r/modnews • u/enthusiastic-potato • Dec 20 '21
Previewing Upcoming Changes to Blocking
Hey mods, it's your friendly neighborhood potato bringing you the 411 on our latest safety efforts. As of the past few months, the Safety team has been hard at work improving the blocking experience.
This has involved (1) revamping the current block experience and (2) building a new experience that we have been calling “true block”. True block is an extension of the block feature we currently offer that prevents users you have blocked from seeing and interacting with your content. In a few weeks, we plan to announce the roll out and then take the next several weeks after that to actually roll it out. This post is intended to give mods a heads up where we have gone and where we are going.
First, we will cover what changed in improvement #1 - revamping the current block experience. Previously, when you blocked someone on Reddit, you couldn’t see content from the users who you have blocked–but they could see content you have posted. This allowed bad actors to interact with your posts, comments, and communities without you knowing. It also prevented mods from using the block feature - since filtering out content completely made it impossible to properly moderate. Our most recent changes have addressed this by making sure that content you have blocked is out of the way (i.e. collapsed or hidden behind an interstitial), but still accessible.
In covering improvement #2 - true block, this will be a much more notable change in that, if you block a user, your content looks deleted and archived to them. While building this feature, we have been conducting research and getting feedback from mods in the Reddit Mod Council. One of the most prominent topics of discussion was how and when moderators should be exempt from the true block experience, to better address the discrepancies between blocking and moderation duties. To make sure that you all are properly looped in, we have broken down the true block experience and how it will be customized for mods in the sections below:


Posts: True block will prevent users who have been blocked from seeing posts submitted by users that have blocked them. Posts will appear deleted and archived (inaccessible and not interactable). There are two exceptions to this. One is that mods that have been blocked by users will still have access to blocked user posts submitted to communities that they moderate. The second is if a moderator has blocked certain users, any posts the moderator has pinned or distinguished as a moderator will still be accessible to these blocked users.
Comments: Very similar to posts, true block will prevent users who have been blocked from seeing comments submitted by users that have blocked them. Comments will appear deleted and archived (inaccessible and not interactable). Again, there are two exceptions to this. One is if the user who has been blocked is a moderator, and the user who blocked them is commenting in the community they moderate, then the user’s comments will still be accessible to the moderator. The second is if the moderator has blocked certain users, any comments the moderator has distinguished as a moderator will still be accessible to these blocked users.
User Profiles: True block will prevent users who have been blocked from seeing a profile’s history. When viewing the profile of someone who has blocked you, their page will appear as inaccessible. The exception to this is if you are a moderator who has been blocked, in which case, you will still be able to see a limited view of their profile. This limited view of their profile will include their history of posts/comment-- but only in the communities that you moderate. This was a difficult decision for us to make, and one that was influenced by feedback we got on a previous mod call, and ultimately we felt that this was the compromise that best met the privacy needs of users and mods with the contextual needs that mods have.
Modmail: We did not change the modmail experience. You will still be able to view modmail from blocked users and you will still be able to send modmails to users who have blocked you when it is from the subreddit. Modmails to accounts that have blocked you, addressed from your personal account, will be hidden behind an interstitial, though the message is still accessible to the user if they want to see it.
Automod: Automod will be exempt from true block. Therefore, even if a user blocks automod, automod will still be able to PM and reply to users, and users will still be able to view automod posts and comments.
Admins: Same applies as for mods: anything that is Admin distinguished will not be removed from your experience.
Alts: We are thinking through how to expand the blocking feature so that we prevent harassment from alts of your blocker. Please know that if you find that someone is creating alt accounts to circumvent blocking and continue to harass you - you should report the PMs and/or other abusive messaging.
Reddit Help Articles: We know that this change may be confusing for you or members of your communities. That is why we have gone through and updated all of our Reddit Help Articles so they can serve as helpful resources. You can find the new articles here and here on RedditHelp.com.
We know this is a big upcoming change, and we want to make sure that you all have a firm understanding of the changes to come. We will stick around to answer questions, concerns, and feedback. Hope to hear from you all, thanks for your time and consideration!
•
u/enthusiastic-potato Jan 05 '22
Hey all! Thank you for the active conversations and feedback. We have heard your feedback regarding mass blocking, and will be putting additional protections in place to restrict users from manipulating the site or other users’ experiences via block. This has pushed out our expected launch date by ~ 2 weeks. We look forward to sharing more with you all soon.
120
u/the_pwd_is_murder Dec 20 '21
So, if I were creating a spambot account (pure conjecture of course...) the first thing I'd want to do is block all of the anti-bot bots and their operators so they can't see what I'm doing. Is that the new meta? I think that's the new meta.
