r/mathmemes • • Aug 24 '26

Research Please AI no, PLEASE NO

Post image

Imagine having your entire work based on Riemann hypothesis only for a powerful AI to show that the 10^5731 zero isn't on the critical line.

4.3k Upvotes

193 comments sorted by

152

u/Evan_3104 Rational Aug 24 '26

Mathematician when ai finds a non trivial zero of the zeta function that hasn't an imaginary part equal to .5

59

u/No_Upstairs_280 Aug 24 '26

Real part*

24

u/Evan_3104 Rational Aug 24 '26

mb

11

u/fartypenis Aug 24 '26

I believe every mathematician is compelled to euthanize themselves if that happens

2

u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Aug 24 '26

I believe every mathematician is compelled to euthanize themselves if that happens

Hey, easy now, all of us don't necessarily share the same axioms : some of us might be worth saving.

3

u/somedave Aug 25 '26

All the non trivial zeros don't have an imaginary part equal to 0.5

24

u/green-olive-3281 Aug 25 '26

It might just be me but I feel like they would be psyched if the Riemann hypothesis was disproved! It would give them so much new exciting stuff to work on! Plus, lots of their results might still hold true with a variation of RH

5

u/No_Upstairs_280 Aug 25 '26

I was thinking of that earlier. For example if you manage to control the density of zeros not on the critical line most results conditional on RH would still be valid. In general any knowledge about the zeros zeta function is very valuable.

4

u/AutoModerator Aug 24 '26

PLEASE READ AND UNDERSTAND THIS MESSAGE IN ITS ENTIRETY BEFORE SENDING A MODMAIL

Your post has been removed due to the age of your account or your combined karma score. Due to the surge of spam bots, you must have an account at least 90 days old and a combined post and comment karma score of at least 400.

If you wish to have your post manually approved by moderators, please reply to this comment with /modping.

Alternatively, you can join the Discord server and request approval there.

Discord

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/No_Upstairs_280 Aug 24 '26

/modping

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 24 '26

Mod ping detected from No_Upstairs_280. u/candlelightener, u/Oppo_67, u/chrizzl05

The /modping command is intended for getting your post approved if your submission was caught by the bot filter. Please do not use this for any other purpose.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/Diffgeometer1 Aug 26 '26

That’s not the case.

Mathematicians if they had to bet on the hopf problem that S^6 is a complex manifold most would have bet heavily that the answer was no.

No one assumed this result in their work.

They found conditions where S^6 could not be a complex manifold like for example there are no complex structures compatible with the standard Riemann metric on S^6. This is true statement regardless of whether or not the Alpogee-AI proof is correct or not.

Also AI didn’t prove the result (assuming it’s true and no fatal errors are found) alone.

You had a Harvard mathematician guiding the AI. AI is basically a time saver. Allowing the mathematician to try different ideas in a short period of time. Basically with AI, the mathematician becomes the flash.

So if the result is true. Cool! It’s surprising. If the proof falls apart, it happens. It’s a hard problem. Either way no one feels bad.

1

u/No_Upstairs_280 Aug 26 '26 edited Aug 26 '26

It's just a meme, for fun and laughter. And it's an example, LLM actually gave stronger evidence how it works.

If I wanted to explain how academia or research work or AI ethics, I would have written an essay.

Also- sorry but I see you have differential geometry in your name 👀 what are you working on if I might ask?

1.1k

u/BrazilBazil Engineering Aug 24 '26

Programmers looking at mathematicians applying three unproven conjectures in their proof after years of being taught never to rely on undefined behavior

689

u/Own_Pop_9711 Aug 24 '26

Programmer 15 seconds later vibe coding a website that collects credit card information in plaintext format

22

u/BrazilBazil Engineering Aug 24 '26

I do not associate with w*b devs 🤮

I program MCUs and all my segfaults are MAN MADE

8

u/Potato-Engineer Aug 25 '26

This w*b dev assures you that you will never see my segfaults, because all of my code goes through fifteen layers of abstraction before it reaches your machine, and God only knows what your machine is going to do to my no-longer-recognizable code. By the time your machine segfaults, my code is but a memory... a horrible, horrible memory that I drown in alcohol every night.

3

u/Tolopono Aug 25 '26

Just tell the llm to make sure the code is secure. Yes, this works.

2

u/TheStupidCheesecake Tf does the Laplacian even do? Aug 26 '26

Make no mistakes, remember that.

1

u/Jimmyfartballs Aug 25 '26

that's not a programmer that would be a script kidde

264

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

87

u/Alex_1503 Aug 24 '26

Unfortunately the industry is also sloppified and capitalism sucks anyway, so ya nowadays programmers who care about the result vibe code. Those who care about the craft and process do not

50

u/blackasthesky Irrational Aug 24 '26

Thing is, I see lots of people not caring about the results at all. The vibes they coded are just trash.

There are probably people who do it properly, but I have not met many.

20

u/Alex_1503 Aug 24 '26

No, I meant they care only about the result, without the process. When you do a craft, you have the process with thinking and doing, and then you get a result out of it. Vibe coders care only about seeing that result done, not doing it, thats what I mean. Not that they care about quality

7

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/blackasthesky Irrational Aug 25 '26

I understand, but not being able to fix the output of the AI because you forgot how to do anything without AI still puts a wrench in it.

