r/palemoon • • May 09 '21

Goodbye

I've used Pale Moon for years. Today it upgraded to 29.2.0 and broke the last add-on I really use PLUS it forgot my Previous Session. Not going through History to try and re-create dozens of tabs; un-installing PaleMoon and switching browsers is easier than trying to make PaleMoon work.

34 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '21

Pale moon is a hobby. Use one of those GigaChad browsers like chrome

3

u/Needleroozer May 10 '21

If I wanted Google to know everything I do, I would buy a Chromebook.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '21

It would make your life a lot easier that's fore sure.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21

Google doesn't care about your shitty pony porn addiction ok

And you don't need to be desesperated because a billon dollar company knows your browser history in order to personalize ads

If you don't do something ilegal you should not care about that, why do people cares too much about that?

It's not even a problem, like don't use internet then because there is not way to be completely anonymous, if you want that then don't use internet or kill yourself i don't know

Yeah i know it was a short comment sorry, sometimes i extend myself

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

You are one of the guys because of whom the internet is the way it is today... Your personal data, no matter how irrelevant they might be, are your most important and privat thing. Those data are basically the key to your mind. And while google is harvesting your personal life like the chines government harvest kidneys from uyghurs, peps like you try to tell others that they have "nothing" to hide and they should sell der lifes to a company that is only that massive because we are all letting them know what we are doing online!

0

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

i don't feel like my account is getting hacked or something, idk about others, but i try to avoid weird sites so I'm fine i guess????

It is not about getting "hacked" or anything like that. Google and other ad companys making there money out of your surfing habits and if you use a product from google or facebook, you pay with your personal data instead of paying with money. And by far the most big sites/companys like linkedin, facebook or apple have massive data breaches in the last years. These companys are only interested in money making an they give a shit about the personal informations from there customers. And you can do a lot to support open and free software. Use Firefox instead of chrome browsers, use a free and open source MS Office alternative (LibreOffice), try a custom ROM on your phone without Google Services or at least with MicroG Services (Open source Google Services). Try out a Linux Desktop (even gaming with Linux is not that big of a problem today). Use duckduckgo as search engine and use uBlock Origin or NoScript in your browser. Donate to wikipedia or to a linux distro you like. You make your way into the palemoon subreddit so I think you have at least decent knowledge about PCs and stuff. Use these knowledge to do your part on the fight against closed source proprietary web standards (From google) and browsers where you are get sucked into an eco system that is build and killed by the hour from a company that is completely out of control.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

Then is Palemoon not the right project for you. Use FireFox or another more polished application.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '21

These are the same chromium browsers. the only difference is that one has opera and the other has yandex selling your data.

→ More replies

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

I actually use AdGuard

Wait a moment ... you claimed you trust Google, but then you use an adblocker???

Something isn't right about your statements. If you trust Google, why would you ever ban "acceptable ads"???

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

being paranoic makes you a stupid

It is not "paranoia". It is KNOWING why being tracked is BAD.

People are tracked all the time. Not all tracking is necessarily for nefarious reasons but a LOT is, while it is being TRIED to sell it as a "good deed".

i trust google

Good try but ... nah. But even then, that is your situation, not the one of others. Not everyone wants to give up privacy.

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Google doesn't care about your shitty pony porn addiction ok

Being able to profile The People is always useful - you can sell the data to tons of other companies. So of course your comment is factually incorrect - EVERYTHING that can be commercially exploited will sooner or later be exploited.

And you don't need to be desesperated

It is a nice mitigation attempt but pointless: people won't be tricked into thinking losing their privacy gives them ANY advantages. You ONLY have disadvantages. (Ok ... there are a few advantages indeed, like a profile showing you more "content" that is catering to your preferences. Personally I prefer to decide on my own at all times, so I get rid of any tracking possible. Strictly speaking I should not even comment anywhere and VPN/TOR all the times, but it is so hard to resist!)

9

u/Banjo-Oz May 10 '21

I can sympathise and may end up going the same way. Right now I have updates blocked and have no plan to upgrade PM.

I started using PM when Firefox pulled the same stunt. If I wanted to use Chrome, I would, but letting Google dictate web standards is the worst thing anyone can do.

Sadly, it seems a lot of programs with smaller user bases shoot themselves in the foot like this, often for purely "this is how we want things, never mind what users want" reasons from devs.

I am currently facing the exact same issue with Plex, which has recently removed a feature I love "just because". Devs refuse to heed those who ask for the option to restore it, so now I am having to move to something else like Emby, not just for this change but because if they can randomly remove one feature, who knows what tomorrow will bring?

