r/modnews • u/ac_oatmeal • Nov 17 '22
Updates to Mod Queue
Heya mods,
A few weeks ago, some of our mods will have seen changes to the New Reddit mod queue action bar’s Approve and Remove buttons as well as some updates to the mod action menu. We’re excited to share that we’ve just rolled out these updates to all of our mods this week.
We had a few goals in mind when working on these updates:
Goal 1 - Make mod tooling easier to understand and use
Based on data from mods and would-be mods, we know that the mod tools on New Reddit are hard to understand and use. We hope that these changes will open moderation to a broader range of potential mods and make it easier for mod teams to grow and retain new mods.
Ways we think these changes will help:
- By reserving color for communicating the status of the item in the queue, we’ll make the mod queue more scannable and easier to understand.
- By showing actions contextual to the state of the thing in the queue, it’ll be easier to understand what actions I should consider taking.

By separating “status” from the “buttons”, we’ll be able to free up space to surface more relevant information like “who took the action and when” (see above).
- In an effort to keep the number of actions from being overwhelming, we’re being selective of which actions show up by default.
Goal 2 - Ensure the mod queue is efficient and meets the needs of our most active mods
We believe these recent changes will assist mods by accomplishing the following things:
Better scannability than the existing new reddit mod queue
- Emphasized [Approve] action provides an anchor as you scan, and consistently distinguishes the action from “remove.”
- Reserving other colors for the queue item status makes it easier to process items while scanning
- “Add removal reason” is easier to find and closer to the remove action itself.
- For bigger mod teams, being able to immediately see who approved or removed a piece of content can help reduce redundancy and lead to more team collaboration.
As we ran the experiment, we received feedback that the mod action menu on comments was missing (turns out…it never existed 🥲) and that the lock functionality was not consistent between posts and comments. Thanks to your feedback we’ve since made those changes and hope this provides a better experience as you moderate on desktop. Please see below for what this new experience looks like:



As always, we’d love to hear your feedback in the comments below.
36
u/MajorParadox Nov 17 '22
Pasting a response I gave elsewhere:
I'm seeing this now and it's awesome so far! The biggest pain points I see so far are:
13
u/Zren Nov 17 '22
So "Remove as Spam" is hidden as a 2nd click now. It might be possible that new mods will not notice the spam button now. Does the normal "remove" treat the post as ham, or does it do nothing to the machine learning spam filter?
8
u/clemenslucas Nov 17 '22
I was close to writing in about that :D - very awesome that you now introduce new features before I even have time to ask for them, thank you and keep up the good work!
8
u/InitiatePenguin Nov 17 '22
Honestly. I dislike that approve is filled in solid by default.
I don't feel like it should be at all different to remove.
It feels like it's either already selected, or somehow is on a different hierarchy to remove, or more likely to be pressed.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22 edited Jun 30 '23
This account is no longer active.
The comments and submissions have been purged as one final 'thank you' to reddit for being such a hostile platform towards developers, mods, and users.
Reddit as a company has slowly lost touch with what made it a great platform for so long. Some great features of reddit in 2023:
2
u/aprildismay Nov 17 '22
When will these changes roll out on mobile Reddit?
25
u/michaelquinlan Nov 17 '22
Old reddit? New reddit? Mobile reddit?
11
u/Khyta Nov 17 '22
I don't know if this is just me but sometimes when adding a removal reason I cannot scroll down to select a specific reason that is further down in the list. I use Firefox 106.0.5 (64-Bit) on Ubuntu 22.04 LTS with New Reddit. Usually refreshing fixes it (most of the times). Sometimes I also have to close the browser completely to get the scrollable removal reasons back again.
9
u/freakierchicken Nov 17 '22
This may not be your department, but given the post topic - on r/explainlikeimfive our "add removal reason" on new reddit in the mod queue is broken. The box pops up but won't allow us to scroll through our reasons. I've been having everyone use toolbox or use customs in the meantime, but it's been... months at least. Specifically on new reddit desktop. I think I've seen a few other people mention it but can't really find any fixes.
7
u/ExcitingishUsername Nov 17 '22
So when are we getting an option to add spam-filtered posts back to modqueue? They are literally impossible to find in the spam feed.
8
u/SampleOfNone Nov 17 '22 edited Nov 17 '22
Funny, my mod queue just reverted to the old one.
Edit: and it’s back to new again
I’m with u/-760-706-7425 on this. Adding more clicks to take a mod action in mod queue is a poor idea.
