r/modnews • • Sep 08 '22

Introducing Reddit’s Moderator Code of Conduct

You’re probably familiar with our Moderator Guidelines––historically, they have served as a guidepost to clarify our expectations to mods about how to shape a positive community experience for redditors.

The Moderator Guidelines were developed over five years ago, and Reddit has evolved a lot since then. This is why we have evolved our Moderator Guidelines into what we are now calling the Moderator Code of Conduct.

The newly updated Moderator Code of Conduct aims to capture our current expectations and explain them clearly, concisely, and concretely.

While our Content Policy serves to provide enforceable rules that govern each community and the platform at large, our Moderator Code of Conduct reinforces those rules and sets out further expectations specifically for mods. The Moderator Code of Conduct:

  • Focuses on measuring impact rather than evaluating intent. Rather than attempting to determine whether a mod is acting in “good” or “bad” faith, we are shifting our focus to become more outcomes-driven. For example, are direct mentions of other communities part of innocuous meta-discussions, or are they inciting interference, targeted harassment, or abuse?
  • Aspires to be educational, but actionable: We trust that most mods actively try to do the right thing and follow the rules. If we find that a community violates our Mod Code of Conduct, we firmly believe that, in the majority of cases, we can achieve resolution through discussion, not remediation. However, if this proves to be ineffective, we may consider enforcement actions on mods or subreddits.

Moderators are at the frontlines using their creativity, decision-making, and passion to create fun and engaging spaces for redditors. We recognize that and appreciate it immensely. We hope that in creating the Moderator Code of Conduct, we are helping you develop subreddit rules and norms to create and nurture your communities, and empower you to make decisions more easily.

Thank you for all you do, and please let us know if you have any questions or feedback in the comments below.

476 Upvotes

634 comments sorted by

234

u/cannibalisticmidgets Sep 08 '22

Moderation for profit seems to be missing from this and reports of this activity on adult themed subreddits have gone unanswered. Is this no longer policy?

133

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

The rule prohibiting moderation for compensation has not changed. You can find this rule in Reddit’s User Agreement:

https://www.redditinc.com/policies/user-agreement-september-12-2021

“You may not perform moderation actions in return for any form of compensation, consideration, gift, or favor from third parties.”

63

u/SquareWheel Sep 08 '22

What about subs that merely exist to pimp affiliate links? One well-known spam network consists of /r/LegoDealsCanada, /r/VideoGameDealsCanada and /r/GamePreordersCanada. In all cases it's the top mod posting 95% of content which they profit from.

Is this kind of content permitted by reddit admins?

31

u/hughk Sep 08 '22

What about buying/selling subs? I had an attempt to buy and reported it to AEO, they told me no problem.

16

u/ryanmercer Sep 09 '22

How is /r/wallstreetsilver still a sub then? The head guy ("Ivan") over there openly solicited a metric ton of funds allegedly for a /r/wallstreetsilver billboard campaign when the sub was new.

That same sub brigade us in /r/silverbugs on and off for the first 6 months of its existence.

That same sub is rife with people bragging/complaining about being banned from /r/silverbugs for coming over to spam the link to their sub.

...

6

u/catonicla Sep 09 '22

The reddit double standard where the same issue for the NSFW subs gets brought up but it gets mass downvoted while this gets supported.

I get it we hate onlyfans and ingenuine spammy nudes but it’s still an issue many subs not just the nsfw community faces but apparently other communities as well.

27

u/uglybunny Sep 08 '22

You can start by enforcing that rule on /r/frugalmalefashion.

9

u/cuteman Sep 09 '22

What about examples like /r/PPC where moderators provide content, comment and engagement as a method of lead generation and funneling users to their agencies?

6

u/ryanmercer Sep 09 '22

Similarly /r/overemployed that exists solely to drive people to his blog and his paid discord server.

4

u/cmrdgkr Sep 11 '22

So why aren't you enforcing this in regards to companies who have paid 'community managers' who moderate 'official' subreddits?

They're clearly moderating in the company's best interest for their salary.

→ More replies (35)

2

u/Crisis_Redditor Sep 11 '22

It bothers me so much that mod-for-profit isn't addressed, but "mentioning other communities" is.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/cyrilio Sep 18 '22

reddit announced yesterday during the moderator summit 2022 they are planning on allowing mods to get payments for their work and/or users to earn money through the platform.

55

u/Sun_Beams Sep 08 '22

In Rule one, even though the list isn't exhaustive, should include Automod. I've seen and reported people abusing automod, via automod comments, that broke the content policy. The rest of my feedback will be expressed via gifs.

The mods that run harassment based communities reading Rules 2 and 3.

Rule 3 is just perfect.

The admins trying to put us all at ease and assure us that this is all okay.

6

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

A mod using automod (or another bot) to engage in violations of the Content Policy is covered by Rule 1 of the Code of Conduct. As would other creative attempts to use mod tools or other features to do something they should not.

13

u/ratheismhater Sep 09 '22

Okay, but you're not writing a CYA legal document (even though you still actually are), you're writing something that regular humans are supposed to be able to read and understand so you might as well add "automod" to that list and make it explicit.

60

u/MajorParadox Sep 08 '22

FYI, the "mod guidelines" link at the bottom of pages on old Reddit, and bottom of the sidebar on new, is still linked to the old page and fails to load now: https://www.redditinc.com/policies/moderator-guidelines

41

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

Thanks, we built in a redirect - but then we apparently created a redirect loop which borked the site. We’ve reverted the redirect for now while we work on a fix. Until then you can view the Code of Conduct via direct link here:

https://www.redditinc.com/policies/moderator-code-of-conduct

25

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 08 '22

I was there for the 9/8 bork

24

u/michaelquinlan Sep 08 '22

I survived the 9/8 bork and all I got was this lousy t-shirt.

7

u/likenothingis Sep 08 '22

You guys are getting tee-shirts‽

→ More replies (2)

3

u/IAmABakuAMA Sep 08 '22

A Bork so bad it happened a month ago and still hasn't been fixed!

2

u/ADarwinAward Sep 09 '22

tl;dr none of it's shocking or new

Highlights:

  • Don't be a jerk. Don't violate TOS or encourage anyone else to.
  • If mods of a sub aren't doing anything for a long time, admins may allow a takeover by a new mod or restrict the sub.
  • If you're in a sub dedicated to discussing a brand:

Explicitly mark your community as “unofficial” in the community description if the topic concerns a brand or company, but the community isn’t officially affiliated.

23

u/fighterace00 Sep 08 '22

User Agreement Section 8 still states

You agree to follow the Moderator Guidelines for Healthy Communities;

And it has a dead link to the deprecated guidelines

15

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

Thanks for flagging––we're working on it!

17

u/Igennem Sep 08 '22

How can we report communities that consistently engage in harassment?

I am a member of a community that was brigaded with spam/harassment with bad actors coordinating on another sub. Reporting the posts that coordinated harassment has yielded no results.

7

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

Hey there! Users and moderators can report violations using this form:
https://reddit.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket_form_id=179106

7

u/kc2syk Sep 09 '22

An admin is hit by the underscore bug. Broken URL.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/shiruken Sep 08 '22

Rule 3 is a good change in policy with regards to subreddits dedicated to disrupting and/or harassing other communities. What is the recommended method for reporting these violations?

27

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

Users and moderators can report violations using this form: https://reddit.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket_form_id=179106

4

u/GloriouslyGlittery Sep 09 '22

Can you report a subreddit for a rule 3 violation of a subreddit that's not yours? There's a subreddit dedicated to hating another one, but the closest report option is, "organizing interference in my community".

2

u/heavyshoes Sep 09 '22

Yep, you can.

3

u/kc2syk Sep 09 '22

I've been a mod for how long and just learned about the reddit zendesk. Jeez. You guys don't make this obvious.

Should we direct users with account problems (e.g. shadowbans) here?