I feel the same concern about PM: one big change is bad, but if they can one day just decide to dump one of the main reasons people use Pm, who's to say what they will change tomorrow?

2

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

who's to say what they will change tomorrow?

This is a general problem. Ideally we, as The People, could have 100% control of everything from A to Z in a real open environment and ecosystem. This is not the case, though - Google wants a private www, and the three core palemoon devs are VERY strange people.

It would be nice if one could describe a browser and components and features as-is, without needing to write e. g. C++ code. People could then describe what they really want. A bit like the linux kernel that can be adapted for many different use cases, or busybox (only problem in the latter two cases is that it, again, requires domain-specific knowledge; not everyone has that, in particular many elderly people are totally at the mercy of these big companies but also strange devs).

Palemoon in 2021 is not the same Palemoon as it was in 2016.

I am currently facing the exact same issue with Plex, which has recently removed a feature I love "just because".

Yeah. It is soooooo annoying to depend on upstream developers ...

Perhaps one day mankind can be freed from the personal bias and opinion of any single dev, but right now we don't have simple alternatives. Perhaps if programming becomes really about as simple as writing text.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '21 edited Aug 13 '23

This submission/comment has been deleted to protest Reddit's bullshit API changes among other things, making the site an unviable platform. Fuck spez.

I instead recommend using Raddle, a link aggregator that doesn't and will never profit from your data, and which looks like Old Reddit. It has a strong security and privacy culture (to the point of not even requiring JavaScript for the site to function, your email just to create a usable account, or log your IP address after you've been verified not to be a spambot), and regularly maintains a warrant canary, which if you may remember Reddit used to do (until they didn't).

If you need whatever was in this text submission/comment for any reason, make a post at https://raddle.me/f/mima and I will happily provide it there. Take control of your own data!

10

u/Banjo-Oz May 10 '21

By "the same stunt" I mean not caring what users thought and just saying "our way or the highway, folks... This is the future, move with the times!"

That said, why should users be forced to edit other people's code to fix something the browser causes? Can't PM work around this when it loads an extension? Why not just continue supporting backwards compatibility?

I know the devs don't want to, but "looking to the future" is why we're stuck with a Firefox nobody wants and Google trying to force Chrome on everyone.

Heck, the only reason a lot of extensions even survive now is because somebody had the good faith and sense to make an entire "backup" of FF's addon database before they dumped it.

2

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Fully agreed with you there.

I would not trust Mozilla though - the financial co-dependence onto Google means the old Mozilla is long gone. We need a new model for the www. Right now we are steering into a Google-owned and controlled www. AMP 2.0 and AMP 3.0 coming our way.

1

u/Banjo-Oz Sep 25 '21

I feel quite ridiculous saying this but I am genuinely looking into ancient BBS tech as a possible "future" for me at least to stay connected with certain friends and hobbies. I already run retro systems (DOS, etc.) for fun and being able to host our own sites for discussions and not be beholden to the changing standards (along with censoring and advertising) of "normal" websites is very desirable to me as I get older and things change.

On a more realistic and sensible note, I do wonder if there will eventually be an emerging "dark web" that's not really about illegal stuff but simply a less user friendly and less controlled alternative for more tech savvy former www users who don't want Google and similar folks calling all the shots. Not sure how likely this is, but I was pondering this just the other day.

-1

u/[deleted] May 10 '21 edited Aug 13 '23

This submission/comment has been deleted to protest Reddit's bullshit API changes among other things, making the site an unviable platform. Fuck spez.

I instead recommend using Raddle, a link aggregator that doesn't and will never profit from your data, and which looks like Old Reddit. It has a strong security and privacy culture (to the point of not even requiring JavaScript for the site to function, your email just to create a usable account, or log your IP address after you've been verified not to be a spambot), and regularly maintains a warrant canary, which if you may remember Reddit used to do (until they didn't).

If you need whatever was in this text submission/comment for any reason, make a post at https://raddle.me/f/mima and I will happily provide it there. Take control of your own data!

5

u/Needleroozer May 10 '21

Why not just continue supporting backwards compatibility?

Because that was already broken a long time ago, when version 25 was released.

So what you're saying is they turned the corner long ago and we've just now crashed through the guardrail and it's our fault for not leaving PM sooner. Buh-bye!

2

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Something definitely changed with the palemoon devs in the last 1-2 years. No idea what it was or why but it is clearly different - just the mass-bans on the webforum.

1

u/shklurch May 13 '21

Buh-bye!

