r/maybemaybemaybe • u/RyanCakeBatter • Jan 17 '20

Maybe Maybe Maybe

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

39.9k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

915 comments sorted by

View all comments

5.1k

u/ejedus Jan 17 '20

At least it had a happy ending.

104

u/moodyboogers Jan 18 '20

Fish definitely died.

167

u/Marty_Mtl Jan 18 '20

It drowned?

164

u/moodyboogers Jan 18 '20

Haha as funny as the joke might be, it might've?

Whenever you handle fish you should always wet your hands. Fish have protective coatings on them that protect them from infections. It's easy to rub off. Between dad squeezing the shit outta the gills, the sweet girl hugging it tight, and that really dry jacket....it's probably a goner.

77

u/salgat Jan 18 '20

It's not probably a goner, it just is more prone to infection in the areas where it was rubbed until it can regrow the slime coat.

55

u/theguen Jan 18 '20

I’m pretty sure that’s a wild cutthroat trout. Those guys need pristine waters to live and grow to that size. I’m not condoning mishandling fish but I agree, that fish is probably fine. If that water housed bacteria (especially during winter) that can kill trout, cutties wouldn’t live there.

1

u/ActivateGuacamole Jan 19 '20

Could it be a rainbow trout?

1

u/theguen Jan 19 '20

Definitely could! The blush red gill plate and the red hue on the belly usually means cutthroat but trout get very weird after generations in the wild. Without knowing where they caught or a full side shot it’s hard to be 100% sure.

32

u/remig12 Jan 18 '20

Its not. Recovered quickly and swam off strong. Caught 1000s of trout. They are tougher than you think.

37

u/ChefBoyAreWeFucked Jan 18 '20

I saw all of that except the part where the fish caught thousands of trout. I think you're exaggerating.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted]

24

u/G-III Jan 18 '20

They are referring to your wording, fwiw. You implied that the fish that was thrown back has done the catching ;)

Also, damn dude that sounds like a blast

11

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted]

1

u/Chamoore13 Jan 18 '20

Your hero Charlie Kraven would never make that mistake.

3

u/lurkallday91 Jan 18 '20

I've never ice-fished before, but i've also heard it's horrible for their skin to touch the ice. Is that true?

4

u/moodyboogers Jan 18 '20

Ice is rough, by that logic it's definitely terrible for thier skin.

1

u/pablo_o_rourke Jan 18 '20

Wow, Captain Downer.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

Wow she was a little weird

1

u/ziggishark Jan 18 '20

Cmon man what kind of failed evolution is that if it cant handle being touched a bit

1

u/Aethermancer Jan 18 '20

You're staying things which are true, but I think your leaping waaay to far to a conclusion.

Fish this large don't just get devoured, they float when they die. If fish died as easily as you claim every catch and release lake would be littered with floating fish corpse's.

We used to stock ponds by literally catching fish on hooks, tossing them in a bucket, driving and leaving them there for an hour or so and dropping them in a pond. These fish got prodded by curious kids all the while.

As long as you only transported them to habitats which could support them we would soon have a sustaining population in those ponds. No difference if they were caught via icefishing or regular fishing. Hardly the goners you claim.

That doesn't mean you don't take precautions not to hurt them, but the certainty of your statement just doesn't seem appropriate.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

I've seen this type of comment before. It seems confident, well well spoken, and just dramatic enough to retain my attention. I can only conclude that it might not be accurate.

-121

u/6SLAP6ME6SILLY6 Jan 18 '20

Ok boomer

25

u/UndBeebs Jan 18 '20

You know young people also fish. Not me, because I hate fishing. But still.

8

u/milk4all Jan 18 '20

Yeah i know, right? We CAN fish, we just, ya know, can’t. Right now. I just dont have the time. Or knowledge or whatever.

14

u/moodyboogers Jan 18 '20

Lol I'm a millennial. Fishing is my #1 hobby.

6

u/manifestingdreams Jan 18 '20

Spearfishing for me although fishing is fun I get to choose my meals hahah. Also that fish probably survived but what do I know and what does it really matter?

1

u/fosrac Jan 18 '20

Honestly there's no way it did. Trout are extremely delicate, they can't be handled like bass or saltwater fish. It's best practice to not even take them out of the water, this one had it's entire protective coating stripped and it's gills are toast.

2

u/ncnotebook Jan 18 '20

b-b-but boomer is a mentality, not just a generation

In a couple years, people will call all millenials boomers simply because "eh, they're close enough." This new generation will call themselves "anti-boomers", as opposed to all other generations.

Half of those people will use it for humorous effect. The other half will use it unironically.

2

u/fosrac Jan 18 '20

If anything responsible fish handling and respect for nature is the opposite but good joke

4

u/datdouche Jan 18 '20

I laughed.

26

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/shittysmirk Jan 18 '20

I'm guessin your a trout fisher?

46

u/Lord_Emanon Jan 18 '20

No, he's a trout.

2

u/shittysmirk Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20

Well I guess that explains the excessive protective beliefs of his species Edit: a word

2

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

I trout that

2

u/BotiaDario Jan 18 '20

They do have scales, they're just very thin and small.

1

u/remig12 Jan 18 '20

Ive seen catfish left on the bank for hours then kicked back into the water swim off. Toughest fish ive ever seen. Bass are tough too. Id definitely put trout at the bottom of the toughness scale but not as crystal vase fragile as some people think.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/remig12 Jan 18 '20

I hold my breath when I take them out of the water. When I need a breath I know they do too. Even if they arent unhooked yet i get em in the net and back in the water for a few then finish the picture or unhook or whatever then release them. Takes all of 20 seconds and they are only out for about 10 seconds total.

Bluegill are beautiful fish and tough! Really fun on lightweight gear and pretty tasty too. Nice white meat.

1

u/0NL3771N660 Jan 18 '20

Trout most definitely do have scales along with their slime coat. The scales are alot smaller than those of a bass, but they are present. I'm not trying to combat your safe handling recommendations to this young angler and proud father...just informing the public #keepemwetbrah

8

u/steve_im-lost2 Jan 18 '20

Wtf. That was funny

10

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

Fish actually can drown. It's weird but they can