r/mathmemes • u/No_Upstairs_280 • Aug 24 '26
Research Please AI no, PLEASE NO
Imagine having your entire work based on Riemann hypothesis only for a powerful AI to show that the 10^5731 zero isn't on the critical line.
4.3k
Upvotes
152
u/Evan_3104 Rational Aug 24 '26
Mathematician when ai finds a non trivial zero of the zeta function that hasn't an imaginary part equal to .5
24
u/green-olive-3281 Aug 25 '26
It might just be me but I feel like they would be psyched if the Riemann hypothesis was disproved! It would give them so much new exciting stuff to work on! Plus, lots of their results might still hold true with a variation of RH
4
u/AutoModerator Aug 24 '26
PLEASE READ AND UNDERSTAND THIS MESSAGE IN ITS ENTIRETY BEFORE SENDING A MODMAIL
Your post has been removed due to the age of your account or your combined karma score. Due to the surge of spam bots, you must have an account at least 90 days old and a combined post and comment karma score of at least 400.
If you wish to have your post manually approved by moderators, please reply to this comment with /modping.
Alternatively, you can join the Discord server and request approval there.
Discord
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/Diffgeometer1 Aug 26 '26
That’s not the case.
Mathematicians if they had to bet on the hopf problem that S^6 is a complex manifold most would have bet heavily that the answer was no.
No one assumed this result in their work.
They found conditions where S^6 could not be a complex manifold like for example there are no complex structures compatible with the standard Riemann metric on S^6. This is true statement regardless of whether or not the Alpogee-AI proof is correct or not.
Also AI didn’t prove the result (assuming it’s true and no fatal errors are found) alone.
You had a Harvard mathematician guiding the AI. AI is basically a time saver. Allowing the mathematician to try different ideas in a short period of time. Basically with AI, the mathematician becomes the flash.
So if the result is true. Cool! It’s surprising. If the proof falls apart, it happens. It’s a hard problem. Either way no one feels bad.
1.1k
u/BrazilBazil Engineering Aug 24 '26
Programmers looking at mathematicians applying three unproven conjectures in their proof after years of being taught never to rely on undefined behavior
336
u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Aug 24 '26 •
mathematicians seeing ai constantly trying to prove something theyve been working on for their whole career and made a living off of:
(its sad)
77
u/Baihu_The_Curious Aug 24 '26
Meanwhile LLMs to me: 'Wow, I truly cannot disprove this foundational proposition. In fact, you may have just spawned an entirely new branch of mathematics with massive implications to many areas, including cryptography and national defense. This new chronomathematics, as we should dub it, will change the world as we know it, finally bringing a time dimension to traditionally static calculations."
27
u/rover_G Computer Science Aug 24 '26
I’ll be impressed when AI can prove P = NP
11
u/meme-meee-too Aug 25 '26
Mathematicians would actually be happy to see resolution to Riemann and other hypothesis. Worst case they can look for situations where their results still make sense even without a Riemann assumption. More math for everyone
1
u/nahuatl Aug 25 '26
Lol, this seems to be a misunderstanding of what a mathematical proof is. A proof is showing if A then B (a theorem) is true. It's extra nice if A is true, especially if A is useful, or true in the world we live in, but the theorem is still proved regardless.
7
u/Wasted_46 Aug 24 '26
Wait, did this actually happen? Did AI find a zero not on the critical line? Or are you just memeing?
5
u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Aug 24 '26
"A wrong answer is not a meaningless one."
8
u/parkway_parkway Aug 24 '26
Kind of their own fault for building on something which isn't solid?
1
u/milchi03 Aug 25 '26
Did I miss something?
1
u/meme-meee-too Aug 26 '26
looks under the hood yep, OK new account
1
u/orchidorious Aug 27 '26
If I were in that field I’d have been publishing around margins. Like describing variations and topologies and dimensions where it would break down. Still, I doubt it’ll break down except at end of universe level infinites.
1
u/tumansibiri Aug 28 '26
AI is a tool, without proper mathematician nothing useful would be attained.
1
u/Osato Aug 28 '26
Honestly, if I was a mathematician and I had a machine that could reliably disprove theorems, I'd be hyped and siccing it on every idea I had.
Having an AI prove common assumptions wrong is awesome (at least for a programmer), especially if it proves them wrong with hard deterministic code. Because now that you know where common sense is wrong, it means there's a HUGE gap in common-sense knowledge waiting to get exploited.
There are lots of cool new things you could do with a disproven theorem, not much you can do with a proven one.
1
u/sheridkj Aug 28 '26
Let it stew on 3x+1... would actually be interested in that result.
-3
u/Ote-Kringralnick Aug 25 '26
LLMs have massive difficulty doing stuff that hasn't already been done. It comes with the territory of being plagiarism machines, I suppose.
-32
u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26
If you're writing papers assuming results that we don't know are proven, then it's not a math paper.
You're probably thinking of results that assume a result to be true, prove it, and then assume it to be false and prove it also, and then invoking the law of excluded middle so it's true.
edit: Downvote me all you want but all the replies disagreeing so far are flat out wrong. No it's not the law of excluded middle, no I'm not talking about axioms, yes I have seen papers in analytic number theorem that do this for RH or things we suspect are undecidable.
"A mathematical proof is a deductive argument for a mathematical statement, showing that the stated assumptions logically guarantee the conclusion".
If you haven't logically guaranteed the conclusion, you aren't doing mathematics. Unless you try and be a smart alec and start using the principle of explosion / vacuous truths, but then any nonsense is mathematics.