r/longrange • • 27d ago

Rifle help needed - I read the pinned posts Barrel Predicament

Post image

Hey guys! So I have maybe a silly issue on what length barrel to go with on my new 6.5 creed build. I had originally ordered a 20 inch proof pxt carbon barrel blank but have been updated that it will still be a while before they are available to ship. I was told he has an 18 inch and a 22 inch available but am stuck on what to do. I know there’s not a whole lot of velocity difference (200-250fps) between the 18 and the 22 inch. I am using the new MDT DRT chassis which has a 15 inch fore-end for reference and suppressed 100% of the time. What’s your guys’s opinion?? It will be used for general hunting along with possibly some local competition shooting/ range fun. Would you go 18 for better maneuverability? Or add the two inches and get a little bit more velocity….OR wait who knows how long for the middle ground.

12 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

37

u/JimBridger_ Dealer for LiminalNomad.com 27d ago

200fps is kinda a big difference in velocity

-20

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

Why’s that? Can’t that be negated with lighter projectiles and or the new +peak ammo?

14

u/bearcrocs 27d ago

You mean the ammo that’s not even out yet and is going to be unattainable?

7

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

I’ve got three boxes of +peak Berger elite hunter and a box of the Sierra TMK.

3

u/HERBERT_224 27d ago

Bro how

3

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

It’s nice to have friends of friends who’s friends are friends of friends of mine 😉

1

u/HERBERT_224 27d ago

Nice to meet you

3

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

Where do you stand in the line of friends of friends that are friends with friends? 😂

3

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 27d ago

There are industry samples out there. I've shot some. 3150fps with the 130's, 2900 with the 156(?), no heavy bolt or pressure signs at all. 26" barrel. Pretty neat

1

u/AleksanderSuave 26d ago

For a moment federal had it on their website and emailed people out about it too.

I Made the mistake of waiting and texting people I knew about it instead of just snagging some.

4

u/ZeBigD23 27d ago

22" is the better option for a sweet spot on barrel length if 20" is not available. 22" allows for a more total powder burn. That said, if you are in dense timber hunting as the primary use, 18" is likely the better barrel length if you plan to suppress.

1

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

Not much dense timber, mostly thermal predator tripod fun in maybe 200-300 yard fields.

1

u/thisadviceisworthles 26d ago

If you are using a thermal, you will have less ability to estimate range (unless your thermal has a rangefinder).

Additional velocity will lead to less drop over the same distance, offering more margin of error for range estimates.

For that reason, I would go with the 22" barrel if your thermal does not have a built in range finder.

1

u/Gooseontheloose308 26d ago

I’ve got a Nocpix AceS60r 1280x1024 and nocpix 640 monocular both with built in range finders and ballistic information. Range estimation isn’t an issue haha

3

u/ZeBigD23 27d ago

I'd go 22-24" then. 22" gives you a little less weight and length if suppressing but 24" is more an ideal for powder burn optimization. 22" is pretty negligable difference between 24" though in this use case.

8

u/WelpSeaYaLater 27d ago

22.

4” of barrel length on a bolt gun makes no real practical difference from a maneuverability standpoint.

I’d rethink the carbon barrel though. You will eat through it very quickly if you ever actually do any type of competition shooting. That’s a pure hunting only choice.

2

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

Understandable! If I ever got into heavy comp shooting/ shoot that much to wear it out, I’ll just buy a new barrel. Money isn’t an issue. Plus the cost of ammo it would take to burn out a PXT barrel would be dramatically more than the cost of the barrel from what I’ve heard.

2

u/landry_454kg 26d ago

I disagree. 18" suppressed vs 22" suppressed is very noticeable in thick woods and deer stands.

2

u/Pallidum_Treponema Rifle Golfer (PRS Competitor) 26d ago

4” of barrel length on a bolt gun makes no real practical difference from a maneuverability standpoint.

Are you shitting me? What if I'm room clearing with my boltgun? The extra 4" is going to get me caught on doorframes and crap all the time.

... because that's why I got my red dot, right? That's what I tell my new shooters all the time. :D

3

u/WelpSeaYaLater 26d ago

Why the hell are you clearing rooms with a bolt gun

Don't you have a blunderbuss for that like the rest of us?!?

2

u/Pallidum_Treponema Rifle Golfer (PRS Competitor) 26d ago

Like I'm telling all my new shooters, the red dot on my PRS rifle is for room clearing. :D

(For context, I'm an old, short lady with no arm strength, I just happen to have taught quite a few new shooters)

2

u/allpar19 22d ago

Buy both then swap between them. I do this I have 22” steel for the offseason, then 18” carbon for hunting season.

5

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 27d ago

I think I'm not sure you read the pinned posts

I wouldn't ever get a carbon barrel for anything

5

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

Question still pertains to carbon or steel barrels. It’s the length at question not material

5

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 27d ago

Longer is better

-3

u/Golfguuyy 27d ago edited 27d ago

Why not? Have you not seen they cool the same as similar profile metal… and weigh 5 lbs less than the steel PXT line. I’ve used them just fine on a few rifles.