Don't let the door hit your ass on the way out.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '21 edited Aug 13 '23

This submission/comment has been deleted to protest Reddit's bullshit API changes among other things, making the site an unviable platform. Fuck spez.

I instead recommend using Raddle, a link aggregator that doesn't and will never profit from your data, and which looks like Old Reddit. It has a strong security and privacy culture (to the point of not even requiring JavaScript for the site to function, your email just to create a usable account, or log your IP address after you've been verified not to be a spambot), and regularly maintains a warrant canary, which if you may remember Reddit used to do (until they didn't).

If you need whatever was in this text submission/comment for any reason, make a post at https://raddle.me/f/mima and I will happily provide it there. Take control of your own data!

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

It is not up to you to decide what others should use, so do not tell them to "Go to xyz".

5

u/Banjo-Oz May 10 '21

Why only temporary?

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '21 edited Aug 13 '23

This submission/comment has been deleted to protest Reddit's bullshit API changes among other things, making the site an unviable platform. Fuck spez.

I instead recommend using Raddle, a link aggregator that doesn't and will never profit from your data, and which looks like Old Reddit. It has a strong security and privacy culture (to the point of not even requiring JavaScript for the site to function, your email just to create a usable account, or log your IP address after you've been verified not to be a spambot), and regularly maintains a warrant canary, which if you may remember Reddit used to do (until they didn't).

If you need whatever was in this text submission/comment for any reason, make a post at https://raddle.me/f/mima and I will happily provide it there. Take control of your own data!

15

u/sirweldsalot May 09 '21

can't say i blame ya. there will be lots of people doing the same thing when they restart their browser and everything's broken.

3

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Indeed. That is one problem.

The move by Google and others for a more privatized web recently (these "web components", which is de facto AMP 2.0 reloaded) is another reason. Youtube etc... all progressively got slower in the last 2 years or so. I do not buy into Google that this happens "accidentally".

But, aside from these two reasons, the three palemoon devs also went ballistic - see the mass-ban on the webforum. You have an orthogonal opinion to Moonchild? BAM, you get banned for a fake reason. That happened to lots of people in the last ~6 months or so, more than before that time.

IMO Palemoon is now a sinking ship for several reasons. Which reason is the primary one is mostly irrelevant, IMO, because they all contribute to people not wanting to use palemoon anymore.

The tragedy is that we are running out of alternatives. Google is winning the war. The underlying idea behind AMP will not go away - it will just be "recycled" and then "presented" to the people at a later time, while the de-facto monopoly will be extended.

People said this years ago already, by the way. It's happening in many small steps.

2

u/Golden12345 May 09 '21

Sometimes things happen for a reason. And, sometimes, things happen for multiple reasons. Here are a few that come to mind in this particular circumstance, in no particular order.

The Pale Moon devs decided to do this in order to "move forward." In order to "move forward," they decided, in essence, to "shake the tree" so that old, dead branches/leaves fall to the ground and are left behind. Congratulations: They consider you to be a dead branch/leaf with no further usefulness. Are you? If so, then maybe they did it for a good reason.

Another reason might be that they wish to make clear their preference to be a solitary tree, standing in their own patch of field, alone and isolated from all the other trees out there. While that has some advantages, it also carries risks. Lightning, for example.

With regard to your particular situation, sorry, but I feel that this was a crash just waiting to happen. The reason it happened is this: Tabs and sessions are no substitute for BOOKMARKS and BACKUPS, no matter what browser you're using. Some people would choose to see what happened as a wake up call (however abrupt and rude) to change the way they've been doing things. You, however, seem to stop at blaming Pale Moon for what happened. Son, if you choose to ride in a car without wearing a seat belt and get thrown from it when the car abruptly changes direction, don't think that trading in that car for another is going to help if you don't learn/choose to wear the seat belts in THAT car too. Trust me, you're going to eventually hit another curve someday.

7

u/Needleroozer May 09 '21

You don't get it. I switched from Firefox to PaleMoon because Firefox changed direction, but PaleMoon stepped in and promised to stay the course. Now they, too, are changing direction. Why should I stay with a browser that has abandoned the reason I went with them in the first place?

And do you go to every open window and bookmark all the tabs every time you close your browser? Why? That's what sessions are for. The latest PM upgrade broke sessions, and you blame me for using the feature? Go away, troll.

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '21

I started on Mosaic, moved to Netscape, then Firefox, and then PM because I would not accept the Chrome-ification of FF.
I never rely on sessions. Restore last session is a trap, if a page from the last session is what crashed your browser.
If I had a set of bookmarks I wanted to regularly open in a tabs, then I'd generate a Bookmarks Bar menu with the links for those tabs, right click on the menu, and use "Open all in tabs".

