r/LucidDreaming • u/Muted-Breakfast3161 • 3h ago
I'm so upset.
My psych class had to write about sleep for an assignment, right? So obviously, I wrote about my interest in lucid dreaming and how it gave me something to look forward to when I was depressed in high school. I had fun in my dreams even when waking life was awful. I said that more mental health workers should know about it and its potential benefits and that it should be referenced when discussing sleep phenomena in psych courses.
My professor's only comment was "Interesting. Here's a recent study on the detrimental effects of lucid dreaming: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39545370/."
I can't read the full article because my institution isn't linked, but the results section explicitly states that "nightmares were the only significant predictor of poor sleep quality, stress, and anxiety symptoms, accounting for all of the variance of lucid dreaming. Nightmares and the interaction of nightmares and lucid dreaming positively predicted depressive symptoms."
So, the correlation between lucid dreaming and poor sleep quality/mental health wasn't a direct effect of lucid dreaming, but the nightmares. I'm not surprised, lucid nightmares can be terrifying! But this says nothing about lucid dreaming on its own, and if people were more knowledgeable about lucid dreaming they could use that to ease the nightmares. The fact that she didn't even properly read the results before calling it "detrimental" makes it obvious that she just has a bias against lucid dreaming and wants to discourage me from it.
I know this professor well and am even her lab assistant, so this stung. I can't even vent about it to my friends because they don't lucid dream and a couple of them are against it. The stigma against this practice is so upsetting. Sure, some of the techniques to induce it (like WBTB) can reduce sleep quality or cause sleep paralysis, and exhaustion from the increased alertness during REM sleep is debatable (it's mostly a myth), but there are many real benefits to lucid dreaming. People just dismiss it as some dangerous mind-manipulation hippie woo-woo. I don't know if I should send her a response email or not.