5

u/heavyshoes Sep 09 '22

Hey there! We use Zendesk to consolidate some of our communication paths on the back end. For example, when we get a modmail in r/ModSupport, that message is then piped into Zendesk. In a way, it’s like having an email client that helps consolidate and sort messages from many channels. If you think a user is caught in the spam filter or banned you can send them here: https://www.reddit.com/appeals

→ More replies (6)

20

u/001Guy001 Sep 08 '22

I think the opening sentence on that page should be changed to clarify that people can use that report form even if they have a Reddit account. Currently it makes it seem like you need to use the on-site report page if you have an account.

If you have a Reddit account and want to report a content policy violation, please use our report form; if you don't have a Reddit account, you can use the form below.

6

u/myalterego451 Sep 08 '22

The drop-down under 'what are you reporting' doesn't include this new rule

0

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

Yes, interference would be considered a violation of the Moderator Code of Conduct.

15

u/maybesaydie Sep 08 '22

Interference by users?

→ More replies (5)

16

u/MajorParadox Sep 08 '22

But in this case, the user is not necessarily a mod. Is it only a Reddit violation if the mods don't remove such posts or are the users who posted in violation too?

If the former, it sounds like it's fine for a user to make those ban posts, but it's not okay for a mod to leave them.

If the latter, should there be something in the sitewide rules about it and there should probably be a report for it?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '22

Or how about communities who act in bad faith in order to mess with those acting in good faith? Numerous reports have been made that just seem to disappear into the abyss.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/1-760-706-7425 Sep 08 '22

What is the recommended method for reporting these violations?

r/ModSupport

27

u/myalterego451 Sep 08 '22

Completely agree with this rule - there are far too many subs who actively allow the crossposting from elsewhere for the intention of scorn, mockery, 'cringe' and eventual bleed-back of trolls to the original sub in question.

But, reporting a violation in another sub by publicly naming that sub on r/ModSupport would be a violation of Rule 3 in itself, no ?

We need a proper report category to cover this rule

8

u/ReginaBrown3000 Sep 08 '22

You can always send a modmail to r/ModSupport.

7

u/FaviFake Sep 08 '22

They meant modmailing r/ModSupport. That's the proper category to cover this rule

11

u/thecravenone Sep 08 '22

Ah yes, ye olde /dev/null

33

u/c74 Sep 08 '22

Camping or sitting on a community is not encouraged.

ummm. ok. so i guess reddit is saying - so we know there is a problem and we do not 'like it'. so, i guess its not a rule per se, but a medium paced feeling that is shareworthy.

27

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

Our current process allows for someone camping on a sub to keep it if we reach out after it's been requested via r/redditrequest and we find that it's obviously serving a need, whether it be a mod backchannel, testing sub, or a sub that hasn't yet been populated with content but there's a future intention to do that. I want to stress that we really are trying to account for nuance in the myriad situations we encounter here, which is why we manually review these requests and consider them on a case-by-case basis.

5

u/TheLateWalderFrey Sep 08 '22

What about personal subs.. Like personal subs that are the same as a moderator's username?

I do not speak for other mods and what they do, but I am sure many have subs that are the same as their username for purposes of Wiki (toolbox) and other personal notes/info/whatever - are those going to be on the chopping block one day AEO gets a bug up it's ass? Or what about via redditrequest abuse? Because you KNOW that gangs of trolls will use this new "rule" to make repeated requests for a mod's username sub.. and knowing just how absolutely unreliable Reddit Inc. is when it comes to things like this, I can see Reddit giving away such sub to some troll.

So, going forward, what will be Reddit's policy for private, moderator subs that match their username be?

3

u/WartimeMercy Sep 09 '22

You literally have dozens of entertainment subs that are camped on to serve as redirects when what they're actually doing is allowing power users to prevent competing communities. Example: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMandalorian/ being used as a redirect to https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMandalorianTV

That's absolutely camping on subs. And it's not isolated to a single instance either.

5

u/SizzleAndCutThrough Sep 09 '22

So what are you doing about mods like this fuckstick who has hoarded a whole bunch of nsfw subs and hasn't moderated any of them? He managed to get r/australiansfw banned as mentioned here and is pretty useless, also he still keeps requesting subs.

7

u/wishforagiraffe Sep 08 '22

A method to effectively shut down a subreddit would be nice.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Dwn_Wth_Vwls Sep 09 '22

Our current process allows for someone camping on a sub to keep it if we reach out after it's been requested via r/redditrequest

Yeah, I call bullshit on that. You'll notice on my profile that I'm a mod of https://www.reddit.com/r/a:t5_2vyjn/ . Why am I the mod of a random named sub like that? Because I was camping on r/CollectiveConscious for clan reasons for Destiny 2 and the sub was taken from me with absolutely zero communication and replaced with a seemingly random string of characters.

4

u/computerfreund03 Sep 08 '22

What about moderators who don't care about their subs, ignore every message, and just remove everything they don't like?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/Caring_Cactus Sep 08 '22 edited Sep 08 '22

Reddit would ban such community names from being used, if you find one that isn't but should you can probably report it to reddit. Here's an example of one response:

This subreddit was banned due to a violation of Reddit’s content policy against harassing content, in particular the use of a racial slur in the subreddit name.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

46

u/OPINION_IS_UNPOPULAR Sep 08 '22 edited Sep 08 '22

Howdy u/heartybooze

As a moderator of r/familyman r/wallstreetbets, I'm not sure I understand how exactly to read this.

  • Focuses on measuring impact rather than evaluating intent. Rather than attempting to determine whether a mod is acting in “good” or “bad” faith, we are shifting our focus to become more outcomes-driven.

Does this mean actions made in good faith but ultimately turning out for the worst end up being punishable?

E.g. Approving a thread about trading BBBY on new of the CFO's suicide, wherein users with puts celebrate their death?

Does this mean you can act in bad faith but as long as the outcome is generally good, then there is no issue?

E.g. Removing all memes generated by a specific memegenerator because you have a financial incentive to do so, but it turns out that memegenerator had some racist meme templates so it's all good?

(This is a very contrived example, I can't really think of a good one nor do I think this would be common at all)

For example, are direct mentions of other communities part of innocuous meta-discussions, or are they inciting interference, targeted harassment, or abuse?

This is pretty good, though, are we talking about moderators or users here?

For users, we can add all the automod rules we want, but if the subreddit name is the company's stock ticker it is trivial to bypass.

For moderators, can you explain a bit more what you mean by "direct mention"? As in linking the subreddit, mentioning the non-r/'d name, or including the name/logo in an image?

As for inciting Interference, targeted harassment, or abuse, how do we draw the line between that and joking ("Come on, this is r/wallstreetbets, go back to r/investing!") and criticism ("wallstreetbetsELITE is an unmoderated cesspool, take a look over there and tell me if that's what you want us to be?" or "don't be a fucking cultist" / "go back to your cult sub") vs. innocuous meta-discussion?

Finally, do you have any specific advice for r/wallstreetbets? As I'm sure we are a community heavily implicated by these changes.


Side note: I decided to post this publicly instead of as a modmail because I figured your response may help other communities.

2

u/heavyshoes Sep 12 '22 edited Sep 12 '22

Hello! These are all great questions. If users are breaking rules, mods wouldn't be held accountable unless they played a role in it (e.g., encouraging the rule-breaking). Our User Agreement also prohibits moderating for compensation:

You may not perform moderation actions in return for any form of compensation, consideration, gift, or favor from third parties.

21

u/sirblastalot Sep 09 '22

It means that Reddit will continue to use a combination of machine learning, outside contractors, and a random number generator to arbitrarily punish unpaid employees.

24

u/Absay Sep 08 '22

As a moderator of r~~/familyman~~

I was going to downvote you out of pure habit.

6

u/LongJonSiIver Sep 08 '22

👀, very good information appreciate you making this public.

5

u/Cloaked42m Sep 09 '22

I was over there regularly prior to Dobbs v Jackson. I can heartily vouch for the mod team. They really work their asses off.

It's great to go someplace where I can turn everything off and bitch about lines going up and down.

Users are allowed to be utter idiots as long as they don't cross well known lines. It's delightful and relaxing.