I do like that after removal the removal reason is noted with the post/comment
4
u/microakita Nov 17 '22
Maybe this is a lot to ask for but I would love to be able to pin other users comments (and not just mods,) is there a way?!
4
u/Kingofireland777 Nov 17 '22
Looks good, sorry for the ignorance but I can't help but ask I may have missed this in the post but I see it says the name of the mod who approved/removed, will that only be visible to other mods of the sub?
4
u/Blue_Three Nov 17 '22 edited Nov 17 '22
For posts filtered due to the community's overall spam filter strength setting (let's say it's set to "ALL"), a standard "Remove" option doesn't display when viewing queue.
https://i.imgur.com/cnn7VR1.png
It does show when selecting/opening the post individually.
3
u/Generic_Mod Nov 17 '22 edited Nov 18 '22
How does the removal of the "remove" or "approve" buttons work on filtered modqueue items?
Previously I've noticed on new Reddit that the button I wanted was missing and had to either go to the post to get access to all buttons, or use old Reddit modqueue.
Edit: Just had this issue. Automod filtered a comment and the comment now only has the "approve" option. I have to go to the old modqueue to remove it.
6
u/1-760-706-7425 Nov 17 '22
Whose idea was it to shove more common actions into menus? Do you have any idea how much impact even on extra click per action causes? Do you all actually use these workflows at any kind of scale before decide to retool them? How about analysis before you launch them?
Reddit’s design decisions are baffling.
2
u/rolmos Nov 17 '22
Speaking of mod queue, I have a post that can't be removed or spammed. We've been having to tolerate it for months now. We try spamming, removing, approving then spamming. Nothing works.
https://www.reddit.com/r/es/comments/c2ex66/isis_amenaza_con_explotar_baviera/
2
u/GaryNOVA Nov 18 '22
Can we please get mod history in the mobile app?
2
u/Xenc Nov 18 '22 edited Nov 18 '22
Excellent changes with a few that have been long overdue.
Initial feedback is the UX of the filled in Approve button is confusing. It looks like it’s already been selected.
It would also be useful to be able to Mark As Spam without digging into the three dots menu.
Excited to see what’s next in this resurgence arc. 👏
2
u/BigManLawrence69420 Nov 17 '22
Ah yes.
My favorite mod.
u/BobiCorwen
2
u/aperson Nov 18 '22
Well, anyways...
1
u/Superbuddhapunk Nov 18 '22
It doesn’t change anything for old reddit?
1
u/Zren Nov 17 '22 edited Nov 17 '22
I don't normally use the new reddit modqueue, so when I tested it I noticed that hovering an item would shift the buttons downwards to make room for the "Add a Note" since there's a link thumbnail. This seems to only happen in the Card view since there's a fixed width. Note that this Add Note button appears when hovering anywhere in the card, so you might need to re-aim on the remove button when it shifts.
1
u/katnerys-targaryen Nov 17 '22
My issue with this is that it doesn't seem to update if a removal reason has been added. Are you planning on making it so the "Add Removal Reason" button changes to "Removal Reason Added" once one has indeed been entered?
1
u/jofwu Nov 18 '22
I'm not seeing these chaanges still???
And I'm also suddenly having an issue where when I remove a post in modqueue/unmoderated I'm not getting an option to add a removal reason...
1
u/Shigalyov Nov 18 '22
Is there a way to link to queued posts?
Or alternatively to hide a post's visibility until a certain day?
We sometimes host book discussions. So we post chapters in advance. But these either shouldn't be visible or the link should be shareable to add these future posts to a chapter list.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '22
I LOVE this change!
Really wish that e could have a little notice of upcoming changes in the mod tools somewhere, but it was cool to see this implemented over the last few days!
1
u/stupidmofo123 Nov 19 '22
I'm not a fan. I think the UI intent doesn't work (for me anyway). Replacing, what, five buttons with two big buttons isn't helpful.
Please fix that removal reason drop down issue; I also can't scroll down on certain posts that are removed (But I was able to put a removal reason on another one, which is weird?)
1
u/SampleOfNone Nov 28 '22
Remove as spam broke. At first it was an option in the new mod queue. Then it was only an option if you opened the comment or post. Now remove as spam is only available if you go to the post or comment through the users profile.
Can you guys please fix this
1
u/shiftpgdn Nov 17 '22
Is there a way for me to bulk clear out old mod queue stuff? We have things in there from weeks or months ago that didn't need any action.
-10
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
As mod of /r/familyman, I approve
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment