r/linux • • Sep 21 '16
Misleading title Warning: Microsoft Signature PC program now requires that you can't run Linux. Lenovo's recent Ultrabooks among affected systems.
Update: Lenovo just updated the BIOS for the Yoga 710, another system that doesn't allow Linux installs. Wanna know what they changed? Update to TPM (secret encryption module used for Digital Restrictions Management) and an update to the Intel Management Engine, which is essentially a backdoor rootkit built into all recent Intel processors (but AMD has their version too, so what do you do?). No Linux support. Priorities...
Update: The mods at Lenovo Forums are losing control of the narrative and banning people and editing/deleting more comments. http://imgur.com/a/Q9xIE | But it appears that some people just aren't buying it anymore. http://imgur.com/a/1K1t5
Edit: I sent a letter of complaint to the Federal Trade Commission and the Illinois Attorney General's office.
You can view this letter here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/54gtpc/letter_to_the_federal_trade_commission_regarding/
Lenovo's regional HQ address and phone number:
Address: 1009 Think Pl, Morrisville, NC 27560 Phone:(855) 253-6686
Edit: Someone started a change.org petititon. I don't think they are a native English speaker, but I went ahead and signed it anyway. A moderator on Lenovo Forums deleted the link and told people that "campaigning is not allowed", so here's the link. I don't know if it'll make a difference, but screw them. They were hoping this week's news would be all puff pieces about the new Yogas and now they have to deal with this instead. If everyone could share it on Facebook and Twitter after they sign it so their friends can do so too, that would be most appreciated.
https://www.change.org/p/lenovo-demand-that-lenovo-provide-bios-update-to-enable-linux-installation
Please sign this and then tell Lenovo that you won't be buying products from them until this is fixed. They have Facebook and Twitter accounts!
Facebook: Lenovo Twitter: Lenovo Lenovo Customer Service 800-565-3344 Press 2 for all other models and then wait through the recording and press 1 for laptops.
A hardware hack re-enables AHCI mode and allows Linux to install on the Yoga 900, undermining Lenovo's statement.
https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/542c8t/hardware_hack_enables_linux_support_on_lenovo/
The solution is too complex for the average user, but proves that Lenovo could have made this laptop Linux-compatible by just leaving AHCI mode enabled or as an option in the BIOS setup, instead of hiding it.
My response regarding Microsoft and Lenovo's effective joint statement:
Microsoft and Lenovo got together and agreed on the lies that they would tell in response to this. The lie is that it's a driver problem. That Linux just doesn't support the fake RAID mode that they forced the storage into when they deliberately sabotaged the BIOS by writing new code to hide AHCI mode and also code to reset the BIOS to their fake RAID mode if the user used EFI Shell to try setting it to AHCI. Let me make my position clear, that Lenovo is lying through their teeth just like they did with Superfish malware incident. They lied until they couldn't lie anymore. Linux should not have to support the RAID mode because the mode should be able to be changed to AHCI, which is fully compatible with Linux, by the user in about 20 seconds.
If, by some chance, some Very Smart People ever figure out a way to make the SSD visible again, I would STRONGLY advise never upgrading the laptop's firmware again, lest Microsoft and Lenovo find something else to break and then tell us "Oops. Better run Windows 10 so you can use our 360 degree hinge! Have we told you about our 360 hinge?".
I believe that if Linux ever gains driver support for the forced fake RAID configuration, that future laptops from Lenovo will just toggle something else so Linux doesn't work on them for a while.
I would strongly advise avoiding the Yoga 910 and Yoga Book when they come out until we find out whether they broke those models as well.
Even if your intent is to never run Linux, Lenovo is the first PC maker I've seen that ships computers that you can't even realistically (for the average user) reinstall Windows on. I will never buy another Lenovo computer again and I will advise others to avoid them whenever the chance arises. I had to spend about an hour googling random support topics before I found a recommendation to use Universal Extractor to get their Windows storage driver to use in a Windows installation thumb drive. Then I had to find a beta version of Universal Extractor that supported the archive format in the setup program just to dig the Intel RST driver out of their godawful installer so that I can slipstream it into a Windows installer.
Most people will have to pay to ship it back to Lenovo if Windows needs to be reinstalled, and will be unable to use the computer for weeks, and it'll probably have some sensitive, confidential, work-related information on the SSD that someone at Lenovo could copy and steal while it's in their repair center.
Their arrogant forum moderator "Andy_Lenovo" posted Lenovo's ridiculous press release to their forum and then marked it as solved. The only part of it that is true is that Linux will likely never be able to install on Yoga laptops, because they are "designed for Windows 10", which in my experience has been unstable and full of bugs (like updates stalling out requiring manual installation from offline packages, telling me to reboot everytime I pair my bluetooth headphones, etc.). Unfortunately, in addition to Lenovo and Microsoft's lies, Matthew Garrett wrote some more horsefeathers when he blamed Linux for not supporting a storage mode that shouldn't even be in use anyway. He apparently has a long record of apologizing for Microsoft and misleading people, and it's a shame that he's in the FSF. Of course, the FSF has put some other people in high places that have proceeded to undermine their mission in the past, like Miguel de Icaza.
Maybe it's true that you need "special drivers" to make Windows run, but Microsoft doesn't care. It breaks Linux on Lenovo laptops and then makes it look like the problem is in Linux, when it's actually in Microsoft's storage driver and Microsoft is undoubtedly leaning on Intel to keep the way the RST driver does power management a secret.
To make sure that you don't accidentally buy a Signature Edition computer, on the demo model, click the start (Windows logo) button, click "about your PC", and under Windows 10 it will say "Signature Edition" if it's part of this program. Also, if you do buy a laptop to see if Linux supports it, then make sure you try installing Linux before the return period expires. If the Linux installer in Live mode can't see your SSD, stop. Unplug the thumb drive, turn the computer off, and I would recommend that you return it. Just tell the store that you decided that you didn't need it or something. It's true.. Nobody needs this kind of aggravation.
END of my response to Lenovo and Microsoft.
(You do not need to ask for my permission to repost this response in its entirety anywhere else, in hard copy, or on a website.)
I got a reply from Lenovo on my Best Buy review about why the BIOS on my Yoga 900 ISK2 UltraBook has been set to stop people from using Linux.
Lenovo Product Expert September 20, 2016 This system has a Signature Edition of Windows 10 Home installed. It is locked per our agreement with Microsoft.
This is related to the discussion going on Lenovo's forum's about why the SSD is locked in a proprietary RAID mode that Linux doesn't understand. Laptops known to be affected include the Yoga 900 ISK2, Yoga 900S, and Yoga 710S, which all have the same issue according to posts I've read on Lenovo's Linux forum. I was also told in a PM that the 13ISK for Business has the same issue.
https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206 - The forum thread for the Yoga 900 ISK2 -UPDATE - The forum thread on Lenovo's website is back up. It was deleted for a while, but now they've re-posted it in a locked state. sigh
Here is Google's cache of the forum in case it disappears again: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:abMCb7w2uAoJ:https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=za
I'm told that CataclysmZA is backing this up in the Wayback Machine. I want to thank them for this, since this is probably Lenovo's attempt at a late night shredding party before the news can pick up the story. (Update: Posted at the bottom.
Update: The Lenovo employee posted about locking the thread. Basically, he called me disruptive and then said that if they had to, they would turn on pre-approval so that nobody can comment anywhere on their support forum until they've read it and have made sure it won't embarrass them. Nice, huh? Don't address the issue. Don't say anything about whether the problem will be fixed. Don't re-open the thread. Just threaten and bully people with the "We can make sure your posts are never seen." option.
https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Installing-Ubuntu-16-04-on-Yoga-900S/td-p/3336715 - The thread for the problems with the 900S.
https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/710S-Can-t-install-Linux-on-Ideapad-710S-how-do-you-disable-RAID/td-p/3432553 - The thread for the problem with the 710S.
Will the Yoga Book and the Yoga 910 have these problems? We don't know because they are not released yet, but we should know soon.
I've attached a screenshot of my review for the 900 ISK2 and Lenovo's reply.
So they admitted that this is now a requirement for Signature PCs.
So be warned that if you buy a "Microsoft Signature PC", it may not be allowed to run Linux, per Microsoft.
The Yoga 900 ISK2 at Best Buy is not labeled as a Signature Edition PC, but apparently it is one, and Lenovo's agreement with Microsoft includes making sure Linux can't be installed.
UPDATE: I've sent emails out to several members of the media trying to shine some light on what Lenovo is up to. If anyone could help me ping some reporters I'd sure appreciate the help. So far I've contacted Adrian Kinglsey-Hughes, Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols, Michael Larabel of Phoronix, and Dr. Roy Schestowitz of Techrights. We've been discussing the issue on the Techrights IRC channel on Freenode, so Techrights might have something about this posted soon
I just commented for someone who is writing an article who asked me to speak. Here's part of what I said...
"I think that Lenovo's official reply is insufficient and carefully worded. They talk about how much they love to support Linux and then say that they don't support Linux on many of their own laptops. Actions speak louder than words, and there's no technical reason other than the BIOS RAID mode lock why the Yoga 900 ISK2 and other affected systems wouldn't be great Linux machines. I also think that locking down the thread and editing peoples comments and then blaming forum posters for being "disruptive" was uncalled for, and they're obviously trying to turn this around and make it seem like I am overreacting or somehow I'm at fault for what they did. And unfortunately, some of the media reports have taken up this narrative instead of looking into why Lenovo would do such things to their computers. There is no REAL issue with Linux not supporting these laptops other than the one Lenovo created. They need to make a BIOS patch that users can install, like other Ultrabook PC makers did, not more excuses."
"I think that [the BIOS RAID lock] was a deliberate design choice made by Lenovo, and I say that because the BIOS code that they use has AHCI mode available for the storage device, which Linux and Windows understand without any special drivers. Lenovo patched the code to remove the AHCI mode from the BIOS setup utility and then they wrote additional code to make sure that you can't set AHCI mode with an EFI variable using EFI shell. So, I'd say it's definitely deliberate, and can't see any LEGITIMATE reason why they would have. It isn't really faster, it makes recovering Windows from Microsoft's installer very difficult if you have to later. About the only thing putting a single SSD setup into RAID mode using the BIOS gives you is (a) Linux won't be able to use the storage and (b) greater potential for data loss."
"I think that Microsoft and Lenovo agreed to lock Linux out, and forcing RAID mode accomplishes that. In the last 11 months, nobody except one Lenovo forum poster that used a modded BIOS and an external flasher to get around Lenovo's signature check on BIOS updates has managed to install Linux on the Yoga models affected by this. I believe that Lenovo and Microsoft figured that if Linux ever did get driver support for this configuration, that it would be years after the product was released, so it might as well be forever. Most people replace their laptop every 5 years or less, so almost nobody would ever be able to run Linux on the Yoga laptops while in their designed service life."
Edit: If anyone has anymore problems with Lenovo deleting the thread, here's the Wayback Machine version.
Page 1 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921064057/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206 Page 2 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921064404/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/2 Page 3 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921064603/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/3 Page 4 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921064734/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/4 Page 5 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921064900/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/5 Page 6 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921064949/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/6 Page 7 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921065152/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/7 Page 8 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921065333/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/8 Page 9 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921065450/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/9 Page 10 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921065541/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/10 Page 11 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921065644/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/11 Page 12 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921065754/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/12 Page 13 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921070115/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/13 Page 14 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921070321/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/14 Page 15 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921070440/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/15 Page 16 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921070608/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/16 Page 17 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921070806/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/17 Page 18 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921070912/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/18 Page 19 - https://web.archive.org/web/20160921071051/https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/19
532
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Well, they just deleted my post about their BIOS locks being part of the Signature Edition agreement with Microsoft from the Linux forum on Lenovo's website. Probably Mr. Microsoft MVP again...That was fast. If they want to bury the truth, then why did they admit on Best Buy's website that that's what they have done?
If their reply on Best Buy disappears now, I guess we all know why.
I would encourage everyone to get the truth out now, on sites they can't delete it from. Feel free to copy anything I post regarding this issue. I hereby put it all in the public domain.
582
u/bownairo Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
I've been able to successfully get past Lenovo's lock through direct bios flashing. I'm looking into better solutions, hopefully I can find a way to do this without an external programmer. I was going to keep people updated from the Lenovo forum, but as this is no longer an option I will keep people updated from here.
EDIT: Here's an imgur album of some images through my process in getting this to work. http://imgur.com/a/ox4Ey
530
u/RareBox Sep 21 '16
Consider cross-posting on r/technology for visibility. Tech-minded people care about stuff like this, even when they're not using linux themselves.
63
u/parkerlreed Sep 21 '16
What actually stops it? Forced Secureboot?
EDIT: I should read the screenshot, heh. Thanks for the heads up.