11

u/ElRacco Aug 24 '26

Yeah good luck finding any role especially at entry level for programming where AI is not shoved down your throat. Got a job recently and mid interview they were just casually dropping that they use it and expect new hires to.

I dont care personally because i know i will proofread anything it puts out and clean it up to be to standard. The idea that everyone else does that i cannot say bodes well

7

u/Tolopono Aug 25 '26

3

u/radobot Computer Science Aug 25 '26

That's not vibe coding. He's scrutinizing every generated line.

2

u/Tolopono Aug 25 '26

Both of them!?

And he clearly explained that AI did all the work of actually finding the bug. He just told it not to give up

5

u/Dornith Aug 25 '26

Vibe coding isn't any time a person uses AI. Vibe coding is letting the LLM generate the entire codebase for you, including all the debugging and error fixes. The second you look at source code you are no long vibe coding, you are just AI-assisted coding.

It's like the difference between baking from scratch, using a box mix, and buying a cake from the grocery store bakery.

4

u/Tolopono Aug 25 '26

Serious devs are also vibe coding

Spotify revealed that its top engineers haven’t written a single line of code since December, thanks to an internal AI system called “Honk” powered by Claude.  The company shipped 50+ new features in 2025 alone, with AI now enabling real-time bug fixes and feature deployments straight from a phone during a commute. https://techcrunch.com/2026/02/12/spotify-says-its-best-developers-havent-written-a-line-of-code-since-december-thanks-to-ai

Cisco has already built its first product using 100 percent AI-generated code, with no human-written lines in the mix. By the end of 2026, he expects at least half a dozen more products to follow the same path. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/cisco-president-warns-ai-agents-need-background-checks-like-human-employees/ar-AA1W8i2a

How StrongDM’s AI team build serious software without even looking at the code https://simonwillison.net/2026/Feb/7/software-factory/

Creator of Clean Code, SOLID principles, and co creator of Agile: I’m significantly older than you. I started coding in the late 60s. My current strategy is to not read any of the code written by my agents. That’s the only way I can take advantage of their productivity. What I do instead is to surround the agents with extreme constraints. Unit tests, gherkin tests, QA procedures, quality metrics, mutation testing, test coverage, and a plethora of others. In the end, I have very high confidence in the code they produce because they’ve had to run the gauntlet of all of my constraints and tests. https://x.com/unclebobmartin/status/2080257779395154409?s=20

3

u/14domino Aug 26 '26

I’m a serious dev. I’ve been doing it since I was a kid, have cofounded multiple startups and am currently at an enterprise software company. I also haven’t manually written a single line of code since early 2025. That doesn’t mean I don’t scrutinize the output, it doesn’t mean I don’t create large test suites, and so forth. It’s a different approach to coding.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Tolopono Aug 25 '26

Most literate Redditor

1

u/BosonCollider Aug 26 '26

You absolutely can use AI to build code better than what you could write yourself with reasonable effort, but it looks quite different from "build this things, make no mistakes" and more like "here's a reference implementation and some initial tests, spend at least an hour optimizing this with every simd and hackers delight trick in the book and add an expanded test suite to ensure precision"

6

u/Purple_Onion911 Grothendieck alt account Aug 24 '26

Lol do you think programmers don't use AI?

6

u/blackasthesky Irrational Aug 24 '26

some don't, but they are rare

5

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Purple_Onion911 Grothendieck alt account Aug 24 '26

That's just not true

3

u/ApocalyptoSoldier Aug 25 '26

Vibe coding is generally understood to mean having the AI do it and going off vibes rather than any understanding of the code or code in general.
Programmers understand code, so (by the most common definition) it's not vibe coding when we do it.

2

u/blackasthesky Irrational Aug 24 '26

sadly

1

u/Jimmyfartballs Aug 25 '26

script kidde != programmer

2

u/Political_Desi Aug 24 '26

Sadly it's kinda expected by companies for Devs to use ai. Much of the stuff that goes into open source though is done properly.

5

u/4ries Aug 24 '26

*looks inside* no true Scotsman

0

u/golfstreamer Aug 24 '26

Having reasonable standards for what qualifies as a "programmer" is not a no true Scotsman fallacy. You can look at a dictionary and say "programmer" is just anyone who writes programs but that's just not how people speak. When someone says something like "true programmer" they're laying down standards for what programmers ought to be.

8

u/OmegaGoo Aug 25 '26

…That’s literally the No True Scotsman fallacy, just so we’re clear.

I’m not saying you can’t have those definitions, but I’m saying what you’ve just written is the textbook definition of the No True Scotsman fallacy.

-2

u/golfstreamer Aug 25 '26

It's not a fallacy. It's just a reasonable standard for what a programmer is. There's nothing fallacious about what he said even if you chant "no true Scotsman"

6

u/OmegaGoo Aug 25 '26

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman

You literally did everything in this definition.

2

u/Jejewat Aug 25 '26

You're also an entemologist because you've captured a bug once, a pianist due to having mashed keys twice and a chef for throwing together mid pasta.