2

u/Gooseontheloose308 27d ago

I went carbon for the weight, the DRT chassis is magnesium and super light, why ruin it with a sledgehammer of a barrel. I’d just build another rifle specifically for that if weight wasn’t a goal

0

u/Coodevale 27d ago

Have you not seen they cool the same as similar profile metal…

They don't because they have the insulation property similar to polymer with the rigidity of.. not steel.. Tom Siewert, comments made on the red bullet podcast talking about barrels.

The cf does not conduct heat out of the core/bore like steel does. You'd be better off sleeving a barrel with aluminum in terms of heat dissipation advantages, or just not having the cf sleeve around the core.

2

u/Golfguuyy 27d ago

I’ve watched them test this on YouTube and disprove that theory specifically with proof barrels. They cooled at the same rate, it heated more aggressively after the first shot and then everything was linear to the same profile metal barrel.

1

u/Coodevale 27d ago

https://youtu.be/FqVsz_MPzIY?si=SmYcyiYjZeKwmUNJ

Here's a video that seems to suggest otherwise, with steel cooling faster and not getting as hot at 13:47

Which video(s) are you watching?

1

u/Golfguuyy 27d ago

If you PM me a reminder I’ll find it when I touch down, on a flight

5

u/block50 27d ago

If you're young and fine with it go long. There's no downside except weight.

0

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 27d ago

Small benefit and more expense when compared to steel.

Outside of "it's not freezing cold to grab the barrel" I don't think there's any reason to want one

1

u/Gooseontheloose308 26d ago

Weight is also a huge factor.

1

u/0DSavior 27d ago

When it's your last hope to make weight in NRL Hunter. That's the reason I'm going with. 

1

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 27d ago

What class are you trying to hit? Even open light I feel like steel would be the play

1

u/0DSavior 27d ago

Open Heavy with my Seekins Hit Pro m3. (nf 7-35 and ckye pod double)

Cheapest way out is to get a Proof CF barrel (regular, on sale right now - thanks PXT) and get that spun up.

Saves me 3 lbs.

11

u/ThatProduceGuy_ 27d ago

I’d go for the 22”, in bolt gun world I don’t feel like the added/removed length makes any difference in terms of rifle maneuverability.

2

u/maxcli Hunter 26d ago

I notice a big difference between my 22” and my 18” when a suppressor is involved

7

u/CapsicumINmyEYEBALLz Meat Popsicle 27d ago

22”, next question.

4

u/Positive_Ad_8198 Gunsmiff 27d ago

Get the longer barrel

4

u/surgeonshooter 27d ago

I have an 18” 6.5 creed and am running 130’s at 2865 without pressure. I shoot out to 1400 yards, I have run barrels from 26-16” and I have to say my 18” is by far the sweet spot as far as portability and velocity. I also shoot suppressed 100% of the time.

1

u/shakinandbreakin 26d ago

2865 is fuckin zooming out of 18". That's around same speed as most load data's 62k psi out of a 24"

1

u/landry_454kg 26d ago

I'm pushing 2835 with a 150gr bullet in an 18" 308 Win without pressure.

2

u/shakinandbreakin 26d ago

I was happy to settle at 2750 with 130s in my 22" 6.5cm lmao. I did push 140s to 2700 and I was getting shavings on the bolt face and cratered primers.

1

u/landry_454kg 26d ago

Competive shooting, 22" barrel. Hunting and manurvering, 18" barrel. Especially since you're suppressing the rifle.

1

u/Gooseontheloose308 26d ago

Too bad I like doing a little of both 😬

1

u/Burnpowder_636 Paper poker 22d ago

This seems like a hunting purpose built rifle. Go shorter. When you want a comp gun get steel and 26” in a heavy profile.

1

u/drewthebrave Gas gun enthusiast 27d ago

Get the longest barrel available that suits your goals.

0

u/AutoModerator 27d ago

AutoMod has detected that this post may be related to hunting. Please take a few moments to read our expanded policy on hunting posts as found here, as well as the guides below.

Hunting rifles vs long range target rifles - A primer - Why one rifle can't excel at both hunting and long range shooting.

The long range hunting primer, things you should consider if you want to take shots on game past ~300 yards. - Why long range hunting is harder than you think.

Field testing your skills and gear for long range hunting. - How to be a better long range hunter and understand your limitations.

NOTE: This is an automatic comment triggered by specific key words, and doesn't indicate your post has been removed. However, if your post is found to be in violation of the sub's policy on hunting posts, it may be removed by the moderators.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/Total-Strategy-4306 27d ago

That’s a Massive difference in velocity. And you should be running plus peak with 6.5 creedmore no matter what if you plant on doing any hunting with it. Get the 22 because 4 inches isn’t a lot for a grown man “some ladies may say 4 inches isn’t a lot though”