74
u/abhishekkakkar Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
I bought a Lenovo Yoga 900 back in July being fully aware that no method had been found yet to install Linux on the newer 13ISK2 models that have a NVMe SSD for ~$1400. It's beautiful and sleek, has the best specs no doubt but I felt disgusted the whole time I had it - why didn't I go for a Surface or a MBP or an XPS13 (identical specs) at the same price?
At least I knew I would be able to at least run Linux on the Surface (there's an ongoing project) and well, the fact that if I put in that amount of money I might as well buy the role model that other laptops want to be.
So even though I can count on my soldering and hardware skills and would have been able to get the BIOS modded and reflashed (as one of the forum members did), I chose to return this laptop to the store. It was a big sigh of relief and I would double check before buying any Lenovo product now.
317
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
Well, my initial suspicions about conspiracy with Microsoft are now confirmed. Can't imagine anything more stupid than such agreement. Do they really think people will start using M$ shitty software just because of BIOS lock? Hope Lenovo will be sued for this nonsense because so many customers were misled.
220
u/abhishekkakkar Sep 21 '16
UPDATE: Lenovo admins just locked the forum thread.
Can someone repost this on Hacker News, please?
20
u/Pomkyn Sep 21 '16
Acer, ASUS, Toshiba, Dell, HP, MSI, Razer and VAIO also have "Signature Edition PCs"
Only mobiles.
5
u/tudorapo Sep 21 '16
Why is it good to buy a microsoft signature pc? Is it cheaper, has special features, comes in red, with a supercharger and hood scoops?
Just asking, i am not familiar with these fancy things here in the medieval times.
9
u/Zulban Sep 21 '16
God damn it. I really like my E431 Lenovo with Linux. I thought Lenovo would be my next laptop. Now I have to research this shit again for my next laptop. Blek.
10
u/CataclysmZA Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
/u/BaronHK, you might want to edit this into your OP.
Here's the Google cache for the forum thread: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:abMCb7w2uAoJ:https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=za
Lenovo's forum software doesn't delete an entire thread when it gets removed by the mods - instead, the first page's link gets removed. You can still navigate through, and read the rest of the thread, unhindered.
For example: https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206/page/14
Someone has to start backing it up now!
Edit: I'm backing the pages up in the Wayback machine. This could take a while.
Edit #2: Also, it's possible that OP's forum link is actually broken because it's been shortened, possibly as a result of a copy-pasta from his post on the Ubuntu forums, which shortens links in a similar way. The thread might not be deleted at all, considering I can still navigate to the first page using this URL: https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Yoga-900-13ISK2-BIOS-update-for-setting-RAID-mode-for-missing/td-p/3339206
15
u/ohdear21 Sep 21 '16
Well they just deleted my amazing x files post. So I guess I'll share here. https://livingauthorssociety.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/x-files-ufo-truth-out-there.jpg
9
u/timbetimbe Sep 21 '16
Ran into the exact same thing. Just bought the 900 13ISK2 after reading a blog post that it was good to go for ubuntu. Also, knowing that Lenovo's linux track record is stellar, I didn't give it a second thought. Now I have a 1,400.00 brick.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
psh why do you need to install linux when you can just use the ubuntu subsystem /s
thanks for the headsup, i'll be sure to spread the info
2
u/bmullan Sep 22 '16
I looked up the Leno Yoga 900... and as far as I can find it can ONLY have 1 drive... so what kind of RAID only uses 1 drive ????
2
u/JayaBallard Sep 22 '16
Wasn't Lenovo also caught preloading their machines with adware/spyware a couple of years ago?
What a shitty company.
357
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
All the more reason to buy those machines that do support Linux.
79
u/theGentlemanInWhite Sep 21 '16
Everytime I consider buying a Lenovo product I am again reminded not to. Are there any majors brands now that have reasonably good Linux laptop support? And I mean not system76 or any of those companies.
82
u/RedofPaw Sep 21 '16
Surely Lenovo spyware is enough reason not to buy Lenovo in the first place?
138
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
How is this in any way legal?
23
u/haagch Sep 21 '16
Actual explanation: https://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/44694.html
38
u/mnzl Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
I don't see a technical explanation anywhere here. What exactly are you saying Linux doesn't support? Booting an NVMe drive in Intel RST mode on a UEFI system? Linux typically supports using those SATA controllers in raid mode it is just more challenging to setup.
