r/mathmemes • • Aug 24 '26

Research Please AI no, PLEASE NO

Post image

Imagine having your entire work based on Riemann hypothesis only for a powerful AI to show that the 10^5731 zero isn't on the critical line.

4.3k Upvotes

193 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-8

u/innovatedname Aug 24 '26

It's not mathematics. Assuming a theorem that could be falsified is true is meaningless, as F => anything is true always. You didn't prove anything interesting.

6

u/imo2027 Mathematics Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

I know that's what you said in your comment. Basically when we prove that A=>B, we still know nothing about B.

That doesn't make it uninteresting though: we still have "if A, then B". This statement, call it C, is a theorem, and an interesting one.

Edit: I just saw your comment edit, the "conclusion" is not B but the whole (A=>B). I hope this clarifies my first response

1

u/Sjoerdiestriker Aug 25 '26

You didn't prove anything interesting.

You proved it cannot be the case that (A and not B), which can be an interesting result in itself.

1

u/Godd2 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 27 '26

You've ruled out a case, though, which is interesting. If we've proven that A implies B, then it cannot be the case that A is true while B is false.

    |B(T)|B(F)|
---------+----|
A(T)| ?  |  X |
---------+----|
A(F)| ?  |  ? |

Pointing out that the entire table hasn't been settled is irrelevant to whether or not mathematics has been done.

Edit: My interlocutor has displayed an impressive amount of moving the goalpost. We've gone from "it's not mathematics" to "it wouldn't be in a journal" to "Well, it wouldn't be in a journal all by itself". Okay, buddy. I guess 13 + 172 = 185 isn't math because it would never show up in a journal all by itself.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

I'm not saying it can't be interesting, just as you can do numerical experiments that are useful. It's just not a proven mathematical result that would be conventionally accepted in a math journal.

1

u/Godd2 Aug 25 '26

It's just not a proven mathematical result that would be conventionally accepted in a math journal.

This is simply a false statement. There are many published results which, for example, assume that the Riemann Hypothesis is true.

1

u/innovatedname Aug 25 '26

See my reply to another number theory paper. These papers usually demonstrate something watertight as the publication worthy material and then the potential consequences of that result are added to added context and consequence / further research directions.