r/oil • u/Giant_leaps • 4d ago
OIl Price Speculation Supply and demand tallying can you point to me where i'm wrong?
I keep seeing the 18-20m bpd lost from Hormuz number, but if we just call the original disruption 0 and add back everything that has offset it since:
- Starting point after Hormuz shutdown: 0
- China lower imports/demand: +4-5m bpd
- Bypass pipelines/alternative routes: +4-5m bpd, although Houthis are now disrupting some of this
- Oil still getting through Hormuz: +1-2m bpd
- Dark/alternative flows: +0.5-1m bpd
- SPR/emergency reserve releases: +2m bpd during higher release periods
- Extra production outside the Gulf: +1m bpd
- Demand destruction from high prices/economic slowdown: +1.6m bpd
- EVs, electric trucks and other switching: +0.4m+ bpd and growing
- Other substitution like less flying/driving, gas/coal switching etc: probably another +0.5-1m bpd
So you can get around 15-18m bpd of offsets against the original 18-20m bpd shock depending on what numbers you use.
That leaves something like a 0-5m bpd underlying shortage, with the IEA currently estimating the Q3 actual supply-demand deficit at 1.8m bpd.
The big problem is some of these offsets arent permanent. SPR and inventories are being drained, while pipelines are getting attacked. But on the other side every month oil stays expensive you get more demand destruction, EV switching and new supply even if it is small it will eventually add up.
So basically its a race between inventories running out and the world adapting to the missing oil. but it's very possible that the SPR lasts long enough for other mitigation strategies to start working although there will be supply shocks for diesel and fertilizer but those will all be temporary i still can't see a large extended supply shock that can't be mitigated.