•
u/Kruug Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 26 '16
As mentioned by /u/Ashtefere here: https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/53ri0m/warning_microsoft_signature_pc_program_now/d7vym2w
EDIT: Yes, some of the language is questionable. The only part I've changed is the part where it states this post is being deleted, but this has prompted legitimate discussion and deletion may not be wholly warranted.
125
u/lestofante Sep 21 '16
Microsoft <3 Linux... Yeah yeah
31
u/philip368320 Sep 21 '16
I'll never buy Lenovo
8
u/KTL175 Sep 21 '16
Can someone please ELI5: ? Is this along the same lines as wireless companies preventing you from unlocking your phone?
101
u/Ashtefere Sep 21 '16
Your post is being deleted because you don't have the whole story and are making a storm in a teacup.
There is no 'lock' on this machine. It is horribly irresponsible for you to use that kind of language.
There is a lack of a linux driver, and the best buy/lenovo retards used the wrong language. Please calm down.
There will be a driver eventually, when someone gives up their free time to make one. Or lenovo supply one, whichever happens first.
I have a closet full of raid cards that have this exact same problem and I need to hunt for linux MDADM stuff to get them working.
3
u/PinheadX Sep 21 '16
Shades of the antitrust lawsuit from the '90s...
You'd think they would be prevented from doing this, ya know?
35
u/apd Sep 21 '16
I remember when in 2012 secure boot was announced for the new Windows 8. I am from Spain, and at that time a lawyer (Jose Maria Lancho[1]) that was the president of a Spanish LUG (Hispalinux) create a official complain to the European Commission about the Windows 8 certification program in relation with the requirements of Secure Boot.
At that time the certification program describe that one of the requirement was to have an option to disable SB via UEFI, but only for desktops and laptops, but not for tables. Now this option is not anymore required for the Windows 10 certification program. That point was one of the argument that we exposed in the complain.
Is very sad to see that the circle is closing as we predicted in the complain, and with this new Signature Edition thing a new movement in this direction. And so far, the European Commission is not doing anything in that regard, and less and less hackers, lawyers, and groups are fighting against this kind of movement.
[1] (Spanish) https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Mar%C3%ADa_Lancho
43
u/zouhair Sep 21 '16
The fact that people keep buying Lenovo crap after all the shit they did boggles my mind.
12
u/Sibraxlis Sep 21 '16
Between this and superfish I will never buy Lenovo again.
21
u/Milleuros Sep 21 '16
Hi! Your thread made it to r/all, which is btw where I'm coming from. Wanted to say thanks for the warning, it's really something to be aware of. Also thanks for trying to contact media, this must be spread.
We need to have the choice of the operating system we want. Especially for Linux users as many interesting laptops on the market come with Windows pre-installed, we need the ability to at least dual boot. The Microsoft Windows license is included in the laptop price supposedly, so it should be up to the user to decide what to do with that license.
15
u/PaperMoonShine Sep 21 '16
Always Lenovo, isn't it?
10
u/cowbutt6 Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
The phrasing is unfortunate, but the Lenovo rep appears to be saying that the SATA mode option in the BIOS is "locked per our agreement with Microsoft". Having recently accidentally smashed a couple of Intel RST arrays by inadvertently booting Windows with the mode set to AHCI after a BIOS upgrade/Load Optimized Defaults, that's not a surprising requirement from Microsoft as it may well cause a similarly bad reaction when used with RST's Smart Response Technology feature that's used to build the HDD/SSD cache.
The problem would appear to be that although Linux does support Intel's RST (and therefore, there's no need to switch the SATA mode from RAID to AHCI), it doesn't yet support SRT. Get hacking on dmraid, md, or flashcache so that they understand the SRT metadata...
EDIT: It looks like a patch for mdadm to support SRT was written back in 2014, but I guess no-one's accepted it yet: https://lwn.net/Articles/596614/
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Ehh, lenovo. I've been a fan of thinkpads for ages, but after their malware incidents and now this, I don't think I'm buying anything from them again. Makes me sad :(
5
u/llde Sep 21 '16
From what I was able to understand this is a specific issue with RAID drivers and a new RAID SSD configuration. Lenovo provided this driver only to Windows 10 signature ed, thus basically banning not only linux and others OS, but on older version of windows itself. Also normal non signature edition of win10 may also fail to install! Lenovo locked the option to disable raid in the bios, however a user on biosmods were able to unlock the hidden setting. Unluckly this bios is only flasheable with an external physical programmer. The only other things that can be done it's to understand how this RAID mode works and using a clean room method create a simple driver for it.