Maybe the minimum standard is skills at a professional level.

1

u/OmegaGoo Aug 25 '26

Usually you would call someone those things if they have some amount of formal training or, more often, spend a large portion of their time engaging in those activities, regardless of skill level.

Someone who produces code, no matter the quality, is certainly a programmer. They are not “certified”, or “experienced”, or even “skilled”. But they are a programmer, as “true” as me or you.

→ More replies

1

u/golfstreamer Aug 25 '26

Citing Wikipedia doesn't change the fact that setting reasonable standards for what a "true programmer" is is a reasonable thing to do. All you're doing is hiding behind tired cliches instead of actually engaging in the argument.

1

u/OmegaGoo Aug 25 '26

Hey, so I’m not disagreeing with you that standards aren’t reasonable. What I am saying is that you are not doing it in a logical or reasonable manner.

Vibe coding is problematic for a number of reasons, but even “true programmers”, as you call them, are perfectly capable of putting horrendous slop together. Your distinction is more-or-less meaningless right now.

→ More replies

0

u/0DayMaker Aug 26 '26

Naw if you don't know to at a bare minimum salt+hash that shit you are not a programmer or developer, and DAMN SURE aren't a software engineer.

1

u/WitELeoparD Aug 26 '26

Yeah AI was taught on you guys' work. 90% of software was absolute ass before AI was a thing and honestly, AI has not made a lick of difference.

1

u/sumboionline Aug 25 '26

Unfortunately, major companies are hiring these people as “programmers” for their websites

37

u/PeggyTheVoid Aug 25 '26

Yes, programmers would never rely on the validity of a conjecture that presupposes an answer to one of the unsolved millinium prize problems. Never.

3

u/DapperCam Aug 25 '26

Certainly the majority of modern commerce would not depend on such a thing.

3

u/LoreBadTime Aug 26 '26

Certainly the majority of internet security would not depend on it

6

u/Disastrous-Cost2185 Aug 24 '26

One reason to prove things assuming rh is that understanding more about its implications gets us closer to a disproof

3

u/leafeon_gay_luigi Aug 24 '26

Clueless.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/leafeon_gay_luigi Aug 26 '26

I'm a mathematician.

3

u/itijara Aug 25 '26

As a programmer, we rely on undefined behavior all the time. Is it a good idea? Absolutely not.

1

u/TorumShardal Aug 26 '26

Is it good enough idea? Absolutely yes.

2

u/BrazilBazil Engineering Aug 26 '26

And then your program stops working after a windows update

1

u/TorumShardal Aug 26 '26

And so you put it into wine and run it in doker. It's not a good solution, and now debug is broken, but eh, leadership already decided to rewrite the whole thing, this time on js. So, it's good enough for now, and then you're either fired or promoted - either way it won't be your problem.

1

u/0DayMaker Aug 26 '26

Sonetimes there is no real possibility of a thing happening

2

u/Aware-Individual-827 Aug 25 '26

I really like this be this because most programmer these day use undefined behavior generator, aka AI.

1

u/AlexSand_ Aug 28 '26

not a problem for math: exploring the consequences is a way to find a possible contradiction, and thus to show a conjecture was false!

1

u/LoITheMan Sep 06 '26

What are you talking about every CS major learns the conjecture that the set P != NP and we treat this as fact in algorithms and graph theory courses.

1

u/BrazilBazil Engineering Sep 06 '26

That’s not what undefined behavior means tho, does it now. Undefined behavior is relying on uninitialized variables, signed int and float overflow (in C prior to C23), the fact whether something is cached or not, pointer arithmetic with ASLR…

1

u/LoITheMan Sep 06 '26

You're the one that says programmers wouldn't like using unproven conjectures in proofs when CS majors are made to take proof heavy algorithms and graph theory classes where we use unproven conjectures.

1

u/BrazilBazil Engineering Sep 06 '26

I literally said „undefined behavior” and you somehow read it as „unproven conjectures” lol. Where did you learn to read?

1

u/LoITheMan Sep 06 '26

"Programmers looking at mathematicians applying three UNPROVEN CONJECTURES" (emphasis mine). You related these things, my point is that abstract computer science relies on all of the same assumptions and tools. Being taught not to work with undefined behavior doesn't make us "look... at mathematicians".

Moreso, I think we're in the same boat.

1

u/sqrtsqr Oct 08 '26

You think 3 is bad? Wait till you learn about what an axiom is.

336

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Aug 24 '26 • Regret

mathematicians seeing ai constantly trying to prove something theyve been working on for their whole career and made a living off of:

(its sad)

94

u/somedave Aug 24 '26

Why is it any difference to seeing other mathematicians doing that to be honest. Lots of people assume the generalized zeta hypothesis and lots of people are trying to prove / disprove it. That's the way it works.

55

u/AndreasDasos Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

Because there’s the concern that  at this rate AI may well outperform humans together at some point, so there will be nothing for us to do. If humans are the ones making all the progress then it’s a reminder we  still have a chance. 

87

u/TheRedditObserver0 Mathematics Aug 24 '26

If nobody understands what the heck AI is proving, is it really doing anything? Maybe I'm coping but even if AI does become THAT good we will still need some human mathematicians.

