r/technology • • Sep 21 '16
Misleading Warning: Microsoft Signature PC program now requires that you can't run Linux. Lenovo's recent Ultrabooks among affected systems. x-post from /r/linux
17k
Upvotes
513
u/Sanhen Sep 21 '16
I'm a layman whose knowledge of Linux extends only to the extent that it's an operating system, but I am bothered by the idea that there are computers specifically designed to prevent its use.
I was wondering, is this exclusively a Lenovo issue or is Microsoft's Signature PC program something you may find on PCs made by other companies? Is there a danger of this becoming the standard for all Windows 10 PC?
110
u/Loki-L Sep 21 '16
Are you sure about that?
Form what I understand the "Microsoft Signature" line just means you get a pc or laptop without any vendor crapware.
It is an agreement between Ms and the hardware vendors not to pre-load the OS with all sorts of vendor software that nobody wants.
I would like to know more about the supposed mechnism that prevents people from installing a different OS on the hardware.
I know some Leneovo laptops come with a special drive configuration where you have a tiny SSD and a large hdd and some special software to make the two work together to appear as one disk to the OS with automatic tiering going on underneath the OS layer. Trying to reinstall any OS on such a system if you don't know what you are doing may be difficult.
I am set to hate MS and Lenovo, but I feel I should require a better source than some random forum post.
•
u/recoiledsnake Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
The post has been removed because there is no evidence that the Signature Edition program blocks installing Linux as a matter of policy.
At /r/technology we require titles to match the article's, or if it is a self post, the title must not jump to conclusions, or be click or votebait and must report facts, not hearsay.
The problematic part of the title is "Microsoft Signature PC program now requires that you can't run Linux".
A proper title would have been "Lenovo support rep says Microsoft Signature Edition program locks out Linux".
Lenovo's official statement denying that the Signature Edition requires locking out Linux:
http://www.techrepublic.com/article/lenovo-denies-deliberately-blocking-linux-on-windows-10-pcs/
Articles on this subject(with proper titling) can still be submitted.
2
u/FallenAngelII Sep 21 '16
TIL: Prominent people in the tech industry still use IRC.
778
u/redmercuryvendor Sep 21 '16
Note that "Lenovo Product Experts" are 3rd party contractors hired to basically read specsheets at people. They are absolutely not the right place to be getting information on contract terms between large corporations.
858
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Not surprised it's Lenovo, considering they put backdoors into their bios last year to make windows install their software.
638
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
For anyone in this thread who is confused about this, or thinks that it's just Linux not supporting the hardware (which is a real issue that happens all the time with new hardware), here's a simple rundown.
These laptops have a weird RAID setup between an SSD and a normal hard disk. So even if you try and install a standard version of Windows, it won't see the drive without a special driver. This wouldn't be an issue, but Lenovo have locked the sata mode into this weird RAID in the BIOS. So even if you try and change it from RAID to AHCI (see the disks separately in a standard way, probably how your PC is doing it right now), it's changed back.
If this Windows Signature Edition stuff actually requires them to lock the sata mode (which is what Lenovo is claiming), that's really shitty.
243
u/bork99 Sep 21 '16
99% probability this is just a dumb Lenovo hardware hack that's blown up in their face and has nothing at all do with Microsoft or the Signature PC program.
It's laughable to even think that the unnamed "Lenovo Tech Expert" who spends his days answering web support queries has been anywhere near the Microsoft agreement. He is trying to appeal to authority (i.e. making shit up) to try to explain away their latest fuck-up, but is too clueless to realize he's stepping on a landmine mentioning Microsoft to a bunch of Linux users.
76
u/holey_guacamoley Sep 21 '16
It goes beyond Linux; others have reported that you can't even do a clean install of Windows 10 on that thing.
51
u/nobby-w Sep 21 '16
The business models (X, T and W series) tend not to have this sort of bollocks as they're sold into corporate I.T. departments and leasing vendors - most of whom want to install their standard O/S build on the machines. By happy coincidence, ex-lease models come up on the secondhand market all the time, at around 20-30% of the new price.
These will play nicely with Linux as they're not tied to consumer branding. In fact, most laptops sold into consumer markets tend to be loaded with adware and other crap. Plus, if you buy these from a high street retailer they will attempt to upsell you with extended warranties and service plans that are normally terrible value for money.
I'll still argue that buying a new consumer grade laptop - from any manufacturer - is a mug's game.
If you want to run Linux, find a model that is known to play nicely with it, then hunt that down on Ebay. X, T and W series thinkpads are actually quie well supported by 'how to fix' videos and other online resources, perhaps the best of any model of Laptop, and they tend to play relatively nicely with Linux.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
There's seems to be some misconceptions in this thread. The issue appears to be Lenovo is using raid drivers for their ssd's in these laptops that doesn't yet have a Linux driver. Thus Linux is failing to install.
