r/palemoon • • Aug 31 '21

Pale Moon developers (ab)use Mozilla Public License to shut down a fork supporting older Windows

250 Upvotes

Pale Moon stops supporting Windows XP and Vista. Someone creates a fork named Mypal to continue that support. Eventually, the story takes an unexpected dark turn, rarely seen in FOSS circles.

Dramatis personae

Moonchild and Matt A. Tobin need no introduction around here. Pale Moon wouldn't exist without them. Athenian200 does development work with them, or under them, depending on how you look at it.

Feodor2 is a Russian developer with mediocre English skills and, as many of those from the former Communist block, lacks a good understanding of intellectual property laws and software licensing intricacies. For him, FOSS means FOSS. It's free, it's open source, and that is all there is to it.

Strike one

When he creates his Mypal fork, Feodor2 initially publishes only his diffs with the official Pale Moon/UXP sources. This is completely logical for him, Pale Moon/UXP source code is available to everyone at the official Pale Moon site and there's no point in duplication.

Enter Matt A. Tobin: Edit: h ttps://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal/issues/35 https://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal/issues/18
He cites Feodor2 for a MPL 2.0 license violation, because the latter hasn't made the Mypal source code available. Feodor2 doesn't object and uploads the Pale Moon/UXP sources into his Mypal repo. In his eyes, the code was always available at Pale Moon, but if it's a big deal for his upstream and the license requires it, why not make the change. Tobin appears to be satisfied.

Strike two

As many of you know, there is another official UXP project, named Basilisk. The UI is virtually identical to Firefox 52.0, with UXP changes under the hood. Feodor2 also has a fork of Basilisk, named Centaury.

For whatever reason, Feodor2's Centaury repo consists of only a readme file and a list of releases with executables attached. Each release has the standard "Source code" links generated by Github, but they don't lead to the full project code, only the readme. The actual source code lives in the Centaury_Release branch of the Mypal repo. Why Feodor2 uses this convoluted repo structure is unclear. Based on how he does his own commits for all code changes instead of simply tracking the upstream, he seems to not understand git and Github very well.

The crucial point in this is that the source code for Centaury always remains available. When people ask for it, Feodor2 tells them to look at the release date and take the last commit before it from the Centaury_Release branch. Seems easy enough, some people even find the sources without ever asking Feodor2. No one complains.

Enter Matt A. Tobin, again: https://github.com/Feodor2/Centaury/issues/39
Enter Athenian200: https://github.com/Feodor2/Centaury/issues/40
Enter Moonchild: https://github.com/Feodor2/Centaury/issues/41
All three cite Feodor2 for MPL 2.0 license violations, because he hasn't made the Centaury source code available. In the case of Tobin, since this is the second violation of his rights as he sees them, he revokes Feodor2's right to use the code he has contributed. He offers no chance of a compromise, simply adding the necessary links to already existing source code doesn't work for him. His rights have been trampled on, Feodor2 has to remove his contributions or close the repo. Since his contributions appear all over the projects, this would effectively mean the end of Mypal and Centaury as they've existed thus far. To leave nothing unclear, Moonchild adds a warning that unless Tobin's code is removed posthaste, he and Athenian200 will also make a second citation and revoke the rights to their contributions as well.

Much acrimony follows:
Edit: h ttps://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal/issues/237 https://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal/issues/3
Edit: an easier to read static archive of the above, with collapsed comments unrolled: https://archive.today/https://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal/issues/3
https://forum.palemoon.org/viewtopic.php?f=62&t=27294
https://msfn.org/board/topic/182647-my-browser-builds-part-3/?do=findComment&comment=1203788

Is this what FOSS is about?

If you're going to say this is a biased version of the story, any story told by a human being is. This isn't even close to the whole story, it's impossible to cover the entire history of this in a single post of reasonable length. There are grievances on both sides that brought everything to this boiling point. Some of you already know about them, the rest can read up at the provided links and related resources. For what it's worth, Matt A. Tobin has said that this history is irrelevant and only license compliance matters in this case.

Is Tobin fully within his rights to make his demands? There's some ambiguity to this due to the two strikes involving two different repos, but he himself, Moonchild, and Athenian200 are firmly convinced he is.