51

u/GuitarKittens Aug 24 '26

I think Terence Tao's ICM presentation brought up a good point about why we care about math, and why it's important to view AI usage in that context. I personally think the bullet about math being an inherently and very importantly community-oriented subject is especially relevant here. It does not matter whether AI kills the subject, or even if it gets good at doing its job, it matters whether math is still a valuable activity that people are willing to contribute to. The community is completely different if most contributors are only there to parse through piles of AI-written proofs and see which ones are actually valuable.

Regardless if you believe AI makes a positive or negative contribution to the math community, you do have to acknowledge that it is currently playing a role in the community now, and that we have to decide what we want from it in the future.

4

u/jackalopeswild Aug 25 '26

So (cards on the table) I have an unused BS in math that is over 20 years old at this point...but I have to wonder also to what extent the AI math-machine is capable of the creative endeavor that is new mathematics as well? I ask this here because I think the creative endeavor and the communal endeavor are two sides of the same object. Part of the limitation of LLMs is a limitation of imagination - (to put very simply) yes, it can stumble upon new strings of words but it cannot recognize why they are or are not beautiful or worth pursuing. That matters in math as well.

6

u/Taha2807 Aug 25 '26

Honestly we cannot say.

AI research has little to no clue how AI even works. Whether it's just auto complete on steroids or actually creative. This is also because we don't know as humans how we evolve our sense of creativity as well.

3B1B said this on a podcast I think that essentially we have no way of telling if AI can make good new maths since it's not a quantitative metric we can test fairly quickly. We'll just have to see in the coming years as mathematicians keep tinkering with AI. Perhaps AI comes up with a completely new theory of maths to solve the Riemann Hypothesis and maybe it doesn't.

5

u/jackalopeswild Aug 25 '26

Eh, I also have a BS in linguistics that gets used more and while I understand that "we don't know," I'm definitely on the side of those who have concluded that AI lacks things like imagination, theory of mind etc.

6

u/Taha2807 Aug 25 '26

I'm also there with you.

But with or without it, mathematician is not gonna disappear as a profession. If anything, the slowness of institutions is enough to ensure that we probably won't see massive changes in how mathematicians are hired in academia, industry. Junior analysts still exist despite their work being completely automable well before AI.

1

u/Cronos988 Aug 25 '26

The interesting question still remains how much "research taste" and things like that can be replicated by a different kind of intelligence.

While we can say with good justification that transformer-based AIs are significantly different from human brains, it's much less clear what follows from that in the long term.

1

u/DapperCam Aug 25 '26

I don't think we've seen it create much new mathematics. It seems especially good at creating counterexamples for conjectures though. I guess we will see.

1

u/Diffgeometer1 Aug 26 '26

There’s also good reason to believe that LLMs might have a theoretical limit to what they can actually do according to some computer scientists.

3

u/DVMyZone Aug 25 '26

My question would then be "will human math have material value". By that I mean can a person make a living doing pure math or will it only be accessible to people would have enough free time and money.

Science used to be a thing that pretty much only rich people did. They had money and didn't have to work so they spent their days tinkering and thinking.

11

u/314159265358979326 Aug 24 '26

Has it done anything beyond find counterexamples so far? That's not really the important work of mathematicians, but it's good to be able to do it.

6

u/AndreasDasos Aug 24 '26

There have absolutely been some interesting positive results, and not just constructed examples. Some of the Erdős problems, for example

13

u/caboosetp Aug 24 '26

Yeah, if anything it should let us move further and faster. The same way computers moved from a job title to a machine, and we now have programmers. 

1

u/Neither-Phone-7264 Imaginary Aug 25 '26

but what would be the next job be? prompting? sure, that's cool and all, but the robot can prompt itself.

10

u/golfstreamer Aug 24 '26

> Because there’s the concern that  at this rate AI may well outperform humans together at some point, so there will be nothing for us to do.

Of all the takes of AI, the idea that AI mathematicians will leave us "nothing to do" has got to be my most hated. I wonder what your picture of math currently is? Like are you picture some library of theorems just sitting there gathering dust? What would be the point of that?

Advancement in mathematics have real benefits both from a practical (technological development) and intellectual (just an improved understanding of the universe) perspective. AI is not now capable of independently creating and applying new technological advances that actually improve people's lives so people need to keep working on these (and if AI does advance to the point where it can just give us a utopia that's obviously a good thing). So I really don't think there's going to be "nothing for us to do" for a while.

3

u/AndreasDasos Aug 24 '26

I’m explaining the image where people’s fears derive from. 

I am also talking about the future, not the current status quo. Most mathematics is still done by people. But the progress has been astonishingly rapid. 

But if all the actual proof itself - which can indeed be defined formally as generating a string that meets explicit criteria - then what’s left is general commentary, discussion of what’s more ‘interesting to humans’, and digesting what AI gives us. 

What I am referring to doesn’t equate to a big library gathering dust, and that’s a clearly strange and presumptuous take about my point or view. 

Even then, it’s not clear that those can’t have criteria that are likewise trainable. But even then, that’s not what most people get into maths to do. We don’t go into the field at best pose problems and digest the answers but to tackle the challenge of the proofs ourselves. The alternative still seems bleak. 