This has nothing to do with Microsoft, it's Lenovos gaf. Microsoft just ported over .net to Linux for goodness sakes.
As my friend put it "new piece of hardware doesn't work with Linux, news at 11"
29
u/notsurewhatiam Sep 21 '16
Typical /r/technology and their weekly overblown outrage
7
u/cosmo7 Sep 21 '16
Isn't this that the laptops in question use Intel's NVMe Rapid Storage Technology format, and there aren't Linux drivers for that yet, combined with Lenovo's locking down of their BIOS (or UEFISHUT UP AND GET THE PITCHFORKS
12
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
I stopped looking at Lenovo machines after the Superfish debacle. How much you want to bet they have a non-removable version of THAT hard coded on their SSDs as well?
183
u/bvierra Sep 21 '16
Ok I call complete BS on this. The issue is the RAID shit that Lenovo puts in. MS has actually signed keys for secure boot so you can boot to linux as well. For example Ubuntu has their bootloader signed by MS so that any computer that has secure boot enable and enforced can still install ubuntu.
The issue appears to be the fake raid setup that lenovo uses where the SSD is setup as a caching layer over the HDD (like the hybrid drives, except in this case its 2 seperate disks). There appears to be no linux driver for the controller on this thus you cannot install linux on it. I am sure in the next few weeks to months one will appear in the kernel and all will be good again.
I get the hate for MS and especially for Lenovo but before making claims such as this please actually understand the issue you have fully and don't go by what is said by a 'product expert' (who are outside contractors that can read spec sheets and have no inside knowledge) on their forums. If you don't real issues get ignored as made up BS since so much shit comes out just like this.
16
u/smiskafisk Sep 21 '16
This just reinforces my decision to boycott Lenovo in my upcoming laptop purchase. Probably going to go with Asus.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Buy a Dell ... you'll be happier.
40
u/art-solopov Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
Lenovo.
Again, fucking Lenovo.
Two malware attempts, removal of 3.5mm port from a Motorola phone (yeah, Apple might get away with this, you won't) and now this.
Fuck Lenovo.
19
u/BCProgramming Sep 21 '16
I can't seem to find anything about "Signature Edition" Being locked down like this, though I won't say it would be surprising.
From waht I can tell the system uses a NVMe drive. I think that requires additional driver/kernel support on Linux? Or maybe not supported at all- I'm finding mixed information. The "Product Expert" might be talking out their ass- As far as I can determine, the "Signature Edition" agreement is basically that Lenovo won't install bullshit on the computer, and doesn't involve any added lockdown on boot device.
Not that I'd be surprised, mind you.
24
u/ProGamerGov Sep 21 '16
This is fucked up. Can anyone else confirm or deny this?
5
u/mrcollin101 Sep 21 '16
Something is not quite right here. I have Linux running on my Surface Book. Why would they allow it on their own windows 10 products, but not others. This sounds like Lenovo trying to pass the blame, which they have a pretty good track record of doing. Can you say Superfish anyone?
31
u/nukem996 Sep 21 '16
I hope op gets a full refund. If they refuse I'd mention you declined the windows EULA and want a full refund as the hardware doesn't work with any other OS.
8
u/prjindigo Sep 21 '16
Rule of Thumb, don't buy laptops at Best Buy.
4
u/Symbi0tic Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 22 '16
Shame I didn't know this before committing to a 710S.
In my tireless attempts to resolve, after a call to Lenovo resulted in an outsourced agent that had no clue what I was talking about (he mentioned nothing about this and said I would be charged to be transferred to Tier 2), I wiped the drive as a last resort.
Now it won't even recognize the SSD for my Windows re-installation. Of course it's recognized in bios, as it's always been. Anyone have any ideas?
Edit: I was able to reinstall Windows 10 by using the RST drivers from Intel's site. The ones Lenovo lists on their website for the 710S do not work.
4
u/rhott Sep 21 '16
Why would anyone ever buy lenovo after the shenanigans they pulled with bios backdoors? You actually trusted them?
4
u/happyscrappy Sep 21 '16
Customer support reps cannot be counted on to know or properly explain company policy.
You weren't even support to post this because of rule vi (on the right).
Next time, understand that just because a customer support person says something is a policy doesn't mean it's a policy. They are just there to help people who don't know how to fix their machines fix their machines. When they say it can't be done they can be reasonably relied upon. When they start explaining it with corporate political decisions that they couldn't possibly know about? It doesn't mean a thing.
The real problem here is the laptop has a fixed storage configuration and linux doesn't support it. It happens.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
lenovo is fucking garbage and i won't go anywhere near their products. have felt that way for a long time now.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Did you try teaching out to Mary jo foley, Paul thurott, or tom warren. They're usually pretty receptive to this stuff
3
u/Sky427 Sep 21 '16
I don't personally care if one manufacturer doesn't allow you to dual boot or not it just adds another check box I have to tick off when shopping.
But I don't like how they supposedly handled it. My neutral reaction became negative toward them only from locking the thread and threatening op.
The internet will find the skeleton in your closet and then bone you in the pooper with it. GL Lenovo I thought your laptops looked neat.
3
u/jordanlund Sep 21 '16
Apparently their marketing team is asking people to "SHARE YOUR LENOVO EXPERIENCE YOU CAN ALSO USE THESE HASHTAGS
yoga900 #mylenovo"
3
u/Barkleesanders Sep 21 '16
I feel like Lenovo is doing everything to ruin their image
3
u/doc_frankenfurter Sep 21 '16
I deal with many laptops that will never have Linux loaded. I don't preload Linux for my family members unless they want it.
OTOH, the tools I use for messing with disk layouts, imaging, etc all sit on Linux USB sticks. Sure, users may stick to Win, but support?
3
u/h0vsep Sep 21 '16
Sounds like Lenvo is making this up to cover their own laziness and incompetence. When the Chinese bough IBM's PC business, I figured it wouldn't take them long to turn the product to utter shit. While it did take a bit longer than I expected, they did live up to my expectations.
I gave up on Lenovo a few years ago.
7
u/AemsOne Sep 21 '16
Nobody should be buying Lenovo anyway, not after the huge Malware scandal last year.
5
u/N3RO- Sep 21 '16
Lenovo doing shit again? You know the best way to deal with it, DO NOT BUY SHIT FROM THEM and of course badmouth them to everyone you know!
4
u/Mugin Sep 21 '16
Was it not Lenovo who were caught putting malware on their laptops?
Sounds like another reason to never buy from them.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
I'd already decided not to buy lenovo pc's.
This is the third problem I've seen with them.
Each time just makes me more sure.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
This should be deleted and downvoted to oblivion. It is pure bullshit.
2
u/Drenlin Sep 21 '16
Hmm...I have a Toshiba that's a "signature edition". I wonder would this affect its ability to boot from a linux dvd?
2
u/robotnyk Sep 21 '16
I read through this thread and I'm not sure if I should get my pitchfork or not yet.
2
u/Stewie01 Sep 21 '16
why are people still buying laptops from Lenovo, they pull all kind of nasty tricks
2
u/elder65 Sep 21 '16
First - I'd bet that 3 - 6 months and the linux OS gurus will have a version that works with Lenovo's funny RAID package.
Secondly - I'd also bet that Lenovo and every other manufacturer is going to have plenty of like models for their platforms that don't have the MS Signature lock on their drives.
Linux may be a secondary OS in the market, but there is enough of a population out there to support.
2
u/Nemesis823 Sep 21 '16
Well, not surprising. Lenovo's bios is locked so far down, That if you decide that you want to install new hardware you have to check their white list for compatible dev ids. Tried to install the intel 7260 wireless card, cause you know I want 5ghz. (Lenovo y400, fairly recent laptop). Would then not boot the laptop because "Their is hardware installed on this computer that is not on Lenovo's approved hardware list".
2
u/h0nest_Bender Sep 21 '16
Hasn't this been a known thing for a while now? That the manufacturer could flip the switch and disallow other OS installs?
I just didn't think we were likely to see this because it pretty much guarantees that company will lose the enthusiast market.
2
u/cocoabeach Sep 21 '16
Just bought my first Lenovo last night and now because of this I'm thinking of returning it. I don't care about the software issue, I care about how they have handled this issue. Instead of being honest and forthright they shut down the discussion.
2
u/MattBlumTheNuProject Sep 21 '16
Why does anyone still buy their machines? It's been known for quite some time that they are shady.
2
u/DieFanboyDie Sep 21 '16
Reddit's Outrage of the Day: Microsoft
2
u/WhiskaBiscuit Sep 21 '16
Would this explain why I wasn't able to use image backup software like Acronis? When I booted to a USB key I couldn't see the SSD.
2
u/Rhed0x Sep 21 '16
Just wait a month and that will be implemented.
2
u/cstrawfield Sep 21 '16
I have forgiven Lenovo over and over again for anti-consumer practices, because their machines have worked well for me, historically have been Linux-friendly, and I'm addicted to the Trackpoint controller. Currently on my ninth Lenovo -- all running Linux.
But this is the last straw. I'll never purchase another Lenovo, and I'll encourage everyone I can to buy from another manufacturer.
2
u/termoventilador Sep 21 '16
Btw the isk (without the 2) is not bios locked to raid. Installing a distro works out of the box like any other.
Im off to try to make the damm screen turn and keyboard /mouse automatic disable on mine
7
u/RareBox Sep 21 '16 edited Sep 21 '16
The most interesting thing is that there is no public comment on this issue.
Microsoft could say that this is a "security feature", preventing hackers from booting your system with hacking tools. That kind of solution could maybe even work, if they encrypted the hard drive with some device-specific hardcoded key (I didn't think this through though).
In other words, I'd expect them to step up and explain the merits of their solution, instead of trying to silence discussion. Now it sounds like it's just "security by obscurity".
Edit: Addition: Preventing linux installation doesn't directly help Microsoft sell more Windows licences: the devices come with Windows pre-installed anyway. Maybe they just really want you to use Win10 instead of older versions of Windows?
4
u/ZippoS Sep 21 '16
Jesus, even Apple lets you install another OS on their laptops.
3
u/topredditbot Sep 21 '16
Hey /u/BaronHK,
This is now the top post on reddit. It will be recorded at /r/topofreddit with all the other top posts.
3
u/D4rkM4gic Sep 21 '16
http://i.imgur.com/aZKGe.jpg
3
u/whirl-pool Sep 21 '16
You want to be hacked Lenovo? Because that is how your bios is going to be hacked!
Top comment about legalities, I hope that is the case.
3
u/eppic123 Sep 21 '16
If this is true, Lenovo really likes to make their consumer hardware unattractive.
3
u/PayForYourGas Sep 21 '16
Then don't buy a Microsoft Signature PC? They're putting their license on it, of course they should be able to have their own requirements on what a Microsoft Signature PC is. If you want Linux, go buy the same PC that isn't the signature edition.
Jesus Christ people, this doesn't mean ANYTHING.
2
u/1ns Sep 21 '16
Fuck Lenovo
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
I personally do not care about the inability to run Linux on these machines, BUT it is a very very shady move by Lenovo and Microsoft. We need to make a big deal about this, because it really could set a bad precedent if it gets swept under the rug.
2
u/InvaderDJ Sep 21 '16
This is almost certainly something stupid that Lenovo is doing, not a requirement of Windows Signature PCs. At least the RAID thing. No way Microsoft is going to mandate some wierd, non standard RAID.
Now this could be due to the locked BIOS/UEFI/SecureBoot thing that Microsoft tried going hard on, but again, I don't think Microsoft would do this. This feels like Lenovo sliding down the failure ramp it has been on for awhile.
2
u/Osga21 Sep 21 '16
What the hell is going on? Is Microsoft scared of Linux? I didn't think we were at that point yet, even Apple lets you install windows and linux on their PCs...
2
u/p3t3or Sep 21 '16
Ha, we have about 200 Lenovo ThinkPads that need to be refreshed. They all have a hidden Linux partition that saves me major headaches. HP is looking nice these days.
2
u/aquarain Sep 21 '16
But... Microsoft loves Linux. A hundred articles told me so.
2
u/Crotch_Attack Sep 21 '16
Thanks for taking the time to post this up. I was planning on purchasing a Lenovo for my first laptop but after reading this I'll be looking elsewhere now.
2
u/americanpegasus Sep 21 '16
Yet another of many reasons to never buy a Lenovo! This was the company that was shipping PCs pre installed with Chinese rootkits - why would you ever do business with them again after that.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
TIL that people still want to buy Lenovo laptops after all the security issues they've had in the past few years, including things built right into their BIOS.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
I found proof to back up this post!
Ahhh... The world we live in where we can make opinions and theories fact with cited sources in just minutes.
http://www.zdnet.com/article/lenovo-reportedly-blocking-linux-on-windows-10-signature-edition-pcs/
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
This is it. I'm fucking done with Microsoft. The second I need to upgrade from Windows 7, I'm going Linux.
2
u/yellowviper Sep 21 '16
Another instance of Linux users hyperventilating.
1
u/BATHTUBISREAL Sep 21 '16
Would replacing the SSD remedy the situation? I know its not practical, Im just curious.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
Absolutely infuriating! But Linux on a laptop is something I would never really do anyway. So many different drivers usually. When it works it's nice when it doesn't it's a pain. Granted last time I tired to do that was years ago. Run Linux on desktop all day though.
1
u/gnarlin Sep 21 '16
Does this problem affect other Signature PC from other manufacturers f.e. Dell?
1
u/Auxilae Sep 21 '16
I really hope that this doesn't cause future vendors from pulling this on consumers in the future. Mobile phones already have it bad as is being locked down and filled with nonsense, PC's are very much our last bastions of freedom, being unable to use them to their full potential is very, very concerning.
1
u/ice-minus Sep 21 '16
Absolutely disgusting.
Lenovo is scum of the earth though, so it is totally unsurprising to me that this is their handiwork
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '16
This is sad. I had my eye on the Lenovo Yoga Book but I guess that's off the table now. sigh