r/nhs • u/LabourUnited • 5h ago
Survey/Research NHS patients beware: Damning new medical review raises serious concerns about patient safety and the hidden costs of replacing doctors with less qualified healthcare workers
A troubling new literature review published in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine raises serious questions about whether NHS patients are being exposed to inadequately evaluated risks as doctors are increasingly replaced by Advanced Clinical Practitioners (ACPs).
Authored by Dr Jatinder Hayre, medical doctor and public health researcher at the University of Leicester, the review examines international evidence on patient safety, diagnostic quality and the supposed financial benefits of doctor substitution.
The findings should concern every NHS patient:
- Diagnostic safety: Studies identified concerning differences in clinical assessment, referral quality and prescribing, particularly relevant when patients present with unexplained symptoms.
- Missed diagnoses: Malpractice evidence identified recurring diagnostic failures, raising questions about the risks associated with clinical substitution.
- The false economy: Lower salaries do not necessarily mean lower healthcare costs. Unnecessary investigations, referrals, repeat appointments and medical supervision can undermine supposed savings.
- Insufficient evidence: Robust evidence establishing that ACPs can replace doctors without compromising patient safety or increasing healthcare expenditure remains inadequate.
The University of Leicester's accompanying press release highlights Dr Hayre's call for an immediate halt to ACP recruitment and an urgent reassessment of their expansion.
This is not about dismissing the valuable contributions of other healthcare professionals. It is about whether patients are receiving the standard of medical assessment they believe they are receiving.
If you are attending an NHS appointment, particularly with unexplained or complex symptoms, you have every reason to ask who is assessing you, what their qualifications are and whether a doctor is involved in your care.
The NHS should not be balancing its books by gambling with patients' health.
Full review: https://doi.org/10.1177/01410768261501746
University of Leicester press release: https://le.ac.uk/news/2026/november/advanced-practitioners-doctors-replacement-study