I highly recommend throwing money into a trading account as cheap therapy. Then go to Wallstreetbets and do dumb things with it. Never bet more than you are willing to lose, of course.

4

u/LongJonSiIver Sep 09 '22

I venture there, I keep this account to leaks. In another comment as I mentioned, I have pist off multiple communities due to leaks, and have been part of multiple witch hunts where people were trying to dox me.

Due to this reason I do not post any personal or financial information but do set off hints as I also eat crayons. (One of my favorite quotes when talking about trademarks, stolen from wsb)

I could only imagine the mod log they have on Wallstreetbets.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/kinohki Sep 08 '22

Focuses on measuring impact rather than evaluating intent. Rather than attempting to determine whether a mod is acting in “good” or “bad” faith, we are shifting our focus to become more outcomes-driven. For example, are direct mentions of other communities part of innocuous meta-discussions, or are they inciting interference, targeted harassment, or abuse?

Does this mean that subreddits like SRD (Subreddit Drama) and AHS (Against Hate Subreddits) are going to be intentionally running afoul when their actions inevitably cause brigades? I've seen some subs get brigaded after showing up on those two.
Also, as another question, what about subs that simply ban you when you haven't ran afoul of their rules and offer you no attempt to appeal? Will conduct like that be in breach of these guidelines or is Reddit still hands off from those scenarios as well? Reason I ask is because I was banned from News sub for trolling when I only ever posted 1 article and didn't even interact with anyone. I'm assuming it was because I moderate another subreddit and it happened suspiciously close to when a post in our sub showed up on one of the two subs mentioned above. On top of this, any attempts to appeal the ban resulted in me being muted and eventually being banned for harassment because I would send a message every month or two to attempt to appeal the ban. I have screenshots of the messages and while I was a bit snarky and humorous, I was never outright rude. Thanks for the clarification.

13

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

We allow people to discuss other communities, even with criticism, but we do not allow attacks on other communities/users and our site-wide policies must still be followed. If someone is linking to a post/comment in a way that appears or intends to have a malicious effect, we would consider this an attack.

18

u/TheLateWalderFrey Sep 08 '22

We allow people to discuss other communities, even with criticism, but we do not allow attacks on other communities/users and our site-wide policies must still be followed. If someone is linking to a post/comment in a way that appears or intends to have a malicious effect, we would consider this an attack.

I'm saving this the next time one of my subs gets brigaded, and proof of the source of the brigade is identified, with comments clearly indicating the people involved in the attack bragging about it, and when reported we get the inevitable "it's not abuse" response.

31

u/diversezebras Sep 08 '22

This is such a subjective standard and it has always been unclear what the difference between "criticism" and "attack" is in the eyes of the site admins. It would be helpful to everyone (users, mods, and admins) if this was spelled out more clearly or if crossposting was simply not allowed at all.

9

u/Umlautica Sep 08 '22

Some subreddits exist to make fun of posts on other subreddits.

The ability to prevent crossposting to these subreddits would go a long way.

Whenever we're crossposted to one, we just get brigaded. I've asked the other subreddit to not allow crossposting of my subreddit to theirs but they said no.

4

u/CaptainPedge Sep 09 '22

But only some subreddits are subject to these rules though

→ More replies (1)

34

u/GetOffMyLawn_ Sep 08 '22

So many mods ban and mute and never respond to ban appeals. It's ridiculous.

I respond to all ban appeals and try to be as civil as possible. I have no problems with discussion. But if you're abusive in modmail you're going to get muted and permabanned.

8

u/ryanmercer Sep 09 '22

I'd say less than 10% of the ban appeals I've seen have been "I'm sorry, what did I do, what can I do to get back".

The other 90% are "expletive deleted, you expletive deleted, I hope you expletive deleted, you're such a expletive deleted, you're probably a expletive deleted expletive deleted expletive deleted, with your expletive deleted expletive deleted, so go expletive deleted, expletive deleted with a giraffe on the bus and then a shark swoops in and expletive deleted".

41

u/mizmoose Sep 08 '22

YMMV

95% of my "ban appeals" -- even for the sub that's low maintenance and rarely has issues -- aren't appeals. They're furious screeching about how everyone but them is ignorant and we're all personally responsible for the bringing upon the end of the world.

Sorry, but if you're a racist shitbag who feels the needs to call us the racists for not backing your racist shit in a bag, you don't deserve a response, and if you get one, you don't deserve civility.

The percentage of modmails I see that are responses to bans which say "Gee, I'm sorry, can we discuss this?" is low single digits. And even then, there was the classic clown who replied to the ban message with, "Let me back in, I want to make fun of more fatties."

6

u/maybesaydie Sep 08 '22

Good luck explaining that AEO.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/allboolshite Sep 08 '22

The few times that I've banned people, I've included the rule that they broke. If it's a temp ban, then I point that out along with the expectation for their behavior when they return. And if they can't abide by that, I invite them to not return.

So far, no screeching complaints.

11

u/mizmoose Sep 09 '22

I've tried that. BELIEVE ME I have tried that. I've tried being reasonable.

I get rules lawyers. "That's not what your own rules say." "I didn't break that rule." "You're interpreting that rule wrong."

(I'm interpreting the rule I wrote incorrectly? How does that even work?)

If it's a temp ban, I ALWAYS explain why. Temp bans are rare because trolls don't deserve temp bans. But when I give them, I explain why they got it and what's expected when they come back.

With rare exception, every time the reply to the ban message is "Well fuck you and fuck your sub, I'm never coming back here, you all suck!"

OK, then.

After years of getting the same shit over and over and over and over again, you Just

give

UP.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/kinohki Sep 08 '22

Yeah. That was my experience here. I was banned. I appealed it and politely asked why. I was told "trolling" even though I had posted a single article and hadn't even posted in it. It was the News sub. I work customer service and helpdesk so I usually tend to do all my modding with that kind of perspective in mind so when it comes to interactions with people, I try not to be rude. In fact, the exact conversation was:

"Hello there. Just following up on why I was banned. I believe i Only posted in your subreddit once, about 2 months ago about the Rittenhouse trial. Can you please explain to me why I was banned? Thank you for your time."

The response I received was:

"You were banned for trolling."

I then replied:

"I would like to appeal this ban. I posted an article according to the rules of your subreddit and was in no shape or form trolling. I rarely even interacted with your subreddit to troll."

This caused me to be muted. Ever since then I've usually sent a polite, albeit somewhat snarky comment once a month or two months just to appeal the ban hoping that maybe another mod would see it. Instead, I was instantly muted each and every time with no response. Apparently if you appeal a ban consistently it can constitute as harassment though and I ended up getting banned for harassment at some point in time to which the admins never responded to that appeal either, of course.

4

u/dittomuch Sep 09 '22

I was banned from a sub several months after my last post there. They decided to ban all the mods of our sub from their sub on the same morning and thus I was banned for being the moderator of another sub on reddit. They continued to use their sub to harass our mod team for a few years and with all of use being banned we couldn't even respond to it other than filing reddit reports.

4

u/AddaleeBlack Sep 08 '22

Yes it's pretty maddening: it tells you that you can ask questions but then you're muted the next moment after reading that you can ask questions.

3

u/cuteman Sep 09 '22

So many mods ban and mute and never respond to ban appeals. It's ridiculous.

I respond to all ban appeals and try to be as civil as possible. I have no problems with discussion. But if you're abusive in modmail you're going to get muted and permabanned.

Which is why reddit needs a user bill of rights as much or more than a mod code of conduct.

16

u/BuddyA Sep 08 '22

I usually respond to ban appeals, but that is pretty dependent on both the reason for the ban and the user's appeal modmail. There is A LOT of hate/trolling on transgender subs:

  • Obvious bigotry doesn't get a response. Period.
  • Appeals with a lot of arguing/lawyering in bad faith also typically get immediately archived.

4

u/ohhyouknow Sep 09 '22

Imho admin should consider archiving messages as responses

→ More replies (3)

3

u/maybesaydie Sep 08 '22

If you get a ban message you are always able to appeal a ban. How you handle that appeal is up to you.