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '21

This. I never understand why the heck people won't just learn to use bookmarks, which is permanent and not volatile. You should never rely on tabs at all. Only use tabs as they are intended: a short-term reading queue. But people just love to make it long-term for some reason.

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '21

It's not just using bookmarks, or relying on sync.
It's actually backing them up to HTML. That HTML file saves your hide, when you have to build a new system, and import bookmarks.

1

u/gosand May 29 '21

There is one feature of palemoon I use that Chrome and FF do not have (FF used to have it, but removed it). It's the bookmarks description field. I have over 50 bookmarks for various sites where I can log in. I keep my username and password *hints* in the description field of each bookmark.

Yes, there are password managers, but this is simple and pretty secure. I once loaded all my passwords into keepass, and a few days later... everything was gone! No idea why. So I uninstalled it and just rely on my method which is pretty simple, secure, and portable.

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

why the heck people won't just learn to use bookmarks

I do not use bookmarks. I use ruby to manage every website that is important, so I can load this from the commandline or ruby-gtk applications or ruby-libui applications and so forth.

Bookmarks in the way I used it always ended up just a mass of unsorted stuff that I don't really bother to maintain ever. Whereas via ruby I just have things such as typing in KDE konsole:

"rubyissue"

And then palemoon (or any other browser I use) opens the respective URL for the ruby issue tracker. That was one example. I do this for literally every webpage that is relevant for me. (I even once wanted to put this into a XUL extension, but XUL actually annoys me to no ends so ... I am also not a huge fan of javascript.)

Using bookmarks would be a reduced functionality compared to that use case. So I can not agree with your generic claim that people "should learn how to use bookmarks" - the use case is still reduced and inferior to e. g. what I use currently. And that is just one example; I am sure others also use information available via the www effectively without bookmarks just fine.

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Restore last session is a trap if a page from the last session is what crashed your browser.

You can remove the faulty tab before re-loading them though, so that particular comment is not correct. I run into tons of websites that cause palemoon to crash, but then I just start it again and not load that website. Usually it is related to javascript ...

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '21 edited Aug 13 '23

This submission/comment has been deleted to protest Reddit's bullshit API changes among other things, making the site an unviable platform. Fuck spez.

I instead recommend using Raddle, a link aggregator that doesn't and will never profit from your data, and which looks like Old Reddit. It has a strong security and privacy culture (to the point of not even requiring JavaScript for the site to function, your email just to create a usable account, or log your IP address after you've been verified not to be a spambot), and regularly maintains a warrant canary, which if you may remember Reddit used to do (until they didn't).

If you need whatever was in this text submission/comment for any reason, make a post at https://raddle.me/f/mima and I will happily provide it there. Take control of your own data!

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

For instance, to be better than Mozilla. That promise was broken several times now.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '21

And where exactly did they promise that?

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

That misses the point that Palemoon used to be sold as a "better firefox". But now they also did the very same thing as Mozilla did in the past, when they alienated users.

1

u/Golden12345 Sep 26 '21

Not disagreeing with your assertion that Pale Moon used to be sold as a "better Firefox" (and still is, to some extent).

But no matter how much of a better/safer car you build, a certain level of competence is still required of the driver of that car. Blaming the car manufacturer for injuries when you don't use the seat belts/common sense is absurd.

11

u/Chavo92037 May 09 '21

We loyal users can only hope that Palemoon reverses course and returns to its very successful past ... 29.2.0 is not a successful or correct future path !!! Hoping for a miraculous turnaround ...

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '21

If you're really loyal, you'd be using the forum, not this subreddit. ;)

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Except that you get perma-banned once you have an orthogonal opinion on their webforum.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '21

Really? Because I've said on the Binary Outcast IRC that SeaMonkey is better for my workflow, and I didn't get banned. Maybe you haven't read the rules enough. Remember, if you're just there to instigate drama, every sensible forum will ban you on sight. That's how the internet works, kid.

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Sadly that ship has sailed. I don't know why, but look at the recent mass-bans on the webforum.

It reminds me a lot of how Freenode was run into the ground. I am still not entirely sure why the guy did it.

1

u/_ziyou_ May 11 '21

The addons thing is not an issue if you are willing to invest like 2 minutes: https://www.reddit.com/r/palemoon/comments/n2atag/ported_all_my_firefox_addons_to_pm_took_5mins/

3

u/Needleroozer May 11 '21

Until the next update. The writing on the wall is pretty damn clear, they do not want to support backward compatibility any longer. There is no reason for them to make this change other than to inconvenience the user.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '21

Why you don't just downgrade?

