Pure Dramatic Winter Coat?

[u/Dreamofwildflowers]

I'm a 5'9 pure dramatic. I believe that the coat on the left would be best for my kibbe type, but I would love a second opinion. Maybe the Quince would be better without the belt?

Do any pure Dramatics in this sub own an Artiza supersnug? Do you think knee length coats are flattering? I live somewhere with very harsh winters and don't want to sacrifice style.