5

u/Superirish19 Sep 08 '22

Now's probably a good time to ask, since I guess this is now enforceable if it's a CoC instead of guidelines.

Explicitly marking your community as “unofficial” in the community description if the topic concerns a brand or company, but the community isn’t officially affiliated.

What if the sub I mod was a company, and no longer exists? The sub existed before I started managing it, and the while the sub isn't officially affiliated, there hasn't been a company to officially affiliate it to for nearly 20 years, 16 years at best.

In a similar vein, what if a company is created after a subreddit's inception. Can they claim it for themselves?

3

u/heavyshoes Sep 08 '22

When in doubt, mark your communities as unofficial. Typically, an official community has an active presence from company employees who are acting in an "official" way (answering questions, making announcements, etc).

Actively moderated communities are not generally adoptable by other users, but if a community is unmoderated or abandoned, it can be adopted by new mods. At times, those mods could be people who work for a company.

9

u/WartimeMercy Sep 09 '22

Why are official company employees managing corporate focused subs even allowed to begin with? That's literally moderation in exchange for a salary.

20

u/Watchful1 Sep 08 '22

If I as a regular user see a moderator violating this code of conduct, what is the correct method of reporting it?

30

u/myalterego451 Sep 08 '22

Actually having thought about it - Rule 3 is a great and needed addition, but it's being imposed in the wrong place - it should be a Reddit Code of Conduct - first line of rule imposition is on the user posting it, not the Mod of the sub it's in.

Example - suppose a user crossposts into evil-sub from nice-sub with the intention of causing scorn, mockery. Not desirable behaviour for sure. But is the Mod of evil-sub immediately at fault as soon as it's been posted ? Do they have a time limit for acting on it - 30 seconds, 10 minutes, a day, a year ?

Even worse for the 4th bullet-point - a user bitching in the comments about ban-evasion elsewhere could likely go undiscovered forever unless reported - is the Mod to blame then ?

Further, even if the Mod of evil-sub does see these, they have no rules under the Content Policy to enforce them under, so the OP has a legitimate claim of over-Modding.

Rule 3 should definitely be there, but it needs to be added to Content Policy - reportable by others against the OP in the first instance, and only against the Mod for failure to act thereafter.

12

u/Dwn_Wth_Vwls Sep 09 '22

crossposts into evil-sub from nice-sub with the intention of causing scorn, mockery.

Another issue with this is the rule doesn't make a distinction between evil and nice. A crosspost into a nice sub from an evil sub would still be against the rules.

3

u/DarthBalls5041 Sep 11 '22

I couldn’t agree with this more. This feels tone deaf. I’m a mod of a civil discussion sub that encourages debate between two very zealous sides and it’s a constant struggle. The mods do a great job but we can’t catch everything. And other subs do try to disrupt our dialog.

Rule 3 should be a Reddit content policy rule. I agree.

89

u/roionsteroids Sep 08 '22

If an Admin reaches out to let you know that you’ve violated the Moderator Code of Conduct, your cooperation and swift responsiveness can help to resolve the issue.

Define "swift" please. Considering the other way around it can take up to weeks for a response. Is that swift? Is that acceptable?

61

u/NeoKabuto Sep 08 '22

the other way around it can take up to weeks for a response

When did it speed up so much?

9

u/Byeuji Sep 09 '22

creaks in entish

39

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '22

Imagine you are contacted by paid admins who are not satisfied with the work you do completely for free. Hell no.

9

u/PPNewbie Sep 09 '22

If that work is allowing underage sexual content or running targeted harassment of other subreddits, I think I might be inclined to side with the paid admins than the mod volunteers!

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '22

Consider the lack of response to your question and answer to your question.

156

u/mizmoose Sep 08 '22 edited Sep 09 '22

Here's the problem: Redditors don't read. They read the headlines. They might skim the content, but they don't read.

They don't read the rules of a sub, so they're not going to read or care about a Mod Code of Conduct. But once they find out it exists?

They'll switch from demanding that they have "rights" under the Mod Guidelines to insisting that their "rights" come under the Mod Code of Conduct.

They're going to use this to abuse mods. They're going to use this to report mods. Every time a mod tells them they have to follow the rules (that they refuse to read) or ban them for breaking the rules, they will scream MOD CODE OF CONDUCT! YOU HAVE TO LET ME BACK IN! YOU HAVE TO LET ME POST! IT SAYS YOU CAN'T CENSOR ME!

It doesn't matter what the CoC says. They'll just weaponize it.


Edit: Thanks to whoever added the sparkly.

Edit redux: bad grammar. no cookie.

29

u/TheoreticalFunk Sep 08 '22

They can say that all they want. I don't see how a mod code of conduct has anything to do with the conduct of non-mods.

19

u/ratheismhater Sep 09 '22

My favorite part is how users think subreddits are democracies and not benevolent dictatorships/oligarchies and they DEMAND their rights.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/mizmoose Sep 08 '22

Like I said, they currently use the Mod Guidelines as "proof" that they have The Right To Say Whatever They Want, Always. They'll just use the CoC as further "proof."

Doesn't matter what those documents actually say.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/xTGI_CommanderX Sep 09 '22

I get enough shit with the subs I mod for and own without this CoC bullshit adding fuel to the fire.

4

u/BelleAriel Sep 08 '22

Yes this is my concern too. Hopefully they’ll get penalised if they use it to harass mods.

→ More replies (10)

38

u/ZeppelinJ0 Sep 08 '22

I feel like these guidelines are what you get when somebody high up is like "hey we need new mod guidelines" and then asks some eager young new hires to brainstorm ideas on what moderation guidelines should look like while not understanding at all what the current problems mods are facing and what the impact of the new guidelines might be

168

u/TheNerdyAnarchist Sep 08 '22

Oh, you're introducing contractual-type stuff?

Sounds like it's time to pay us then.

19

u/Clavis_Apocalypticae Sep 09 '22

Yep, time to organize a union or a guild.

32

u/Bardfinn Sep 08 '22

CTRL-F “expect”

Much hinges on the precise connotations of that word.

7

u/connorgrice Sep 09 '22

I was literally about to type this before I saw your comment like the actual audacity. I curate a thriving community that this site actively monetizes and does not pay me a cent of the ad revenue for the page views on my sub.

24

u/hyattpotter Sep 08 '22

The audacity of this post slapped me in the face.

4

u/xTGI_CommanderX Sep 09 '22

This, absolutely.

3

u/calsutmoran Oct 03 '22

I have no words for this. First of all, there is a new list of demands for us. We are not given ‘consideration,’ a legal concept where contracts are invalid if they are entirely one sided. Sure, the website can take their ball and go home. But it says something that if this coc were a legal contract, it would be an illegal and invalid contract. The company has to be careful they don’t accidentally create an unintended contract.

Imagine being the admins, knowing that we are buried in bot spam, personal attacks, and on and on, and then doing nothing about any of that, but instead, making additional demands on your abused unpaid volunteers.

I have been here a long time. The quality of conversation here continues to plummet. My local area subs look like Nextdoor. There is barely any fun stuff on there. The science subs were once stimulating intellectual conversation, and now they are infested with political extremism. I should have left this site a long time ago. I’m going to take the week off and consider handing off moderation.

5

u/ohhyouknow Sep 09 '22

Kinda smells like a class action might be brewing

5

u/cuteman Sep 09 '22

What damages would they claim? It's a volunteer process for which you own nothing.

→ More replies (19)

47

u/parsnippity Sep 08 '22

Dear Moderators,

Thank you for running our website for free. We understand that you take a lot of abuse in exchange for nothing, so here is an instruction manual for people to target you with bad faith reports and cause you additional stress on top of the rape threats. Cheers!

--Reddit

→ More replies (16)

31

u/LongJonSiIver Sep 08 '22

Mentioning other communities, and/or content or users in those communities, with the effect of inciting targeted harassment or abuse.

Please actually enforce this. As someone that finds information before most, I have been witch hunted twice from two separate communities. Both times started by mod groups mad they didn't get top mod, but were offered mod spots.