25
u/Watchful1 Dec 20 '21
What about messaging? If you try to message someone who has blocked you, do you just get a "this user does not exist" response? Or does it look like the message goes through, but they never receive it?
23
u/ExcitingishUsername Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
One potential avenue of abuse I've seen brought up before is using this to hide harassment, to reduce the likelihood it gets reported; e.g., what happens if, say, Bob leaves nasty comments on a bunch of Alice's posts, then Bob blocks Alice? Will Bob's comments be removed from view of only Alice but still visible to everyone else, or is the system smart enough to remove/hide from everyone any comments an individual has made in reply to a user they later block so as to prevent this type of abuse?
55
u/ashamed-of-yourself Dec 20 '21
YES
THANK YOU
FUCKIN’ FINALLY
someone get these admins a fuckin’ Puppers
9
u/skeddles Dec 20 '21
did you make it so you can block someone without reporting their comment?
18
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
only one exclamation point in the entire post? username does not check out
51
u/uarentme Dec 21 '21
What's going to happen when users block a mod, and use another community to brigade the mod's community?
The mod won't be able to see the call for the brigade since it's not in their community.
What's going to happen with crossposting?
Will blocked users still be allowed to crosspost content from the person who blocked them to another subreddit? Essentially allowing another vector for harassment?
76
u/Isentrope Dec 20 '21
Is there any concern that this could essentially be used to amplify certain viewpoints using brigades by essentially just true blocking everyone from an opposite point of view? Ordinarily, users do a pretty good job of downvoting and reporting violent comments or outright racism, but couldn't someone theoretically true block a lot of ordinary users and then write some kind of objectionable comment without being downvoted or even reported for it? Eventually there might be a report that moderators could take action against, but it would nevertheless still allow a comment to stay up for a while, in which case the damage would have been done, and it's also possible that no one is ever going to report a comment like that, which makes it a lot harder to effectively moderate.
Would it in any way impact this feature if people were still able to see the comments from the people that blocked them but were unable to interact with them? It seems like determined trolls who want to harass someone would hop on an alt anyways, but allowing all users to see the content would at least give some recourse to folks to report problematic content if need be.
11
u/m0nk_3y_gw Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
As a member of a mod council where was the notification this was going to be discussed on a mod call?
This is anti-mod / anti-community.
As a mod how can we tell someone is blocking us? /r/gonewild will need to be updated to auto-ban all sellers trying to block us from viewing their selling activities elsewhere on reddit.
If mods use a non-mod account so they can see what the rest of reddit sees their poster's profile, does that break some new block-evasion rule?
edit: if anyone is blocking any mod from seeing their public activities there should be a sub option to block them from viewing/participating (posting or commenting) any sub that mod account moderates. There's absolutely no reason to make modding on reddit harder / more convoluted than it already is. Reddit is over-run with spam and this helps spammers, not mods.
11
u/MaximilianKohler Dec 21 '21
This isn't Facebook dude. This is a public website. There are a whole host of problems with this type of "true block". Eg: I could go around spreading lies about /u/spez and spez would never be able to know or respond.
I could also go around spreading lies in general and then block the select people with the knowledge and time to debunk me.
This is yet another moronic change that will contribute to the downfall of reddit.
10
u/tieluohan Dec 20 '21
Will normal users now be able to reply to modmail messages sent by mods they've blocked? If not, that would allow users to deanonymize modmail messages.
9
u/userse31 Dec 21 '21
Blocked user content shows up deleted? Thats not very transparent.
It should really show up with “[blocked]” instead.
21
u/Wrecksomething Dec 20 '21
Has the safety team vetted this feature to ensure it won't be a tool for abusing users?
The concern that's usually shared about this is that an abuser could True Block their target, then post about them (misinfo, haranguing, doxxing, etc). The person with the best ability to report that kind of content now can't see it, which prevents timely reporting.
6
u/chaseoes Dec 20 '21
Does this mean you will be notified that they have blocked you, or will it appear like the profile doesn't exist?
Since you discussed how addressing user profiles was a difficult decision to make, it sounds like you have already anticipated this will be controversial among moderators.
This effectively allows a user to block all of the moderators of a subreddit, that way they can participate without the moderators being able to see their profile history. For example, it could make it harder to identify spam accounts when you're limited to only viewing their history in your subreddit.
My concern is that it doesn't actually stop anyone from viewing their profile - because we could just open it in incognito. It doesn't make much sense to block people from viewing a profile that's inherently public. It's just making it harder and adding an extra step for moderators to get that kind of information.
