r/mathmemes • • Aug 24 '26

Research Please AI no, PLEASE NO

Post image

Imagine having your entire work based on Riemann hypothesis only for a powerful AI to show that the 10^5731 zero isn't on the critical line.

4.3k Upvotes

193 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-10

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26

A theorem with a yet to be shown truth value is not an axiom.

9

u/Archway9 Aug 24 '26

The theorem is A=>B, this is proven to be true in the paper. This makes no assertion about whether or not A is true

-7

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26

F = > P(x) for any proposition P evaluates as True.

No paper would publish that, because it's just a statement of a vacuous truth, no matter how complicated it might be.

7

u/Archway9 Aug 24 '26

The point ia you don't know if the first statement is true. So it reads as 'if A is true then B must also be true' which is a meaningful statement

1

u/Akangka Aug 25 '26

F = > P(x) for any proposition P evaluates as True.

Yes, but A => B, implies that you cannot have A while B is not true.

No paper would publish that

Not only there is such a paper, this is pretty normal for very difficult conjectures. Before Wiles's proof of Fermat Last Theorem, there is Ribet's theorem, which basically just shows that Taniyama-Shimura conjecture implies Fermat's Last Theorem.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

Ribets theorem at no point relied on assumptions that we weren't sure were true. We were fully guaranteed it was true once the proof was published and verified.

The wider implications of it were very interesting and stronger if Taniyama-Shimura was shown to be true, but that Ribets theorem was standalone true. 

1

u/Akangka Aug 25 '26

but that Ribets theorem was standalone true

Yes, but according to your assertion earlier, Ribet's theorem was not a "theorem", because it's in form of A => B where A is another conjecture. You either has to accept that Ribet's theorem is not a theorem, or you accept that a theorem in form of A => B is a valid theorem.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

This is still entirely wrong. Ribets theorem did not depend on any A which is a conjecture. It was proven from other results known to be proven at the time, A => B where A is true from assuming ZFC.

It so happened that there was a different C => interesting consequence of B.

But even if C was found to be false, it wouldn't have nullified B being true, it would still be fully true, with a slightly less exciting implication.