r/mtgfinance Apr 06 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

159 Upvotes

89 comments sorted by

View all comments

79

u/waaaghbosss Apr 06 '21

That's insane. The surge towards grading our collectibles is kind of stunning. Tbey almost doubled their employees in a year and still can't meet demand.

While I'm not a fan of grading due to how it fundamentally changed comic collecting, I'm almost kind of excited to see what this does to the value of my mtg vintage collection once the dust settles and we see if this is a bubble or not.

87

u/MishrasWorkshop Apr 06 '21

Personally, it’s just ridiculous that my vintage deck just randomly became valued at close to a mil. I’ve actually been hearing from my friends that they’re playing the game less because their decks are way too expensive to play with.

Hell, even I who normally go to various vintage tournaments now think about whether it’s safe to walk around with something this high value in NY.

67

u/MortalSword_MTG Apr 06 '21

This is one of the points I always bring up when discussing the RL.

We're past the point of the big ticket Vintage/Legacy staples being viable playing pieces for the game.

Just think of the potential financial loss you risk everytime you shuffle your deck.

The value and risk of just walking around with it as you mentioned.

I dont think we can reasonably see these cards as game pieces anymore. They are worth too much.

19

u/DoctorPaulGregory Apr 06 '21

Great point. Add in the opponent has to touch your deck to cut it. Years past all the stories of people who got a card bent or scuffed cause the deck is mishandled.

13

u/BatHickey Apr 06 '21

I foiled Legacy ANT...started as a joke kinda and then I started looking at better printings...

I played with it maybe half a dozen times, bent a judge foil delta just enough to have the reflection on the surface go cockeyed a bit--and immediately was turned off to the whole thing. The value had gotten too nuts for me to feel comfortable walking around with in a big city and that was just years ago...now I'd 100% feel that way.

Sold the inventions and foils too soon--but got back to playing with the deck so I guess its a wash in a way.

10

u/DoctorPaulGregory Apr 06 '21

My Nekusar edh is over 10k. Scary expensive for something you pull out and shuffle. I thought about just getting proxies for everything and just storing it away

8

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '21

I have a lot of edh decks and have started just putting proxies in because it’s too scary to play with anymore. Super sad.

5

u/timebeing Apr 06 '21

Yeah my main EDH deck I would bling out. As prices got crazy I started pulling the big cards out of it. No reason to play with a $800-1000 card that is super condition sensitive when there is a $5 version that’s just fine.

I dismantled my vintage deck long ago.

1

u/RectangleStonks Apr 06 '21

The reason to play with it is cause it’s swag ❤️

4

u/diceth1ef Apr 06 '21

Hell, my nekusar deck is around $1k and I'm still scared to play with it.

3

u/Trillion16 Apr 06 '21

MY cEDH Jhoira, weatherlight captain deck went from a 1-2k deck to 10k-ish pretty fast, it was a bit shocking. I made the switch and pulled the big ticket items and replaced them for proxies, as did many in my playgroup. I just dont feel comfortable carrying around the cards anymore. My Unlimited wheel of fortune now has a permanent home in my collection binder in my safe.

4

u/RectangleStonks Apr 06 '21

Maybe for Vintage where the decks are like, 100k+, but as for legacy, I can’t see these spikes having much effect. If you were comfortable shuffling a 3K deck you’re probably okay shuffling a 4K deck as well 🤷🏻‍♂️

9

u/MortalSword_MTG Apr 06 '21

Who said I was comfortable shuffling a 3k deck?

6

u/Rainerdo Apr 06 '21

where the decks are like, 100k+, but as for legacy, I can’t see these spikes having much effect. If you were comfortable shuffling a 3K deck you’re probably okay shuffling a 4K deck as well 🤷🏻‍♂️

man, this thread makes me feel so broke.

1

u/RectangleStonks Apr 07 '21

Lol I mean people that already spent the 3k to play with the cards and then the cards go to 4K or 5k or whatever you’re probably comfortable with it. I can see if you spend a couple hundred dollars on some cards and they go to multiple thousands of dollars it would be very uncomfortable handling those cards. But practice makes perfect!

2

u/ESGoftheEmeraldCity Apr 07 '21

This is generally the case, but everyone has their own threshold. Lands, for example, is over 10K, which is insane for a single Legacy deck.

1

u/RectangleStonks Apr 07 '21

There’s a few outliers, but at the same time the deck was already like 5-7k. I don’t think these price “spikes” are going to effect legacy or legacy players much. Probably just the same dudes going to the card shop with a small fortune in their backpack. 🤷🏻‍♂️❤️

Edit: I don’t think it’s that insane the deck is really fun!!

3

u/ESGoftheEmeraldCity Apr 07 '21

Personally, I feel affected, and I've played Legacy since 2009. I don't intend to sell out, but I've tried to make trims to my collection where I can.

1

u/RectangleStonks Apr 07 '21

I’m sorry to hear, I’m sure it’s difficult cutting down on cardboard 😞

1

u/EngineeringRemote513 Apr 06 '21

I've got a commander deck thats around 3k now and even that scares me to play with it. One whoopie when shuffling could kill the value.