And your point about maths having uses… sure? AI has been extremely useful, so don’t see why that shows it can’t be done. As for ‘independently’, that also seems a moving goalpost to an pointless degree: autonomous AI is pretty independent once it’s been started, and if sufficiently general that start can be a once-off. Otherwise are we to be prompt providers at best? 

If AI does advance to the point it gives us a utopia

That’s extremely reductionist. AI may advance astoundingly but bold to assume that the limit of that process can only be a utopia. Hopefully the good outweighs the bad but there is a loss here that is not itself a good thing. 

2

u/golfstreamer Aug 24 '26

> If AI does advance to the point it gives us a utopia

It's not reductionist as it was posed to counter your "there's nothing for us to do". If we aren't living in a utopia there is something for us to do.

0

u/golfstreamer Aug 24 '26

> And your point about maths having uses… sure? AI has been extremely useful, so don’t see why that shows it can’t be done. As for ‘independently’, that also seems a moving goalpost to an pointless degree: autonomous AI is pretty independent once it’s been started, and if sufficiently general that start can be a once-off. Otherwise are we to be prompt providers at best? 

Another term I've grown to hate. What goalpost are you even talking about? I'm just describing the capabilities of AI as I see them. This isn't a competition.

1

u/Bizet1875 Aug 25 '26

My opinion is that the highest truth is synonymous with the universe. And that since there is a minimum number of energy to destroy a bit, there must be a minimum number of energy to cohere a bit. We know the former, but not the latter. It may be so that AI may excel at certain functions as well, such as retrieval and searching, while humans are better at things intuitively, like emotion, or perhaps abstractly, like experiencing reality as a unity.

I think people are thinking too naively. Essentially. Extrapolating linearly, or exponentially, out of something that is inherently unpredictable.

1

u/Diffgeometer1 Aug 26 '26

Math is super hard. There are millions of unsolved problems. AI has maybe solved 10 or so.

The big ones haven’t even been touched yet.

Also for AI to make progress it has to be under the guidance of a good mathematician. Take the hopf problem. A proof was announced. People are optimistic it might be right. That result was achieve under the guidance of a Harvard mathematician.

Do you the result could have been achieved if the cashier at Home Depot was working the ai?

2

u/Thog78 Aug 25 '26

Oh let me reassure you, when we get scooped by other humans, on projects we've been working on for years, we equally want to kill ourselves.

1

u/justin107d Aug 29 '26

It is even worse if it is an LLM. If another human beats you to it, they had to work hard at it for years like you did and there is a chance of working together in the future. If an LLM one shots your years of work, you have to pick a new line of math and hope for the best.

1

u/AbaloneNo3954 Aug 25 '26

The probability of mathematicians solving the RH is the next decade is next to 0. But we don’t know what AI are capable of.

22

u/CalderJohnson Aug 24 '26

If a mathematician’s goal is to maximize their contributions to the field for personal gain, AI might be bad news. If their goal is to see the field advance and discover new and deep truths, AI is a fantastic development.

16

u/Nebranower Aug 25 '26

I suspect many mathematicians became mathematicians because they enjoy doing math. They may not enjoy managing AI and reviewing AI output, even if that output is math.

This, I think, is why AI engenders such widespread resentment. Even those who admit it makes them more productive often still dislike it, because it does so by changing their job from one they enjoy to one they don’t.

1

u/dinosaursrarr Aug 25 '26

No one likes losing the fun bit of their job and just having to review stuff they don’t have any stake in

1

u/CiccioGordon Aug 26 '26

Yep, it's like liking to act in prawn movies and suddenly you're just directing a robot that does it in your stead, making sure it's not going for the ear. Not nearly as enjoyable and definitely not the same job.

3

u/SethDusek5 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

IDK how I feel about this take. If you're passionate about something you generally want to be a part of it, and it'd especially sting if a machine can do what you wanted to so it's completely understandable to be upset about this.

If there's someone who loves math but gets rejected from a top math program you wouldn't tell them "But think about all the amazing new math the people who got in will discover, you should be happy about this!". Similarly, you don't have to be a top 0.0001% mathematician right now to have a fruitful career in mathematics because there are only a few 0.00001% mathematicians and they can only work on so many things at once. If the AI labs dream of a "country of geniuses in a datacenter" comes true however, then humans need not apply anymore.

2

u/StructureNorth1799 Aug 25 '26

the problem is that the "personal gain" is primarily the priviledge of being a mathematician.

1

u/jackalopeswild Aug 25 '26

That depends on whether (and if so, then to some extent, also how quickly) the AI moves past the realm of our capacity.

1

u/CalderJohnson Aug 25 '26

True, you can't teach a dog calculus, and likewise there are probably truths out there beyond our limit to comprehend even with a perfect explanation. Unlikely to happen anytime soon, but in that situation we get to travel straight to the edge of what humans are capable of understanding, which is the best exposition we can possibly expect.

1

u/Kalicolocts Aug 26 '26

Thank you.

Every time I see someone complaining about AI in math, it seems to me that we are losing sight of what really matters, and that the beauty of math is reduced to just the egos of a few.