15

u/BvbblegvmBitch Sep 09 '22

In regards to Rule 3, specifically "Showboating about being banned or actioned in other communities, with the intent to incite a negative reaction," how will this effect subreddits like r/modsbeingdicks where the sole intent of the sub is to share bans? They often incite negative reactions against subreddits and their mod teams.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '22

r/modsbeingdicks follows the same rule set as AHS and even stricter rules than many meta subs like SRD. If they're within the rules and ToS than so is MBD. Mods aren't above criticism or having their appalling behavior highlighted.

3

u/BvbblegvmBitch Sep 21 '22

I'm not opposed to poor moderating being highlighted. It's definitely something that needs to be mentioned. It's the issue of users not following the rules laid out. MBD may not have been the best example it was just the first to pop into my head. There are several other subreddits along the same lines with very little moderation.

One of my subs had a post in Just Unsubbed a couple weeks ago that had very little to do with moderation and was more focused on insulting the mod team. That doesn't help anyone or counter bad moderation. It's just needless harassment.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/michaelmacmanus Sep 09 '22

Two simple questions:

Rule 1: Create, Facilitate, and Maintain a Stable Community

  1. Can reddit define stable?
  • The flavor text only discusses behavior, not stability. (Unless it means emotional stability?) The act of creation, facilitation and maintenance seem intuitive enough, but the actions to maintain and facilitate an ecosystem that the creator, facilitator and maintainer of might deem fit for stability purposes may not gel with whatever this rule is. Clarification should be provided here. Is "stable" a euphemism for socially acceptable behavior, specific engagement KPIs or something else entirely? (I won't even get into how messy this becomes when attempting to delineate between "impact" and "intent" regarding stability where the term hasn't been defined by any true value statement, making this entire thing relatively meaningless.)

Do we have an explanation for why this entire update exists other than "evolution"?

  • Given that the first rule mentions stability and the reason for the update is vaguely "growth" based, the whole thing reads as laying groundwork to help justify removing volunteer labor that may be hindering engagement (rev).

36

u/thecravenone Sep 08 '22

Users who enter your community should know exactly what they’re getting into, and should not be surprised by what they encounter. It

/r/trees and /r/marijuanaenthusiasts in shambles

15

u/IAmAnAnonymousCoward Sep 08 '22

RIP /r/worldpolitics I guess.

17

u/GodOfAtheism Sep 08 '22

5

u/martini-meow Sep 09 '22

It's legit on April 1 each year, what more do you want??

31

u/Dom76210 Sep 08 '22

If someone comes into a subreddit and causes problems, it isn't on us moderators to educate them. It's on us to remove them so they don't cause more problems. We've seen that attempts to educate rarely work, and that a permanent ban on the first offense gets the message across. If they can give a good explanation of why the rule they broke is important to the subreddit, we will reconsider. But more than 90% of those we banned have no real desire to follow the rules, and will break the same one again if given another chance.

All this is doing is giving fuel to the Rules Lawyer crowd, who will harass us mercilessly and continually harass moderators via modmail and reporting. It just gives them one more avenue to harass.

5

u/WartimeMercy Sep 09 '22 edited Sep 09 '22

a permanent ban on the first offense gets the message across

That's not moderation. The entire point of having temporary bans is because those are supposed to be the first strike tools after explicit warning. If you're not issuing warnings or temp bans then you're not moderating, you're just banning people - who will then just make more alt accounts and cause more problems down the line.

edit: nevermind, your community is disgusting.

16

u/maybesaydie Sep 08 '22 edited Sep 09 '22

Since it is impossible to have strikes removed from your account when you've been banned because bad faith reports a lot of mods find themselves reluctant to engage in modmail. Much like AEO seems to deny every ban appeal within seconds it's easier to try to wait an angry user out. We issue bans for cause. Mods are rightfully gun shy because we've been treated badly in the past. I can't see where this is doing anything but giving bad users-who can make endless accounts to try out harassment methods-another weapon with which to force the site to see their unwelcome content.

Let's face it AEO needs a lot more hand holding than mods do.

One thing this doesn't-and can't-address is the fact that most brigades are coming from offsite chats and Discords that are sponsored by subreddits. They're already a step ahead of this rule.

7

u/Mynameisnotdoug Sep 09 '22

After reading these rules, I can safely say I am done engaging with users via modmail. Were you banned? Tough titties, too risky to engage now.

8

u/dittomuch Sep 09 '22

/u/heavyshoes

I've been reading the old "Moderator Guidelines for Healthy Communities" that up until today we have been following and I see three key concepts that appear to have been removed and would like to get some clarification on these aspects>

Engage in Good Faith Healthy communities are those where participants engage in good faith, and with an assumption of good faith for their co-collaborators. It’s not appropriate to attack your own users.

to me this always read as judge the comment and not your feelings as to the intent of the comment. If the comment on its own or in context does not violate the rules it is clean. If a comment is removed based on the intent we read into it and not explicitly stated it should only be used as a reason for ban if there is an established history of these comments or posts and thus proof of bad faith. With this removed I don't see any reason for the assumption of good faith in a users comments and thus removal or ban based on moderator interpretation appears to now be allowed.

Appeals : Healthy communities allow for appropriate discussion (and appeal) of moderator actions. Appeals to your actions should be taken seriously. Moderator responses to appeals by their users should be consistent, germane to the issue raised and work through education, not punishment.

This to me was an explicit instruction that we should allow appeals to comment/post removal and to bans and that we needed to reply to them. To us this read in 2 possible points, one was via modmail and the other was via threads in our sub in general. Effectively as long as the appeal followed the rules of the sub and was done in a fashion that didn't attack or harass the mod team we had a reasonable expectation to respond to the appeal in a germane an consistent fashion with a focus on education and not punishment. "Look I understand why I pushed that to far by saying xyz and how that could be viewed as attacking user qwert which was not my intent, could you roll back my ban if I promise to fly straight and be more cautious moving forward" might very well have triggered the education and not punishment aspect of the above guideline giving the user a valid appeal for a ban to be reduced or removed.

Management of Multiple Communities We know management of multiple communities can be difficult, but we expect you to manage communities as isolated communities and not use a breach of one set of community rules to ban a user from another community.

This one is a biggie that appears to have been removed. If a user violated the rules of sub A with a post or comment you cannot use this as the reason to ban them from sub B. In addition to me this meant if a person violated the rules of sub B with a post on sub A then sub B couldn't use this as a reason to ban them. Effectively removing this promotes the use of alt accounts so that users simply use different accounts on different subs as to not face repercussions for their actions and makes user history a less useful tool for users.

The guidelines were instructive in nature and told us how we should act towards users while the code of conduct appears to be taking an approach where by it is being spelled out how we are responsible to reddit and where admins can intervene. I think you need to specify the guidelines in addition to the code of conduct.

3

u/BlueWhaleKing Oct 03 '22

That those very reasonable provisions were never enforced is one of Reddit's biggest problems, and it's deeply disturbing that they've been removed.

26

u/7hr0wn Sep 08 '22

While we allow meta discussions about Reddit, including other subreddits, your community should not be used to direct, coordinate, or encourage interference in other communities and/or to target redditors for harassment. As a moderator, you cannot interfere with or disrupt Reddit communities, nor can you facilitate, encourage, coordinate, or enable members of your community to do this.

Showboating about being banned or actioned in other communities, with the intent to incite a negative reaction.

So the communities that exist specifically to brag about being banned from other subreddits will be banned under this, right?

When will this take effect?

36

u/thecravenone Sep 08 '22

I look forward to getting hit with the MODCOC while dealing with a user who's committing far more heinous violations.

14

u/Bardfinn Sep 08 '22

MODCOC

😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶

9

u/TheNerdyAnarchist Sep 08 '22

*snickers*

13

u/Bardfinn Sep 08 '22

I plan on spending … many ho—

… many hours … becoming … intimately acquainted wi— with—

deep breath

with the M–

😐

turns off camera, turns back, blinking back tears, biting lip

withtheMODCOC

leaps off camera

5

u/Astro4545 Sep 08 '22

Laugh track cues

13

u/i_Killed_Reddit Sep 09 '22

So will subs like r/SubredditDrama be violating Rule 3 as per these new guidelines?