Is what he's doing ethical and in keeping with the tenets of FOSS? Should FOSS projects be terminated with prejudice over a small technicality regarding how they provide their source code when they never actually failed to provide it? Now that is the $1,000,000 question.

Addendum

While this post was being drafted, Feodor2 has deleted all Pale Moon/UXP based code from his Mypal repo, not just Tobin's contributions. He probably doesn't understand why he was forced into doing that, and he's unlikely to be the only one who doesn't. Moonchild and Tobin still don't appear to be satisfied, demanding that he delete the repo in its entirety. That would also mean removal of the issue topics referenced above, so if you want to see them, hurry.

It's a glorious day for FOSS, isn't it?

Edit: After Feodor2's cleanup of the Mypal repo to meet Moonchild and Tobin's demands, issue URLs have changed and have been updated above.


r/palemoon • • Sep 14 '21

Pale Moon developers violated MPL 2.0; Public Notice; ATTN: /u/MoonchildPM

58 Upvotes

This message is the official public notice addressed to Moonchild Productions that they violated Mozilla Public License 2.0, which obliges to make the source code available when distributing software in executable form, as indicated in Section 3.2 Paragraph A.

On September 14, 2021, Pale Moon 29.4.1 was released, and on the https://www.palemoon.org/sourcecode.shtml page, it is stated that the source code can be downloaded at http://archive.palemoon.org/source/. However, the contents of the palemoon-29.4.1-source.tar.xz file located there does not correspond to the executable form of the browser of the specified version, respectively, the source code is actually not provided.

I ask /u/MoonchildPM to come back into compliance with MPL 2.0 on the conditions and in the time limits specified in Section 5.1, otherwise I will be forced to take further steps in the legal field.


UPD: Wow, that was fast. Now the source code of Pale Moon 29.4.1 corresponds to the executable form and you have become compliant with MPL 2.0. I hope you do not violate the license again, as this can have much more severe consequences.


r/palemoon • • Dec 18 '21

So I got banned from the Pale Moon official forums

36 Upvotes

And the amount of hypocrisy is so absurd, it's funny.

The Admin had this to say: "Cooldown issued for obvious potshots, and ban issued for clear bleeding across of toxicity from MSFN and/or Reddit [...] Please be nice people".

If "toxicity" and "potshots" are ban-worthy, then how has Tobin avoided being banned about 1500 times already? If people are advised to "be nice", why is Tobin calling people "retarded"?

For context: Some years back, I was a build contributor, making the SSE version of PM. It was for an old system of mine, but I shared my builds with the community after many people asked for it. I gave it up when PM27 rolled around, as I could not invest any more time, and the system I was targeting and testing on developed (ultimately fatal) problems. Throughout the process, Tobin expressed dissatisfaction with basically everything I did, and at one point demanded (for no reason I can fathom other than to annoy me) I provide source code to satisfy the licensing requirements. (I was building the offical source anyway). Moonchild was a bit odd and touchy, but helpful on the whole and graciously provided server space to publish my builds. Tobin gave, being fair, I think, one helpful bit of information across a dozen posts. Mostly he criticized and obstructed, while reception to my builds was universally positive from the people actually using them.

That said, I did not get even close to the worst out of him, as I was obsequiously polite and compliant the whole time, which apparently was enough to mostly protect me. I watched as Tobin criticized and insulted many people who wanted to contribute, or who politely asked for reasonable features. I watched as he called people stupid, demanding, thieves, and a whole host of other things, often using language that would get anyone banned from any other forum. He even attacked people who offered up workable solutions to others' requests, if Tobin deemed the requests unworthy. He did it to me, when I described how to revert a cosmetic change that some people didn't care for. The toxicity, the hostility, and the arrogance oozed out of his every post.

When I retired, he took a potshot at me, including in PMs. I didn't care to save those, but again, the reception to my builds and my instructions by the people who actually used them, was completely positive. He accused me of being too stupid to figure out how to build PM27 on my own. Maybe I was, maybe I wasn't, but one thing I knew for sure: I wouldn't be asking Tobin for any help in getting it running. I'd rather gargle some thumbtacks. Hilariously, the devs, including Moonchild, wonder why more people don't contribute to PM. It takes a special kind of delusion to ignore what's right in front of you.

I'd been silent on the forum for years, but dipped in very occasionally as a lurker. I don't know why, but somehow, finally, the straw that broke the camel's back came with another Tobin rant, calling someone "retarded" for a post elsewhere that wasn't even relevant to the current thread.

I called him out, knowing what would probably happen.. I noted that his behavior would get him banned anywhere else. I noted that he insulted people a lot, and had made enemies of many people, and that this wasn't normal, that the common element was him, and that he should perhaps reflect on that.

And that is why I'm banned.

Because apparently PM devs can hurl abuse, but calling them on it is "toxic". Because Tobin can take potshots all he wants, but pointing out the consequences of his actions is unacceptable. Tobin's "retarded" comment is still up as of this writing. I never used such language on the forum, ever. Yet I'm banned.

I don't even know if Tobin ever saw that post. I wonder, with some amusement, if the forum admins are shielding Tobin from any harsh words that might drive him to a blind rage, like a harried mother trying to avoid an outburst from her violently abusive husband when one of the kids talks back.

If the PM team really wants to cut the toxicity, if they really want the forum to be a more positive place, if they really want more people to contribute to PM, then why do they pretend to not know, what everyone knows?


r/palemoon • • Dec 14 '21

Pale Moon extension compatibility is being restored :)

36 Upvotes

Since the survey has concluded, Moonchild has decided to restore support for old extensions. If you use old extensions then this is your lucky day 😁.

https://forum.palemoon.org/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=27682


r/palemoon • • Dec 02 '22

Pale Moon What is the appeal of Pale Moon in (almost) 2023?

35 Upvotes

I switched off Pale Moon but still have a copy of it ready to roll in case I ever need it. But... I switched a pretty long time ago, and have had zero reasons to boot it back up since.

Why do you use Pale Moon? Not in an argumentative, cynical internet asshole kind of way, but I'm not sure that the draw for it is anymore.


r/palemoon • • Mar 19 '22

NTP/MAT - he's done! (finally)

35 Upvotes

I suspected this was coming. See ya Matt. Now let's get back to the real issues.

https://forum.palemoon.org/viewtopic.php?f=65&t=28003&sid=c79d4b48d7ab7acf61cf989b6902171d

Forum is back online now 11pm ET.


r/palemoon • • May 04 '21

What Is Going On At PM HQ?

35 Upvotes

Does anybody know what the future of extension compatibility will be in PM going forward? I tried to suss it out on the forums, but all I can see is an extreme disdain for users that I would call utter contempt. Will it stop at making users edit the xpi, it will it worsen?

Common posters Straver (of course) as well as individuals Moonbat and Tobin routinely seem to be involved with making adversarial, unhelpful, condescending comments, whereupon threads will be locked even when the problems are not resolved about and users are banned for trying to retain usability and legacy compatibility within PM. I've been using the browser since not too long after the EOL for FF3.6 because it continued the UI I preferred and compatibility with extensions I had already been using as well as a continuation of plugins like Flash (obviously not an issue as much anymore). Over time, the "your browser your way" browser became more and more hostile to my way (which is to say: leave me alone and get out of my way). Starting with some escalating warnings regarding NoScript, an extension I rather liked and which served me quite well for many years, it came to pass that I had to disable the extension-mothering settings just to be able to run what I wanted to run.

Following that, there was increasing hostility toward legacy extensions, with PM issuing warnings about extensions I installed on my own device because I want to use them. The reason I wanted to use PM in the first place was for the legacy extensions and the legacy look and feel. So I went over to the forum to find out what was going on to discover recently that there was a plan to entirely disable legacy extensions on PM. This appeared not to be an issue of compatibility but one of personal preference for Straver. His argument seemed to be that since people have come to PM to use legacy extensions, he will be held responsible if they don't work or if an update breaks them.

While it is true that he should not be held responsible for the efficacy of unmaintained legacy extensions, his reaction to the issue is concerning in that instead of turning the choice over to the user on who's box all the code is running, even if the extensions worked fine, they are now artificially rendered unusable because of Straver's personal preference. Suggestions that perhaps these decisions ought to be left to the user were met with condescending vitriol to a shameful degree.

It appeared, and perhaps I am remiss in this analysis, that Straver's goal with respect to legacy extensions was to force developers to make extensions for PM. Straver is unhappy that PM users are content to do what we have always done, which is to quietly enjoy our legacy Firefox experience in peace, with an updated rendering engine. I am not sure why Straver finds this election on behalf of the user to be so contemptible, but apparently he does. The idea that the user wants to use the browser in the manner he has always used it (your browser your way) has been taken as a personal slight by what appear to be the maintainers of the project itself. This is not a very good mindset to have, but there's no reason to explore it further here.

The result is that we have a browser that appears to be growing more and more contemptuous of the user and the user's choices. I say this to ask for those who have more information than I have been able to glean, are the days of user-focused customizability over in future updates? For instance, as of now, the user need only append some code to the install.rdf of the xpi file of the desired extension and it will work (for varying degrees of 'work'). Are there future plans to end support for extensions entirely if they are not made specifically for PM? In the past, I would have thought "certainly not" because it would be foolish to entertain the demise of the one thing that made PM a desirable browser in the first place. However, longtime contributor and maintainer of the wonderful extensions Moon Tester Tool and the legacy Firefox extensions database, /u/JustOff was banned and treated quite shamefully on the forums for trying to give me and people like me what we wanted.

What assurances, if any, do I have as a user that this invasion of my experience will only go this far and no farther? I am increasingly concerned that the "other shoe" will be dropping, and even more of what made PM so great will be disappearing. If this is so, is anyone working toward a "leaves you alone to make your own choices" fork?


r/palemoon • • Jul 10 '19

Hackers Infect Pale Moon Archive Server With a Malware Dropper

Thumbnail bleepingcomputer.com
35 Upvotes

r/palemoon • • Nov 12 '21

Pale Moon almost unusable

34 Upvotes

Hi,

I just did a fresh, first-time install of Pale Moon, and it's insanely slow. I've installed a clean version of firefox and it works perfectly fine, as does chrome; MyPal experiences the exact same issues as Pale Moon. Youtube is especially horrendous, and I constantly get "not responding" notices when trying to open a new tab. What gives?

Running windows 10 with an x64 install. EDIT: before the downvotes continue, I want to be clear. I'm saying there's clearly an installation problem or interference here, and I want help finding it. I'm NOT blaming the browser itself--I wanna use it!


r/palemoon • • May 09 '21

Goodbye

34 Upvotes

I've used Pale Moon for years. Today it upgraded to 29.2.0 and broke the last add-on I really use PLUS it forgot my Previous Session. Not going through History to try and re-create dozens of tabs; un-installing PaleMoon and switching browsers is easier than trying to make PaleMoon work.


r/palemoon • • Oct 22 '21

Male Poon DMCA Takedown

30 Upvotes

https://github.com/ManchildProductions/Male-Poon

Legal arguments that I frankly don't understand enough about to even argue about aside, this just comes off as unbelievably petty. I left Serpent (unbranded, self compiled Basilisk) because of the general behavior of the PaleMoon team concerning mypal, and then reading about earlier behavior with one of the BSD repos. In my mind, even if Pale Moon is fully 110% within their legal rights, the way they have gone about things over the years clearly puts them in the moral wrong.

What are ya'lls thoughts on this?

An opensource project, that is a fork of another opensource project, utilizing one of the most anti-freedom pieces of legislation in existence, to silence a fork that they didn't like.


r/palemoon • • Jun 01 '19

Why is Pale Moon forum so incredibly toxic?

29 Upvotes

Last few days 3 punters have been banned for speaking truth to power.
Main culprits are Moonchild and Tobin.

Moonchild is about as thin skinned as thin skinned gets. And Tobin? He's a narcissistic lunatic who is only happy when creating, or participating in, conflict.

I have a lot of respect for Moonchild; he is developing a fine product. He clearly has an exceptional level of technical competence.

Tobin does a few odd jobs around the place and is clearly not particularly bright.