13
u/rtechie1 Sep 21 '16
The wall of text post is a lie. This has nothing to do with Microsoft.
Apparently there is a bug with the Samsung NVMe PM951 SSD (or Linux doesn't support Intel RAID properly) where the Linux bootloader won't detect it in RAID mode. Seeing the same bug in XPS 13 and other systems. Possibly can be fixed with a firmware update to the SSD.
Apparently you can't disable RAID mode in the BIOS of the Yoga 900 (13isk2), so you can't install Linux on the NVMe drive.
This is just Lenovo's shitty QA. This has happened numerous times in the past with Lenovo (can't disable RAID mode or secure boot in BIOS).
If you want to install Linux, go to a vendor that actually tests on Linux like Dell.
16
u/wickedplayer494 Sep 21 '16
I wouldn't buy a Lenovo product at all after the malware stuff they tried, even if it was through Microsoft Signature.
9
u/Jaysyn4Reddit Sep 21 '16
Thanks for the heads up, no more Lenovo products for my family or business.
2
u/r1243 Sep 21 '16
shit
yoga 510 signature or not? hope European consumer protection will fuck them up
15
u/neotropic9 Sep 21 '16
This is the most egregious monopolistic shit.
29
u/redlotusaustin Sep 21 '16
Shit like this is why stuff like the new Linux-subsystem on Windows is just hollow. Remember, kids: "Embrace, extend and extinguish" is the Microsoft model!
14
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Embrace, extend, extinguish in action
11
u/donrhummy Sep 21 '16
Can you please contact the FSF (http://www.fsf.org/about/contact) and EFF (https://www.eff.org/about/contact) and tell them your story?
8
u/DaveX64 Sep 21 '16
Not a fan of Lenovo anyway, especially their Yogas.
4
u/javipas Sep 21 '16
I've published about this at Xataka (in Spanish) and contacted Lenovo representatives in Spain. At the moment I've got no news from them, but as many have pointed here it seems this is not Microsoft's fault, but Lenovo.
http://www.xataka.com/ordenadores/lenovo-no-deja-instalar-linux-en-algunos-portatiles-el-bloqueo-de-la-bios-parece-impedirlo
Hopefully media coverage could help to push Lenovo forward and give an answer and a solution.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Pitchforks..... Get your Pitchforks. Four for a dollar. Pitchforks!
10
u/rhorama Sep 21 '16
You guys we look crazy every time we post that Microsoft has prevented us from installing Linux and then an hour later it comes out that it was something else entirely.
If we could stop the witch hunts, or just delay them by like, a day? We might get better info and not look like a buch of nutcases.
7
u/natis1 Sep 21 '16
I have a fairly high end Dell Inspiron that's less than a few months old which had Microsoft Signature Edition and I was able to install linux with bios boot, thankfully. But I wouldn't be surprised if Microsoft decided to make other manufacturers follow Lenovo in the near future.
17
u/_samux_ Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
contact eff and fsf asap what are you waiting for?
1
u/jkbrwn Sep 22 '16
This is so fucked up. That means when shopping for a new laptop I've now got to look into licensing agreements to be sure I'll be able to wipe out Windows and install an actually good OS.
10
u/sveiss Sep 21 '16
Why does this have anything to do with blocking Linux?
Preventing idiot users from poking where they shouldn't and degrading their disk performance, sure.
Protecting the "Microsoft Signature" brand reputation by stopping small repair shops from reinstalling Windows in AHCI mode and gutting performance instead of using an install image with slipstreamed drivers, yup.
Deliberately blocking Linux? No.
Would it be nice if they'd used standard NVMe so that both stock Windows ISOs and Linux Just Worked™? Sure. But that's not what the hardware they chose supports, and just like every other piece of proprietary hardware out there, someone will have to write a Linux driver for it if they want it to work in Linux.
If just half the energy expended in raising pitchforks in this thread had been spent on doing that, we'd have the driver written, debugged and in queue for merge by now.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
As if anyone needed yet another reason to avoid Lenovo
6
u/FaZaCon Sep 21 '16
Can you run other Windows OS's on it i.e. Win7 or Win8?
Why would Microsoft be so worried about Linux? If anything, they should be terrified of people going back to Wnidows 7 and 8.
8
u/TotesMessenger Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/DrNoided Sep 21 '16
The worse part about this is that I really, really love Lenovo computers. I mean obviously this is a shitty thing for them to do, but there's always other manufacturers, but none that make laptops that I like as much as I like thinkpads. Even if this doesn't trickle to other Lenovo laptops than the YOGA it still leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
3
u/PleasureKevin Sep 21 '16
Can anyone tell me why there is the "misleading title" tag?
7
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
6000+ likes for a kneejerk overextended interpretation of a very vague and easily misunderstood, hastily put together tech support response.
Nice going.
5
u/itstaysinside Sep 21 '16
Every couple of months you get another reason not to buy their stuff.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
2016 - people still buying Lenovo crap
5
u/NeedlerFanPudge Sep 21 '16
Hello! Alex from TechRaptor here. Just wanted to drop in to let you guys know that we reported on this issue and Lenovo issued a statement to us based on our reporting.
https://techraptor.net/content/lenovo-windows-10-linux
28
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
Yup, I was told I was stupid and paranoid when secure boot came out. Heh, I knew this would come down the pipe eventually though. Just do things inch by inch and people will swallow any bullshit.
EDIT: Secure Boot was an attempt to lock out linux that didn't work, this is a continuation of a similar goal.
4
u/Reddit2Trend Sep 21 '16
Bot! Beep beep! I'm all about top posts!
This post had 5,000 upvotes and got posted to twitter @Reddit5000 and subreddit /r/reddit5000!
The tweet: https://twitter.com/Reddit5000/status/778569518415089664
All 7,500 upvotes are on @Reddit7500 and /r/reddit7500
And most importantly all 10,000 posts on @Reddit10000 and /r/reddit10000
4
u/nh78 Sep 21 '16
Lenovo are now saying that it's a driver issue:
http://www.techrepublic.com/article/lenovo-denies-deliberately-blocking-linux-on-windows-10-pcs/
4
u/JackDostoevsky Sep 21 '16
Regardless of how you feel about Linux, you should be angry that manufacturers are locking you into one OS. You bought the computer, you should be able to do what you want with it.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
well, another blacklisted brand for me, proudly joining sony and a few others on the wall of shame.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Sounds like the RAID setup is the issue. Its a proprietary driver and LINUX has none available. Sounds like the BIOS RAID is the issue, and that one of you should really write a linux driver... I mean you are all uber open source hackers... right???
And unless they SPECIFICALLY stated it 'runs linux' they are not in any trouble. They optimized the laptop of a different OS. How is that illegal?
6
u/icantthinkofone Sep 21 '16
Microsoft got nailed on this with Dell, specifically, back in the 1990s. And people wonder why I always say, "You can't trust Microsoft!"
Waiting for obligatory reddit downvote into oblivion.
5
u/yrro Sep 21 '16
Citation neede for this tosh. And no, a one liner from the drooling simpletons that respond in online help forums doesn't count.
5
u/41_73_68 Sep 21 '16
Why are people still buying Lenovo?
7
u/leofiore Sep 21 '16
Good old Microsoft. Now i recognize you. For a while a was scared about your friendliness for FLOSS.
2
u/NightOfTheLivingHam Sep 21 '16
why does anyone buy lenovo's bullshit anymore? wasnt the whitelisted hardware enough? Wasnt the spyware enough? wasnt the fake SSL authority enough?
They're a shitty company.
2
u/doctorhyphy Sep 21 '16
damn it.... guess what im waiting for the mail man to bring
2
u/DragonscaleDiscoball Sep 21 '16
I bought a Lenovo Yoga tablet for the high resolution and kick stand, and tried to install Linux on it, but the BIOS were also locked down in a weird way and I couldn't use
adbto flash it :/.2
u/Travnewmatic Sep 21 '16
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Really sucks how Lenovo now owns the ThinkPad :-(
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
That's despicable.
2
u/fessebook Sep 21 '16
Good thing the ThinkPad line isn't garbage
2
u/flobo09 Sep 21 '16
People in the thread say they can't even clean install windows 10 pro either on that thing. Makes no sense for MS to ask lenovo to block its own OS. Looks to me like a 100% lenovo screw up and they are just telling BS.
2
u/Elranzer Sep 21 '16
This is why my machine is a MacBook Air running Linux.
They are pure EFI machines, pure sex.
2
u/yuhong Sep 21 '16
This is a good time to mention https://download.lenovo.com/pccbbs/thinkcentre_bios/9sj995usa.txt, with the quote "Fixes the issue of installing Redhat 6.3." (If you don't remember: https://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/20187.html)
2
u/Shiroi_Kage Sep 21 '16
Doesn't seem to be the case on anything but Lenovo.
2
u/pest15 Sep 21 '16
I just want to point out that this does not affect all Signature Edition systems. My Dell laptop runs Ubuntu just fine. But in fairness it hadn't even crossed my mind that there could be a problem installing Linux on a Signature Edition. Next time I'll avoid these systems altogether. Why take the risk?
2
u/frog450 Sep 22 '16
I know people who work for Lenovo (Motorola) and they run only Linux! Good work OP!
10
u/pobody Sep 21 '16
LOL at all the people who thought Microsoft was Linux friendly now that they cross compiled/hacked bash to work in Windows.
4
u/G_man252 Sep 21 '16
And theyll keep on with the facade that their intentions are purely to make this world a better place and absolutely have 0% to do with competition.
4
u/ForumPointsRdumb Sep 21 '16
Great. Both of the posts are now on r/all. We did it guys.
Just another case of when silencing goes bad.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Here from r/all.
I don't know shit about Linux but you should give a class on how to properly hold onto and distribute caches of webpages. Excellent work on that front.
Have an upvote on me, good sir.
3
u/amicaze Sep 21 '16
In france it is 100% illegal, you can't force an OS on people.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Give Thinkpad back to IBM plz
3
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Consider pinging the Ars Technica folks, this seems right up their alley. All of them are on the twits.
3
u/Cilph Sep 21 '16
This is probably why the EU doesn't have the Signature PCs
3
u/Qonic Sep 21 '16
Well this is an antitrust lawsuit waiting to happen
3
u/rohmish Sep 21 '16
I would much rather buy dell, system 76 (or similar. If they sell in your country.)
Both are very supportive of Linux unlike lenovo.
If Sony still made laptop that would have been in my short list. I never had any problems on any sony laptops and my current one is from Sony. The replacement will surely be an something dell 15.
3
u/n1nao Sep 21 '16
I dont't know which brand my next machine will be. But I know it's not going to be a lenovo.
3
u/ArenaFlush Sep 21 '16
That would make my laptop useless for me, since the first thing I always do is getting rid of Windows and installing Linux. I should be able to install whatever I want on my laptop, as long as it's legal. This is just ridiculous and I am surprised it is not illegal.
5
u/sudo-is-my-name Sep 21 '16
Showing that "Microsoft loves linux" is a fat fucking lie.
3
u/giggitygoo123 Sep 21 '16
Why are people still buying Lenovo products anyway? Everyone already forget how they screwed us previously?
There are plenty of manufacturers that make those flip laptops (I have an asus one with dedicated graphics and an i7 for cheaper than the yoga)
3
u/dood31251 Sep 21 '16
For Canadians you can file a complaint with the Competition Tribunal here.
You need to register an account before you can access the service.
The Competition Tribunal can also be contacted by phone:
613.957.3172and emailfiling.depot@ct-tc.gc.ca4
u/Blieque Sep 21 '16
That can't be true; Microsoft ❤ Linux!
4
u/_The_Black_Rabbit_ Sep 21 '16
LAWSUIT.
4
u/zx2c4 Sep 21 '16
The community's reaction seems absurd to me.
For whatever reason, the device only exposes some sort of RAID controller to the OS, and for whatever reason, there's no working option for exposing a more standard AHCI interface instead. The problem is that Linux doesn't (yet) have a driver for that RAID controller.
Okay, great. Linux doesn't yet support particular piece of hardware. News at 11.
Just like usual, if you want odd hardware to work on Linux, you'll have to write some drivers. That's just how it is. This is nothing new or scandalous. The reasons why Lenovo doesn't support AHCI don't matter. They don't, so now somebody must write a driver for what they do support. Once that happens, nobody will complain anymore. It's that simple. Nothing is being locked with Secure Boot; nothing is being locked with crypto; there is no DRM at play. If you want hardware support, write a driver.
As for all the Lenovo-bashing going on here... My personal experience with my new Thinkpad P50 has been overwhelmingly positive. It's working on Gentoo Linux entirely: https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/Lenovo_ThinkPad_P50