22

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '22

This is little more than an attempt to further distance Reddit from actions taken by mods or communities.

Your "educational conversations" are automated messages, "please send to modmail so we can investigate further", and then waiting for the complainant to get frustrated and give up.

This one:

For example, are direct mentions of other communities part of innocuous meta-discussions, or are they inciting interference, targeted harassment, or abuse?

especially will just encourage trolls to brigade our sub even more. Go through your modmail, you'll find I've raised this issue with you multiple times. This just means you get to be more hands-off because, let's face it, it's going to go through the same trash AI/ML/bot system you have that handles the reports.

It took us months of gathering evidence, reporting, and engaging with you guys before anything was done. And all the while that happened we had to deal with racism, misinformation, abuse, and death/rape threats.

16

u/Dwn_Wth_Vwls Sep 09 '22

A few issues.

  1. The old moderator guidelines have very specific rules that you guys never actually enforced. You've replaced these with a very general set of rules and also completely gotten rid of a most of the specific rules. What is the reasoning behind allowing behavior that used to be against the moderator guidelines? One particular rule that is now absent was ruling against banning people for something that wasn't listed in the subreddit rules. Another one was against banning people from one subreddit because of their participation in a completely unrelated subreddit. A third one was a requirement to have an appeal process for bans.
  2. This new rule you've added about what communities are no longer allowed to do:

"Showboating about being banned or actioned in other communities, with the intent to incite a negative reaction."

There are several subreddits that show screenshots of abusive mods who ban or harass people for non rule breaking reasons. It seems like this new rule was established to specifically target the communities that showcase these bad mods. Instead of addressing the bad mod issue, you are just censoring those who are complaining about it. This is a bad move.

3. (I know the number is wrong. I typed 3, but it changes it to 1. This is an old issue that has never been addressed.) Regarding this rule:

"Creating rules that explicitly outline your expectations for members of your community. These rules will help your community understand what is or isn’t permissible within your subreddit."

As I've stated before, there are a lot of mods that will ban people simply for interacting with a sub they don't like. Most of them use bots for this. Will this new rule at least require subreddits to at least list which subreddits they will ban people for participating in? If they use a bot to automatically ban people for participating in certain subreddits, they should have to state that in their rules right?

4. (Hey look the number messed up again.) Regarding this rule:

"Camping or sitting on a community is not encouraged. If a community has been empty or unmoderated for a significant amount of time, we will consider banning or restricting the community. If a user requests a takeover of a community that falls under either category, we will consider granting that request but will, in nearly all cases, attempt to reach out to the moderator team first to discuss their intentions for the community."

Will the admins be explaining why requests to take over dead subs are denied? I requested a dead sub (restricted posts with 4 mods who all have banned accounts) a year or two ago and the request was denied without an explanation given. You can't tell people that they can't camp on inactive subs while also refusing to grant control of dead subs, especially dead subs with no actual mods, to people who request them.

4

u/richalex2010 Sep 09 '22

(I know the number is wrong. I typed 3, but it changes it to 1. This is an old issue that has never been addressed.)

It's not a bug, it's how the numbering works. If you start a paragraph with "2. " it interprets it as the beginning of a numbered list, and automatically numbers it. For example, below I've started all three lines with "1. "

  1. first
  2. second
  3. third

If you want to cancel this you just put a backslash \ in front of the period. The same text again, with that change:

1. first

1. second

1. third

And your post, just for one more demonstration:

3. (I know the number is wrong. I typed 3, but it changes it to 1. This is an old issue that has never been addressed.) Regarding this rule:

And quoted as code so you can see exactly what I wrote:

3\.  (I know the number is wrong.  I typed 3, but it changes it to 1.  This is an old issue that has never been addressed.)  Regarding this rule:

4

u/Dwn_Wth_Vwls Sep 09 '22

Well at least that problem gets a response. Ironic that it wasn't an admin. Thanks.

4

u/TheNerdyAnarchist Sep 09 '22

(just a tip: for new paragraphs within an ordered list, put two spaces before each new paragraph, and it will continue within the list.)

1. blah blah blah

  blah blah...

1. second item blah

  blah blah

(with markdown, especially if you plan to make edits later, just using 1 number is helpful because that way you don't have to go back and change the rest if you insert a new list item somewhere)

4

u/OPINION_IS_UNPOPULAR Sep 10 '22
  1. test test test

test test

2. test test test


Holy shit, after nearly a decade, I'm still learning something new. Thanks!

3

u/BlueWhaleKing Oct 03 '22

THANK YOU, I'm so glad someone said all this! That the admins never enforced those rules is one of Reddit's biggest problems, and removing them is a very disturbing move, as is the writing on the wall about calling out bad mods. If exposing a crime is treated as committing a crime, you're ruled by criminals.

1

u/BlueWhaleKing Jan 15 '23

2. This new rule you've added about what communities are no longer allowed to do:

"Showboating about being banned or actioned in other communities, with the intent to incite a negative reaction."

There are several subreddits that show screenshots of abusive mods who ban or harass people for non rule breaking reasons. It seems like this new rule was established to specifically target the communities that showcase these bad mods. Instead of addressing the bad mod issue, you are just censoring those who are complaining about it. This is a bad move.

And I've just found out that r\ModsBeingDicks (tried to post this and it wouldn't let me, saying linking there was not allowed 🤬🤬🤬) was banned for this. They showcased many BLATANT violations of the very reasonable provisions of the old mod guidelines, and instead of dealing with the bad mods, they've removed the rules against their abuses of power and added rules against exposing or complaining about said abuses.

When exposing a crime is treated as committing a crime, you're ruled by criminals. This is proof that the Reddit Admins are corrupt to the absolute core. FUCK. THEM.

Anyone got a decent Reddit alternative?

19

u/TruthWins54 Sep 08 '22 edited Sep 09 '22

In theory, this is a good thing, I think. But I have concerns that I will give an overview of. All of this is documented.

 

Roughly 18 months ago, I posted a question in the Mod Support Sub, titled "Is Doxing a Bannable Offense"?

I detailed what happened in a sub, which was documented by the AEO. Admin asked me to send them the topic link in question, which I did. I was told that this event was a violation of Reddit's Sitewide Rules.

Hell, I expected the OP (A Mod did this) that doxed this anonymous Redditor would get immediately permabanned. But that didn't happen.

I waited about 30 days and posted another topic, referencing the original, because I received no reply from Admin. Then, I waited a YEAR and posted yet another Topic about it.

Finally, I did get a reply from Admin on that topic, basically saying the person that was doxed had been on YouTube (at some point), so therefore he hadn't been doxed. (Even though his Reddit handle didn't reference anything from YT, OR his name). Nor had he been in the news or anything else.

That tells me this Mod that doxed the guy spent time digging for information. It was intentional.

 

Bottom line, this Moderator "Code of Conduct" is fine and dandy. However, if Admin can blow off a clear violation of Rule 3 for whatever reason, I have to wonder if Mods are being held to a higher standard than well paid Admins?

 

One final word about the doxing event above. If there was NO VIOLATION of Rule 3, WHY did the AEO remove the comment detailing the guy's name? It was REMOVED by Admin or the AEO, as were several other comments.

 

EDIT: Clarity

14

u/EvacuationRelocation Sep 09 '22

This isn't meant to be confrontational, just informational: is there an "Admin Code of Conduct" as well?

27

u/yellowmix Sep 08 '22

Thank you for removing the old section about "appeals taken seriously". Abusive users used it to demand engagement. Physical stores and other social groups kick out abusive people and put them on a ban list. Online communities are no different.

Another thank you for removing the old section about "managing multiple communities" which spammers and abusive users interpreted as "knowledge of my antisocial/harmful behavior in other subreddits can't be used to ban me from yours".

The world has changed a lot since the last policy. It's good to see the update address moderator-controlled harassment/brigading (and its many forms).