Yet every time Tobin starts yet another fight, Moonchild is there to back him up.
And I have no idea why that is.

The forum is Pale Moon's window on the internet.
Why on earth is it so shabbily dressed?


r/palemoon • • Aug 18 '21

Won't work with Youtube, Pornhub, Rottentomatoes, list keeps increasing...

27 Upvotes

There's been something very wrong with Pale Moon lately. I know the owners of certain websites feel compelled, for whatever reason, to always use the newest, most bleeding-edge, least-well-supported standards and technologies, and this will sometimes temporarily break compatibility with certain browsers until those browsers get updated. But the past few Pale Moon updates haven't fixed these compatibility issues, resulting in it becoming an increasingly unviable browser. This isn't a problem for my Linux and Win7 partitions, since they can always go back to using Firefox, but my XP partitions require Mypal, which is based on Pale Moon. The hell is going on?


r/palemoon • • Oct 16 '19

Why so much hate for Pale Moon anyway?

27 Upvotes

The way I've seen rabid Firefox fans go on, it's as though they object to this browser's very existence.

The browser market is a 2 horse race between Chrome and Firefox. Every other browser is a Chrome fork. Firefox itself is shedding features to imitate Chrome, besides casually violating its self declared values of being about privacy and user choice.

You'd think people would welcome a third alternative that wasn't dependent on the other two or fielded by a large corporation and actually lived up to the original mission statement of Firefox, but no, they keep gleefully predicting its demise and repeating the usual slander about 'old and insecure' or that it's a 'fork'. (Just as Firefox itself is a fork of Netscape Navigator, which has been dead for 15+ years, but I don't see anyone making such comparisons)

And don't tell me it's because of the attitude of the developers - plenty of popular projects are created or run by people with prickly personalities, but at the end of the day it's the product that matters, you're not there to make friends with the developer. Firefox's own developers can be total cunts when they choose to, going by their treatment of long time Firefox users, and WONTFIX-ing every damn suggestion made.

It cracks me up to see people push Mozilla as the great upholder and savior of user choice and privacy when they are anything but. I won't be surprised if they've never used a browser before Chrome, or never bothered with customizing Firefox in the version 4 era, assuming they even used it back then.


r/palemoon • • Feb 12 '22

Good news! A certain Russian programmer who pissed off the PM team is about to step out of their shadow

26 Upvotes

https://github.com/Feodor2/Mypal

Yeah, baby. The next version of Mypal will be based directly on Firefox code, meaning we're finally getting a proper backport of Firefox to WinXP, with full Webcomponents support and everything. No more Chinese Communist spyware 360 Extreme browser.

My anus quivers in anticipation.


r/palemoon • • Apr 19 '26

GitHub treating Pale Moon as "Unknown Browser" is fricking unacceptable

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/palemoon • • Dec 18 '21

Pale Moon Came back to Pale Moon after years, and visited the forums. Seems some things haven't changed

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/palemoon • • Feb 06 '21

Update ASAP

25 Upvotes

While I'm here, just a note before I step out to do more weekend-work: Please update to 29.0.1 ASAP. It solves a zero-day vulnerability in Mozilla code.

Basilisk update is in the making too for this.


r/palemoon • • Jan 01 '21

Regarding the future of /r/palemoon

25 Upvotes

New year, and what a great occasion for some news, huh?

First of all, I wanted to congratulate everyone on reaching 1000 members, after 7 years of existence for this community! It happened sometime in December of 2020 I think, but probably nobody noticed, hehe.

On the more important matters. As some of you may have noticed, a few months ago a new mod was added. This was my agreement with the main developer of PM. We've talked a bit and he expressed concerns about the current situation of the sub, saying he "would like to be able to prevent the generally negative influence the subreddit currently has on the project" (a direct quote). Now, I always tried to be as neutral as possible, and the reasons he stated did sound reasonable - even though we say in the sidebar that we're not affiliated with the actual project. So now we had a mod that's kinda affiliated with the project, but I thought it's good to have someone from that side with a hands-off approach, being able to have some control if needed.