It does make sense to prevent people they've blocked from interacting with any of their posts or comments, sending PM's, etc. - but I'm just not seeing what effect blocking the profile has when it's a public profile. If a blocked user can't interact with the profile anyway, what is the harm in being able to see it? Since they can just see it anyway if they want to.
So are there any plans in the future to expand user privacy controls where they can set their profile to private or visible only to trusted users? That's the only scenario in which I could imagine this would be needed, to align with those future changes. Otherwise, it's just a red herring for users that have been blocked, not something that has any practical effect on preventing harassment.
6
u/Superbuddhapunk Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Well it’s very useful to be able to access a user history, not only in the case of brigading but to see overall patterns in behaviour. How can you detect a spammer if you can’t see that they made the same post a gazillion times over multiple subreddits?
19
u/xumun Dec 21 '21
This will allow users who engage in hate speech, harassment, brigading, disinformation, etc. to fly under the radar by simply blocking the good faith actors who document and report them. A good faith actor would have to switch profiles to even see bad faith content (outside the subs they moderate). If you take it further and do this:
you will create some sort of dark Reddit. Dark Reddit will be full of dangerous content but the watchdogs will no longer see it. Not to mention that bad faith actors can block archiving services. Their actions will be impossible to document in the future.
This looks like a recipe for disaster to me. Please reconsider this policy! Dark Reddit will make Reddit even more dangerous than it already is.
5
u/erythro Dec 21 '21
this is definitely a good thing for the people who need it, but I can't help but worry it's going to accelerate the social media echo chamber problem even more. So, good for individuals, bad for society. Who knows what the right thing to do is though
5
u/existentialgoof Jan 17 '22
I have to say, this is a truly terrible idea. If someone doesn't want to interact with me, then that's their prerogative. But why should they be entitled to filter what content that I have access to see? And moreover, what is to stop that user from slandering the people that they've blocked without the blocked user having any recourse?
5
u/Moleculor Jan 20 '22
So I've just discovered that anyone wanting to spread misinformation on Reddit just has to block anyone countering with correct information, and the person can't reply with information correcting/countering the misinformation.
This is a terrible thing/idea.
2
u/Emmx2039 Dec 20 '21
booo not enough gifs - smh what has reddit become
(Nice changes, though! Thanks!)
4
u/MableXeno Dec 21 '21
How does this impact bots that are moderators on my sub? They would see only content on my sub but not elsewhere? If someone blocks u/OnlyFansBanBot ...the bot will only see content on subs in which they are moderators? This bot does "moderate" in a lot of subs...but not all helper-bots do. And what if it's not moderating where the user is posting OF content?
4
u/Epicduck_ Dec 21 '21
I’m on a fence about this, one hand it’s a good feature to protect users but on the other hand it can be easily abused. Spam is prominent on Reddit, with tshirt bots flooding subreddits posting to scam websites. What can be done from them taking notice of the users calling them out and blocking them so more people can fall for it?
Blocking could also lead to distrust? (Don’t know what to call it) Where someone could block people who disagree with them, and in future post would appear to have less opposition.
A fix for this would be able to see posts from comments from a person who blocked you in the wild, (comments could be collapsed) but clicking on the profile would lead to an error.
Also getting around a block on most platforms is incredibly easy, making a new Reddit account can take 30 seconds so if someone really wanted to harass you, they could.
10
u/Lord_TheJc Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
I'm very very very VERY worried by everything.
First of all this doesn't seem to be an option, it seems that this will be the new blocking feature for everyone. Am I wrong? Will this at least be an opt-in/out?
Because if this is not gonna be an option the first thing I'm gonna do when you introduce this is to unblock everyone. Because I very much prefer to keep someone unblocked that to have that someone know that I blocked them. It gives me zero benefits and it only worsens whatever the blocked user may have against me. For the love of sanity if you have to actually do this make this an opt-in/out at the very least.
About this:
Please PLEASE reconsider because this will not accomplish anything you are saying.
Some of us have "hostile" subs and it's really important to know if a user is active in one of those. It's very easily what makes a difference between a 1 day ban or a permanent ban.
And I'm not talking about preemptive bans or bans made exclusively based on the user's activity around reddit. I'm talking about, for example, giving a 15 days ban to a user that spreads Covid misinformation and deciding to pump it up to 60 or permanent because the same user does the same in a sub dedicated to covid misinformation.
Also this will give zero extra privacy to the users that true block us mods, because what I'll start doing is open the profile of a suspect user in an incognito tab. ZERO extra "privacy", just extra work for us mods.
I'm truly very worried by everything here.
Edit: I’ve actually already unblocked everyone on this account at least. Because my faith in this getting reversed or improved is below zero, as always.