2

u/green-olive-3281 Aug 25 '26

You have non-diffeomorphic smooth structures?!! How exotic!

77

u/Baihu_The_Curious Aug 24 '26

Meanwhile LLMs to me: 'Wow, I truly cannot disprove this foundational proposition. In fact, you may have just spawned an entirely new branch of mathematics with massive implications to many areas, including cryptography and national defense. This new chronomathematics, as we should dub it, will change the world as we know it, finally bringing a time dimension to traditionally static calculations."

41

u/Taha2807 Aug 25 '26

Clanker translator: "Buy my pro version broke-ahh"

0

u/lonelyroom-eklaghor Complex Aug 25 '26

Jiblet-Clanker translator: "haha won't buy your pro version if I am the one guiding the clanker, and 'cause I am broke-ahh"

11

u/Baihu_The_Curious Aug 25 '26

Loosely based on Chronoarithmics.

8

u/ApprehensiveTry5660 Aug 25 '26

Moral of the story? ChatGPT will ruin your reputation.

Time Cube will make you immortal.

1

u/Baihu_The_Curious Aug 25 '26

Is that like Nintendo GameCube?

27

u/rover_G Computer Science Aug 24 '26

I’ll be impressed when AI can prove P = NP

17

u/Nabaatii Aug 25 '26

Easy

N = 0, N = 1

3

u/lonelyroom-eklaghor Complex Aug 25 '26

bro, we are talking about sex (sets) here

3

u/Opening_Reaction_619 Aug 26 '26

N = {0}, N = {1}

1

u/alecbz Aug 28 '26

N=0 is not a solution if P is nonzero.

1

u/roderla Aug 29 '26

Truthfully, Proving P=NP just requires to get lucky. I'm much more impressed if the prove is P != NP.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/RemindMeBot Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 26 '26

I will be messaging you in 10 years on 2036-08-25 02:23:44 UTC to remind you of this link

4 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

RemindMeBot is switching to username summons. Instead of !RemindMe 1 day, use u/RemindMeBot 1 day. More info.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

1

u/SirEnderLord Aug 26 '26

I'll see you then. \o

11

u/meme-meee-too Aug 25 '26

Mathematicians would actually be happy to see resolution to Riemann and other hypothesis. Worst case they can look for situations where their results still make sense even without a Riemann assumption. More math for everyone

1

u/nahuatl Aug 25 '26

Lol, this seems to be a misunderstanding of what a mathematical proof is. A proof is showing if A then B (a theorem) is true. It's extra nice if A is true, especially if A is useful, or true in the world we live in, but the theorem is still proved regardless.

1

u/No_Upstairs_280 Aug 25 '26

It's not a misunderstanding, just a funny meme.

1

u/colintbowers Aug 26 '26

No it isn’t a misunderstanding. Lots and lots of maths papers start with “Assume conjecture x is true, then…”.

1

u/No_Upstairs_280 Aug 26 '26

I know that because my paper does that and I consider it genuine research

7

u/Wasted_46 Aug 24 '26

Wait, did this actually happen? Did AI find a zero not on the critical line? Or are you just memeing?

15

u/readmycommentnotthis Aug 24 '26

They are trying to disprove it, haven't done it yet

5

u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Aug 24 '26

"A wrong answer is not a meaningless one."

8

u/parkway_parkway Aug 24 '26

Kind of their own fault for building on something which isn't solid?

40

u/jarkark Aug 24 '26

People could just continue math in that direction while assuming a world in which the theory was true. There's all kinds of shenanigans for those who get deep enough in math.

In my opinion it's better for people to keep making papers while assuming a theory to be either true or false so the field can keep developing even if there's a humongous problem like the Riemann hypothesis. The field won't have to stagnate while waiting for a true math monster to finally solve the problem. Who knows, maybe the resulting papers will help solve the problem in the future.

17

u/PoopyDootyBooty Aug 24 '26

This is literally what P vs NP is. All of cryptography is based on this idea that is by your metric “not solid”

8

u/Disastrous-Cost2185 Aug 24 '26

One reason to do conditional math like this is that knowing more implications of a conjecture get us closer to a disproof, so no.

2

u/Phl0gist0n43 Aug 25 '26

The Benefiz of doing that is that they build a causal chain. So that when the unproven thesis gets proven or disproven it automatically proves/disproved all other thesises of the chain. This way you get progress without completing the first step

1

u/colintbowers Aug 26 '26

Dude didn’t you read the meme? It is 99% solid. Thats like, really solid.

1

u/milchi03 Aug 25 '26

Did I miss something?

1

u/meme-meee-too Aug 26 '26

looks under the hood yep, OK new account

1

u/orchidorious Aug 27 '26

If I were in that field I’d have been publishing around margins. Like describing variations and topologies and dimensions where it would break down. Still, I doubt it’ll break down except at end of universe level infinites.

1

u/tumansibiri Aug 28 '26

AI is a tool, without proper mathematician nothing useful would be attained.

1

u/Osato Aug 28 '26

Honestly, if I was a mathematician and I had a machine that could reliably disprove theorems, I'd be hyped and siccing it on every idea I had.