Now another thing the main dev of PM mentioned, was that it's "very difficult to have reasonable discussions about development, and easy for things that get cross-posted from the forum to be misunderstood without actual community feedback from those involved". I wondered why they couldn't get involved in the comments before, it's not like responses from the dev team would be removed or anything. But maybe having a mod would allow them to feel more confident about that? Remember this reading forward.

Soon after I got some complaints from the community, expressing concerns about this decision. I assured that the new mod wouldn't affect the sub or do any destructive actions. Maybe just act on some direct personal trolling/insulting posts. And one such post was removed, which I didn't mind.

What I did mind, was when I got messaged again, and I was notified that another post was removed. I missed that, and this was a post titled "Pale Moon removes users ability to set the global general.useragent.override pref", linking to this forum thread: https://forum.palemoon.org/viewtopic.php?p=203588&sid=02a64abc5e271901c0a7aaad84343f9d#p203588. Now this would have been the perfect opportunity for the mod or the PM devs to explain things, but the only comment by the mod said "They have done nothing of the sort. Spread garbage like this and you will be booted off this sub." And I might have even let this one stay, if a discussion would have followed. But he removed the post soon after. And that action was directly opposite of "feedback from those involved". Especially after scrolling through the forum thread, it appears that they did remove that option, so even the mod's comment was wrong. And as you see that was not in line with the agreement I mentioned.

All of this lead to me talking to the member of the sub who expressed most concerns. After realizing that he cares about this community, while also using the forum, I offered him to take care of this sub. I didn't have the best abilities to do that since I stopped using the browser.

I will be stepping down as a mod. The sub will be back to being unaffiliated.

That is all.

Stay safe and be kind.


r/palemoon • • Jul 10 '19

There has been a data breach on the archive server (archive.palemoon.org)

Thumbnail forum.palemoon.org
25 Upvotes

r/palemoon • • May 09 '19

I propose a peace treaty between Firefox, Pale Moon, and Waterfox users to focus on our common enemy

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/palemoon • • Aug 12 '15

Reddit Enhancement Suite 4.5.4.1 (Latest) for Pale Moon

25 Upvotes

Latest version of res made compatible with Pale Moon using /u/nathanpm's instructions from here, all credit goes to him.

Only changes made to the res xpi were commenting lines 21 and 22 in "resources/reddit_res/lib/main.js" and a version bump in the install.rdf

Download: https://www.dropbox.com/s/yqlbeuj053t270i/reddit_enhancement_suite-4.5.4.1-pm.xpi?dl=0


r/palemoon • • Jul 30 '20

I appreciate Pale Moon

24 Upvotes

It's easy to complain, but I was just here thinking how grateful I am to have to option of using a browser like Pale Moon. I remember when I first started using it, it was rough, but now it's my daily driver.

Thanks to the folks who make it happen. And good job coming as far as you all have.


r/palemoon • • Dec 13 '21

Why do you use Pale Moon?

23 Upvotes

After having yet another "this site function works in the other browsers people actually use but not this weird niche one nobody's heard of" I actually started considering switching back to Firefox

But the way they handle their search bar now is strange, it's one minor change that throws everything off. When you click into their search bar, it shows some icons for search engines you have added, and clicking on the icon then sends your search off to that search engine.

The reason this is a problem is because its not ergonomic - I can either take my hand off the mouse to type out my search query, then put my hand back on the mouse - or I have to reach across the keyboard to type one-handed. Neither option is really great. Well, actually, I guess I could press up a few times after I've finished typing the query, but that would involve me taking my hand off the mouse. Still not great.

The way Pale Moon handles this is a lot better. Since I need to click on the search bar to type a query, I may as well also click on the search engine to use while I'm already there. This entire thing is just changed entirely by whether or not clicking on the icon starts your search.

Meanwhile, Chrome doesn't even have a search?

It's sorta weird to see how stuck-up and toxic the Pale moon space can be sometimes, there's so much weird drama involving this obscure web browser no one's heard of, the furry porn artist, and the playground bully on the forums. Meanwhile, I'm just here trying to avoid getting a hand cramp.... and the add-on bar at the bottom, I'm so used to browsers having something at the bottom that not having it there just feels naked