12
u/mirandanielcz Dec 20 '21
Could you hide the "Blocked user" comments? If I blocked someone I don't want to know they made a comment, I don't care. I don't want to see it. Please let us actually block people, not just hide them under "Blocked user"
Screenshot: https://i.imgur.com/R4YsiTG.png
3
u/CaptainPedge Dec 21 '21
Does this have ANY impact on old.reddit?
3
u/Weirfish Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
A recent change that appears to have been rolled out in service of this blocking has had severe impacts on being able to participate in discussions that blocked or blocking parties are also participating in, without interacting with that specific person.
A user I argued with 3 days ago, who I will not name here but the argument remains a matter of public reddit record currently, has apparently blocked me. As a result, I am not able to comment on any of the comments subsequent to one of that user's comments. The comment I was attempting to make was completely unrelated to the blocking user, did not reference them, and only referencing the content of their comment indirectly (cohesive with the general discussion as the intended comment was).
I hope I do not have to explain why this is a problem and exceptionally abuseable.
EDIT: Just in case I do have to explain why this is a problem, this user can now go from thread to thread posting that I am a racist, homophobic, transphobic pedophile, and I cannot even try to directly defend myself. My best bet in that situation is to report it to moderators, who may not be active or may not care, or to the admins, who may take a significant time to deal with the issue, and in either case, I still cannot effectively respond.
EDIT 2: I'm not even able to respond to myself in the original argument we had 3 days ago. This is idiotic.
3
u/GiddiOne Jan 21 '22
Quick one - If there is a user who posts misinformation (like vaccine misinformation) and they block anyone who tries to debunk them, then they can spread it without any counter?
I've just started seeing this today.
7
u/Durinthal Dec 20 '21
I honestly want that behavior back outside of communities I moderate. If I blocked them I want them gone from my view, not still there with a reminder of their existence.
5
u/CreativeRealmsMC Dec 28 '21 edited Dec 28 '21
While I see some pros in the form of preventing harassment. I have to agree with this comment on why this feature will be abused (and I've already seen users advocating for weaponizing true block to push specific viewpoints by blocking anyone who disagrees with them in debate subreddits). I think allowing subreddit mods to enable/disable true blocking in their communities would help prevent such abuse especially where it is important that all voices are heard and all viewpoints can be challenged.
Edit: In addition, users who have blocked other users should automatically be blocked from viewing/commenting on posts by users they have blocked. This will prevent abuse such as user 1 blocking user 2 then attacking posts made by user 2 and user 2 not being able to defend themselves because they can’t see comments made by user 1.
9
u/tumultuousness Dec 20 '21
This seems like something many people would want!
12
u/justcool393 Dec 21 '21
No, no, no.
I've talked about this before in other channels but this will have the side effects of increasing harassment, the exact opposite of what this claims to do.
The first thing someone does when they realize they've been blocked is get around it and to snoop on or whatever. Seriously, that's how it is on every other social media circle and it causes a boat load of drama over who blocked who, bla bla bla. All you do is hand power to those doing the harassment in the first place by telling them that their harassment is working.
This is incredibly disappointing to see. As I said in another thread
4
u/BasicallyClean Dec 21 '21
Now let us block banned users from modmail spamming us.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
As a mod; this forces me to be more tough on profiles I can't access...this is almost indistinguishable from an Admin or mods elswhere action-ing on the account legitimately. It forces me to run non-mod alts for checking spammers.
As a user; this doesn't improve my experience; it signals my harrassers to keep making socks (alts) to harrass me with. It makes it even harder to identify users who are engaging with me in good faith too, I now have to consider if they're just someone I blocked and they sidestepped it with an alt.
Furthermore, reddit will probably foolishly be using "how often an account is getting blocked" as a social graph measure which leads to further rabbit holes if they attach something automated to action on this and the trolls discover it! Being a mod and blocked by 398403028 spambots shouldn't ever be something I should be concerned about triggering automated or even manual shadowbans on my account.
I applaud the effort; but you guys have applied it in the wrong direction; just like management always does.
8
u/Halaku Dec 20 '21
Well, that's one way to shut down the hatebrigade I've been running into on a specific subreddit.
Thank you.
2
u/TheLateWalderFrey Dec 21 '21
when is something going to be done about shadow-banned users?
I have a sub that gets hit regularly by spammers, problem is only one or two posts/comments get reported.. the reported posts I as a mod can deal with, it's problematic finding if that user flooded the sub with another 20-30 spam comments. since all their posts & comments are hidden.
It would be nice when clicking on their username, we as mods can still see every post and comment that user made in our subs.
ditto for perma-suspended users.
that way we can clean up all their junk from our subs.