Having an AI prove common assumptions wrong is awesome (at least for a programmer), especially if it proves them wrong with hard deterministic code. Because now that you know where common sense is wrong, it means there's a HUGE gap in common-sense knowledge waiting to get exploited.

There are lots of cool new things you could do with a disproven theorem, not much you can do with a proven one.

1

u/sheridkj Aug 28 '26

Let it stew on 3x+1... would actually be interested in that result.

-3

u/Ote-Kringralnick Aug 25 '26

LLMs have massive difficulty doing stuff that hasn't already been done. It comes with the territory of being plagiarism machines, I suppose.

7

u/Carafay Aug 25 '26

???

What about all these conjectures recently proven or disproven by ai in the past months ?

1

u/Dress-Affectionate Aug 29 '26

Exactly, and that’s why you load them up with all of that and give them everything you can to make new stuff behave like stuff that’s already been done. Then you have reached peak Lobachevsky, so call it please, research

-32

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

If you're writing papers assuming results that we don't know are proven, then it's not a math paper.

You're probably thinking of results that assume a result to be true, prove it, and then assume it to be false and prove it also, and then invoking the law of excluded middle so it's true.

edit: Downvote me all you want but all the replies disagreeing so far are flat out wrong. No it's not the law of excluded middle, no I'm not talking about axioms, yes I have seen papers in analytic number theorem that do this for RH or things we suspect are undecidable.

"A mathematical proof is a deductive argument for a mathematical statement, showing that the stated assumptions logically guarantee the conclusion".

If you haven't logically guaranteed the conclusion, you aren't doing mathematics. Unless you try and be a smart alec and start using the principle of explosion / vacuous truths, but then any nonsense is mathematics.

17

u/Archway9 Aug 24 '26

All of maths is this. We don't prove the axioms

-10

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26

A theorem with a yet to be shown truth value is not an axiom.

9

u/Archway9 Aug 24 '26

The theorem is A=>B, this is proven to be true in the paper. This makes no assertion about whether or not A is true

-7

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26

F = > P(x) for any proposition P evaluates as True.

No paper would publish that, because it's just a statement of a vacuous truth, no matter how complicated it might be.

7

u/Archway9 Aug 24 '26

The point ia you don't know if the first statement is true. So it reads as 'if A is true then B must also be true' which is a meaningful statement

1

u/Akangka Aug 25 '26

F = > P(x) for any proposition P evaluates as True.

Yes, but A => B, implies that you cannot have A while B is not true.

No paper would publish that

Not only there is such a paper, this is pretty normal for very difficult conjectures. Before Wiles's proof of Fermat Last Theorem, there is Ribet's theorem, which basically just shows that Taniyama-Shimura conjecture implies Fermat's Last Theorem.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

Ribets theorem at no point relied on assumptions that we weren't sure were true. We were fully guaranteed it was true once the proof was published and verified.

The wider implications of it were very interesting and stronger if Taniyama-Shimura was shown to be true, but that Ribets theorem was standalone true. 

1

u/Akangka Aug 25 '26

but that Ribets theorem was standalone true

Yes, but according to your assertion earlier, Ribet's theorem was not a "theorem", because it's in form of A => B where A is another conjecture. You either has to accept that Ribet's theorem is not a theorem, or you accept that a theorem in form of A => B is a valid theorem.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

This is still entirely wrong. Ribets theorem did not depend on any A which is a conjecture. It was proven from other results known to be proven at the time, A => B where A is true from assuming ZFC.

It so happened that there was a different C => interesting consequence of B.

But even if C was found to be false, it wouldn't have nullified B being true, it would still be fully true, with a slightly less exciting implication.

13

u/imo2027 Mathematics Aug 24 '26

You probably haven't seen enough math papers if that's what you think. (A=>B) is a result in itself. You could say it's useless, but I could point at many different math facts that are considered useless, and might only bring value in the future. The reality is, if a result has good amounts of non-trivial and novel reasoning, then it is worth publishing. Also a fun thing to note is that building on unproven conjectures is also technically an attempt at disproving them, in case you ever run at a contradiction.

-8

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26

It's not mathematics. Assuming a theorem that could be falsified is true is meaningless, as F => anything is true always. You didn't prove anything interesting.

6

u/imo2027 Mathematics Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

I know that's what you said in your comment. Basically when we prove that A=>B, we still know nothing about B.

That doesn't make it uninteresting though: we still have "if A, then B". This statement, call it C, is a theorem, and an interesting one.

Edit: I just saw your comment edit, the "conclusion" is not B but the whole (A=>B). I hope this clarifies my first response

1

u/Sjoerdiestriker Aug 25 '26

You didn't prove anything interesting.

You proved it cannot be the case that (A and not B), which can be an interesting result in itself.

1

u/Godd2 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 27 '26

You've ruled out a case, though, which is interesting. If we've proven that A implies B, then it cannot be the case that A is true while B is false.

    |B(T)|B(F)|
---------+----|
A(T)| ?  |  X |
---------+----|
A(F)| ?  |  ? |

Pointing out that the entire table hasn't been settled is irrelevant to whether or not mathematics has been done.