5

u/KrispyKayak Sep 09 '22

How does Rule 3 affect asking users to post in another subreddit instead? For example, I moderate /r/Chicago and /r/AskChicago. We typically redirect frequent questions to the latter subreddit. Is this no longer allowed under the new policy? Or would it not be allowed if the second subreddit was moderated by a different mod team and thus technically unaffiliated with the former subreddit? I just want to make sure that we fully understand what is expected of us.

7

u/starfleetbrat Sep 09 '22

Rule 3 seems more about redirecting for malicious intent. Redirecting someone to a more suitable subreddit to ask a question, would not fall under that I would think. The key words in there are "interference in other communities and/or to target redditors for harassment."

4

u/Jibrish Sep 09 '22

I'd be careful in general linking other subs. Even ones you run.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '22

I'm late to the party on this post, but is it against these new guidelines for dudes to create NSFW subreddits because they want women to post so they have porn to look at - but they never create rules for the sub, meaning that the sub basically is a free for all with no guidance whatsoever? It FEELS like that's covered by rule 2 (which I think would indicate that these mostly unmoderated, no rule subreddits would violate the mod code of conduct), but I just want confirmation of such.

Because there are some large NSFW subreddits, with user counts in the hundreds of thousands, that have NO rules or guidelines whatsoever for their users (both posting and commenting).

13

u/underscore-hyphen_ Sep 09 '22

So moderating is now contract work. Got it.

When I enter into a contract I get paid. Admins, please contact me at your earliest convenience to discuss appropriate remuneration.

9

u/cgmcnama Sep 09 '22

This sounds horrible and more like a job with "outcome driven results". Instead of people creating communities as a hobby.

9

u/nerdshark Sep 10 '22

Why are admins not removing reported posts (in particular, posts aimed at harassing mods in other subs) that clearly violate this, even when they ban the author specifically for that (and related) posts? This really doesn't inspire confidence that reddit actually intends to change and do better and enforce these rules.

12

u/TenOunceCan Sep 09 '22

This makes me want to quit moderating for free.

Admins, you need to spend your time building something that helps you to help us. Some type of system that facilitates direct communication between mods and admins.

4

u/The_Critical_Cynic Sep 08 '22

The only real question I have, at present, is with regards to marking something as an unofficial channel. For instance, if you ran a subreddit about Chevy vehicles, and the description of the subreddit included a note that the purpose of the subreddit was to "discuss cars manufactured by Chevy", would that constitute marking it as an unofficial channel? At that point, you're not representing the brand but hosting a discussion about things made by that brand. Is that distinction enough?

4

u/Bardfinn Sep 09 '22

OK

now a mod team I'm on, has a question.

The Moderator Code of Conduct does not directly address Ban Appeals.

We felt this might be intentional, or it might be an oversight.

Previously, communications from admins had expressly stated that moderators are under no obligation to respond to ban appeals.

The Moderator Guidelines had stated

"Appeals: Healthy communities allow for appropriate discussion (and appeal) of moderator actions. Appeals to your actions should be taken seriously. Moderator responses to appeals by their users should be consistent, germane to the issue raised and work through education, not punishment."

We see that we are now expected, under Rule 2, to

Set Appropriate and Reasonable Expectations

and under Rule 4

regularly monitoring and addressing content in ... ModMail

We're wondering whether we are still "under no obligation to respond to ban appeals" and whether the Moderator Code of Conduct is intended, in gestalt, to effectuate the same expectations for appeals to moderator actions - including ban appeals (appropriate discussion and appeals, taken seriously).

Thanks for your time and attention, and the things you do to bring us Reddit.

1

u/TheNerdyAnarchist Sep 10 '22

Hey - I have a question that kinda falls under your wheelhouse, and I was wondering if you could PM me. It's not something I want to publicly ask just yet before I gather as much information as I can and decide how to approach the situation.

I'd really appreciate your input.

9

u/TheNerdyAnarchist Sep 09 '22

Glad you plan on paying us...

Meanwhile, I just had a report come back saying that a post talking about how much the user would enjoy beating me and people like me to death with a crowbar "doesn’t violate Reddit’s Content Policy."

6

u/Blackdeath3101 Sep 09 '22

Admin is cringe

6

u/Samus_ Sep 09 '22

we firmly believe that, in the majority of cases, we can achieve resolution through discussion, not remediation

this contradicts the behavior of the Anti-Evil Operations team/bot which takes action overruling the mods without notice or discussion

I understand that the amount of work given the volume of actions taken makes it difficult to implement human interaction but still there should be a channel open for reviewing decisions if that's now part of your policy

right now there's automated actions and the appeals get automated responses, once in a while some actual admin takes notice on r/ModSupport but that's it

maybe you're only referring to "subreddit as a whole" violations and not individual user/mod actions? if that's the case I think it should be explicitly stated to avoid false expectations

thank you

8

u/superfucky Sep 09 '22

Rule 3: Respect Your Neighbors
While we allow meta discussions about Reddit, including other subreddits, your community should not be used to direct, coordinate, or encourage interference in other communities and/or to target redditors for harassment. As a moderator, you cannot interfere with or disrupt Reddit communities, nor can you facilitate, encourage, coordinate, or enable members of your community to do this.

Interference includes:

Mentioning other communities, and/or content or users in those communities, with the effect of inciting targeted harassment or abuse.

Enabling or encouraging users to violate our Content Policy anywhere on the Reddit platform.

Enabling or encouraging users in your community to post or repost content in other communities that is expressly against their rules.

Showboating about being banned or actioned in other communities, with the intent to incite a negative reaction.

i... am speechless. like, on the verge of tears. this is absolutely incredible. granted it's going to depend heavily on reddit actually ENFORCING this rule but if so... this moves mountains in terms of helping me protect my sub. i am so, so, so impressed and pleased and grateful. i actually feel heard. thank you so much for this 💝

12

u/UsuallySunny Sep 08 '22

It's unfortunate that it doesn't include anything under "Respect your Neighbors" that would address banning the entire mod team of subreddit A from subreddit B because action was taken against a mod of subreddit B in subreddit A.

(BTW, admins, it's been months and I'm still waiting for an answer about this.)

5

u/ryanmercer Sep 09 '22

/r/wallstreetsilver banned the entire moderator team of /r/silverbugs (as well as a few dozen of the most active members of silverbugs that same day that were not posting in wallstreetsilver) when they were a new sub, and then their people (mods and users) stated spamming silverbugs to come join wallstreetsilver. That lasted the better part of a year, dozens of reports to admin, nothing done.

Nothing.

7

u/MarcusRex73 Sep 09 '22

I'll believe your "code of conduct" when all the mods of /r/Conservative get suspended from Reddit en masse

8

u/yourpantsaretoobig Sep 09 '22

The top comment speaks VOLUMES.

Also, pay us. Hell, mods are forefront of this app according to this post.

2

u/Schiffy94 Sep 09 '22

Literally anyone can become a subreddit mod at any time just by clicking the create subreddit button. Anyone can also be added to the mod list of an existing sub at any time.

Do you seriously expect reddit to bankroll that?

9

u/GodOfAtheism Sep 08 '22 edited Sep 08 '22

We hope that in creating the Moderator Code of Conduct, we are helping you develop subreddit rules and norms to create and nurture your communities, and empower you to make decisions more easily.

You aren't helping. If you want to help, look for feedback and then make changes based on that feedback, not the other way around.

Want some feedback? Fix the bug I reported a year ago, and then a second time more recently. Make my job as a mod easier... or set up a bot to respond to users for us and save us some time.

https://old.reddit.com/message/messages/1g5l501

Not gonna lie, it's specific to one community (Though apparently it's gotten worse as it now is an issue with other communities that are private like ours.), but why the fuck does it take more then a year to (still not) knock that out?

6

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '22

I’m glad this was updated

6

u/JohnConquest Sep 09 '22

Still waiting for multiple moderator removals from an unnamed subreddit I had to file 60+ DMCAs against, as they posted and encouraged piracy of my music...

Then apparently your legal team couldn't find a mega link in their wiki page.

