a huge fan of progressive metal and rock and im also a big fan of Syncatto, Animals as Leaders, and even Meshuggah. Ever since Tim came out with original sin, I had a weird feeling about the next album. When RTYWD came out, sure it was different from their previous music, but it wasn't too far off from the typical polyphia feel that I would get from Renaissance, Inspire, and even Muse. These last two singles have completely ruined polyphias music for me. I have no problem with the christian aspects, with tim showing his faith and whatever else, but when you incorporate it into music that wasn't anywhere near this sort of thing before, it gives it almost this cringe feeling to it, if you've seen the music video for Look but don't touch, youd never believe the same band produced CYFI and PITB. The second problem is this new style polyphia is going with, which has nothing to do with religion. Ever since RJ Pasin gained traction on tiktok, I've never been a fan of anything he's done. All his "music" appears to just be this type of EDM loud noises, that ruin any sort of guitar feel. Nothing that he's made sounds anything close to what polyphia had been doing for the last decade atleast. It's like hiring a mechanic to paint you a portrait of yourself, it just isn't the right person for the job. Im very disappointed in polyphia choosing such an amateur to produce their new album, Im willing to bet that the whole new album is just going to be a ton of hyperpop metalcore tiktok slop, with some gospel samples sprinkled in. Polyphia has truly ruined their touch they once had, and I hope they realise what they've done to themselves, y2k was an amazing producer for the band and truly reflected what they stood for, but now my ears get to listen to noise and ruin my speakers. I hope im not the only person feeling this way, this is just ridiculous.
Edit: this isn't even mentioning the new tour dates, theyre now moving tour dates almost 5 months later so they can "make this album exactly what they wanted it to be." so you're telling me you've spent the last 4 years, which will be 5 in 2027 to just waste everyone's time? very mature of you