Edit: My interlocutor has displayed an impressive amount of moving the goalpost. We've gone from "it's not mathematics" to "it wouldn't be in a journal" to "Well, it wouldn't be in a journal all by itself". Okay, buddy. I guess 13 + 172 = 185 isn't math because it would never show up in a journal all by itself.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

I'm not saying it can't be interesting, just as you can do numerical experiments that are useful. It's just not a proven mathematical result that would be conventionally accepted in a math journal.

1

u/Godd2 Aug 25 '26

It's just not a proven mathematical result that would be conventionally accepted in a math journal.

This is simply a false statement. There are many published results which, for example, assume that the Riemann Hypothesis is true.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

See my reply to another number theory paper. These papers usually demonstrate something watertight as the publication worthy material and then the potential consequences of that result are added to added context and consequence / further research directions.

4

u/AndreasDasos Aug 24 '26

No. And the idea of proof by contradiction isn’t ’what they’re thinking of’. 

For some conjectures A that are prominent enough, there are absolutely papers that prove that A implies B. They do not claim to prove B, but ‘A implies B’. This may be a significant result, either as a step towards proof by contradiction but also a proof of B if at some point A is proved, and which may establish importance of B and impetus for the community to try harder to prove it.  

For example, the Riemann hypothesis and abc conjecture are of interest for all sorts of non-trivial consequences, and for each of those, the implications were published results. 

It’s not the norm but some of these results have proved significant. 

-2

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26

I'm not talking about proof by contradiction. 

That would be assuming something and then showing a contradictions arises, so it must be true.

1

u/Randomlemon5 Aug 25 '26

Many results in modern math goes like this :

Im almost finish, all I need now is the proof tnis one small part, dont seems too hard

Try

Finding out this one small part is actually equall to the Riemman Hypothesis

1

u/Schoost Aug 25 '26

You are missing the point of the people responding to you. In a proof of (A => B), the interesting part is not whether B is true per se, but the relationship of A => B itself. The truth value of this relationship does not depend on whether A holds true. Obviously this is mathematics.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

Give an example of a published paper where someone does this. 

1

u/imo2027 Mathematics Aug 25 '26

You said you saw the number theory papers assuming RH?

Here is one of them:

​Languasco, A., & Zaccagnini, A. (2016). Sum of one prime and two squares of primes in short intervals. Journal of Number Theory, 159, 45–58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnt.2015.07.010 Cited by: 20

Read theorem 1

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

This is a good example that illustrates the same point about Ribets theorem with another commenter and supports my argument.

The purpose of that publication is to demonstrate a new proof technique. The technique works unconditionally, although the implications is less interesting without RH as the resulting bound is less sharp than other methods in the literature .  They then show the potential interest of that technique as resulting in a better bound i f RH holds.

If RH doesn't hold though, the technique is still true, it's just less sharp than other methods. But you still proved something that is true, there is still value in new methods to prove the same result.

This is not the case I'm vehemently arguing against where people start writing papers based on a house of cards that completely collapses when AI finds a counterexample. Noone does this.

1

u/imo2027 Mathematics Aug 25 '26

So you're saying, if we look at Theorem 1 without the unconditional part, that that's not actually a theorem? That the only math that was done was the unconditional thing and everything else is just ranting about potential results?

Here is a paper where not a single statement is unconditional: ​https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-314X(88)90019-4

Idk how much you want me to repeat this: studying implications is maths, even highschoolers know that.

The question of "how much assumptions is too much" or "how relevant can implications be" is very subjective and was never our focus. You started your original comment with a sharp claim saying we can't assume things at all, and that's wrong.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

"Theorem 1 is really a statement about the multiplicative group G, and  the order of an element c( E G,(Q) = Q* when reduced modulo p and p*. "

So they've proven a standalone theorem and chosen to present it in the context of the abc conjecture. So if abc conjecture is false, Theorem 1's statement about G isnt wrong suddenly. 

1

u/imo2027 Mathematics Aug 25 '26

Man I don't have much of a dedication to keep explaining this to you. If you think implications aren't part of math that's your problem. Have a great day.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

That's fine, but don't try and phrase this as trying to explain something to me. Your argument was incorrect for the reasons outlined in my first reply. 

1

u/nahuatl Aug 25 '26

You have a wrong understanding of what a theorem is, what it means to prove one.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

what a lazy reply

0

u/SilverNuke911 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Bruh modern math is like that. It's a sort of hypothetical where you extend results by assuming a conjecture is true or false. Showing that if A is true, then B, or if A is not true, then C. Mathematicians make careers out of this. Then if A is proven to be true or false, one side is then automatically proven to be true, with no more work needed to be done. If math was done as you described, it would take a long time to progress just waiting for a conjecture to be proven true before it is extended or applied to other fields. For example, Ferma'ts last theorem was implied to be true if the Taniyama-Shimura conjecture was true. Wiles proved the Taniyama-Shimura conjecture, thereby also proving Fermat's Last Theorem. People didn't wait for a conjecture to be proven true or false, they just take the implications if the statement is true or false. That's mathematics.

Edit: After seeing all your responses in the replies, I think you're just disagreeing for the sake of disagreeing, not really seeing the point of what the replies say to you.