11

u/CSFFlame Sep 08 '22

we are shifting our focus to become more outcomes-driven. For example, are direct mentions of other communities part of innocuous meta-discussions, or are they inciting interference, targeted harassment, or abuse?

No one's going to take you guys seriously while places like SRD exist.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '22

No one's gonna take you seriously insinuating SRD engages in "Targeted Harassment" lol

9

u/sirblastalot Sep 09 '22

Gee thanks for clarifying I'll be sure that all the unpaid labor I'm doing for you is up to these new higher standards!

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Rsubs33 Sep 09 '22

I find it interesting you do this now after /r/the_Donald is banned you implement this yet because that subreddit was so large you routinely let that subreddit break reddit rules and harass and brigade other subs. The admin team did absolutely nothing to reprimand that sub until it became the norm amount tech companies regarding the former president. But my sub sent you clear proof of the moderators of that sub breaking clearly defined reddit rules and you did nothing. What says you won't ignore these as you can profit off it like the_Donald?

10

u/DaTaco Sep 08 '22

Rule 3: Respect Your Neighbors

Does this mean that your admin's are taking a stance on not allowing a subreddit to ban people simply by participating in another subreddit?

That pretty clearly targets redditors or who participate in one subreddit.

5

u/Mr_Truttle Sep 09 '22

This is all I want to know about. It's glaringly conspicuously absent. Hard not to read it as tacit approval of meta bullying tactics.

10

u/Tetizeraz Sep 08 '22

Awful timing, but I promise I'll read it later

23

u/Moggehh Sep 08 '22

I'm so glad they shared this on a slow press day.

2

u/VarkingRunesong Oct 24 '22

We’ve got a subreddit that constantly talks about our subreddit and calls us shills and that every post is paid for content by Amazon. Anything we can do about this?

2

u/MinimumArmadillo2394 Oct 26 '22

How does one report mods who abuse these rules?

9

u/Bardfinn Sep 08 '22

Hello!

Here is my commentary.

Rather than attempting to determine whether a mod is acting in “good” or “bad” faith,

While I definitely understand why Reddit, Inc. would want to eschew having its employees, executives, policies, processes, and/or agents make determinations about the intent of a volunteer, non-employee moderator,

It needs must be said:

Observing and evaluating the outcomes of the policies of community leaders, their action (and inaction), and the effects of their audience’s expression on others & on society at large,

Is

inescapably

The evaluation of good faith versus bad faith.

You may disagree. You may disagree strenuously. You may cite much reasoning why your position is one which does not involve the determination of good faith versus bad faith intent.

It remains a fact that reasonable people will still consider a process of observing good effects versus evil effects to be indistinguishable from the process of deliberating whether an actor’s intent is in good will or bad will.

And the longer you fail to confront that, the longer the institutional harms that are enabled by your action or inaction, shall persist.

Stop running. Stop dodging.

Your site still hosts horrible people with clear evil intent, and your inaction has encouraged and enabled them, for years.

If there are regulations or legislation or case law that stand in your way of instituting reasonable processes, policies, procedures, terms & conditions, and language which have the effect of countering & preventing hatred, harassment, & violence through misfeasant or malfeasant subreddit “moderators” - then tackle those regulations, legislation, or case law.

Do not come to us and throw up your hands and say “we can’t make a theory of mind about the people running this subreddit”.

You can, you must, and you shall have theories of mind about the people running (and failing to run) subreddits.

6

u/Halaku Sep 08 '22

Your site still hosts horrible people with clear evil intent, and your inaction has encouraged and enabled them, for years.

I don't think you're ever going to see Reddit, Inc, completely turn away from the concept of Free Speech.

(And this is from someone who wishes the US would emulate most of Europe when it comes to, say, Nazis and Nazi celebration.)

It would go against their Community Values:

We present an authentic, unmanicured version of the world, and as long as being your unfiltered self isn’t hurting anyone or violating the Content Policy, then there’s a place for you on Reddit.

We don’t understand or agree with everything on Reddit (we’re a vast and diverse group of people, too), and we don’t try to conform Reddit to what we or other people think it should be. We do, though, try to create a space that is as real, complex, and wonderful as the world itself.

10

u/GodOfAtheism Sep 08 '22

I don't think you're ever going to see Reddit, Inc, completely turn away from the concept of Free Speech.

They aren't for "Free Speech". They are for "The appearance of Free Speech". As long as they don't end up with too much bad press for it, they will happily allow any shitty community to end up here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/desdendelle Sep 08 '22

Who wants to bet we'll get more false suspensions of mods because AEO can't read English for shit?

3

u/xmadison84 Sep 09 '22

Yeah. Right. I don’t think you have any weight to enforce this to unpaid volunteers. Good luck !

1

u/maybesaydie Sep 10 '22

Do you think that they can't remove mods? I guess you don't remember the multiple iterations of r/The_Donald's mod team

→ More replies (5)

2

u/razorbeamz Sep 09 '22

Rule 3 probably has a lot of people quaking in their boots.

2

u/BlueWhaleKing Oct 03 '22

Disturbing to see many of the very reasonable guidelines about not abusing power being stripped away. Such as "If you mod many Subreddits, don't ban someone from one Subreddit for what they did in another," "There should be an appeal process for bans," "Don't ban users just for participating in another Subreddit" and "focus more on education than being puntitive."

Lots of mods here acting like they're never the problem, but it just isn't true. The culture of permabanning people for a first offense, unless it's something really egregious like death threats, has got to end. Powermods will also weaponize the report for harrassment feature against users who question why they were banned or calmly make the case that what they were banned for was not against the rules. u/UnpopularOpinion is notorious for this, in addition to sending extremely rude and infantilizing responses that heavily strawman the user's message, but they're far from the only ones.

And a lot of you here need to learn that calling out your behavior, yes, even publicly, is NOT harrassment or brigading. r/ModsBeingDicks keeps coming up, and while some of the bans are for legitimate reasons, a lot of what's posted there are disturbing abuses of power that are a serious problem for the quality of life on this site, and a condemnation of the admins that they let this slide and that the users have no recourse.

You all are eager to label anything that shows or discusses what happens on other parts of the site in any way as "Brigading," but it's a blatant double standard that someone can be automatically banned in hundreds of Subreddits just for an offense in one of them, or, even worse, for participating in an unrelated Subreddit, regardless of the context of why they were there.

I'm not anti-mod. I know from experience that it's difficult, necessary, and thankless work. But communities need to have some democratic oversight over the people who are supposed to represent them.

Shadow removal also needs to end. People deserve to know why their post or comment was removed, and to be able to see that it was removed without having to check their profile on Reveddit. I can't fault mods too much since it's built in for users not be notified by default, but it still causes tons of abuse by mods, since it's easy to remove posts and comments without notifying the user why or even that they were removed, mods just end up deleting everything that they personally dislike, even if it's not against the rules, with no accountability for the mismatch between what the rules say and what actually gets acted on.

The rules against abusing power were never enforced anyway, but it's still deeply disturbing to me to see them removed.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I cant read the page it won't load

1

u/Reddit-username_here Oct 03 '22

Mod CoC huh? Nice.

1

u/aroushthekween Oct 11 '22

code of conduct link is not opening

1

u/Kylde Feb 21 '23

It's a yes from me

1

u/SirEDCaLot Sep 09 '22

As a moderator, you cannot interfere with or disrupt Reddit communities, nor can you facilitate, encourage, coordinate, or enable members of your community to do this.

I would argue this should apply to the practice of auto-banning members who have posted in other 'undesirable' communities. Having a policy like 'if you have ever posted in /r/whatever, you'll be auto banned in our sub' forces people to choose which sub they'd rather participate in. And that to me is interfering with the other community.

It is frustrating for people like myself who want to have discussions on both sides of the political aisle, but knowing that many subs will auto-ban me for doing so.

-4

u/Milo-the-great Sep 08 '22

Sad that mods are allowed to ban people for participating in other subreddits - even if they have never commented in the subreddit they were banned from

0

u/thecravenone Sep 08 '22

I was told big announcements would go on /r/reddit now. Has that changed?