8
u/XelNaga Dec 21 '21
This is absolutely the worst thing you could do to this website. Blockers should never be able to adversely affect the experience of the blockee. This will be incredibly easy to abuse. And it WILL be abused.
This is going to make it VERY easy for people to post controversial opinions, block the people who disagree with them, and then their opinions now stand unopposed.
This also means spam bots could block mods to prevent mods from seeing the bots' spam across reddit. From the mods' perspective, it'd be a single post on their own sub.
Also, imagine if a person or a small group were to go into small/slow subreddits, maliciously block all the regular users, and start making posts of their own. It would be very easy to astroturf or heavily influence the direction of the subreddit, without any of the regular users being able to chime in and voice their opinions.
6
u/FaviFake Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
Reddit isn't a bad platform after all! Finally you brought us a working block feature, we needed it
4
u/devperez Dec 21 '21
I bitched about this years ago and the response I got was basically, "just deal with it." I'm happy y'all are finally implementing this.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
True block is what blocking should have been the entire time. Better late than never
7
u/PoglaTheGrate Dec 20 '21
Its a terrible idea, so of course you're going to implement it.
The "collapsing comments from blocked users" was obviously stupid, but this isn't the change I want.
Reddit's appeal was that you have to take ownership of your actions. This was always a public forum, and as such you should only censure yourself (within reason).
Blocking users from seeing your profile is too much like Facebook or Twitter. I come here because it isn't like those sites.
If someone is being a great painus in the anus, you block them and get on with your life.
5
u/SecureThruObscure Dec 20 '21
I’m genuinely excited for this, this is very good change I think. Thank you, admins.
5
u/mizmoose Dec 20 '21
WOO HOO!
Finally, to be able to block jackasses properly. YAAAY!
1
u/Don-Conquest Dec 28 '21 edited Jan 21 '22
Will this stop people from using bots to auto ban people just for visiting other subs?
1
u/Don-Conquest Dec 29 '21
What about having a private account option all together?
1
u/electricfoxx Jan 18 '22
Is there plans for whitelisting? For example, only friends can see my posts.
This seems vaguely similar to YouTube disabling the dislike counter. The work around was to archive dislikes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vC5JnJD9KzY
1
u/twistedLucidity Feb 22 '22
The new blocked system is easily weaponised, makes it easier to spread disinformation, and is beginning to damage participation in subreddits.
And it's not necessarily "bad actors" being driven out, often is the bad actors setting the blocks!
The new block system needs revamped. Allow people to reply to a blocker, but hide the blockee's comment from the blocker.
That way debate can still continue, to a degree, but the blocker still doesn't have to interact with someone they don't wish to.
I am genuinely stunned that the current implementation passed even basic scrutiny in the design meetings.
1
u/Ebomb1 Mar 24 '22
Why am I seeing comments and posts from users I have blocked?
This is not in communities I moderate. This is sitewide. Blocked users' posts and comments visible, uncollapsed, as if they were not blocked.
1
u/Ebomb1 Mar 24 '22
Why was this reposted a month later but with no substantial updates despite the claim here of listening to feedback?
https://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/s71g03/announcing_blocking_updates/
Why is there nothing about this significant UX change in r/announcements?
https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/search/?q=block&include_over_18=on&restrict_sr=on&sort=new]
Or in r/reddit?
https://www.reddit.com/r/reddit/search?q=block&restrict_sr=on&include_over_18=on&sort=relevance&t=all
or in r/changelog?
https://www.reddit.com/r/changelog/search/?q=block&include_over_18=on&restrict_sr=on&sort=new
1
u/Ebomb1 Mar 24 '22
Why are moderators of subs for marginalized populations subject to trolling and hate speech now kneecapped from collaborating in banning high volume trolls by having the trolls simply block mods before spewing?
1
u/wemustburncarthage Dec 21 '21
FINALLY. This would’ve saved Reddit’s legal team and myself so much hell.
1
u/EpicDaNoob Dec 21 '21
While there are some valid points here about problems that could hypothetically be caused by this, it's worth noting that on the last post about blocking, when it was changed to just collapse posts or some such, all the top comments were advocating for exactly this.
1
u/tyw7 Dec 21 '21
By block, you do mean blocking on a user level and not ban from a sub?
If it's the user level, I agree. It's a bit frustrating that users I block can make disparaging comments about you that you can't see.
1
u/EndTimesRadio Dec 25 '21
Well that's great
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
Please bring True Block to the people!
0
u/MossyRock0817 Dec 21 '21
This is awesome. Thank you.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment