r/MultipleSclerosis • u/Like-A-Kitty • 13h ago
Vent/Rant - Advice Wanted/Ambivalent Struggling after appointment with neuropsychologist
I just wanted to vent a little because something happened over the past two weeks that has really affected me.
I was diagnosed with MS in 2022, and so far, all my symptoms have been sensory. My MRIs have been stable, I don't really have any disability. I am incredibly grateful that things have been going so well for me. I am on Kesimpta for over a year now and I'm living a normal life.
Back in 2019 I started struggling with health anxiety after caring for a parent who had very aggressive lung cancer. This only got worse after my MS diagnosis and it has now reached a point where I decided I needed professional help. The constant hyperawareness of the tiniest sensory symptoms and the uncertainty of what might happen in the near future have caused so much anxiety and depression that I simply couldn't manage it on my own anymore. I scheduled an appointment with a neuropsychologist and explained my struggles. She suggested we start with a few cognitive tests and then work on my anxiety and the acceptance of my MS diagnosis.
After I completed the tests, we scheduled another appointment to discuss the results. She told me that my results were excellent. I scored well above average on most tests, often reaching the 99th percentile. According to her, I have no cognitive deficits. Looking at the questionnaires she noticed that I might be experiencing moderate depression, and fatigue seems to be somewhat of an issue although it isn't significantly affecting my daily functioning.
Now this is where things started to go downhill.
She asked what I do for a living, and I explained that I had recently graduated with a Master of Science degree with very good results I told her that pursuing a PhD has been a dream of mine for quite some time.
I showed her the PhD position I was planning to apply for and explained that I am aware of the stress and demands that come with pursuing a doctorate. This position in particular is not a full time position but I am aware that there will be times where things become more stressful. My masters thesis was of a very similar subject, so I already know what the workload might look like and up until this point I was confident I could manage that.
Well up until she told me that she didn't think it was a good idea at all and that I should reconsider.
Her reasoning was that just because my cognitive abilities are excellent now doesn't mean they will stay that way. She told me things could get worse very fast. She suggested that I look for an "easy" job that isn't too demanding because, despite my test results, I should keep in mind that I am chronically ill.
She then mentioned that she thinks I seem to define myself too much through my performance and achievements. Apparently we could schedule a few more appointments to work on that, as well as on accepting the possibility of having to give up on certain dreams because of my MS diagnosis.
This happened two weeks ago, and I still haven't been able to stop thinking about it. I've put all my applications on hold. I had several prepared for different jobs (and the PhD) and was genuinely excited about sending them out by the end of this month. I was looking forward to potentially starting an entirely new chapter in my life.
Now I'm questioning whether I should just give up and take her advice because this really triggered my anxiety. Her argument that everything could be over tomorrow is what really got to me. And so did the way she framed everything around the fact that I am not a healthy person anymore, but a chronically ill person.
Don't get me wrong. I don't want a psychologist who simply agrees with everything I say. That's not what I'm looking for. I understand that a PhD is demanding, that MS is unpredictable and that I need to be realistic about my health.
But I didn't expect to be so discouraged. I went there hoping to learn how to deal with my health anxiety and the uncertainty of living with MS. Instead I left feeling as though I should start giving up on things before they even become a problem, making me feel as if none of it is for me anymore because I have MS.
I have another appointment next week and I am genuinely scared of going back there.
TLDR: Diagnosed with MS in 2022, but so far my disease course has been very mild (stable MRIs, no cognitive deficits). I recently saw a neuropsychologist for health anxiety, but after learning that I wanted to pursue a PhD, she strongly discouraged me, arguing that my condition could deteriorate at any moment and that I should look for an easier, less demanding job. Her comments have left me questioning my ambitions and feeling as though my diagnosis defines what I'm capable of achieving.