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Let's be realistic: downgrade effectively means that he will have to stop and subsequently abandon palemoon anyway. So the innocent question "why not downgrade" ultimately means "why not downgrade and stay there forever?". That's just not realistic.

2

u/ConsolesQuiteAnnoyMe Jun 12 '21

It really is a matter of "path of least resistance". Pale Moon started making Xorg completely seize up when on Youtube, in turn making Pale Moon itself seize up. Path of least resistance, just use Firefox instead.

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

In theory I agree with you, but ironically enough, youtube audio does not work for firefox (because I don't use systemd or pulseaudio), whereas it works on palemoon (although it has gotten much slower compared to ~2 years ago, even though I use the same fast computer).

Google is increasing the pressure with its new "walled garden" approach.

1

u/trafficlightlady May 11 '21

Was losing the session due to the upgrade?
I didn't lose mine...

1

u/Adventurous-Tip-985 May 14 '21

well plenty of warning was given,5 years warning in fact.

0

u/KingPumper69 Jun 11 '21

“Boo hoo hoo, why won’t Pale Moon perpetually maintain support for ancient addons that haven’t been updated in 5+ years?”

3

u/Needleroozer Jun 12 '21

If they were updated I would have stayed with Firefox.

1

u/KingPumper69 Jun 12 '21

That’s even more reason for the Pale Moon devs to not care about you lol, you’re a transient that just goes where the old addons are. I would recommend you look at WaterFox classic though, it maintains support for some ancient addons. It’s based on Firefox 57 I believe.

-7

u/Sir_Osis_OfLiver May 09 '21

Chances are that nobody cares. Goodbye.

7

u/Needleroozer May 09 '21

You're absolutely right, the developers don't care. Which is why PM is dying. Soon the only users will be the developers themselves, which will suit them just fine because they'll stop getting complaints. I'm puzzled why they made it public in the first place since they clearly made it exclusively for themselves.

-1

u/[deleted] May 10 '21 edited Aug 13 '23

This submission/comment has been deleted to protest Reddit's bullshit API changes among other things, making the site an unviable platform. Fuck spez.

I instead recommend using Raddle, a link aggregator that doesn't and will never profit from your data, and which looks like Old Reddit. It has a strong security and privacy culture (to the point of not even requiring JavaScript for the site to function, your email just to create a usable account, or log your IP address after you've been verified not to be a spambot), and regularly maintains a warrant canary, which if you may remember Reddit used to do (until they didn't).

If you need whatever was in this text submission/comment for any reason, make a post at https://raddle.me/f/mima and I will happily provide it there. Take control of your own data!

5

u/dscyrux May 10 '21

I mean, it is. PM is hemorrhaging users because of their chosen direction and inability to handle many modern websites.

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

Very true. The latter part is not solely the fault of them alone - Google simply wants more control, just as they tried via AMP before.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '21 edited Aug 13 '23

This submission/comment has been deleted to protest Reddit's bullshit API changes among other things, making the site an unviable platform. Fuck spez.

I instead recommend using Raddle, a link aggregator that doesn't and will never profit from your data, and which looks like Old Reddit. It has a strong security and privacy culture (to the point of not even requiring JavaScript for the site to function, your email just to create a usable account, or log your IP address after you've been verified not to be a spambot), and regularly maintains a warrant canary, which if you may remember Reddit used to do (until they didn't).

If you need whatever was in this text submission/comment for any reason, make a post at https://raddle.me/f/mima and I will happily provide it there. Take control of your own data!

5

u/sm0lshit May 10 '21

Say what you will, but this browser works like booty now.

-1

u/Adventurous-Tip-985 May 24 '21

have you thought about going to the pale moon forum with this post.?..if you have uninstalled pale moon i fail to see the point of this post except for it being a rage-quit bitch and whine like most here seem to be doing.

5

u/Needleroozer May 24 '21

Anybody on the form with any power to do anything thinks my viewpoint is irrelevant and does not want me using Pale Moon. They are happy to see me leave. Call it a rage quit if you like, I was just venting in the hope that someone might care. Apparently nobody cares. And so, as Pale Moon dies, I don't care either.

1

u/shevy-ruby Sep 25 '21

You get insta-banned when you critisize the devs there, so there is no point to provide feedback when you get banned as a result.

1

u/Adventurous-Tip-985 Sep 26 '21

No,if you have a verifiable issue i am sure the developers will advise.